Repeaters

Ordinance officers feared that the soldier would use up his rounds too fast and would call for more ammo...not cost affective to them. They preferred the slower rate of fire of the muzzle loaders - ammo wise.
 
henry.jpg
 
There is written evidence of the use of the Henry rifle at Hoover Gap. In at least 2 diaries there is mention that the scouts of Wilder's Brigade were armed with Henry rifles. The scouts were at Hoover Gap. Although it would be interesting to find a spent Henry cartridge or even a dropped live round it is really not needed to have proof that Henry rifles were used at Hoover Gap.
 
Ordinance officers feared that the soldier would use up his rounds too fast and would call for more ammo...not cost affective to them. They preferred the slower rate of fire of the muzzle loaders - ammo wise.

The reality of the situation is that more ammunition for muzzle-loader weapons was wasted than that of Henry rifle cartridges or Spencer cartridges. This was due to the fragile state of the paper cartridge. They were bounced apart during transit, got wet, dropped, ruined during the loading process under stress, etc. Regimental firing or firing by company was more of a waste of ammunition than being effective in inflicting casualties on the enemy.

Another fact about using repeaters is the fact that fewer men could be put into the field with a far greater firepower and effect than 5 times their number armed with muzzle-loaders.

Ordinance officers really were never concerned about the expenditure of ammunition or much about weaponry but were more devoted to legal matters. Ordnance officers were concerned about ammunition expenditures but also they were not too concerned about the well being of the troops in the field but mainly cost and supply aspect. While Henry rifle production could never keep up with demand due to the complicated production process the Spencer was relatively easy to produce and utilized many of the same parts of the Sharps. By 1865 more and more cavalry regiments were being armed with Spencers and Ordnance officers were forced to keep them supplied with ammunition and were able to do so. Lack of ammunition was no greater a problem for those armed with repeaters than those armed with muzzle-loaders. Those armed with a repeating rifle did not just blast away all of their ammunition as fast as they could cycle their weapon.
 
There is written evidence of the use of the Henry rifle at Hoover Gap. In at least 2 diaries there is mention that the scouts of Wilder's Brigade were armed with Henry rifles. The scouts were at Hoover Gap. Although it would be interesting to find a spent Henry cartridge or even a dropped live round it is really not needed to have proof that Henry rifles were used at Hoover Gap.
I'm a believer! I just want a spent or dropped cartridge from there. I have several Spencers from Hoover's Gap.
 
I ran across this today. There was an estimated 7,000,000 rifle bullets fired at the Battle of Gettysburg. If you look at the number of casualties in that battle and exclude the artillery inflicted casualties that is about 200 shots fired per casualty inflicted. Another thing amazing about that number is the government only purchased 4,200,000 Henry cartridges for the entire war. That can be a little misleading in that state governments and private individuals also purchased ammunition for Henry rifles.

While the repeating rifles played a small part in the war when compared to muzzle-loaders, by 1865 repeating rifles were on the increase. If the war would have lasted longer the repeating rifles would have been in the majority rather than muzzle-loaders. Of those repeaters most would have been Spencer carbines.
 
That's pretty much the way of it for most countries, unless they're planning to start a war.

The tales of the Spanish being better armed than US troops is only partly true. They also had blackpowder arms, Rem Rolling Blocks in .43 Spanish in particular.

The Brits adopted the Lee Enfield prior to 1900 and kept it well into the 50's. I've always been amused that the first Brit designed rifle or Inf small arm adopted by the brits after the P53 was the Sten Gun. The Martini Henry, designed by an American, the Lee Enfield designed by an American, The FAL a by product of a John Browning design & FN. It wasn't until the SA-80 there was a home grown Brit design... and the soldiers of the Brit Army are owed a HUGE apology for that circle jerk piece of junk.

The Russians fielded the Mosin Nagant from 1898 till replaced by the AK. Always adopting weapons almost too simple to screw up and so reliable & effective as to be legend.

French various servicable bolt action rifles ending w/ the excellent MAS 36 until replaced by the MAS 49 in 1949.

It was the US that was the first to adopt a semi auto rifle for mass issue to its military in the M1 Garand and then the M1 Carbine. Unprepared for the start of a war, but always prepared to end it w/out crying to anyone else to do the lions share of the fighting. The M16 had teething troubles but has evolved into, arguably, the most accurate off the rack main battle rifle in


Holding on to arms well past the time when something better or more effective is around is not reserved for the US or for the modern era.
Interesting post. The Soviets did introduce the Tokarav semi auto rifle just before WW2 but it didn't perform very well so Stalin had to resume production of the Mosin-Nagant. The USMC just prior to WW2 was starting to introduce the Johnson which I fired once and had very low recoil despite being chambered in 30-06. Unfortunately it didn't work very well. I have known ex- soldiers in 3rd world armies they hated the M 16 but they liked the Ak-47 and Galil better.
Getting back to the CW it seems the Henrey and Spencer were very effective but I can see the problem of them being expensive and difficult to transport all that ammo.
Leftyhunter
 
Interesting post. The Soviets did introduce the Tokarav semi auto rifle just before WW2 but it didn't perform very well so Stalin had to resume production of the Mosin-Nagant. The USMC just prior to WW2 was starting to introduce the Johnson which I fired once and had very low recoil despite being chambered in 30-06. Unfortunately it didn't work very well. I have known ex- soldiers in 3rd world armies they hated the M 16 but they liked the Ak-47 and Galil better.
Getting back to the CW it seems the Henrey and Spencer were very effective but I can see the problem of them being expensive and difficult to transport all that ammo.
Leftyhunter

FWIW I knew a WW2 vet who considered the Johnson superior to the Garand. He liked the 10 rd magazine that could easily be topped off & insisted that it was easier to field strip & clean than the Garand.

