NYC Terrorist Plot

Was "terrorist" a commonly used term in 1864? If he were hung, it would likely be for something else.
 
Insurgent

Was "terrorist" a commonly used term in 1864? If he were hung, it would likely be for something else.

From the start of the 61-65 fracas Northern chronicalers used the term "Insurgents" in reference to the Southern energetics. Gideon Wells, Lincoln's Secretary of the Navy, used the term frequently, as did William Tecumseh Sherman. I've seen much usage of the word terror in period; none of the pronoun "Terrorist". Anyone come across this usage?
 
The earliest use of the term "terrorists" that I am familiar with is in conjunction with the Zionist irregulars (can't spell the military version of gorilla) in the struggle for the liberation of Palestine ( Formation of the nation of Isreal)
I think this is a mid 20th century term..
 
From the start of the 61-65 fracas Northern chronicalers used the term "Insurgents" in reference to the Southern energetics. Gideon Wells, Lincoln's Secretary of the Navy, used the term frequently, as did William Tecumseh Sherman. I've seen much usage of the word terror in period; none of the pronoun "Terrorist". Anyone come across this usage?
The link posted in #1 has paragraph from David Homer Bate's fine 1907 book Lincoln in the Telegraph Office of the United States Military Corp during the Civil War. Though the vanacular isn't exact: "The attempt to set fire the city of New York is one of the greatest atrocities of age. There is nothing in the annals of barbarism which evinces greater vindictiveness."
This falls in the category of "A rose is rose by...."
 
Word "Terrorism" used in the era of Civil War:

O.R.-- SERIES I--VOLUME 5 [S# 5]
Correspondence, Orders, And Returns Relating Specially To Operations In Maryland, Northern Virginia, And West Virginia From August 1, 1861, To March 17, 1862.
UNION CORRESPONDENCE, ETC.--#3
[Inclosure.]
TO His Excellency ABRAHAM LINCOLN,
President of the United States:
Please take the map of Virginia, Kentucky, and Ohio. You will find the most southern portion of Ohio near the junction of these three States, at which point the Big Sandy River, a river navigable for steamers at this season for 60 miles, almost due south, in the direction of the Great Southwestern Railroad and East Tennessee, enters the Ohio River, and which forms the common boundary of Virginia and Kentucky for a hundred miles.
[excerpt]
That part of the territory of Virginia watered by the Guyandotte and the Sandy Rivers is in a state of perfect anarchy, no one claiming to hold a civil office, and a perfect terrorism paralyzes every effort to restore law and order in that region; and such will be the state of the country as long as the rebel chiefs (Jenkins and Clarkson) are permitted to remain in that region and make their periodic raids through the same at pleasure. The people are divided in sentiment, but would flock to that power that would inspire confidence that they would be protected.
[excerpt]
And as in duty bound will ever pray, &c.
F. H. PEIRPOINT,
Governor of Virginia,
By H. I. SAMUELS,
Adjutant-General of Virginia.
H. I. SAMUELS,
Adjutant-General of Virginia.
RALPH LUTE,
Of Ohio.
-----
O.R.-- SERIES I--VOLUME X/2 [S# 11]
UNION CORRESPONDENCE, ORDERS, AND RETURNS RELATING TO OPERATIONS IN KENTUCKY, TENNESSEE, NORTH MISSISSIPPI, NORTH ALABAMA, AND SOUTHWEST VIRGINIA FROM MARCH 4 TO JUNE 10, 1862.--#1
HEADQUARTERS EIGHTEENTH BRIGADE,
Camp Brownlow, March 6, 1862.
Lieutenant-Governor FISK, Frankfort, Ky.:
DEAR SIR: I desire to submit through you to the honorable General Assembly of Kentucky the consideration of the condition of the Union men of the Sandy Valley. They have been robbed of all their means of defense by the rebel army which has lately been driven from this portion of the State.
[excerpt]
I earnestly commend this matter to the attention of your honorable bodies, hoping that immediate steps may be taken to shield this unhappy people from the terrorism which has reigned for the last three months. I am happy to assure you that the Union sentiment is rapidly growing among the people, and I believe they can now be safely trusted with their own defense and the maintenance of the Federal authorities in their midst.
Hoping that arrangements may be made for their protection when the troops under my command are withdrawn, I am, very truly, your obedient servant,
J. A. GARFIELD,
Colonel, Commanding Brigade.
--------------------------------------------------
O.R.-- SERIES I--VOLUME XX/2 [S# 30]
Correspondence, Orders, And Returns Relating Specially To Operations In Kentucky, Middle And East Tennessee, North Alabama, And Southwest Virginia From November 1, 1862, To January 20, 1863.
UNION CORRESPONDENCE, ETC.--#5
HEADQUARTERS FOURTEENTH ARMY CORPS,
DEPARTMENT OF THE CUMBERLAND,
Nashville, December 4, 1862.
General BRAXTON BRAGG:
GENERAL: With regard to General Orders, of your War Department, No. 84(+), I protest against it as inhuman and barbarous. These officers have had no hearing. The accusations on which the order was probably predicated have never been referred to their superiors, and it is highly probable that the persons who have made complaints against them have been following the savage and disgraceful system of guerrilla warfare, the effect of which is to breed robbers and murderers, and to carry war and desolation into peaceful communities. I speak from observation and conviction. As to complaints of outrages on citizens of Clarksville, were I to furnish you with a tithe of the complaints which I receive of the treatment of quiet and peaceful citizens, of loyal men, loyal to a Government older and having better title to claim loyalty than the one you represent, it would take a wagon to carry the communications on the subject. I have always and everywhere expressed my abhorrence of the system of harassing and arresting non-combatants, who are strictly so.
[excerpt]
I requested an expression of the same sentiments from the Confederate officers in Mississippi, but had not the pleasure of receiving it. I believe I may anticipate an expression of entire disapprobation of the system from you, and hope that you will forbid the system of terrorism and abuse by your troops of those peaceful people, who are supposed by them not to sympathize with your cause. Pillage and wanton destruction of private property is strictly prohibited and vigorously punished whenever detected. The burning of houses is only justified when they have been used as little fortifications. As to complaint No. 4, I think it so improbable as to deserve no comment.
I am, general, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
W. S. ROSECRANS,
Major-General, Commanding.
----------------------------------------------------------
[There are several more examples of 'terrorism' used as a term in the Official Records of the Rebellion]

