Henry Rifle Production and Availability Difficulties
By: Andrew L. Bresnan 2014
Winchester Collectors Association #7839
The Henry Repeating Rifle was the first successful repeating rifles. Benjamin Tyler Henry was given a patent for his design October 16, 1860. His rifle was a revolutionary design that allowed for sixteen shots to be fired in just a few seconds, unlike any other rifle of its day. The Henry repeating rifle was in higher demand than the New Haven Arms Company could produce. Had the New Haven Arms Company been able to produce the Henry repeating rifle as fast as the other rifles were produced the Civil War would have ended a year or two years earlier if issued to soldiers in mass.
The New Haven Arms Company from the beginning was only able to produce a few rifles to at most around two hundred rifles a month. At its best they were able to produce four hundred rifles a month. That is a far cry from the demand for the rifle. John Wilder wrote the New Haven Arms Company wanting to place an order for nine hundred Henry repeating rifles. That number would have been equal to the entire production for three to four months. The company just could not produce any more rifles. Therefore Wilder's ordered was denied however there were a few Henry repeating rifles for sale. The scouts of Wilder's Brigade were able to arm themselves at their own expense with the Henry Repeating Rifle. While Wilder's Brigade is most noted for using Spencer Rifles there were an estimated 50 to 150 Henry repeating rifles used in Wilder's Brigade. The Henry repeating rifle would allow the scouts of Wilder's Brigade to shoot their way out of a tight situation if need be. 1
The reasons for the slow production rate are many. When the New Haven Arms Company began it had plenty of good machinery for the task. They had several milling machines, lathes, drill presses, rifling machines, screw press, and more. Although they had the machinery they still needed money to begin construction of the tools and fixtures needed to manufacture Henry rifles. During this interim time period it is thought by researchers of the Henry rifle that The New Haven Arms Company turned to other manufacturing facilities to act as subcontractors. 2
Once the New Haven Arms Company was established it started making everything needed for the brass frame Henry rifle. 3 The first brass frame Henry rifles were made beginning in the spring of 1862. Again keep in mind the production run of these was still very low, less than two-hundred per month. July of 1862 the New Haven Arms Company had produced enough Henry rifles to begin to work on some of their back orders. 4
Production of the Henry rifle was slow which meant sales were also slow. This brought the added problem of debt and lack of investors to keep the machines turning. By 1863 both sales and orders picked up. For the first two and a half years of production sales and profits were not something the New Haven Arms Company was to see. 5
It seems that when business picked up in 1863 there was a failure to increase the workforce even when additional machinery was purchased. As with many partnerships tension between Benjamin Henry and Oliver Winchester increased. In December of 1863 Winchester leased the Dwight, Chapin & Company armory in Bridgeport, Connecticut. Winchester's reason for this was to expand the production of the Henry rifle. Because of the tension between the two men the production at the Bridgeport armory did not begin immediately. It was not until September, 1864 that the Bridgeport facility was in full operation. 6
No sooner had the Bridgeport facility started up there was an order for five hundred Henry rifles from the Kingdom of Bavaria. These five hundred Henry rifles are different from previous Henry rifles in that there was a slightly altered method of loading the rifle. The use of a sliding cover rather than a swivel barrel section was used to open the magazine. 7 At any rate this order becomes an issue in that these five hundred rifles are being shipped out of the country. That many Henry rifles could have been used to fill orders that would have been used in the American Civil War. That many Henry rifles would have been enough to arm a regiment of infantry.
One of the problems was the fact that their facility was just too small but a bigger problem was that Benjamin Henry did not have the machinery needed to increase production. Oliver Winchester tried to find new lathes and other equipment. Another problem that existed was the lack of skilled workers to run the machinery. During wartime Civil War many of the skilled workers were off fighting the war. Those that were hired could only produce so many products. When coupled with wages for workers the New Haven Arms Company struggled not only to make rifles but to make money.
Most companies today do not make 100 percent of the product they are putting out. There are subcontractors making parts that are used in the finished product. The same was true with the New Haven Arms Company. Barrels for example were not made in house but in England, according to one source. The main supplier of barrels for the Henry repeating rifles was the English & Atwater Company of Liverpool England. In a letter to the company Oliver Winchester complained about late deliveries of barrels and that it was difficult to keep the machinery running in his factory making Henry repeating rifles without having the needed barrels. He complained on August 12, 1863 that he placed an order for 5,000 barrels but only 600 were delivered. He also complained that past due orders of over 1000 barrels had not been delivered. 8 Without barrels for making rifles the factory was out of work. One of the leading experts on the Henry rifle stated to me that the New Haven Arms Company made their own barrels in house. He stated that they did purchase bar stock from England and the bars were machined in-house to create rifle barrels with integral magazine tubes. 9 The production of barrels was a difficult time consuming process. The Henry barrel and magazine were machined from the same piece of bar stock. Not only did the bar stock have to be bored and rifled the magazine also had to be bored. On top of that the magazine collar also needed to be machined. All of this slowed down the production of rifles that just could not be increased.