There are those who laud the Henry as the best thing since sliced bread, I'm not one of them preferring the Spencer. There was an issue w/ the magavine spring being exposed, enough so that it was abandoned in the 1866 Henry. According to the 1960 Winchester 100th Catalog... the 1866 change from an open magazine tube w/ an exposed spring (the kind of thing that admikts dirt & debris) it was changed to a closed magazine w/ a different style loading gate.

The Henry is a fine weapon, a sporting arm. The Spencer is a military arm from the word go.
 
The patent date for the Henry Repeating rifle is October 16, 1860 however production doesn't get under way for full scale production until the summer of 1862. Also in the summer of 1862 commercial advertisements appeared offering Henry
Repeating rifles for sale. "In all probability the beginning of the Civil War in April 1861 offered Oliver F. Winchester the opportunity for significant possible sales to the United States military establishment (both Army and Navy) Based on the potential for those sales the acquisition of production equipment was expedited." (Les Quick) The Henry Repeating rifle was indeed a military rifle that was marketed to the civilian market however these civilian purchases would have been used for military purposes by the civilians that purchased them.

In fact the Henry Repeating rifle is much the same as what Eugene Stoner's Armalite would become. The M16/AR15 has become one of the most versatile small arms designs in the world today for both military and civilian uses. The Henry Repeating rifle was the M16/AR15 of its day. Most all lever action rifles to follow after the Civil War owe their existence to the Henry Repeating rifle and its evolution. From the very beginning the Henry Repeating rifle was looked upon as a military rifle in a war that started much the same time as did the Henry rifle. The fact is that most all of the original buyers of the Henry Repeating rifle were using the rifle for military purposes.

The Henry Repeating rifle was a radically different design than what the military of the day was used to but then so was the M16/AR15 a radically different design than the M1/M14 design.
1860%20Henry%20Ad.gif
 
Last edited:
Our Chickamauga company is coming together. We will be portraying the 17th Indiana of Wilder's Brigade Scouts. They were originally armed with Henry and Spencer Rifles. Our group consists of 37 to 39 men armed with 8 Spencer rifles and about 26 Henry rifles and a few Sharps rifles. This will be the largest company of men armed with repeating rifles in reenacting history. It should be interesting. We also have 4 of the new Henry Repeating Arms Company Henry rifles that have been loaned to us.
Group.jpg

Bentonville 2010
 
I know that may people out there have their favorite repeater, be it the Henry Repeating Rifle or the Spencer. Many have listed several reasons for their choice. However no one has actually talked about which one is more user friendly. There is a clear cut winner in this category. Hands down it is the Henry Repeating rifle.

A muzzle-loading rifle is a lot of work to load and fire during a battle. Realistically you might be able to load and fire 2 shots per minute. The physical motions of grabbing a cartridge from the cartridge box, tearing it open, loading it down the barrel, ramming it down, returning the rammer and fumbling with a cap is all a lot of work under stress.

The Spencer rifle is a lot better than the muzzle-loader. First you had to remove the magazine spring/tube and hold on to it being careful not to drop it. This in itself could be a major problem under fire and stress of battle. Before the days of the Blakeslee Box you still had to grab cartridges from the cartridge box, load them one at a time. The Balkeslee box did not appear until the end of the war. Once loaded with 7 carridges you then had to insert the magazine tube. Once loaded you worked the lever to chamber a round but then you also had to manually cock the hammer back. After firing the round you worked the lever and cocked the hammer back again. You would repeat this for each shot. It was very difficult to have a constant cheek weld with a Spencer so the sight picture had to be re-established after each shot. All of the Spencers that I have handled had a pretty strong hammer spring. During the course of firing several rounds it does become a lot of work. In a battle Spencer armed men could and did fire as many as 150 or more rounds depending on the fight. Unless you have fired that many rounds in a Spencer you really do not know what work is involved in firing a Spencer. While better than a muzzle-loader, it is a lot of work and under stress it can be time consuming. A person would be very lucky to get 14 aimed shots per minute.