M. E. Wolf
 
Because i can't help myself,it looks like Judah P Benjamin should have been tried in abstentia for these acts and attempted acts. Benjamin is still on my possible co-conspirator list involving Lincoln's assassination .

"Villain,Villian, Smiling ****ed Villian!" William Shakespeare
 
Because i can't help myself,it looks like Judah P Benjamin should have been tried in abstentia for these acts and attempted acts. Benjamin is still on my possible co-conspirator list involving Lincoln's assassination .

"Villain,Villian, Smiling ****ed Villian!" William Shakespeare


Curious as to why you think Benjamin might be involved. Why?


Lee
 
Curious as to why you think Benjamin might be involved. Why?


Lee
Martin and kennedy among others( example, ST. Alban's raid) reported to Jacob Thompson.His reports show Benjamin as his commander, along with his ordering Thompson home, after the recent debacle's and attempts, in December of 64.
The Richmond confederate posting of the coded time to start the New York fires, in the Oct.15th 1864 Richmond Whig ,shows the Confederate command's duplicity.
Booth's contacts and trips in these time periods to meet with Martin and Thompson is part of why I believe Booth may have been under direct command of Richmond until the end.
 
Wow. You've done some serious research obviously. Ok, thanks for the information and reply.


Lee
 
Elsworth_Avenger, sir;

Extremely good research and detail into the theory as to who all was involved in the terrorism within Union controlled boarders, e.g. NY fires, assassination of Pres. Lincoln, etc.; in regard to Judah P Benjamin
involvment.

I think this would be good enough to present to PBS "History Detectives" and or Ken Burns to investigate even further. And, I feel that you deserve the attention to these fine details of being yours first to be presented in a clear and convincing manner.

I think it would be worthy of a trial in abstentia . It would be very interesting to get a bunch of retired Judges, prosecutors, lawyers and create a Grand Jury and perhaps that trial in abstentia. (In my opinion)

Just some thoughts.

Respectfully submitted for consideration,
M. E. Wolf
 
Jacob Thompson


Recollections of a Confederate Staff Officer (Sorrel)
Chapter III—Reminiscences And Horses.
Visit to Mr. Francis Sorrel's country-seat—Interment of Captain Tillinghast, U.S. A.—Sir William Howard Russell, Times correspondent—McDowell and July 21st—Seward and the French princes—Army begins to march to Peninsula.
--------------------------------
Not long after the battle I set out on a visit to my father's country place, Ireland, fifteen miles from our camp. Hitching up two good mules to a light army ambulance, what we needed was put in, our intention being to bring back some delicacies for the messes. Captain Thompson, of Mississippi, one of the aids, accompanied me. He was an extraordinary looking person. Nature had been unkind. The son of Jacob Thompson, Buchanan's Secretary of the Interior, he had much to hope for, but for his affliction. His teeth and jaws were firmly set and locked, and no surgical ingenuity had yet succeeded in opening them. Liquids could be conveniently taken, but mechanical arrangements had to be made for solid food by the removal of some teeth.

