Repeaters

Hoover's Gap is just down the road from me and I know several diggers that scour the gap at every chance. I own several Spencer cartridges and casings from there and to my knowledge they haven't recovered a Henry casing or dropped cartridge from there. Just saying, but the total ground has yet to be covered.
 
The ballistics of the Spencer round are rather unimpressive when compared to modern arms but when compared to say a .577 or .58 not as hard hitting but hard hitting enough. It was an honest to god rifle round, if mediocre, where the Henrry was a pistol round fired out of a long barrel. The Henry Rifle is a 100 yard gun the Spencer Rifle a 300. Both could make a lot of smoke and noise in a short while. W/ the Henry being able to make more racket, the reality of hitting more wasn't there as you were only creating more smoke to try and see through.

IMO the Spencer is superior to the Henry in every way except that the Henry holds twice the rounds... and loaded is abolut a third again the weight. If I were to choose between a Henry & a Spencer I would take the Spencer rifle hands down.

The Henry had reliability issues though some vehemently deny it. The exposed magazine feed spring collected mud & dirt. The lack of a forearm made grasping the barrell uncomfortable during rapid fire, rapid fire heats up the barrel... The open ejection port on top also was a way in for dirt. And the Henry isn't as quick and easy to clean as the Spencer.

The Henry gave some impressive performances during the war, at Allatoona Pass in particular. They didn't worry about ammo for two reasons. First they knew they were going into a nasty fight and brought extra ammo on the train w/ them and second Allatoona Pass was a supply depot, w/ a sizeable amount of ammo there already. The 7th IL started out manning the rifle pits and were pretty quickly driven into the works where they did continue to give good service. IMO they helped decisevly slow one attack but their contribution was not the saving factor. Though they certainly said they were. The long range enfilade fire provided by the 4th MN & devestating fire from 6 cannon had more than a little contribution to the repulse. It was in Winchesters best interest to hype every little bit of press he could fromthe Henry rifle, it helped sell Winchesters. You can find claims of 6 & 800 yard shots from a Henry... pure moonshine.

As I said in an earlier post the Henry was never adopted by any military in the world. Only two lever action repeaters were. The M1866 by the Turks... who actually discarded it fairly quickly, though it gave good service at the siege of Plevna. The other was the M1895 by the Russians (who loved it) which had only the lever in common w/ a Henry.

The Henry saw very little actual combat whereas the Spencer saw extensive service during and well after the war. The Spencer also saw combat on more than one continent. Part of the reason they are not more common today is that the US sold them and they sold like hotcakes. The French in particular liked them, a lot. The Prussians were impressed w/ them but opted not to get a different weapon than they already had as they didn't want to logistically screw themselves. By the time other nations were looking at the Spencer Spencer had been bought out by Winchester and put out of business.

The Henry/Winchester is a darling of powder burners and the Hollyweird crowd because it looks cool. But the reality of the "Wild West" is that settlers & cowboys bought what they could afford and while the Winchester was popular it was far from universal, largely due to the high price tag. A surplus muzzle loader could be had for a couple dollars, a good Sharps, w/ a DRAMATICALLY more powerful and more accurate round was less than half the price of a new Winchester. To quote a professional soldier: "The Henry and Winchesters were good ranch guns, the Sharps, Rolling Blocks and Peabody's were good military guns."
JS, this is off the original OP but after reading your post I have a question. I have a '73 Winchester with the surprisingly small caliber of 22 short. The barrel appears as thick as one of larger caliber but with the small bore makes it very heavy; lots of steel. Were these intended for ranchers and varmints? It just looks impractible to me.
 
But the heavier shot and the larger grain??

The .44 Henry cartridge used a 200 to 216 grain bullet and 26-28 grain of BP depending on the manufacturer. The Henry round had a muzzle velocity of 1125 fps and muzzle energy of around 568. The Spencer .56-56 used a 350 grain bullet and about 45 grains of BP again depending on the manufacturer. The Spencer had a muzzle velocity of around 1200 fps and muzzle energy of 1125. Concerning the concept of "stopping power" the Spencer cartridge has the advantage. Generally speaking the great the muzzle energy the more "stopping power". With that said the Henry round has a greater muzzle velocity and energy than the .45 ACP and no one every said that is was a bad cartridge for defense. Then there is the thought that if you wound one soldier it takes 2 to carry the wounded soldier off taking out 3 for the price of one bullet. Then too the Henry holds twice as much with the ability to put twice as many soldiers out of action than a loaded Spencer, well at least in theory.

The midrange trajectory at 100 yards was about 4 inches for both cartridges. At 200 yards the midrange trajectory is about 15 to 18 inches for the Henry round and about 15 inches for the Spencer. Once you get out to 300 yards the the midrange trajectory is measured in feet making hitting a target very difficult. If you are shooting at known ranges you can adjust your sights according, however if you estimate a range incorrectly you will miss. NRA Black Powder Silhouette shooting is made easier since the ranges are known ranges out to 500 meters. During the Civil War ranges were estimated making first round hits on targets of 250 yards and farther very difficult. If a person missed and saw where the bullet hit then a second shot might end in a hit.

