I thought the photo looked a little "post War of the Rebellion" so checked fold3 military registers. This looked promising: Levy Mellspaugh Hathaway
But I don't know. He was born in Kentucky in 1877 and that's about the period that your photo brought to mind. So. unless he was born asa full-grown man with a moustache, the picture would have to be much later!
Does this picture of an older Levy resemble your chap at all, do you think? Expired Image Removed
Your Levy M - father of this Levy M????
Ah good find by Missouri Rebel -- 1860 census has "LIVY" Hathaway. In 1870 he appears to have become a drug store clerk in Indiana (this time as LEVY). Looks like my Levy M Hathaway isn't the right one after all... just a nephew.. Sorry