This young officer showing a great desire to go along with me, was taken, although I could not help picturing some surprise on the part of my father and young sisters. We were made very welcome, as fresh from the glorious battlefield, and the day was a happy one. The girls had made a captain's coat for me out of homespun cloth; but such a fit! big enough for two captains of my thickness, it hung at all angles and flapped furiously in high winds. But love had prompted its making and I would never suffer any ugly remarks about it.
[excerpt]
Captain Thompson was not subject to military duty and soon returned to his home.
---------------------------------------------------------
Southern Historical Society Papers
Vol. VII. Richmond, Virginia, March, 1879. No. 3.
Official Correspondence Of Confederate State Department.
Letters from Hon. Jacob Thompson.
Wilmington, N. C., May 2, 1864.
Hon. J.P. Benjamin, Secretary of State:
Sir -- Mr. Clay did not arrive until after dark last evening; and he delivered to me your letter with its inclosures. Herewith you will find my receipt for the bills forwarded by you. We shall sail today at one o'clock in the "Thistle," which is considered by shippers as a safe boat, for Halifax; touches at Bermuda on the 13th instant, and the voyage thence to Halifax usually occupies four days. With no untoward event we will reach Canada by the 20th instant.
I am, &c., J. Thompson.
-----
Saint George's, Bermuda, May 10th, 1864.
To Hon. J.P. Benjamin:
Sir -- We reached this port safely this morning. While we were chased by a blockade vessel for five hours on our way out, yet we escaped with no further interruption than being forced to leave our true course for that length of time. I am informed today the steamer for Halifax is not expected to leave Saint George's before Monday the 16th instant.
I am, &c.,
J. Thompson.
-----
Telegrams.
Wilmington, N.C., April 29, 1864.
To Hon. J.P. Benjamin:
Arrived this morning. Six thousand bales of cotton burnt last night, which will delay all boats until Monday or Tuesday.
J. Thompson. care E. Salomon.
-----
Winston, N.C., May 2, 1864.
To Hon J.P. Benjamin:
Mr. Clay delivered me your letter with inclosures last night
J. Thompson.
-----
Wilmington. May 3, 1864.
Hon. J.P. Benjamin:
We think copies of President's message would serve our purpose. If you agree, send them. We can't go till Thursday
J. Thompson,
C.C. Clay, Jr.
-----
Southern Historical Society Papers
Vol. IX. Richmond, Va., July And August, 1881. Nos. 7 And 8.
The Attempt To Fasten The Assassination Of President Lincoln On
President Davis And Other Innocent Parties.
By Judge W.W. Cleary.
(The following paper was read before the Louisville Branch of the Southern Historical Society and well deserves a place in our records that the future historian may see what methods were employed to blacken the name and fame of Confederate leaders.)
On the 2d day of May, 1865, his Excellency, Andrew Johnson, President of the United States, published to the world the following proclamation -- viz:
"By the President of the United States:
"Whereas, it appears from evidence in the Bureau of Military Justice that the atrocious murder of the late President, and the attempted murder of the Hon. W.H. Seward, Secretary of State, was incited, concocted and procured by and between Jeff. Davis, late of Richmond, Virginia; and Jacob Thompson, Clement C. Clay, Beverley Tucker, George N. Sanders, W.W. Cleary, and other rebels and traitors against the government of the United States, harbored in Canada. Now, therefore, to the end that justice may be done, I, Andrew Johnson, President of the United States, do offer for the arrest of said persons or either of them within the limits of the United States, so that they can be brought to trial, the following rewards:
"One hundred thousand dollars for the arrest of Jefferson Davis; twenty five thousand dollars for the arrest of Clement C. Clay; twenty five thousand dollars for the arrest of Jacob Thompson, late of Mississippi; twenty five thousand dollars for the arrest of George N. Sanders; twenty five thousand dollars for the arrest of Beverley Tucker; ten thousand dollars for the arrest of W.W. Cleary, late clerk of C.C. Clay.
"The Provost Marshall General of the United States is directed to cause a description of said persons, with notice of the above rewards, to be published.
"In testimony whereof, I have hereunto set my hand, and caused the seal of the United States to be affixed. Done at the City of Washington, the 2d day of May, in the year of our Lord 1865, and of the independence of the United States of America, the eighty ninth.
Andrew Johnson.

"By the President: W. Hunter, Acting Secretary of State.
The evidence in the Bureau of Military Justice, upon which this accusation was brought against persons, some of whom had occupied high positions under the Federal Government, and all of whom through life had enjoyed the confidence of their fellow Citizens, and unblemished reputations as private gentlemen, was carefully withheld from the public by the Bureau of Military Justice, thereby depriving the accused of the opportunity of at once exposing the equally extraordinary and improbable perjuries by which the President was deceived into the issuance of the Proclamation; while, meantime, the exalted source from which this indictment issued, and the morbid excitement of the public mind, gave color enough to the accusation to subject the accused to an ignominy scarcely less than should have ensued upon full proof of guilt.
[excerpt]
Sandford Conover, examined by Judge Advocate Bingham, swore (see page 5), repeating four different times, in a variety of forms of expression, that late in January and early in February, 1865, and every day in the month of February, he held conversations with Hon. Jacob Thompson at the St. Lawrence hotel, in Montreal, touching the assassination.

Let me quote in full his statement of the alleged conversation:
Q. -- "State, if you please, what was said at that time by Mr. Thompson on that subject, in your presence?" A. -- "I had called on Mr. Thompson to make some inquiry about a raid which had been contemplated on Ogdensburg, N.Y., which had failed because the United States Government had received some intimation of the rebels there, and were prepared for it, and I called to hear what was to be done next, and being supposed by Mr. Thompson to be a good rebel, he said: "We would have to drop it for a time, but we will catch them asleep yet," and then he observed: "There is a better opportunity, a better chance to immortalize yourself and save your country." I told him that I was ready to do anything to save the country, and asked him what was to be done. He said: "Some of our boys are going to play a grand joke on Abe and Andy." That was his expression. This led to explanations, when he informed me it was to kill them, or rather remove them from office. To use his own expression, he said: "It was only removing them from office; that the killing of a tyrant was no murder."
Q. -- "State whether anything was said at that time on the subject of commissions from the rebel authorities in his hand, in blank?" A. -- "He had commissions, and conferred one on Booth. I am not so positive whether he had conferred it on Booth then or not; but he told me, either then or subsequently, that Booth had been commissioned, and that everybody engaged in the enterprise would be commissioned; and if it succeeded or failed, and they escaped to Canada, they could not be successfully claimed under the Extradition Treaty."
The fact is fully shown in the testimony herewith: First, that Mr. Thompson was not in Montreal at any time from the 1st of January to the 14th of February, being in the city of Toronto, nearly 350 miles distant; and second, by referring to page 27, it will be seen from the letter of this man Conover, certified to be genuine by United States counsel, General John F. Potter, that up to the 20th of March after, he did not even know Mr. Thompson, and was then seeking his acquaintance, as himself the originator of a proposition to destroy the Croton Water works, etc. This letter was sent by Mr. John Cameron, of Montreal, who testifies that, after Mr. Thompson had read the letter, he exclaimed: "Is the man mad? Is he a fool?" and declined any communication with him.
Again. See page 4, speaking of John H. Surratt.
Q. -- "You say you saw him in Montreal in April, last?"
A. -- "Yes, sir."
Q. -- "About what time in April was it?"
A. -- "It was within a week before the President's assassination. I think about the 6th and 7th of April -- somewhere in that vicinity."
Q. -- "You say you saw him in Thompson's room?"
A. -- "I saw him in Mr. Thompson's room."
Q. -- "State whether he gave any communication to Thompson in your presence in his room, and what that communication was."
A. -- "There was a conversation there at that time, from which it appeared that Mr. Surratt had brought dispatches from Richmond to Mr. Thompson. These dispatches were the subject of the consultation."
Q. -- "From whom in Richmond were the dispatches brought?"
A. -- "From Mr. Benjamin, and I think there was also a letter in cipher from Mr. Davis. I am not so positive as to the cipher, but there was a letter from him, whether in cipher or not."
Q. -- 'Do you mean Judah P. Benjamin, Secretary of State of the so called Confederacy?"
A. -- "Yes, sir."
Q. -- "You say the dispatches were the subject of conversation. What did they say was the substance of the dispatches, or what did they purport to be?" A. -- "I had some conversation with Mr. Thompson previously on the subject of a plot to assassinate Mr. Lincoln, and I had been invited to participate in that enterprise."
(This is the alleged conversation fully described above and disproved.)
Q. -- "By whom had you been so invited to participate in that enterprise?" A. -- "By Mr. Thompson, and on this occasion he laid his hand on the papers or dispatches there, and said this makes this thing all right, referring to the assent of the rebel authorities."
Q. -- "Did they speak of the persons that the rebel authorities had consented might be the victims of this plot?"
A. -- "Yes, sir; Mr. Lincoln, Mr. Johnson, the Secretary of War, the Secretary of State, and Judge Chase."
Q. -- "Did they say anything about any of the Generals?"
A. -- "And Grant."
Q. -- "I am not sure whether you have stated precisely. If you have not done it, I wish you would now, who were present at this conversation which you had with Jacob Thompson early in April, when he laid his hand on the dispatches."
A. -- "Mr. Surratt, General Carroll and myself"
Q. -- "Can you state whether any of these persons participated in the conversation?"
A. -- "General Carroll, of Tennessee, did. He was more anxious that Mr. Johnson should be killed than anybody else."
[excerpt]
continued
 