In the meantime Oliver Winchester tried to increase supplies of other parts such as the finger lever. He ordered five thousand iron finger levers from Arcade Malleable Iron Company. 10 These were probably unfinished forgings and finished in the New Haven facility. 11 His hope was by the time the delivery of barrels/bar stock picked up that he would have enough other parts to continue production. The sad thing for the New Haven Arms Company was that orders kept coming in that the company had to turn down for lack of rifles to sale. The company would never surpass the four hundred per month production rate. Even at that rate of production that only amounts to 4800 rifles per year if the rate of production could have been maintain which was not likely.
It is also said that at least for some of the iron frame Henry repeating rifles the frames were subcontracted out to Colt as well as the butt plates. 12 One source states that it was plausible that Colt may have even produced the first run of iron frame Henry rifles given the amount of money paid Colt by Oliver Winchester in 1861. Even though this is stated by one of the leading researchers of Winchester Arms he also mentions that it remains a matter of speculation.After the initial production it is said that all of the frames were cast and machined at the New Haven factory. 13
Iron was more difficult to work with than brass and in the beginning of production the New Haven Arms Company was trying to figure out which material they could use and be profitable. There were approximately 400 iron frame Henry repeating rifles made at the most. There were separate serial numbers for the iron frame rifles and for the brass frame rifles. That meant you could find a brass frame and an iron frame Henry rifle with the same serial number. 14 Examples of the dual serial number for iron frame and brass frame Henry rifles are serial numbers 12, 20, 31, 43, 66, 78, 117, 149, 156, 176, 205, 215, 287, 325, and 355. These are iron and brass frame rifles with the same serial number that are known to still exist. 15
According to Herb Houze, one of the leading Henry researchers, the New Haven Arms Company produced nearly all the components for the brass-framed Henry rifle in-house. The only parts that were subcontracted were sling swivels and springs from Colt. 16 The purchase of sling swivels from Colt is recorded in that firm's business ledgers. However no mention is made in the ledgers of any other parts purchases. 17
Even after the New Haven Arms Company had all of the parts to complete a rifle it was still a slow task of fitting all of the parts by hand. The use of lathes to cut the necessary dovetails for the rear sight was time consuming. Most of the early rifles made had a dovetail cut in the frame as well as the barrel for the rear sight. This is true for both the brass frame and iron frame rifles. 18 About a third of the way through production of the Henry repeating rifle the frame dovetail was discontinued. There was also the problem with the two prong firing pin. Early on there were reports of breakage of around twenty five percent. The firing pins were beefed up and a warning to users not to "dry fire" the rifle. 19
Slowing down production was a potential problem of the magazine. The rotating collar that needs to be turned in order to load the magazine could rust shut when exposed to the weather if not kept oiled. 20 This in turn prevents the magazine from being loaded. Another potential problem was the slot that ran the length of the magazine. The potential was there for mud and/or debris entering the slot thus jamming the magazine preventing the feeding of cartridges to the action. 21 The first problem was solved with the magazine door that was developed for the Bavarian order. However it was not looked upon as a proper fix so it was not used on Henry rifles destined for the US market. This is evident by the later production Henry rifles that were manufactured with the same magazine as the early models.22 The problem of the open slot running the length of the magazine would not be solved in the Henry rifle but would be addressed in the "Improved Henry Rifle" latter to become know as the Model 1866 Winchester. 23 The research and development of the above two potential problems, although needed to be done, also slowed down production and took resources away from manufacturing of rifles needed for the US war effort in the Civil War.
