Company H Roster

Joined
Jun 21, 2016
My great-great-great grandfather was Samuel Shoop, and he served in Company H of the 130th Pennsylvania Vols. Upon looking at their roster, I saw that two of them were killed at Antietam. Surprisingly, nobody in Company H was harmed at Fredericksburg or Chancellorsville, and none were wounded. I checked the other companies' rosters, and it seemed like every fifth one was either wounded or killed at Fredericksburg. However, I noticed a discrepancy between Company H's roster and the other companies': the phrase "not on muster-out roll" appeared in Company H's. The fact that six people of Company H had this status leads me to believe that they were missing or killed in action. Do you think maybe the officers of Company H formatted the roster differently than their fellow Captains? Also, the amount of people mustered out in Company H is much larger than in the other companies. I'm wondering if maybe the people who weren't there on muster-out day were killed. (they didn't desert, I checked the list of Pennsylvania deserters) Thank you very much for any help.
 
My great-great-great grandfather was Samuel Shoop, and he served in Company H of the 130th Pennsylvania Vols. Upon looking at their roster, I saw that two of them were killed at Antietam. Surprisingly, nobody in Company H was harmed at Fredericksburg or Chancellorsville, and none were wounded. I checked the other companies' rosters, and it seemed like every fifth one was either wounded or killed at Fredericksburg. However, I noticed a discrepancy between Company H's roster and the other companies': the phrase "not on muster-out roll" appeared in Company H's. The fact that six people of Company H had this status leads me to believe that they were missing or killed in action. Do you think maybe the officers of Company H formatted the roster differently than their fellow Captains? Also, the amount of people mustered out in Company H is much larger than in the other companies. I'm wondering if maybe the people who weren't there on muster-out day were killed. (they didn't desert, I checked the list of Pennsylvania deserters) Thank you very much for any help.

Could have been discharged for disability, AWOL on muster-out day, or maybe absent and sick on muster-out day ? Could have been several reasons ? I see 5 that deserted before they left for Maryland & Virginia.
 
Could have been discharged for disability, AWOL on muster-out day, or maybe absent and sick on muster-out day ? Could have been several reasons ? I see 5 that deserted before they left for Maryland & Virginia.
Yes, but the fact that the phrase "not on muster-out roll" appears on no other companies' rosters is odd. The difference between Company H's roster and the other rosters is that Company H's has that phrase, and the others' don't. However, it works the other way around too. The other companies have "Killed at Fredericksburg" or "Wounded at Chancellorsville" quite a bit, whereas Company H's doesn't. Also, when it says "discharged by surgeon's certificate", can that mean they were wounded in action, had disease, or had an accident, or does that only mean one thing?
 
Yes, but the fact that the phrase "not on muster-out roll" appears on no other companies' rosters is odd. The difference between Company H's roster and the other rosters is that Company H's has that phrase, and the others' don't. However, it works the other way around too. The other companies have "Killed at Fredericksburg" or "Wounded at Chancellorsville" quite a bit, whereas Company H's doesn't. Also, when it says "discharged by surgeon's certificate", can that mean they were wounded in action, had disease, or had an accident, or does that only mean one thing?

I would guess it could be for a variety of reasons if not specifically named. The roster of Co.H that I see, has the following men "discharged for disability", in the first few months of 1863. I've put their discharge date in parentheses. They may well have been wounded at Fredericksburg.

John Anderson
(3/5/1863)

John Bothoroyd
(12/17/1863)

Isaac Bowman
(1/20/1863)

Abel Fetrow
(2/10/1863)

John C. Hoffaker
(2/17/1863)

William H. Preston
(3/27/1863)

William H. Reese
(1/14/1863)

Cyrus Rhoads
(3/7/1863)

Joseph G. Stringfellow
(4/1/1863)

Anter'n Townsend
(2/13/1863)

Isaac Uhler
(2/25/1863)

Gibbons Watson
(3/6/1863)

Chauncey C. Wilder
(2/25/1863)
 
Last edited:
I would guess it could be for a variety of reasons if not specifically named. The roster of Co.H that I see, has the following men "discharged for disability", in the first few months of 1863. I've put their discharge date in parentheses. They may well have been wounded at Fredericksburg.

John Anderson
(3/5/1863)

John Bothoroyd
(12/17/1863)

Isaac Bowman
(1/20/1863)

Abel Fetrow
(2/10/1863)

John C. Hoffaker
(2/17/1863)

William H. Preston
(3/27/1863)

William H. Reese
(1/14/1863)

Cyrus Rhoads
(3/7/1863)

Joseph G. Stringfellow
(4/1/1863)

Anter'n Townsend
(2/13/1863)

Isaac Uhler
(2/25/1863)

Gibbons Watson
(3/6/1863)

Chauncey C. Wilder
(2/25/1863)
That's very true, the dates they were released line up with Fredericksburg. I suppose the "not on muster-out roll" phrase still remains a mystery. They didn't desert, so I'd guess that they went MIA. Thanks for all the feedback, it's much appreciated. If you think of anything else, please do check back!
 