Southern Historical Society Papers
Vol. IX. Richmond, Va., July And August, 1881. Nos. 7 And 8.
The Attempt To Fasten The Assassination Of President Lincoln On
President Davis And Other Innocent Parties.
(continued)----

Richard Montgomery. This man was examined before the Military Commission by the Judge Advocate General, Judge Holt. The principal object of his testimony, so far as relates to the assassination of Mr. Lincoln, seems to be to fix guilt upon Mr. Jacob Thompson and myself Let me give a few extracts from the testimony:
Q. -- "State any conversation you may have had with Jacob Thompson in Canada, in the summer of 1864, in regard to putting the President of the United States out of the way, or assassinating him."
A. -- "During the conversation in 1864, Jacob Thompson said he had friends, Confederates, all over the Southern States, who were ready and willing to go any length for the good of the cause of the South, and he could, at any time, have the tyrant Lincoln and any others of his advisers that he chose put out of the way; that he would only have to point out the man he considered in the way, and his friends, as he termed them, would put them out of it, and that they would not consider it a crime when done for the cause of the Confederacy."
Q. -- "Did you, or not, see Thompson some time in the month of January, 1865, and where?"
A. -- "That was in Canada, in Montreal."
Q. -- "Will you state what he then said to you, if anything, in regard to a proposition which had been made him to rid the world of the tyrant, Lincoln?"
A. -- "He said a proposition had been made him to rid the world of the tyrant, Lincoln, Stanton, Grant, and some others; that he knew the men who had made the proposition were bold, daring men, and able to execute anything that they would undertake, without regard to the cost; that he, himself, was in favor of the proposition, but had determined to defer his answer until he had consulted his government at Richmond, and that he was then only awaiting their approval. He said that he thought it would be a blessing to the people, both North and South, to have those men killed."
Q. -- "This was in January?"
A. -- "That was in January last."
Q. -- "Did you meet Booth there?"
A. -- "No, Sir, I never saw Booth in Canada."
Q. -- "Did any of these men of whom you have spoken say that Booth was one of the men referred to by Jacob Thompson, who was willing to assassinate the President?"
A. -- "No, sir; W.W. Cleary told me. I related to him the conversation I had had, or a portion of it, with Mr. Thompson, in January, and he said that Booth was one of the parties to whom Thompson had referred." Now, Mr. Thompson was not in Montreal at any time in the month of January. The time and place of conversation with me is not stated, nor that any third person was present, so that it cannot be directly disproved, but since no conversation with Mr. Thompson took place in January, it could not be mentioned to me. As to the alleged conversation with Mr. Thompson in 1864, I here present, in full, the affidavit of an honored gentleman of this city, then residing in Canada, viz:
Province of Canada, city of Toronto, to wit:
I, John B. Castleman, at present residing in the city of Toronto, but formerly of Fayette county, in the State of Kentucky, an officer in the Confederate army, make oath and say:
First -- That I am well acquainted with Jacob Thompson and W.W. Cleary.
Second -- That I was in the city of Toronto in the early part of August last (1864), in the company of the said Jacob Thompson and W.W. Cleary, and know that Richard Montgomery, then passing under the name of James Thompson, was at that time known to them as a United State detective and spy from New York.
Third -- That said Montgomery was recognized and denounced as a Federal detective in the employ of United States Marshal Murray, within a few hours after his arrival in Toronto, by a friend from New York city, then present.
Fourth -- That the said Jacob Thompson and Cleary conversed with me at that time as to their knowledge of the true character of Montgomery, alias Thompson.
Fifth -- That Montgomery, so soon as he was discovered, left the Queen's hotel, where he was staying, and, I believe, the city of Toronto, for I, with others, searched for him and was unable to find him.
Sixth -- That I was on intimate terms with said Jacob Thompson and W.W. Cleary, both before and since the day on which Montgomery came to Toronto, and have never seen or heard of him being with them at any time, and do not believe he could have been in their company without my knowledge.
J. B. Castleman.
Sworn to before me, at the city of Toronto, this 19th day of August, A.D., 1865.
I. M. Canavan, Justice of the Peace.
[end of excerpt of a lengthy article]
-------------------------------------------------------------
NOTE: Jacob Thompson was a Colonel in the CSA Tennessee Army.
-------------------------------------------------------------
continued
 
