Major_Fool
Private
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2013
- Location
- Los Angeles
Read my article on the web page, the sources are listed in it.
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/civilwarusage.htm
Respect
Read my article on the web page, the sources are listed in it.
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/civilwarusage.htm
No the Spencer is not a better rifle for the infantry. I have shot thousands of rounds in both the Henry rifle and the Spencer Rifle and Carbine. If my life was on the line and I had the choice of a Henry or a Spencer, without a doubt the Henry rifle would be a far better choice. I know others may not agree but I have shot both since I got my first Henry and Spencer back in 1979, reproduction Henry and original Spencer.
I think this question was best answered by Wilder's Brigade. His first choice was for the Henry rifle but for most of the men they had to settle for the Spencer rifle, an excellent second choice. However for the scouts of Wilder's Brigade and a few other lucky soldiers a few of the Henry repeating rifles were available. A much faster follow-up shot can be done with a Henry. Yes, a Henry repeating rifle is my choice. It is a very robust, ruggedly built rifle that was accuracte at all engageable ranges. 17 shots for the Henry and only 8 for a Spencer. Seems like a "No Brainer" to me.
But the heavier shot and the larger grain??
It was said earlier in this thread that stopping power was almost irrelevant. I concur. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off 200 unaimed shots per minute -- that's one thing. When you're facing a hundred guys and they can get off more than 1,000 unaimed shots per minute -- reactions like fight or flee go to the front burner.
Seems to me that "stopping power" is overblown (unless you're talking about drug-induced berserkers. Hah! Got a Norwegian reference in there.) So a belligerant is hit with what is essentially a plinking round, he is still hurt and generally begins crawling to the rear. Two drop out to help him. Hit one and you have three less to shoot at and shooting at you.
One of the reasons the .223 was developed was to wound rather than kill. (The other was the weight of the ammunition. Maybe that plastic wonder was cheaper.)
I'm probably wrong, but I have to guess that 60 rounds of .58 weighed about the same as 200 rounds of Henry or Spencer ammo.
Overwhelming fire power.
My understanding has been that the reloading tubes were not common.Well, for a minute or 2 then it'll get real quiet while all those Henrys are being reloaded 1 round at a time. If I'd had a choice I'd take the Spenser with the Blakeslee box reloads.
Sounds much to sensible for a bunch of young really scared, excited guys to pull off while under fire. As far as the boxes goes I'm not sure, Perhaps some of our gun experts can let us know.My understanding has been that the reloading tubes were not common.
It has also been that, while one was dropping in one cartridge at a time, someone else had done that already and could lay down a field of fire down-range. (You shoot 18 or 8, and another guy shoots 9 or 4. Some few guys have a few shots left while you're reloading.) I suspect that more than a few had some shots left while you were loading. Result? A continuous rain of lead headed downrange.
I'm absolutely, positively certain that they will have some facts. I'm going on speculation of what kind of panic/calm might have existed under such pressures.Sounds much to sensible for a bunch of young really scared, excited guys to pull off while under fire. As far as the boxes goes I'm not sure, Perhaps some of our gun experts can let us know.
I'm absolutely, positively certain that they will have some facts. I'm going on speculation of what kind of panic/calm might have existed under such pressures.
The cost of the Henry was prohibitive for the army. The Spencer less so. Whenever I hear this weapon or that weapon was so superior to another I'm reminded of all those excellent Panthers that were rolled over by waves of T-34's. A competant adversery learns how to deal w/ an enemy wielding a superior weapon.
Essentially what I was getting at, Major. I've not been in that situation and don't really know what I would do in that situation.I got mad when I got shot at. Others reacted differently. You DO react though, and learn that any emotional reaction is not a good thing. You try for calm after awhile, but never get there. To tell you the truth after a bit you get to like it. The rush is addictive. : )
Essentially what I was getting at, Major. I've not been in that situation and don't really know what I would do in that situation.