Gun Research

@Don Dixon ,

Don, is this the image you spoke of in the PM? The big 24-pounder is very distinctive with the 5.82" bore and the handles above the trunions.

mca.jpg


I am very familiar with the two guns that are at the monument today; before I was a Ranger i was in maintenance and took care of the park's historic structures including all of the monuments. Back in 2002 I conducted a very comprehensive survey of the park's artillery collection, which of course included the three 24-pounder howitzers, all of which are model 1841 cast at the Alger foundry.

In June of last year I took a small group on an all-day tour of the park concentrating on the guns in the park collection, not about the guns used in the battle (well not too much). The talk discussed how guns were cast and what the rifling process was like, who the inspectors were and the history of the different foundries. It turned out to be a hit and I will probably repeat it in the spring.

(unless the Park Service has been playing musical chairs with the tubes).
Many of the guns in the collection have been moved over the years, some several times. The original park commission came up with idea of using a system to help identify how many guns were being used at that particular spot during the battle, whether the spot was marked by an iron tablet or a monument. If the full battery was present there would be two guns; if the battery was at half strength there would be one gun; and if the battery had been reduced to a single weapon, no cannon would be placed at the site. If at all possible the guns placed at the site would be of the same type used in the battle. It was a good idea and it stayed that way for many years, though it was very difficult to place the correct types of gun in position due to the lack of certain weapons such as 10 and 20 pound parrots and Napoleons. The system was abandoned years later when a superintendent wanted to mass many of the guns for visual effect and to ensure all cannon could be viewed from the tour route. For example, three full batteries were placed in Sarah Bell's Cotton Field and the left of Ruggles' Line was beefed up with over a dozen guns and all of the Confederate made pieces were relocated to this area of the field.

Over the last 15 years the park has been slowly returning cannon to the original 2-gun system but due to lack of documentation it is unknown which guns were located where in the early days. We are moving the guns in conjunction with the replacement of the original iron carriages which are antiques now and many are in poor condition. There has been some resistance to this plan as some folks have seen the groupings for their entire life and do not want to see the change, even when the original 2-gun system is explained.

I have no idea when the 12-pounder howitzer in the image was replaced by the other 24-pounder which is there today. It is kind of amazing that these two guns were cast one after the other at the same foundry, perhaps on the same day. They were definitely both inspected and received by the army within two days of each other; November 6 & 8, 1841.

There is a third model 1841 howitzer on the park which was cast in 1858 and inspected by future Confederate general Benjamin Huger. For years it was placed in Powell Field just south of the National Cemetery although there is no doubt it was originally placed somewhere else on the field. Powell's Field was a 2-gun site that was changed to five guns for visual effect. Last year this gun was moved adjacent to marker No. 59 which is the site of McAllister's Battery on the east side of Jones Field.

Although I work at the Corinth Civil War Interpretive Center in Mississippi, which is a unit of Shiloh NMP, I keep up with all of the location changes to keep our inventory up to date and it is also a record of the changes for the last twenty years.

We are still making changes on the field, albeit very slowly. We have purchased a number of replica Wiard carriages and we have been moving Wiard rifles from across the park to sites where batteries that utilized this type of weapon were engaged. Shiloh has the largest collection of this distinctive weapon than any other park in the system.

All the best,

Tom
 
Is there any compilation of the foundry's of the CW, where they were located, what or how much they produced? It would
be interesting.

@Larryh86GT is correct. I set out to gather information on the foundries which made the guns in the Shiloh collection. Some foundries are very well documented like the West Point Foundry at Cold Springs, NY. Others proved to be much harder to find information on, particularly those that only produced a handful of weapons like the Samuel Wolff & Co. Founders in New Orleans.

I have two artillery books in my collection which are simply indispensable; Field Artillery Weapons of the Civil War by James C. Hazlett, Edwin Olmstead, and M.Hume Parks and the other is Artillery and Ammunition of the Civil War by Warren Ripley. The former has excellent (though limited) information on foundries of field artillery weapons.

Tom
 
Don, is this the image you spoke of in the PM? The big 24-pounder is very distinctive with the 5.82" bore and the handles above the trunions.

Tom,

That is precisely the cabinet card photo I was talking about in my PM. If you know when it was taken, then you would have an idea of when CPT McAllister visited the site.