Southern Historical Society Papers
Vol. X. Richmond, Va., April, 1882. No. 4.
The Story Of The Attempted Formation Of A N.W. Confederacy.
Letter from General Early
(It is well to give place in our records to the following clear and conclusive refutation of a canard which has been recently taking the rounds of the newspapers.
General Early's letter was originally addressed to the Lynchburg Virginian.)
To the Editor of the Virginian, -- During my absence in the South, what purports to be "A Story of the War," was published in your paper of the 17th inst., and it met my eye for the first time on yesterday. I am informed that it was copied from the Philadelphia Press, and it begins as follows:

THE HISTORY OF A CONSPIRACY THAT FAILED.
"Colonel T.A. Burr, a well known Confederate officer, tells the story of an attempt to release 20,000 Confederate prisoners at Chicago, Columbus and Sandusky in 1864, and to form a northwestern confederacy. Major C.H. Cole, of the Fifth Tennessee regiment, was the leading spirit of the plot. He narrowly escaped hanging, and is now a prominent railroad man in Texas. He received his instructions from Jacob Thompson, who was then in Canada, and was put in command of the department of Ohio, with headquarters at Sandusky. With the force of the 20,000 Rebels whom the conspirators intended to release, and with the active aid of the Northern sympathizers, it was thought that a northwestern confederacy was not impossible; and the time fixed for the assault on the camps where the prisoners were confined was gauged by General Early's attack on Washington, which was to engage the great force of our army, and make it impossible to reinforce the small body of Union soldiers in the Northwest, where there was almost open rebellion against conscription, and people were weary of war. It was first intended to strike the blow while the National Democratic Convention was in session at Chicago, and more than 4,000 Confederate soldiers and sympathizers were there ready for action. But, Early's delay striking Washington caused a postponement."
Then follow some very remarkable statements about the efforts of Major Cole to carry out the projected scheme.
As this story is republished in a paper printed at the place of my residence, and to which I am a regular subscriber, silence on my part might be construed into an acknowledgment of its accuracy. I therefore deem it proper and necessary to notice it, and to disclaim all knowledge whatever of the alleged plot or conspiracy. My first knowledge of it, and, in fact, even of the names of Colonel T.A. Burr and Major C.H. Cole, is derived from the publication from which the above extract is taken.

The project of sending my command to meet Hunter's force, then supposed to be in the Valley, and, after that was disposed of, to make the advance on Washington, was adopted at a conference between President Davis and General Lee, late in the afternoon of the 12th of June, 1864, and I began the movement early on the morning of the 13th. On arriving at Charlottesville, I found that Hunter was advancing on Lynchburg, and it became necessary for me to meet him at that place. After his retreat, and my pursuit of him beyond Salem, General Lee, in a telegram, submitted it to my discretion whether I should make the advance on Washington, and this was repeated in a telegram to me after I reached Staunton; and I assumed the responsibility of continuing the movement. This does not look as if my movement was a part of a scheme for releasing the Confederates in northern prisons, and establishing a northwestern confederacy. In order to reach the vicinity of Washington, north of the Potomac, it was necessary for me to get rid of the Federal forces in the lower Valley and at Harper's Ferry, and after this was done I had to fight another force at Monocacy Junction. Notwithstanding these obstacles in the way of my advance, I reached the front of the defenses of Washington, on the north, on the 11th of July, after a march which, for its rapidity, was unequalled by any march made by any force on either side during the war, or as I believe by any army in any modern war. I did not delay my attack on Washington, for I made none; but finding the defenses of that city occupied by a force much superior to my own, and that the grater part of two corps of Grant's army had arrived about or a little before the time of my own arrival, I retired across the Potomac, in order to save my command from destruction, as Hunter had arrived at Harper's Ferry, in my rear, with a force much larger than my own. I may say here, as I have stated on several occasions, that it was not a part of General Lee's plan that I should make an attack on Washington, but his instructions were that I should threaten that city in order to draw troops away from Grant's army. When I suggested to him the idea of capturing Washington, he said very emphatically that it would be impossible to do so. After I reached Sharpsburg, on my route to Washington, I received a dispatch by a messenger from General Lee, informing me that there was a scheme for releasing the prisoners at Point Lookout, by a naval expedition up the Chesapeake, and I was directed to send a calvary force towards that point, in order to cooperate in the scheme, if I found it practicable to do so. I did order General Bradley T. Johnson to move in that direction with his brigade, after cutting the railroads between Baltimore and Philadelphia and Baltimore and Washington; and he had started and crossed the railroad between Washington and Baltimore, when, having learned that two corps had arrived at Washington from Grant's army, he informed me of the fact by a courier who reached me in front of Washington on the night of the 11th of July. Realizing the fact then that there was no possible hope of capturing Washington, I determined to retire, and sent an order to General Johnson to rejoin me. The attempt to release the prisoners at Point Lookout was not made for reasons not at all connected with my operations.

