Repeaters

Yup. my math was off by a decimal place. I hate it when I'm dyslexic. However, 89k, 44.5K, or 22.25K in only one state is a substantial number of weapons. The other Northern states also built armed militias which were largely armed with 3rd and 4th class weapons.

What you have done is exactly what responsible CWT do when a mistake is made. We all have feet of clay.

Your correction is in stark contrast to bogus content maliciously posted just to provoke arguments.
 
I keep seeing this commentary from you... have you ever managed to actually fire one of the weapons you are criticizing, handle one? Any period arm for that matter? There is a very real difference between reading something in a book or website and actually using it. A big difference between the range and the field.

There is also a big difference between an honest post like yours & malicious misinformation.
 
There is also a big difference between an honest post like yours & malicious misinformation.
At any moment I'm waiting for the "that's the way it works in video games!"

You don't have to be an expert to comment on a subject. But when you've never even handled what is being discussed and those who have speak… maybe one should listen. Instead we get laughter emojis and further evidence that some commenting double down on never needing to handle what they're talking about. Knowledge vs experience… well I'll take actual experience over book learning.

I'm reminded of when my grandfather was sent to Iowa State University by the govt to teach learned college professors how to farm. Why? Because he was getting something like 40 bushels per acre more than educators said was possible. A man with an 8th grade education teaching college professors… imagine that happening today.

Kind of like these conversations. This is the way it works! Ok, have you ever even handled what you're talking about? I don't need to! From his words it's clear he hasn't. From common safety practices to basic handling… then he utterly discounts the words of those who have. Much like a keyboard commando walking up to a combat veteran and telling him he would have done it better… well probably not face to face, it's safer and less humiliating behind the anonymity of a computer screen.
 
At any moment I'm waiting for the "that's the way it works in video games!"

You don't have to be an expert to comment on a subject. But when you've never even handled what is being discussed and those who have speak… maybe one should listen. Instead we get laughter emojis and further evidence that some commenting double down on never needing to handle what they're talking about. Knowledge vs experience… well I'll take actual experience over book learning.

I'm reminded of when my grandfather was sent to Iowa State University by the govt to teach learned college professors how to farm. Why? Because he was getting something like 40 bushels per acre more than educators said was possible. A man with an 8th grade education teaching college professors… imagine that happening today.

Kind of like these conversations. This is the way it works! Ok, have you ever even handled what you're talking about? I don't need to! From his words it's clear he hasn't. From common safety practices to basic handling… then he utterly discounts the words of those who have. Much like a keyboard commando walking up to a combat veteran and telling him he would have done it better… well probably not face to face, it's safer and less humiliating behind the anonymity of a computer screen.

If the whole point is just argument for argument's sake, facts are irrelevant.

A great strength of CWT is its open format. Honest actors can ask questions, pose theories & engage in fact based discussions. Another Civil War forum I regularly read & occasionally post on is academic. Some have footnotes significantly longer than the posting. On CWT the standards are more informal.

An eternal reality is that with freedom comes responsibility. Responsibility requires honest action & integrity, i.e. character.

Your posts are always examples of what upholding those standards can be.
 
Last edited:
You don't have to be an expert to comment on a subject. But when you've never even handled what is being discussed and those who have speak… maybe one should listen. Instead we get laughter emojis and further evidence that some commenting double down on never needing to handle what they're talking about. Knowledge vs experience… well I'll take actual experience over book learning.

In terms of actual experience versus book learning, I would rather submit that - for example - British army officers examining the Spencer for possible adoption by the British army in the post-Civil-War period would have a good idea of what they didn't like about the Spencer. If they complain that the Spencers that they actually had available didn't fire very quickly, and if they complain that they had jams and stoppages, then surely we should take their views seriously?

But of course nobody alive is a British army officer from the 1860s or 1870s. Instead, fortunately, they wrote down their opinions... which we can find in, yes, books.

To look at a specific example.
You stated:
I keep seeing this commentary from you... have you ever managed to actually fire one of the weapons you are criticizing, handle one? Any period arm for that matter? There is a very real difference between reading something in a book or website and actually using it. A big difference between the range and the field.

And this was in response to 67th contending that:

When breechloading rifles like the Snider and Trapdoor became available, the repeaters advantages disappeared, because their rate-of-fire was not greater than these weapons. Hence it was a "no-brainer" to abandon them in the late 1860's as obselescent. With the first full power bolt-action rifle (the Lebel) it had the same problem, because rounds were loaded individually.

Oddly, the US Navy's Model 1885 Remington-Lee rifle really pointed the way forward, with detachable box magazines...
Which is to say, that the repeater's advantage was in rate of fire over muzzle loading rifles, but that it had no rate of fire advantage over a single shot full power breechloader.

And we have period documentation from British tests of repeaters and single shot breechloaders, which shows that they tested the rate of fire of breechloaders and repeaters and they found that the repeaters and single shot breechloaders had comparable sustained rates of fire.

Now, as it happens, militaries around the world had the option of a repeater or a single shot full power breechloader. And they... went for the single shot full power breechloader.


That is to say, militaries around the world in the period in question - including the US army - considered the question, and rejected the repeaters. And we have actual period documentation of the testing which caused the British to reject the repeaters - and they did so, among other reasons, because the Snider had comparable rate of fire to the repeaters. Not greater.

I can't actually provide that documentation right now because the search on this site is messed up, but I have provided it in the past. The question is - would you actually accept it in the first place? It's book information, after all...
 
Now, as it happens, militaries around the world had the option of a repeater or a single shot full power breechloader. And they... went for the single shot full power breechloader.

The State of New York tested the Spencer in 1867 for possible adoption of their militia. Using the magazine, the Spencer was far slower firing than the breechloaders or a Spencer using the Stabler cut-off. The mechanism broke during trials, as it did when tried by Lincoln (twice), in British trials etc.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top