No matter how you look at it the Henry and the Spencer rifle were very limited if the ranges were greater than 250 yards. If the war would have lasted a year or 2 longer more than likely the entire Union army would have been armed with both the Henry and Spencer rifle and carbines with more being armed with the Spencer. Production methods of the Spencer made it a lot easier and faster to produce than the Henry. Once the war would have been over there would have been a lot more "surplus" Spencers for sale. Again the Spencer was a dead end rifle design while the Henry lived on in the Improved Henry later known as the M1866 Winchester.

Heavier and more grains, it is a matter of what a person would prefer, a rifle with a 7 shot magazine or a rifle with a 16 shot magazine. It would also depend on what your job was. It does make for an interesting discussion.
 
JS, this is off the original OP but after reading your post I have a question. I have a '73 Winchester with the surprisingly small caliber of 22 short. The barrel appears as thick as one of larger caliber but with the small bore makes it very heavy; lots of steel. Were these intended for ranchers and varmints? It just looks impractible to me.
It was an Eastern plinker. They used several in the shooting galleries back East.
 
Notice that there is no loading gate on the .22 model 1873.
1k.jpg
 
Notice that there is no loading gate on the .22 model 1873.View attachment 12540

Yes, no loading gate. I assume it is loaded at the end of the tube but there but not sure how to remove that smooth plug without damaging something. Any ideas? Also, note the size of the .22 bore compared to the diameter of the barrel. Don't guess warping is a concern.:smile:

photo(104).JPG


photo(105).JPG
 
Some Spencer carbines were used.It was denied by the secretary of war,but Spencer took one to Lincoln himself and persuaded him to testshoot it.Of course Spencer,a businessman,let the president win the testshoot.Production started soon after.
 
There will always be the argument of which rifle is better, the Henry or the Spencer. They each have their strengths and weaknesses. Personal opinions aside let us look at the facts, some of which have already been covered.



Characteristic​
Henry​
Spencer​
Advantage​
Length
43.625"
47"
Henry, 3.375" shorter
Weight (empty)
9.25 lbs
10 lbs
Henry, slightly lighter
Range
26-28 gr of powder
45 gr of powder
Spencer
Lethality
.44 caliber 200 or 216 gr round, muzzle energy 568
.52 caliber 350 gr round, muzzle energy 1125
Spencer, but are we looking for a lethal shot or to just disable an enemy combatant
Ergonomics
All metal barrel and magazine tube, conducts heat and the barrel gets hot
Traditional wood stock
Spencer, hot barrel is manageable with the full wood stock
Magazine Capacity
15 in magazine +1 in chamber
7 in magazine +1 in chamber
Henry, twice the magazine capacity
Rate of Fire
I didn't have the time to find the stat. Sorry
15 rds 1 min 14 sec (9/16/1864 test)
Henry, higher magazine capacity and the throw of the lever does it all in one cycle.
Action
Single cycle of lever, cocks the hammer and chambers and extracts the cartridge
Lever chambers and extracts, but hammer must be cocked manually
Henry action adds to rate of fire and staying on target. The shooter does not need to break his stock weld and lose point of aim.
Magazine Weakness(1)
Open slot under the barrel, could allow dirt and debris to cause a stoppage
Magazine plunger tube can be lost or damaged and requires a second hand or armpit to hold it
This is a wash. Both magazine systems can be damaged or limited.
Firing Pin
Forked firing pin
Single strike
Henry, with rimfire cartridges the priming solution did not always completely fill the rim. A forked firing pin allowed for two opportunities to make contact with the primer.



(1) Just an additional thought on the whole magazine issue with either rifle or any magazine fed rifle or pistol for that matter. A damaged or worn out magazine is one of the most common causes for a stoppage or malfunction in modern rifles and pistols. As with the Henry and Spencer, a damaged magazine does not take the rifle out of the fight. If the magazine tube of a Henry gets clogged with mud or crushed, it turns the Henry into a single shot breechloader. And if the plunger tube of a Spencer is lost or damaged, it too can become a single shot breechloader. Thereby both rifles can stay in the fight and still have a higher rate of fire than any muzzle loader out there.

Each rifle had its advantages and disadvantages. As for the range question, sure the Spencer's ball will carry farther than the Henry's. But is it an issue? We are not looking to make an 800 yard shot with a Henry or Spencer, that is for Hollywood. I am sure there are some of you out there that remember shooting the little green "Ivan's" on the pop-up range and remember that your front sight on your M16 completely covered your target and realize the challenge it would be to hit a moving individual at 300 plus yards.

As for the troops completely emptying their magazine, I don't think so unless they were being overrun. We have to remember that these Henry and Spencer armed troops, by 1863 and 1864, were veteran soldiers. They learned in their basic skirmish drill, in 1861 and 1862, that one rifle should always be loaded. Why do we think that they would have not carried this mindset or tactic over to a magazine fed weapon? In addition, several of the regiments that ended up carrying the Henry were trained sharpshooters, both the 66th Illinois Western Sharpshooters and the 64th Illinois Yates Sharpshooters. I doubt that they would be so foolish with their repeaters.