If there was this scheme for releasing the prisoners in the North and Northwest, which was to be carried out in connection with my advance on Washington, it is a little singular that General Lee gave me no information of it when he informed me of the proposed attempt at Point Lookout?

I may further remark that, as the project of sending me to threaten Washington was first conceived on the 12th of June and I arrived in front of Washington on the 11th July, it was simply impossible that information of the fact could have reached the Confederate commissioners in Canada, and been sent by them to Sandusky, in Ohio, before I retired from the front of Washington.

It is said: "It was first intended to strike the blow while the national Democratic convention was in session at Chicago, and more than 4,000 Confederate soldiers and sympathizers were there ready for action. But Early's delay in striking Washington caused a postponement."

The Democratic convention for 1864, which nominated McClellan for President, assembled at Chicago on the 31st of August, a little more than seven weeks after I had retired from Washington. When that convention was held I was confronted by Sheridan in the Valley with very nearly 55,000 troops, according to the returns on file in the Adjutant General's office in Washington, while my whole force did not reach the fourth of that number. Was it expected that I should destroy Sheridan, then capture Washington, hold in check the entire force of the United States army, including all the troops in Kentucky, Tennessee and Missouri, while the 20,000 released prisoners should arm themselves, overrun all the Northwestern States and establish a North western Confederacy? Really, this "Story of the War" requires a vast deal of credulity and entire ignorance of the events of the war on the part of any one who accepts it as the truth.

The idea of introducing Mr. Jacob Thompson on board of a United States man of war as a "country aunt" is funny, to say the least of it. And the statement that "the Confederacy (in 1864) had plenty of money in its secret service fund," and that "there was something like $86,000,000 to the credit of the Confederate Commissioner and his colleague, Jacob Thompson, most of which was deposited at a bank in Toronto," is not excelled in its romanticism by that other story of Mr. Davis's carrying off over $2,000,000 in specie about his person when he was made a prisoner at the close of the war.

If there was any such secret fund, that is, a fund that would have been available in Canada, it must have been a very profound secret indeed, and such it will ever remain until that final day when all secrets shall be given up.

In regard to the mission of Mr. Jacob Thompson and his colleagues in Canada, the following statement is to be found in "The Rise and Fall of the Confederate Government," by President Davis, vol. 2, pp. 611-12:

"The opening of the spring campaign of 1864 was a favorable conjuncture for the employment of the resources of diplomacy. To approach the Government of the United States directly would have been in vain. Repeated efforts had already demonstrated its inflexible purpose -- not to negotiate with the Confederate authorities. Political developments at the North, however, favored the adoption of some action that might influence popular sentiment in the hostile section. The aspect of the peace party was quite encouraging, and it seemed that the real issue to be decided in the Presidential election of that year was the continuance or cessation of the war. A commission of three persons, eminent in position and intelligence, was accordingly appointed to visit Canada, with a view to negotiation with such persons in the North as might be relied upon to aid the attainment of peace. The commission was designed to facilitate such preliminary conditions as might lead to formal negotiations between the two governments, and they were expected to make judicious use of any political opportunity that might be presented.

"The commissioners -- Messrs. Clay, of Alabama, Holcombe, of Virginia, and Thompson, of Mississippi established themselves at Niagara Falls in July, and on the 12th commenced a correspondence with Horace Greeley, of New York. Through him they sought a safe conduct to Washington. Mr. Lincoln at first appeared to favor an interview, but finally refused, on the ground that the Commissioners were not authorized to treat for peace."

Mr. Davis makes no further mention of this mission in his book, and he says not one word, anywhere, of the alleged scheme for releasing the prisoners and establishing a Northwestern Confederacy.

t is true that there was a scheme gotten up, perhaps in the Fall of 1864, by some escaped Confederate prisoners, who had made their way into Canada, for the release of the Confederate prisoners at Johnson's Island; but that scheme proved an abortion, as the means for carrying it out were wholly inadequate. There was, also, a raid into Vermont, for the purpose of plundering some bank or banks; but none of these schemes had any connection whatever with my movement on Washington.

Permit me, in conclusion, Mr. Editor, to express my surprise that any respectable Northern journal should publish so absurd a story as the one I have thus noticed, and my still greater surprise that it should be copied into a respectable Southern journal.
J. A. Early.
February 23, 1882.
==================================================
 