The Henry Repeating rifle is by far the best rifle to come out of the Civil War when a person looks at the ease of firing repeated aimed shots. You still had to grab cartridges from you cartridge box or havesack. They were loaded one at a time in the magazine. The magazine opened by running up the magazine follower and pivoting the top portion of the barrel shroud. This is a very quick and easy operation. There is no risk of dropping or losing part of the rifle in the process. 15 to 16 cartridges can then be loaded into the magazine and the magazine closed. The ease of operation makes the Henry Repeating rifle great for repeated shots and effortless. Working the lever will chamber a cartridge and also cock the hammer back. All that is needed is to aim and pull the tirgger. Working the lever again will give the user a very quick follow up shot. In fact soldiers armed with the Henry Repeating rifle could fire repeated shot without ever loosing their sight picture. A Henry Rpeating rifle was capable of firing 16 aimed shots easily in less than 20 seconds. In firing a 150 cartridges in a battle the fatigue factor is not there. At the Battle of Allatoona Pass, GA Frank Orcutt was able to fire more than 400 rounds. There is far less effort in firing a Henry Repeating rifle than a Spencer. Most ranges of battles were 200 yards or less and the ability to shoot your way out of a situation was extremely important if you were a scout. This has been documented more than once. Repeated follow up shots is a very important advantage and being able to fire a shot every second is a major plus.

While both the Spencer and the Henry were very good weapons the Henry Repeating rifle was far easier to shoot and operate. Unless a person has experience using both it is hard to tell just by reading about a weapon which one involves more work. The Henry Repeating rifle is far less work to operate and a better design than the Spencer. "Economy of motion" makes the Henry rifle without a doubt the best repeater of the war. The easy of manufacture would make the Spencer the best. Both the Henry and the Spencer had their advantages.
 
Last edited:
I always like that picture even though it makes me look old, well I guess I am. LOL I think because I write a lot about Henry rifles people may feel that I don't like the Spencer. The fact is that I have fired thousands of live rounds and blanks from both Henry rifles and Spencer rifles. In the 1980's I was one of the few reenactors using an original Spencer rifles and carbine at events and live fire shoots. I was the one that developed an inexpensive blank for the Spencer making it possible to shoot the Spencer at Civil War reenactments. I like both weapons but as to the one I would have used had I been in the Civil War it would be the Henry rifle. As I mentioned above the Spencer rifle is just a lot of work and if you life would depend on it I would rather have as many rounds in the magazine rather than to have to think about reloading after just 7 shots.
Jim%20&%20Me%20Vernon%202011.jpg

Custer's Cavalry with the Spencer Rifles
 
Last edited:
The North imported foreign arms like the Enfield and Lorenzo muskets to supply their troops with arms and they didn't have the production capacity to supply repeating arms to every soldier. Arms back then were hand made and there was no interchangeability like in modern guns. You couldn't have 10 different factories back then producing gun parts for a gun co. to assemble into a gun. That slowed down the manufacturing process.
 
I always like that picture even though it makes me look old, well I guess I am. LOL I think because I write a lot about Henry rifles people may feel that I don't like the Spencer. The fact is that I have fired thousands of live rounds and blanks from both Henry rifles and Spencer rifles. In the 1980's I was one of the few reenactors using an original Spencer rifles and carbine at events and live fire shoots. I was the one that developed an inexpensive blank for the Spencer making it possible to shoot the Spencer at Civil War reenactments. I like both weapons but as to the one I would have used had I been in the Civil War it would be the Henry rifle. As I mentioned above the Spencer rifle is just a lot of work and if you life would depend on it I would rather have as many rounds in the magazine rather than to have to think about reloading after just 7 shots.
Expired Image Removed
Custer's Cavalry with the Spencer Rifles
Expired Image Removed
Wilder's boys blasting rebs.
Expired Image Removed
I have a Navy Arms .44-40 repro and love shooting it. I would give a left arm for an original Henry rifle. I would actually take a Henry over anything if I were in the war as a partisan or a raider or a scout. It makes good sense. I have original Spencers and love my original Berdan Sharps rifle. I just enjoy the romance of the use of these firearms during the war. The debate on the best will never be totally settled to everyone's satisfaction. I like very much your tributes to both the Henry and to the Spencer. You do great work on the repeaters.:thumbsup:
 
Henry cartridges were loaded with a 216 grain bullet and 26 to 28 grains of black powder depending on the manufacturer. It was a good cartridge for under 100 yards but was capable of hitting targets out farther, 200 to 300 yards.
44hptd.jpg

The Spencer cartridge was loaded with a 350 to 365 grain bullet loaded with 35 to 40 grains of black powder depending on manufacturer. It was a good cartridge for under 100 yards but was capable of hitting targets out farther, 200 to 300 yards.
spencerandshot002.jpg

Too many times people assume that it is easy to hit targets at long range. The reality is that it is difficult to hit targets at unknown ranges with black powder cartridges with low velocity. These cartridges have a huge rainbow arc for a midrange trajectory. Neither the Henry cartridge or the Spencer are likely to hit a target with the first shot at unknown ranges past 100 yards. In fact even the muzzle-loading target rifles could not hit past 100 yards at unknown ranges with the first shot.

The Henry and the Spencer made history with there use in the Civil War. Tactics changed as a result of those using either rifle. Wilder and others proved that a regiment armed with a repeating rifle could hold off or even force from the field an enemy force 2 or 3 times their size.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top