In closing I came across an interesting account of an officer in the 13th Indiana Infantry and his "solo" Spencer assault on Ft. Fisher near Wilmington, NC, January 13-15, 1865.

Lieutenant William Ketcham of the Thirteenth Indiana was close enough to see Adam's two brass Napoleon field pieces mounted in the sally port. He had seen their murderous effect on his fellow soldiers and he wanted to put the guns out of commission. Finding his regimental commander, Lieutenant Colonel Samuel Zent, he asked for permission to lead a detail of troops on an assault against the sally port. "That is just the thing," Zent responded. "Pick up a dozen men and go at it." Ketcham organized a detail from the Thirteenth Indiana – all armed with Spencer repeating rifles – and led them double-quick along the front of the landface toward the sally port Forty feet away from the guns, Ketcham saw Adam's gun crews rush out of the sally-port tunnel to man their battery. When they spotted Ketcham and his squad, the Confederates darted back into the bombproofed tunnel. Ketcham turned to urge his men forward, and was shocked to find he was all alone – the others had abandoned the charge and had taken cover. Ketcham saw a huger shell crater nearby and he promptly dived into it. Moments later he heard conversation and peered over the rim of the big hole, expecting to see that his squad had reappeared. Instead, he saw men in gray uniforms loading the guns just a few yards away. He checked his Spencer and was alarmed to find it clogged with sand, and unserviceable. Realizing he was in a serious predicament, he fished a tin cup and a big spoon out of his haversack and began digging furiously, burrowing himself down deep into the shell crater and out of sight.
 
Ok I am sure that this has been discussed befor but why the hell did the north not use repeating rifles? In units that used Winchesters the effective rate of fire was WELL above the norm. The more lead you put down range the better off you are.

There isn't a good excuse for the Union failure to more promptly use both (1) breech loading single-shot carbines, and (2) repeating rifles and carbines. It was probably the biggest blunder on the Union side during the entire War.

MIT Engineer and Pulitzer Prize winning historian Robert Bruce concludes the Federals would have won the War by Gettysburg at the latest if they had adopted single shot carbines and repeaters at a realistic pace.*

==================

*Bruce, Robert V. *Lincoln and the Tools of War*, (Urbana and Chicago, University of Illinois Press, 1987)
 
Ripley was so worried about waste of ammo....did he think the production lines couldn't keep the army supplied if it went to repeaters? Did Wilder's Brigade or any other unit using the repeaters ever have ammo resupply issues during the war?
 
Ripley was so worried about waste of ammo....did he think the production lines couldn't keep the army supplied if it went to repeaters? Did Wilder's Brigade or any other unit using the repeaters ever have ammo resupply issues during the war?

I am not aware of Wilder complaining about a shortage of ammo, particularly by comparison to the offsetting benefits he documented at Hoover's Gap and Chickamauga. Wilson also made effective use of Spencers at Nashville and later. He was a big fan of Spencers and I also don't recall him complaining about a shortage of ammo.

James Ripley had a nephew who was a Confederate general who maybe blackmailed his uncle with family secrets thereby causing James to drag his feet. ;-)
 
The 17th Indiana of Wilder's Brigade did run out of ammo at Hoover's Gap. Fortunately for them support came up in time to avoid a disaster.

Hoover's Gap was secure and as result of the action, the Achilles' heel of the repeating rifle was exposed and a prophecy fulfilled. The 17th Indiana had run out of ammunition. Fortunately for them they were within an easy ride back to Murfreesboro and Sgt. John T. Drury of Company E was sent back to retrieve additional cartridges.

The support for this account is from an unpublished diary of a member of the 17th Indiana. It is also part of an article that I wrote about the 17th Indiana and their Henry rifles. I am in the process of trying to get it published in one of the Civil War magazines out there.
 
Concerning the magazine of the Henry rifle, what people do not understand today is that the main reason for the magazine being changed in the Winchester's Improved Henry was mostly about production costs. It was far cheaper and faster to make a separate tube for the magazine rather than the way the Henry barrel and magazine are as one. Loading from the breech end using a loading gate was a way to construct the magazine using a separate tube. A bi-product of that is that you close up the slot in the Henry magazine allowing a wooden fore stock to be added. Yes, a tube magazine with no slot would keep dirt out if that was a problem which it seems was NOT a problem. If dirt in the slot was a problem I would like to find a few accounts of Henry users where that was a problem. People are fast to complain, if something is not working correctly there would have been comments about the magazine if it was a problem.
 
Regarding the Spencer-

I am convinced that one of the reasons that Custer made the poor tactical decisions he made at The Little Big Horn was that from 1863 onwards he had come to rely on the "firepower" his Spencer armed troopers could provide in battle.

When the 7th Cavalry turned in their Spencers to be replaced by single shot Trapdoor Carbines, Custer lost that all important "firepower edge." That was the first miss step made in the chain of events that led to the Massacre.
 
the only men ive ever heard of using the Henry rifle was one of Sherman's brigades, and even if that it was probably a company of men. But sooner there after they got them they were throwing them away and picking back up the single shot muskets since there was no abundant amount of ammo and on top of that the Henry wasn't even military issued it was a experiment to see how well if performed in the field.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top