Judah P. Benjamin

Southern Historical Society Papers.
Vol. XIII. Richmond, Va., January-December. 1885.
The Battle of Honey Hill.
By Colonel C. C. JONES, JR.
ADDRESS BEFORE THE SURVIVORS' ASSOCIATION OF AUGUSTA, GEORGIA, APRIL 27TH, 1885.
Friends and Comrades:
Since our last annual convocation two members of the Confederate Cabinet have died. On the 7th of May, 1884, within the quiet walls of his apartments in the Avenue Jena, in Paris; the Hon. Judah P. Benjamin, full of years and of honors, entered upon his final rest. With a lucidity of intellect, a capacity for labor, and an ability quite remarkable, he had, during the existence of the Confederate Government, occupied in turn the offices of Attorney-General, Secretary of War, and Secretary of State. The struggle ended, he repaired to England, where, claiming the privileges of a natural born British subject, he was admitted to the bar and rose rapidly to the highest eminence capable of attainment by a practitioner in the most august courts of that realm. His success was most phenomenal. When he laid aside his gown and wig, there was no one in the long list of advocates, lawyers, barristers, and Queen's counsel who could claim superiority over him. When, moved by age and warned by physical infirmities, he determined to seek that repose which had been fairly earned by long, laborious, and conspicuous service, the English bench and bar--distinguished beyond all others--united in public testimonials to his unsurpassed professional learning and abilities, and gave cordial expression to the general regret at his retirement from a practice which he had done so much to dignify and adorn. With our flag at half mast, on the 10th of May, we participated, at this remove, in the last tributes paid to this noted Confederate, as his body was committed to the earth in a land far distant from that which, during years of privation and peril, had claimed and received his loves and devotion.
[end of excerpt]
-----------------------------
Southern Historical Society Papers.
Vol. XIX. Richmond, Va. 1891.
Social Life In Richmond During The War.
[From the Cosmopolitan, December, 1891.]
BY EDWARD M. ALFRIEND.
[excerpt]
BENJAMIN, STEPHENS, YANCEY AND HILL.
I have never known a man socially more fascinating than Judah P. Benjamin. He was in his attainments a veritable Admiral Crichton, and I think, excepting G. P. R. James, the most brilliant, fascinating conversationalist I have ever known. He was a great social lion in Richmond during the war, and always shone most brilliantly whenever occasion gave him the opportunity. Mr. Benjamin loved a good dinner, a good glass of wine, and revelled in the delights of fine Havana cigars. Indeed, even while Richmond was in a state of siege he was never without them.
[end of excerpt]
-------------------------------------------------------
Southern Historical Society Papers.
Vol. XXV. Richmond, Va., January-December. 1897.
Judah P. Benjamin.
Sketch of the Life of this Remarkable Man.
HIS CAREER AS A CONFEDERATE.
An Anecdote of Him Told by Dr. Hoge--His Capacity for Hard Work. His Flight from Richmond at the Close of the War.
(H. T. Ezekiel in the Jewish South, December, 1897. )
One of if not the most unique personage connected with the government of the Southern Confederacy was Judah P. Benjamin, a Jew, as signified by his name.
Although this gentleman was one of the foremost lawyers of his day, a prominent United States Senator, at various times Attorney-General, Secretary of War, and Secretary of State of the Confederacy, and more latterly a Queen's Counsel in England, no history of his life has as yet been written. Such a work is now in course of preparation in England, and it was a request for data in connection therewith that led in part to the writing of this sketch.
Judah Phillips Benjamin was the son of English parents, and was born in 1811. His mother and father were on their way from England to New Orleans. Arriving off the mouth of the Mississippi river, it was found to be blockaded by British men-of-war, so their vessel turned back and put in at St. Croix. Here it was, on English soil, that young Benjamin first saw the light of day.
In 1815 the Benjamins moved to Wilmington, N. C., and ten years later, when only a lad of fourteen, Judah was sent to Yale. He remained there only three years, and left before taking his degree. Upon attaining his majority he was admitted to practice at the bar in New Orleans, and soon forged his way to the front. In 1847 he was engaged as counsel in the famous Spanish land cases, which involved the ownership of immense properties in California. For his legal services in this controversy he received the largest fee on record at that time, $25,000.
Mr. Benjamin in 1852 was sent to the United States Senate from Louisiana, and five years later he was re-elected. His colleague was Mr. Slidell, who afterward figured so prominently in the Trent affair. It was during this time that he was tendered a position on the bench of the Supreme Court of the United States, by President Franklin Pierce, an offer which was declined, he preferring to devote his time to private practice--for be it understood that "Mr. Benjamin, of Louisiana," stood second to no lawyer in the land.
In the Senate he was among the foremost, and Charles Sumner, whom he often opposed in debate, declared that Mr. Benjamin was the most eloquent speaker to whom he ever listened. The stormy days of '61 came on, and he, with the other Southern Senators, withdrew from that body. His farewell address occupied two days in its delivery, and was admitted by all to be the most eloquent and forcible effort on either side. It was in the main a demonstration of the legality of States' rights.
A GENIUS.
When the provisional government was formed at Montgomery, President Davis selected Mr. Benjamin as his Attorney-General. Upon the consummation of the Confederacy he was made Secretary of War, and later on, Secretary of State. An idea of the versatility and erudition of this genius, may be formed from the fact that he filled these three Cabinet positions to the satisfaction of the President and with credit to himself. Mr. Benjamin was commonly referred to as "the brains of the Confederacy," and it was a universal custom of President Davis's to turn over to him every matter that belonged to no particular department. So numerous were his duties; and so great his capacity for work, that it was not unusual for him to remain steadily at his desk from 8 A.M. one day, until 1 or 2 o'clock the next morning. In August, 1862, owing to overwork and some friction with others, he resigned, but not long afterwards President Davis insisted on his returning to the Cabinet. As much of the business of the Confederate Congress was transacted in secret, no great deal is known of its workings, but it is claimed by those acquainted with its inner affairs, that the greater portion of its important legislation was framed by Mr. Benjamin.
SELF--SACRIFICE.
An act performed in 1862 shows the true patriotism of the man. General Huger was in command of Roanoke Island and Mr. Benjamin was filling the post of Secretary of War. A requisition for powder was made and was not filled. This was twice repeated without avail, and Roanoke Island fell. An investigation was ordered by Congress, and it took but a few seconds for the Secretary to inform the committee that the powder had not been forthcoming for the best of reasons--there was none to send. The question then arose as to what might be the probable effect upon Congress and the people in general of this disclosure of the Confederacy's limited resources. It was decided that this would never do, and the committee was in a quandary. At Mr. Benjamin's own suggestion the committee recommended that he be censured by Congress for neglect of duty. History contains no parallel of such patriotism.
IN DANVILLE.
Mr. Benjamin evidently did not accompany the presidential party from Richmond to Danville on the fateful April 2, 1865, for on the following day he was met in the streets of the latter city by Rev. Dr. Hoge, of Richmond, who, after questioning him closely, learned that he, unlike the remainder of President Davis' Cabinet, was not the guest of Major Sutherlin. Being hard pressed by the reverend gentleman, Mr. Benjamin reluctantly admitted that he had, owing to the crowded condition of the city, been unable to secure board. (Dr. Hoge, in answer to a query, assures me that this was simply an accident and was in nowise attributable to race prejudice.) The clergyman, who was a great friend of Mr. Benjamin's, insisted that the latter should accompany him to his abode and share his apartments with him. This the Secretary refused to do, saying that Dr. Hoge's hostess was a stranger to him, and that it would be an unwarranted impertinence for him to intrude upon the family uninvited. Dr. Hoge allayed his fears after some argument, assuring Mr. Benjamin that any friend of his would be more than welcome to the household.
The following Sunday Mr. Benjamin gave an exhibition of his admirable tact, which can best be described in the words of Dr. Hoge:

