Looking for an Honest Appraisal

5thCorpsFan

Private
Joined
Feb 28, 2019
Location
King George County, Virginia
Looking for any honest work that discusses how soldiers and citizens perceived the nation as a construct both before and after the Civil War. We've all heard the "before the Civil War, it was the United States are, and after it was the United States is..." I'm looking for any work that talks about this. Not Lost Cause-y, but an honest work.
 
I know of no books that would directly answer your questions. I could recommend Gary Gallagher's very well researched book, "The Union War," which shows how important preserving the Union, created by the Framers, was to antebellum Americans, many even in the South. Understanding the importance of Union to antebellum Americans can be helpful in your quest.

In a similar sense, I can recommend Elizabeth R. Varon's work, "Disunion: The Coming of the American Civil War 1789-1859." Again, she shows how the concept of Union was so strong and the idea of Disunion so frightening that many, North and South would threaten Disunion as a political tool to obtain what they desired.

A bit different, I could recommend Richard Brookhiser's book, "Founders' Son: A life of Abraham Lincoln" which is an interesting argument that Lincoln emerged as the true inheritor of the Founding Fathers mantle, carrying their vision forward through the 19th century.

You have picked yourself a very debatable issue to consider; whether the war "nationalized" the United States. Many certainly argue that it did. I believe that it did in certain respects, however, it is also clear that the Framers and most Americans considered the "consolidation of our Union" to be, as George Washington, as President of the Constitutional Convention, put it in his September 17, 1787 letter to the President of Congress accompanying the Constitution, "the greatest interest of every true American."

Very interesting topic.
 
I know of no books that would directly answer your questions. I could recommend Gary Gallagher's very well researched book, "The Union War," which shows how important preserving the Union, created by the Framers, was to antebellum Americans, many even in the South. Understanding the importance of Union to antebellum Americans can be helpful in your quest.

In a similar sense, I can recommend Elizabeth R. Varon's work, "Disunion: The Coming of the American Civil War 1789-1859." Again, she shows how the concept of Union was so strong and the idea of Disunion so frightening that many, North and South would threaten Disunion as a political tool to obtain what they desired.

A bit different, I could recommend Richard Brookhiser's book, "Founders' Son: A life of Abraham Lincoln" which is an interesting argument that Lincoln emerged as the true inheritor of the Founding Fathers mantle, carrying their vision forward through the 19th century.

You have picked yourself a very debatable issue to consider; whether the war "nationalized" the United States. Many certainly argue that it did. I believe that it did in certain respects, however, it is also clear that the Framers and most Americans considered the "consolidation of our Union" to be, as George Washington, as President of the Constitutional Convention, put it in his September 17, 1787 letter to the President of Congress accompanying the Constitution, "the greatest interest of every true American."

Very interesting topic.
whether the war "nationalized" the United States...I like how you phrased that. Exactly.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top