When I visted Shiloh in December 1964, there were two 24-pounders at the monument. Battery D tore hell out of the 4th Tennessee Infantry with canister from their 24s. McAllister also had a photo of a group of veterans from the 4th with the flag they carried at Shiloh.

Regards,
Don
 
Last edited:
This piece was once owned by King's Mountain National Military Park where it was used as a fence post. You can see the remains of the concrete in the barrel.

In the 1990's, I would gobwatch a Civil War cannon competition in Mississippi Delta and one group came down from Illinois looking for a place to fire live rounds at targets.
The story they gave about thir gun was it was a post at the entrance of a cemetery. They bought it and rebored it to insert a steel sleeve. It put some good rounds down range.
 
They bought it and rebored it to insert a steel sleeve. It put some good rounds down range.

Yikes! Firing an antique over a century and a half old is a little scary, even with a sleeve. Not quite as scary as the folks that fire the ones that have not been sleeved!

Jeers,

Tom
 
...one group came down from Illinois looking for a place to fire live rounds at targets. The story they gave about thir gun was it was a post at the entrance of a cemetery. They bought it and rebored it to insert a steel sleeve.

The cemetery foundation or whatever it was sold the gun illegally. Doesn't matter that it was stuck upright into the ground as a fencepost. When no longer required for civic use the gun technically reverts to Federal venue - that is, if it was a Federal gun to begin with per the marking "U.S." on top of barrel.

Removals from cemeteries are easy given the level at which some of them are run (or no longer run because association members or the county or city departments had let it slide years ago). That doesn't make it right. It's ethically shady, and technically stealing from the American people who were taxed to have it made and who trusted their representatives to grant it to civic venues -- not private use, especially not private profit from re-sale on the collector market
 
Last edited:
The cemetery foundation or whatever it was sold the gun illegally

I dont know any of the details: that was their story.
However, I would like to know how the cemetery obtained it? Dont know if it was a national cemetery or a state or a town.
Then . . . Who owns it if it was captured Confederate property? Probably doesnt apply in this case as Im sure it was originally a Union gun.
In summary, the US Govt did not sell these guns??

I discovered a similar thing with WW2 items. GI's could keep their uniforms and most examples of their firearms after the war. But by law they were not allowed to keep their company flag. I met a family of a Vet who found his battery's flag lying on the floor of a warehouse and he took it home with him. As I see it, he saved the flag. Otherwise the Army would have crated it up and stacked it on the Lost Ark.
Now the question is what can he legally do with the flag.
 
...I would like to know how the cemetery obtained it? Dont know if it was a national cemetery or a state or a town... Who owns it if it was captured Confederate property?...Im sure it was originally a Union gun. In summary, the US Govt did not sell these guns?

By later 1800s surplus guns could be requested by civic groups through their particular congressional representative. GARs and SUVs or county gov'ts etc. for their court squares, cemeteries and even school yards. My understanding is those requesting agencies would have to pay for rail shipping but not for the gun itself.

My understanding is that Confederate-origin guns are out of scope so it's "whatever." I'm sure many have been sold and bought by whomever got their hands on them.

Anyway, I only bring all this up because it's a bad precedent to suggest new units or individuals think it ok, even clever, to be digging out a heritage Federal gun from some old neglected cemetery, or paying someone else to do that. That gun is rightly provenance of all U.S. citizens. Profiting on the collector market with such a gun is likely technically illegal under U.S. statute; but even if not; it's morally indefensible, yes?
 
So I've been designated both Quartermaster and Historian of my unit. We want to look into where our gun(s) were possibly used. Our first on is a Heavy 12pdr Dahlgren Boat Howitzer. On the breach is stamped USNY WASHINGTON 759 Lbs 69 PRE No. 92. That gun is stamped 1862 on top of the barrel towards the middle section where the chassis is. Our other gun is a Light 12pdr Dahlgren Boat Howitzer stamped USNY WASHINGTON 424 Lbs 24 PRE No 179. This on is stamped 1872. I just would like to know where to search in order to find the official records and documentation on them. We found them about 20 years ago in a cemetery in the Bronx, where our school is, and took these 2 while the third went to a private collector, that none of us know their name. I've searched our own records here at school in the library but they have no records of them either.

Get in touch with a guy named William King in Tidewater VA. He was with the 20th years ago...
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top