Question on Tactics

I once tried to "simplify" for a group the "theory"/"practice" of fire at the time of the 19th century (much of which applies very basically today albeit in very different stats, properties, etc). It turned out to be one of those monologues in a comedy club that gets only one person laughing at the back of the room who the rest of the audience decides you have paid and "planted". I put in a good amount of effort coming up with easy examples, etc. I never wasted my time again. :hot:

Oh yea. I have every sympathy for your situation. What is the polite way to say that the reason you don't get it is that you don't now enough to get it?
 
Having once been a Skill-at-Arms instructor and an Infantry Training instructor (NOT the same thing) I found there were two ways to do it. 'By the book' - as insisted upon by the various schools - or 'in your own words'. The former was always used on inspections and assessments and the latter when no one else was watching. Most classes preferred the latter. Of course you preceded any new course of instruction by 'naming of parts' or explained new terms and actions. To ensure understanding, the classes were always quizzed until they gave the right answers. Explaining was rarely 'by the book'. For example - the book says 'Feel in the breech' (checking for any round in the breech on a No4 or SLR. However, once the breech was open (bolt open or working parts on the hold-open catch), it was always explained as "Stick your little finger in that 'ole" and demonstrated by holding up a right-hand fist but with the little finger extended (knuckles towards group) and then theatrically moving that hand to the open breech, adding "It even works at night." They never forgot.

I do appreciate that you can't always do that with a group of tourists who haven't a clue, but working along those lines does help.
 
In a lot of cases, the reason for drill books for these kinds of minor tactics (things like wheeling, etc.) is because these things are very simple concepts (a wheel is when the unit turns, in the same way a moving car turns) but you need to explain that so that hundreds of individual people all know what to do, under chaotic conditions.

It sounds very easy to form an orderly line of people a set distance apart, but if you actually try it without practice beforehand it will turn out that it is not. Similarly, to actually wheel one method to wheel a company (I admit I'm not sure offhand if it is the only ACW method) is that the man on the inner edge marches at standard pace but with small steps (nine inches per), the man on the outer edge marches at standard pace with large steps, and everyone in between keeps in line with touch of elbows:

8. TO WHEEL ON THE MARCH
RIGHT WHEEL - MARCH

On MARCH, the right guide begins the wheel taking nine-inch steps. The men turn their heads AND touch elbows to the LEFT. The left guide marches at the normal step, the rest of the Company adjusting the step to suit. The wheel continues until either of the following:

  • HALT: the Company halts and dresses right;
  • FORWARD - MARCH: the Company marches forward dressing right.


This is a way of doing it that requires only that you train men in keeping step, have them at the right arrangement that they can reach out their elbows and maintain contact, and that you teach them how to march at nine inches so that whoever is the right guide can march at nine inches. These are fiddly things to teach and deserve practice; the best way to learn is by doing them over and over until you get them right.


The result of all this, multiplied over every manoeuvre in the drill book, is that a commander can tell their unit what to do (using a few key words or words of command) and the unit just does it, which simplifies the job of managing a unit enough that the commander can think about what the correct things to order are without being worried that it will go wrong. But to get that level of drill takes a lot of time.


Actually coming up with all of this off the cuff would take ages! Which is why drill books exist, and before printing presses you had veterans who knew how it was done and so you had a kind of institutional knowledge - and of course, you need the drill book before you can start teaching, if you're learning out of the drill book. For this reason the actual minor tactics of an army tend to be set several years in advance, though it is possible to add new bits to the tactical tool kit. You just need to turn what you want done into a set of instructions that make it clear to someone who does not already know what everyone has to be doing in order for it to work, and then you teach them that.


Of course, just because a drill book exists and you were given lessons from it is no guarantee you will actually follow it. My understanding is that in many cases a line of battle (which is supposed to be properly dressed, evenly spaced and parallel) will actually be closest to that when stationary, in the ACW, but when advancing it will be a bit more ^ shaped with the flag at the point, for example - the men are following the flag, not aligning with it, at least while it is moving.
 
Did the introduction of rifled muskets have an impact on tactics or did that happen postwar. I am guessing drill books were written during smoothbore era.
 
Did the introduction of rifled muskets have an impact on tactics or did that happen postwar. I am guessing drill books were written during smoothbore era.
A lot of what is in the drill books would largely not change for the rifled-musket. Close order drill is still necessary to control a unit and move it around the battlefield.

There are things which can change as a result of the introduction of the rifled musket, but it requires that the military in question really lean into it. In effect, the role of skirmisher in the musket days (sometimes with a jager rifle or the Baker rifle or a rifle a tige or just with smoothbores) would have certain roles and assumptions, and you can do those just the same with a rifle-musket.

The British Army's main drill changes had actually come prior to the rifle musket - their drill book omitted the command to "fire" in 1833 AIUI. This was part of the process of converting their line infantry to light infantry by default.

I think the biggest actual change that comes out in doctrine instead of in terms of when you order each part of the drill book (e.g. you order skirmishing at 500 yards instead of 100 yards, you have more of the army do it, things like that) is that it becomes part of the standard assumptions of the British Army in the 1850s that you keep the enemy hundreds of yards away from the main body of the army as a matter of course - ideally over 1,000 in flat terrain! That is, unless the enemy is actually attacking and pushing in your skirmishers you keep them half a mile away. That is a pretty big change.
 
One of the changes was the quicker pacing for maneuvering.
It might be that that happened in some countries, but I wonder if any drill book in the rifle-musket era prescribed a pace as quick as the "English Gallop" of the American War of Independence. Under the British drills current in that war, 80 paces per minute was only when fully encumbered with the marching order, while 100-120 paces was the standard step, described then as "an easy walk" and 150 paces per minute was the approach march (and even faster for the charge) - by contrast in the Napoleonic Wars, 75 paces per minute was "ordinary" and 108 was "quick".
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top