Repeaters

No the Spencer is not a better rifle for the infantry. I have shot thousands of rounds in both the Henry rifle and the Spencer Rifle and Carbine. If my life was on the line and I had the choice of a Henry or a Spencer, without a doubt the Henry rifle would be a far better choice. I know others may not agree but I have shot both since I got my first Henry and Spencer back in 1979, reproduction Henry and original Spencer.

I think this question was best answered by Wilder's Brigade. His first choice was for the Henry rifle but for most of the men they had to settle for the Spencer rifle, an excellent second choice. However for the scouts of Wilder's Brigade and a few other lucky soldiers a few of the Henry repeating rifles were available. A much faster follow-up shot can be done with a Henry. Yes, a Henry repeating rifle is my choice. It is a very robust, ruggedly built rifle that was accuracte at all engageable ranges. 17 shots for the Henry and only 8 for a Spencer. Seems like a "No Brainer" to me.

But the heavier shot and the larger grain??
 
But the heavier shot and the larger grain??

The ballistics of the Spencer round are rather unimpressive when compared to modern arms but when compared to say a .577 or .58 not as hard hitting but hard hitting enough. It was an honest to god rifle round, if mediocre, where the Henrry was a pistol round fired out of a long barrel. The Henry Rifle is a 100 yard gun the Spencer Rifle a 300. Both could make a lot of smoke and noise in a short while. W/ the Henry being able to make more racket, the reality of hitting more wasn't there as you were only creating more smoke to try and see through.

IMO the Spencer is superior to the Henry in every way except that the Henry holds twice the rounds... and loaded is abolut a third again the weight. If I were to choose between a Henry & a Spencer I would take the Spencer rifle hands down.

The Henry had reliability issues though some vehemently deny it. The exposed magazine feed spring collected mud & dirt. The lack of a forearm made grasping the barrell uncomfortable during rapid fire, rapid fire heats up the barrel... The open ejection port on top also was a way in for dirt. And the Henry isn't as quick and easy to clean as the Spencer.

The Henry gave some impressive performances during the war, at Allatoona Pass in particular. They didn't worry about ammo for two reasons. First they knew they were going into a nasty fight and brought extra ammo on the train w/ them and second Allatoona Pass was a supply depot, w/ a sizeable amount of ammo there already. The 7th IL started out manning the rifle pits and were pretty quickly driven into the works where they did continue to give good service. IMO they helped decisevly slow one attack but their contribution was not the saving factor. Though they certainly said they were. The long range enfilade fire provided by the 4th MN & devestating fire from 6 cannon had more than a little contribution to the repulse. It was in Winchesters best interest to hype every little bit of press he could fromthe Henry rifle, it helped sell Winchesters. You can find claims of 6 & 800 yard shots from a Henry... pure moonshine.

As I said in an earlier post the Henry was never adopted by any military in the world. Only two lever action repeaters were. The M1866 by the Turks... who actually discarded it fairly quickly, though it gave good service at the siege of Plevna. The other was the M1895 by the Russians (who loved it) which had only the lever in common w/ a Henry.

The Henry saw very little actual combat whereas the Spencer saw extensive service during and well after the war. The Spencer also saw combat on more than one continent. Part of the reason they are not more common today is that the US sold them and they sold like hotcakes. The French in particular liked them, a lot. The Prussians were impressed w/ them but opted not to get a different weapon than they already had as they didn't want to logistically screw themselves. By the time other nations were looking at the Spencer Spencer had been bought out by Winchester and put out of business.

The Henry/Winchester is a darling of powder burners and the Hollyweird crowd because it looks cool. But the reality of the "Wild West" is that settlers & cowboys bought what they could afford and while the Winchester was popular it was far from universal, largely due to the high price tag. A surplus muzzle loader could be had for a couple dollars, a good Sharps, w/ a DRAMATICALLY more powerful and more accurate round was less than half the price of a new Winchester. To quote a professional soldier: "The Henry and Winchesters were good ranch guns, the Sharps, Rolling Blocks and Peabody's were good military guns."
 
Regardless of which rifle a person might prefer, the Henry or the Spencer there are certain facts about each. There is the historic fact written by those that lived during the time period and there are facts from today with test firing of the two weapons. The historic facts state time and time again of hitting man size targets easily out to 500 yards and farther. Many like to dismiss this as fantasy but they are willing to believe other information from the time period. Then you have the modern day testing. While there is no rimfire ammunition for either the Henry or the Spencer, centerfire ammunition can be loaded to duplicate both rimfire cartridges. In these tests it shows that without a doubt both the Henry rifle and the Spencer can hit a man size target at 300 yards with about the same level of accuracy and are capable of hitting man size targets at twice that distance, at a 50% accuracy rate. Pure moonshine, maybe for someone that may not have ever fired a Henry rifle or a Spencer rifle at distances.