"At the breakfast table the conversation turned to the subject of church services, and Mr. Benjamin inquired casually of our hostess where she was going to worship that day. Now, I happened to know that as a member of Mr. Davis' Cabinet, official etiquette demanded that he should accompany his chief to his (the Episcopal)church, and when our hostess replied, in a tone that almost implied an invitation, 'We are going to the Presbyterian Church to hear Dr. Hoge preach,' I wondered what Mr. Benjamin would do. He never hesitated a moment, but in his most affable manner asked: "May I have the pleasure of accompanying you ?'"
LEE'S SURRENDER.
After church the party was sitting in the parlor chatting when Mr. Benjamin, who had been called away, entered the room, and, after conversing nonchalantly for a short time, beckoned Dr. Hoge to follow him to their chamber. When they were there Mr. Benjamin said: "Dr. Hoge, I didn't have the heart to tell you before these ladies, something I want to communicate to you." He then went on to say that General Lee had surrendered. Mr. Benjamin's face never revealed what he suffered, "but," said Dr. Hoge in relating the incident, "I could not refrain from sitting down on the bed and weeping, a habit to which I am not addicted."
When Mr. Benjamin set out on his trip southward from Danville shortly after this, he was asked by Dr. Hoge if he was not afraid of being captured. With a significant smile, he replied: "I shall never be taken alive." Mr. Benjamin remained with the presidential cavalcade until it reached Georgia, when he separated from his companions. Up to that time he had passed as a French military officer, having a passport in that language, which he spoke like a native. He rode a very tall horse, purchased in South Carolina, and said to be one of the finest in that State. When he left President Davis' party he purchased a cart and horse, and, disguised as a peddler, wearing immense green goggles, he worked his way toward the coast. On one occasion he stopped over night with a gentleman who was acquainted with and who recognized him despite his disguise. Being the soul of politeness, the host made no sign to show that he had penetrated the incognito of his guest, and that it was not until the morning, when in bidding him farewell, he unwittingly remarked, "Good-by, Mr. Benjamin," that the true state of affairs was exposed.

[continued]
 
ESCAPE TO THE WEST INDIES.
Eventually he made his way to the Florida coast, embarked in an open boat for the West Indies, and after a series of adventures, which would, in themselves, make a readable book, he landed in England. In a short time he applied for admission to the bar, and on his setting up the claim that he was an Englishman, having been born fifty-five years before on British soil, the three years' study required of aliens by law was dispensed with, and he was at once admitted to practice.

Before long his attainments won recognition on every side, and he was made a queen's counsellor. It was while serving in this capacity that Mr. Benjamin did what no other man ever did before, and, probably never will do again--he rebuked the House of Lords. He was arguing a case before that august body, when a member--supposed to be Lord Cairns--*********d the single word, "Nonsense!" Mr. Benjamin never moved a muscle, but ceased reading, folded up his brief, and left the hall. The Lords at once sent him an apology, upon which he allowed his junior assistant to return and complete the reading of the argument.

While practicing in the English courts, Mr. Benjamin gave further proof of his manliness and independence. He had occasion to appear before a judge who was notorious for the discourteous manner in which he treated those lawyers who were so unfortunate as to have dealings with him, and who really stood in dread of him. Mr. Benjamin had only begun his argument, when the judge informed him quite abruptly that it was useless for him to proceed, as his mind was already made up. "Your Honor," hotly replied the ex-Confederate, "you, of course, can refuse to hear me argue this case, but I wish to tell you this--that never again will I condescend to appear in your court." The judge was so surprised that any barrister was bold enough to defy him, that he was at first unable to reply; but, in a moment, he realized that Mr. Benjamin was right, came down from the bench, took him by the hand, apologized, and begged him to proceed, which he did, winning the case. The next week, Mr. Benjamin was tendered a banquet for his temerity, by the leading members of the English bar.

HIS ENGLISH PRACTICE,
It was estimated that Mr. Benjamin enjoyed an income of $75,000 a year from his English practice, and at his death he left a fortune of $300,000 to two relatives in New Orleans. He died in Paris in 1854.
In person Mr. Benjamin was rather short, heavy set, with square shoulders, and was inclined toward corpulency. His face was typically Jewish, the short black beard he wore helping to intensify it. His ability to sway an audience by his eloquence was nothing short of marvellous. When in Richmond he resided on Main street, between Fourth and Fifth. He invariably wore the most immaculate of linen, was always cheerful and affable, and never traveled without a copy of Tennyson, and, strange to say, was also an ardent admirer of Horace.
Mr. Benjamin was the author of a number of works, mostly of a legal character, and his "Benjamin on Sales" is to-day a leading standard authority.
Judah P. Benjamin
was a man among men.
===================================================
M. E. Wolf
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top