How did ANV recruiting work?

Stryker65

Captain
Joined
Jun 5, 2023
Location
William & Mary
Recently thought about this after looking at Spotsylvania casualties. There seem to be pros and cons for every state. Virginia was very close (being in the same state), but the Union controlled much of the state, especially the more populated coastal regions. Almost every other state seemed fine, but there was the distance problem, and also how many men could be found. I know most of the railroads into Richmond/Petersburg were still active up until March, 1865, but it doesn't seem like you could get that many recruits anyway.
 
The Confederate army essentially ceased recruiting in April, 1862 with the implementation of the conscription. Men subject to conscription could avoid the actual conscription by joining volunteer units, either forming or in active service. The Confederate Army itself concentrated upon the conscription thereafter. The conscription acts of 1862-1864 had declared all free white men aged 17 to 50 years to be soldiers in the Army of the Confederate States unless exempted by the same laws. Many once joined, "detailed" to various duties outside of the ranks. The Confederate Army itself managed the conscription. Each State had a conscription officer, aided by the CS forces in that State, and the State authorities.


The number of actual conscripts, or men who would not volunteer, actually taken into service, instructed, and assigned to existing units was calculated by the Confederate Conscription Bureau as of February, 1865 as less that 90,000.

  • Number of conscripts enrolled and assigned to the C.S. Army from camps of instruction since the act of Congress, April 16, 1862:
Virginia .... 13,933
North Carolina 21,348
South Carolina 9,120
Georgia ... 8,993
Alabama, exclusive of the operations of General Pillow. 14,875
Mississippi , exclusive of the operations of General Pillow. 8,061
Florida, suspended and under General Cobb until January, 1863. 362
East Louisiana, from September report, commenced in August, 1864. 81
East Tennessee. 5,220

Total Conscripts to the army....... 81,993.

At the same time, the Bureau of Conscription reported the number of men subject to conscription, etc., who had actually joined the Army to February, 1865 as somewhat less...

B. Approximate estimate of men who have joined the army since April, 1862, without passing through camps of instruction.

Virginia ... 15,000
North Carolina 8,000
South Carolina 6,800
Georgia .. 26,400
Alabama. 10,060
Mississippi 3,032
Florida ... 2,000
East Louisiana. 500
East Tennessee. 500
Total minimum estimate of enlistments from April, 1862 ...... 72,292




President Davis stated in his speech at Palmetto, Georgia in late 1864 that two-thirds of the Confederate army was absent from the ranks for various reasons. The situation did not improve markedly by April, 1865.

As of March 1, 1865 the Army of Northern Virginia had on its rolls over 116,000 personnel. however only a third were on hand and effective.

1740938087170.png

1740938051476.png


But as of its surrender on April 9, there were only about 28,000 on hand, of whom not more than 8,000 were armed and organized for combat.
From the accounts of Union soldiers, etc., the Confederate army definition of "effective" was extremely generous.


Throughout the conflict, General Lee had urged the Confederate government to recruit for the armies, but it declined for its own reasons, preferring the conscription acts in imitation of the Europeans, which Col. Oates of the 15th Alabama observed post-war kept about as many troops away from the front, enforcing them, as they provided to the rank and file of the armies at the front. And as far as the situation generally, stated General Grant's observations were accurate:

1740939575239.png

1740939595457.png
 
The Confederate army essentially ceased recruiting in April, 1862 with the implementation of the conscription. Men subject to conscription could avoid the actual conscription by joining volunteer units, either forming or in active service. The Confederate Army itself concentrated upon the conscription thereafter. The conscription acts of 1862-1864 had declared all free white men aged 17 to 50 years to be soldiers in the Army of the Confederate States unless exempted by the same laws. Many once joined, "detailed" to various duties outside of the ranks. The Confederate Army itself managed the conscription. Each State had a conscription officer, aided by the CS forces in that State, and the State authorities.


The number of actual conscripts, or men who would not volunteer, actually taken into service, instructed, and assigned to existing units was calculated by the Confederate Conscription Bureau as of February, 1865 as less that 90,000.