Some will try to point out reliability issues but offer no research to back up the claim. While I have found 3 or 4 sources where a Spencer rifle got out of action, that does not mean the Spencer was plagued with problems. The historic reseach does not bear out that the Henry was unreliable, in fact the only souce that mentioned the fact that a Henry magazine failed was due to a horse stomping on it. I would dare to say a Spencer would have been out of action also. The modern day testing just does not support that the Henry rifle was an unreliable weapon. I have yet to see a single Henry to be out of action due to a magazine issue of fouling or dirt in the magazine. I have over 30 years shooting Henry rifles and being around others with Henry rifles, this has been in all kinds of condition rain, snow, mud etc. This problem has never surfaced. So historic research and modern testing just does not support the statement that the Henry rifle was not a reliable rifle.

The open ejection port on top is also a way for dirt to get in no matter a Henry or a Spencer. Again in over 30 years of experience and being around many armed with a Henry rifle I have never encountered this. Also the historic reseach does not bear this out either. As far as cleaning, one does not clean any easier than the other. I have cleaned both Henry rifles and Spencers and find not difference in the easy of cleaning either.

It matters not that the Henry rifle was never adopted by a country as their firearm. The Henry rifle evolved into the "Improved Henry" rifle as it was first advertized. It was later that it took the designation as the M1866 and both shot the exact same round. The Spencer never evolved because of being a "dead end" design.

The Henry rifle saw extensive service and action in the Civil War. Sherman's Army had several regiments armed with the Henry as mentioned before. The Historic research does back up the claim of Civil Wasr usage and in any battle Sherman and others were involved in. Were there more Spencer, yes, but to say the Henry did not see much action in the Civil War is again not an acturate statement.
Expired Image Removed
Here is our group of Henry rifles, we had 23 men armed with Henry rifles even though not all made it for the picture. Not one of these rifle got out of action due to a magazine issue of dirt etc.

To sum up, both the Henry rifle and the Spencer were excellent repeating rifles for their time during the Civl War. The historic research proves this. One may prefer the Henry or the Spencer but then that does not mean the other was highly inferior to the other. The Henry was more difficult to make than the Spencer therefore fewer were produced. Wilder's Brigade and the First Maine Cavalry were armed with both the Henry and the Spencer. They both preferred both compared to the alternative. Historic research and modern day testing will usually answer any quetions a person has concerning the Henry or the Spencer.

The Henry and the Spencer rifles are always great topics for discussion and research. I respect other's opinions and it is easy to say IMO and I will respect that but then there is also fact. Fact and opinion are 2 different things. I like the Henry and the Spencer both and have shot both thousands of time at all distance, cleaned them and even used them in the "field" with rain, snow, cold, mud for days at a time. They both are fun and reliable weapons.

Check out the link for my research on the Henry rifle as well as some info on the Spencer. there are well over 100 sources from which the information came from and these are listed.
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/
 
Not one of those men in the pic spent any real time on campaign with them in the Georgia mud. There is a difference between a range and combat conditions and that difference is rather dramatic. See France 1914-1918. Two days in the field, shooting blanks does not a combat test make. History shows the Henry relegated to civilian service because it wasn't up to the task of a military rifle.

A 600 yard shot w/ a .44 RF... 50% of the time... um no.

The Henry is a pretty rifle, it blows a lot of smoke and makes a lot of noise. There are those who look for an excuse to carry one in the field at a powder burning event. It is a very unit and campaign specific weapon and unless doing a unit specific impression really has no place on the field.

The US military didn't adopt the Henry or the follow on 1866, 1874 or any other lever action repeater for a variety of reasons, in fact their service in any military in the world was extremely limited, only the M1866 was used and that by the Turks who rapidly found a replacement for it as it did not hold up to the rigors of war. 30 years later the m1895 (a radically different weapon) was adopted by the Russian Czar, they loved it and believed it gave good service. 150 years, two armies adopted lever action repeaters on a relatively limited scale... there was a reason that designs such as the remington Rolling Block, Peabody, Martini/Henry etc prevailed. History hath spoken.

The Henry is grossly over hyped for what it was.

I've said my bit.
 
For laying down a field of fire the Henry wins hands down! Using a Spencer to fire consecutive rounds you have to (1) work the lever, (2) manually cock the hammer, and (3) then pull the trigger for each shot. In using a Henry all you have to do is (1) work the lever and (2) pull the trigger to fire the next round. That is three (3) steps for the Spencer v.s. two (2) steps for the Henry. I'll take a Henry every time!

J.
 
It was said earlier in this thread that stopping power was almost irrelevant. I concur. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off 200 unaimed shots per minute -- that's one thing. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off more than 1,000 unaimed shots per minute -- reactions like fight or flee go to the front burner.

Seems to me that "stopping power" is overblown (unless you're talking about drug-induced berserkers. Hah! Got a Norwegian reference in there.) So a belligerant is hit with what is essentially a plinking round, he is still hurt and generally begins crawling to the rear. Two drop out to help him. Hit one and you have three less to shoot at and shooting at you.

One of the reasons the .223 was developed was to wound rather than kill. (The other was the weight of the ammunition. Maybe that plastic wonder was cheaper.)

I'm probably wrong, but I have to guess that 60 rounds of .58 weighed about the same as 200 rounds of Henry or Spencer ammo.

Overwhelming fire power.
 
It was said earlier in this thread that stopping power was almost irrelevant. I concur. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off 200 unaimed shots per minute -- that's one thing. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off more than 1,000 unaimed shots per minute -- reactions like fight or flee go to the front burner.