The New Haven Arms Company had several inquiries from those that wanted to purchase Henry repeating rifles. Several of these inquiries unfortunately were turned down. In a letter dated October 16, 1862 from the New Haven Arms Company to Joseph Stewart the company mentions that due to the several changes in the Henry rifle that Stewart wanted they would have to decline his order. His changes included the possibility of a set trigger, globe front sight and the possibility of a telescopic sight as well as a longer barrel. Secretary Cauklin responded that these changes would cause too much of a delay. 24 In another letter from Secretary Cauklin to Charles T. Wells dated October 16, 1862 Cauklin also mentions that they are unable to fill an order for twenty rifles. 25
On November 4, 1862 Cauklin writes to Mr. Kittredge of Cincinnati, Ohio. Kittredge has inquired about buying twenty Henry rifles at $36 each and also receiving a discount. Cauklin writes, "We are obliged to decline your order as we have all that we can attend to for the next three or four months." 26 The New Haven Arms Company produced a very innovative rifle but could not produce it fast enough for the orders coming in. Cauklin also writes John W. Brown of Columbus, Ohio on November 11, 1862 explaining that they are "obliged to decline your order as we have all that we can make…" 27 Kittredge must have been persistent in his inquires. Oliver Winchester writes to him on November 14, 1862. Winchester states, "We have received three letters from you in relation to Henry's Repeating Rifle, to which we replied as briefly as the contents would allow stating that our orders were considerably in advance of our supply and that we could not receive any more at the present." Winchester goes on to tell Kittredge that he is not the most honorable person in his intentions and business. He accuses Kittredge of ordering enough Henry rifles to be given a discount and the selling them below cost. He could still make a profit since he also had the discount. Winchester also states that he thinks that Kittredge is interested in another rifle, possibly the Wesson rifle, and to use his influence to injury the sale the Henry rifle. Winchester states that Kittredge is not only unfair but dishonorable. Kittredge wanted a monopoly on sales and to drive his competitors out of business according to Winchester. The letter goes on and Winchester uses of phrase that is interesting. He states, "Our purpose is to guard our business from any such influence and our rifles from becoming a football in the market." I like the term "football in the market". I think that many may view that as a more modern term. 28 Winchester was very suspicious of Kittredge. In a letter to John W. Brown of Columbus, Ohio dated November 25, 1862 Winchester states, "We sent you today a letter we received from Ira Brown of Cincinnati for 10 rifles. We referred him to you. We more than half suspect that he is an agent of Kittredge. This of course you can best judge for yourself." 29
Oliver Winchester writes to Mayor Franklin A. Stratton of Suffolk, Virginia on April 11, 1863 in response to an inquiry form him. This would have been right at the beginning of the siege of Suffolk by General James Longstreet. Winchesters states that he is enclosing a circular describing the Henry rifle. Winchester also answers an apparent question by the Mayor if Winchester has sold any of the Henry rifles to the government. The answer Winchester gives is "We have never sold any to the general government." 30 He goes on to say; "The demand for them in the west, particularly in Kentucky where they are very popular, has so far taken all we could make with our present facilities." 31
The New Haven Arms Company is a company that is just barely producing enough of their Henry rifle to peak the interest of the public. The fortunate ones that are able to purchase a Henry rifle have inquired about changes that could be made, especially sights. In a letter dated April 15, 1863 Winchester answers one such inquiry. The gentleman had asked about the possibility of a globe front sight or possibly a telescopic sight. At any rate Winchester's response to the gentleman was, "We presume any good gunsmith that you may find in Philadelphia can do this." 32
I do find it interesting that although Henry rifles were difficult to come by due to limited manufacturing capabilities, Winchester offered discounts to people who could purchase a minimum of ten rifles. In a letter dated April 16, 1863 to a Mr. S. Downing Winchester states, "We also enclosed a circular with list of retail prices, on the price we will make a discount of 10 percent only when ordered by the case of 10. If you can make up a Club of 5 to take half a case we will make you an exception and take care of the same discount that we make by the case." 33 Then Winchester goes into the fact there are regulations to try to keep his rifles out of disloyal hands and what Downing needed to do. Winchester suggests that the best way to ship the rifles is by Express rather than the Mail. He explains that if the shipment is lost and sent by Mail then the government is not responsibly but if shipped by Express and you take their receipt the Express Co. is responsible. 34
By May of 1863 The New Haven Arms Company is so far behind in manufacturing of the Henry Rifle there is no hope of filling any large orders. A Colonel G. Harris had written Winchester with inquiry of a large number of Henry rifles. Winchesters quotes him a price of $36 per rifle with slings. In addition Winchester gives him a price for the cartridges of $14 per 1000. However the following statement is made by Winchester which leads one of little hope of completing the order. "Our orders are now two months in advance of our supply our facilities are small and we can make only aabout two hundred per month, from which you will see that it will require seven months from this time for us to complete an order for on thousand." 35
Winchester is really up against a brick wall in the production efforts of the New Haven Arms Company. He not only can't keep up with demand he also has a shortage of workers. The workers that he does have are some of the highest paid workers in the arms industry at that time. Winchester states, "We are doing all we can to increase our production but our efforts will not tell for some time to come as we have to work a long time to get our machines made at big prices and hire hands at extravagant wages." 36
The New Haven Arms Company was producing a revolutionary weapon that in the end changed military rifles. They started the age of rapid fire rifles. However the government was slow to jump on board staying with a single shot rifle for most of the late 1800s. Even their attempt at a repeating rifle with the Krag rifle in the 1890s was a failure as it was a dead end rifle for the military lacking the speed of reloading that the Mausers had with the use of stripper clips. The 1903 Springfield was really a Mauser with a few refinements. With the use of semi auto and full auto the age of rapid fire came into its domination. The M1 Garand proved that in WWII. The Henry Repeating Rifle was the beginning of the evolution of the true repeating rifle. With the difficulties that Benjamin Tyler Henry and Oliver Winchester faced with the production of the Henry Repeating rifle it is a wonder that the design did not just die at the end of the Civil War as did many other rifles including the Spencer rifle. Although only about 10,000 Henry repeating rifles were used in the American Civil War the Henry rifle had a huge impact on the concept of repeating fire for future generations.
Andrew L. Bresnan 2014
Winchester Collectors Association #7839