  • Number of conscripts enrolled and assigned to the C.S. Army from camps of instruction since the act of Congress, April 16, 1862:
Virginia .... 13,933
North Carolina 21,348
South Carolina 9,120
Georgia ... 8,993
Alabama, exclusive of the operations of General Pillow. 14,875
Mississippi , exclusive of the operations of General Pillow. 8,061
Florida, suspended and under General Cobb until January, 1863. 362
East Louisiana, from September report, commenced in August, 1864. 81
East Tennessee. 5,220

Total Conscripts to the army....... 81,993.

At the same time, the Bureau of Conscription reported the number of men subject to conscription, etc., who had actually joined the Army to February, 1865 as somewhat less...

B. Approximate estimate of men who have joined the army since April, 1862, without passing through camps of instruction.

Virginia ... 15,000
North Carolina 8,000
South Carolina 6,800
Georgia .. 26,400
Alabama. 10,060
Mississippi 3,032
Florida ... 2,000
East Louisiana. 500
East Tennessee. 500
Total minimum estimate of enlistments from April, 1862 ...... 72,292




President Davis stated in his speech at Palmetto, Georgia in late 1864 that two-thirds of the Confederate army was absent from the ranks for various reasons. The situation did not improve markedly by April, 1865.

As of March 1, 1865 the Army of Northern Virginia had on its rolls over 116,000 personnel. however only a third were on hand and effective.

View attachment 540931
View attachment 540930

But as of its surrender on April 9, there were only about 28,000 on hand, of whom not more than 8,000 were armed and organized for combat.
From the accounts of Union soldiers, etc., the Confederate army definition of "effective" was extremely generous.


Throughout the conflict, General Lee had urged the Confederate government to recruit for the armies, but it declined for its own reasons, preferring the conscription acts in imitation of the Europeans, which Col. Oates of the 15th Alabama observed post-war kept about as many troops away from the front, enforcing them, as they provided to the rank and file of the armies at the front. And as far as the situation generally, stated General Grant's observations were accurate:

View attachment 540933
View attachment 540934
Guess the camp of instruction at CivilWarTalk could use a little recruiting, too. I'm going after a couple of my friends!
 
Then, how did the conscripts reach the army? Colonel John M. Stone got pretty close with his Mississippi recruits before they were captured at Salisbury.


Hancock understood conscripts on trains were intercepted at Waynesborough in March, 1865.

1740944313174.png


Conscripts would have had to be carried to the army. Likely under guard. From February, 1864, some who subsequently deserted to the US forces claimed they had been under guard...

1740945466914.png





John B. Jones diary, (Vol. II), from the Richmond war department in September, 1864:

1740945037592.png


But by the spring of 1865 they weren't coming back.

Newspaper reports quoting some of the deserters from Lee's army suggest they were principally volunteers rather than conscripts. The conscripts kept under guard more or less in the entrenchments.


1740946162595.png



1740946225759.png


The Conscription Bureau of the Confederate Army was disbanded on March 7, 1865. As Col. Charles Marshall of Lee's staff later noted it had done all the damage it could...

1740947493340.png


I've seen it stated the conscription of slaves under the new act was to commence large scale on April 3, 1865. It would have conscripted the military age negroes in and about Richmond and vicinity. The Confederates abandoned Richmond on April 2.
The conscript camps of instruction throughout the Confederacy were preparing to receive the negro conscripts when the end of the war came.
 
Well, the 1st/3rd NC were never really "replenished" after Spotsylvania: They continued operations after being transferred to Cox's Brigade, but at a fraction of their pre-Spotsylvania strengths.

My notes show, for example, that a Oct. 1, 1864 ANV Inspection Report counted only 52 officers and men present in the 3rd NC Regiment. That's roughly the same size as the day after the big losses of May 12, 1864.

According to a Sept. 27, 1864 notice published in the Raleigh-based newspaper The Confederate, the 3rd NC made efforts to replenish itself by beating the bushes back home for absentees, including wounded men who might be fit for duty. The notice ordered absentees to report to Lt. Col. Parsley at an office in Wilmington to determine if the absentees should be returned to service. Parsley also announced he would soon move on to Fayetteville and Raleigh for the same purpose.

Only 58 members of the 3rd NC were paroled at Appomattox, so it's clear that the regiment struggled to maintain itself at a greatly reduced size in the final 10 months of the War.
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top