Seems to me that "stopping power" is overblown (unless you're talking about drug-induced berserkers. Hah! Got a Norwegian reference in there.) So a belligerant is hit with what is essentially a plinking round, he is still hurt and generally begins crawling to the rear. Two drop out to help him. Hit one and you have three less to shoot at and shooting at you.

One of the reasons the .223 was developed was to wound rather than kill. (The other was the weight of the ammunition. Maybe that plastic wonder was cheaper.)

I'm probably wrong, but I have to guess that 60 rounds of .58 weighed about the same as 200 rounds of Henry or Spencer ammo.

Overwhelming fire power.

Well, for a minute or 2 then it'll get real quiet while all those Henrys are being reloaded 1 round at a time. If I'd had a choice I'd take the Spenser with the Blakeslee box reloads.
 
Well, for a minute or 2 then it'll get real quiet while all those Henrys are being reloaded 1 round at a time. If I'd had a choice I'd take the Spenser with the Blakeslee box reloads.
My understanding has been that the reloading tubes were not common.

It has also been that, while one was dropping in one cartridge at a time, someone else had done that already and could lay down a field of fire down-range. (You shoot 18 or 8, and another guy shoots 9 or 4. Some few guys have a few shots left while you're reloading.) I suspect that more than a few had some shots left while you were loading. Result? A continuous rain of lead headed downrange.
 
My understanding has been that the reloading tubes were not common.

It has also been that, while one was dropping in one cartridge at a time, someone else had done that already and could lay down a field of fire down-range. (You shoot 18 or 8, and another guy shoots 9 or 4. Some few guys have a few shots left while you're reloading.) I suspect that more than a few had some shots left while you were loading. Result? A continuous rain of lead headed downrange.
Sounds much to sensible for a bunch of young really scared, excited guys to pull off while under fire. As far as the boxes goes I'm not sure, Perhaps some of our gun experts can let us know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ole
Sounds much to sensible for a bunch of young really scared, excited guys to pull off while under fire. As far as the boxes goes I'm not sure, Perhaps some of our gun experts can let us know.
I'm absolutely, positively certain that they will have some facts. I'm going on speculation of what kind of panic/calm might have existed under such pressures.
 
The Blakslee box came about at the tail end of the war, not a lot were issued out, though the men who captured Jeff Davis had them. IIRC the first issues were in the spring of 65.

FWIW at Allatoona Pass about 50-75 men of the 7th Illinois were standing behind Rowetts Redoubt when the Missouri Brigade came over the top of the breastworks and they volleyed then emptied their Henry Rifles into the faces of the CS. Not suprisingly the CS attack stopped in its tracks, but the 7th still fled hell bent for the Star Fort to their rear. That masssive roll of fire gained the rest of the defenders enough time to make it safely into the Star Fort, to include the Napolean they manhandled the 250 or so yards back into the Star Fort.

In the right situation the Henry was superb, but the Henry Rifles in the hands of the skirmishers in the rifle pits didn't keep them from being run back to the works.

The cost of the Henry was prohibitive for the army. The Spencer less so. Whenever I hear this weapon or that weapon was so superior to another I'm reminded of all those excellent Panthers that were rolled over by waves of T-34's. A competant adversery learns how to deal w/ an enemy wielding a superior weapon.
 
I'm absolutely, positively certain that they will have some facts. I'm going on speculation of what kind of panic/calm might have existed under such pressures.

I got mad when I got shot at. Others reacted differently. You DO react though, and learn that any emotional reaction is not a good thing. You try for calm after awhile, but never get there. To tell you the truth after a bit you get to like it. The rush is addictive. : )
 
The cost of the Henry was prohibitive for the army. The Spencer less so. Whenever I hear this weapon or that weapon was so superior to another I'm reminded of all those excellent Panthers that were rolled over by waves of T-34's. A competant adversery learns how to deal w/ an enemy wielding a superior weapon.

Very well said sir.
 
I got mad when I got shot at. Others reacted differently. You DO react though, and learn that any emotional reaction is not a good thing. You try for calm after awhile, but never get there. To tell you the truth after a bit you get to like it. The rush is addictive. : )
Essentially what I was getting at, Major. I've not been in that situation and don't really know what I would do in that situation.
 
Education is a great thing and we can all learn from each other. A big advantage of the Henry repeating rifle was the fact that its magazine could be topped off. Rarely did a solider fire his Henry rifle dry and then reload. There was the occassion when the enemy was at short range where they would dump the entire magazine. Topping off was the order of the day and taking aimed shots. The design of the Spencer did not led itself to topping off the magazine efficiently. Skirmish regiments armed with Henry rifles were rarely driven from the field.

During the Selma campaign where Blakeslee boxes were in use two of them blew up while being carried on horseback with the rounds bouncing up and down on each other.
 
The best book out there for Spencer Rifle and Carbine information is "Spencer Repeating Firearms" by Roy Marcot.
The best book concerning the Henry rifle is "The Story of Benjamin Tyler Henry and his famed Repeating Rifle" by Les Quick.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top