I would guess it could be for a variety of reasons if not specifically named. The roster of Co.H that I see, has the following men "discharged for disability", in the first few months of 1863. I've put their discharge date in parentheses. They may well have been wounded at Fredericksburg.

John Anderson
(3/5/1863)

John Bothoroyd
(12/17/1863)

Isaac Bowman
(1/20/1863)

Abel Fetrow
(2/10/1863)

John C. Hoffaker
(2/17/1863)

William H. Preston
(3/27/1863)

William H. Reese
(1/14/1863)

Cyrus Rhoads
(3/7/1863)

Joseph G. Stringfellow
(4/1/1863)

Anter'n Townsend
(2/13/1863)

Isaac Uhler
(2/25/1863)

Gibbons Watson
(3/6/1863)

Chauncey C. Wilder
(2/25/1863)
on top of all this, as a matter a fact, I found the story of Lieutenant McMann, who, on the roster, is listed as being promoted and discharged. However, an article that I found online says that McMann was wounded at Fredericksburg. This seems to be quite promising. If he was wounded and isn't listed as such, who's to say 20 other people in Company H have the same situation. It would make sense if the men who are listed as "not on muster-out roll" were killed/ missing and a couple dozen others who have the same status as McMann were wounded. It would be identical as the other rosters if that were the case. Tell me what you think.
 
The roster of Co.H that I see, has the following men "discharged for disability", in the first few months of 1863. I've put their discharge date in parentheses. They may well have been wounded at Fredericksburg.
Cyrus Rhoads
(3/7/1863)
Isaac Uhler
(2/25/1863)

"On August 7, 1862, Cyrus (E) Rhoads enlisted with the army in New Cumberland and five days later mustered in Harrisburg with Co. H, 130th Pa Infantry, at the rank of private. He was shot in the upper right thigh at the battle of Antietam on September 17, 1862, and reached the hospital at Harrisburg six days later. The bullet had fractured the femur, which usually meant amputation. In this case, surgeons were able to knit the bone together but the result was that his right leg was then shorter than the left. He was discharged on a surgeon's certificate on March 7, 1863." http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=28872727


Isaac Uhler enlisted in Fisherville, Dauphin County, August 8, 1862, and mustered into federal service in Harrisburg August 12 with Co. H, 130th Pa Infantry, at the rank of private. He fought in the battle of Antietam September 17, 1862, but was hospitalized at Bolivar Heights, (West) Virginia, October 25, 1862. Transferred to the convalescent camp in Alexandria, Virginia, where he was discharged on a surgeon's certificate February 28, 1863, for "hypertrophy of heart contracted before enlistment." Despite these alleged cardiac issues, he also enrolled in Harrisburg February 24, 1864, with Co. K, 9th Pa Cavalry (92nd Pa), at the rank of private. Again he was hospitalized for illness and discharged on a surgeon's certificate May 25, 1865. http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=78191547

"Surprisingly, nobody in Company H was harmed at Fredericksburg or Chancellorsville, and none were wounded." Looks like those records are wrong @AlexanderSPQR ...

Private Edward Spangler, a sixteen year old from York County, (130th PA) would later recall one such sight soon after crossing the Rapahannock River into the City of Fredericksburg:

"Emerging into the open we were about to deploy in line of battle under a deadly fire, when we encountered a mill-race or canal, from four to six feet deep and fifteen feetwide,which ran clear around the city in the rear." "It was impassable, except at the few street bridges, some of which had nothing left but stringers over which we had to pass in single file. It was first discovered in our division by the head of column, and was a most serious and embarassing obstacle, and very disconcerting under a raking storm of projectiles. After crossing, we were compelled for a considerable distance to march by columns of four.
While in this formation a shower of missiles created havoc in our ranks, one of which took off the head of Captain McLaughlin of Company H, scattering the brains over our company. http://paemergencymen.blogspot.com/2012/12/fredericksburg-and-130th-pa-monument-at.html

DR. JOHN H. YOUNG. Co H 130th PA, Wounded at Fredericksburg
In the summer of 1862 he consequently was enrolled as a private in Company H, 130th P. V. I., for nine months, but served for ten, participating in the battle of Fredericksburg, where he was seriously wounded. He was struck by a piece of shell in his stomach, injuring him internally, and received another wound in the same battle, on his shin bone. On account of these injuries he was sent to the National Hotel Hospital at
Baltimore, but was finally discharged at Harrisburg. http://files.usgwarchives.net/pa/cumberland/bios/zeamer/young-john-h.txt

JOHN K McGANN. Co H 130th PA, Wounded at Fredericksburg
On 19 August 1862, Mr. McGann enlisted in Company H, 130th Regiment Pennsylvania Volunteers (130th Pennsylvania Infantry), as 1st Lieutenant under Captain Hoofacker and Col. H. J. Zinn. The Captain being on sick leave, McGann comanded the company. He participated in the battles of South Mountain, Antietam, Fredericksburg, and Chencellorsville. Being wounded at Fredericksburg, he was for a few days in the field hospital.He was discharged from the service 20 May 1862, and returned home. http://civilwar.gratzpa.org/2012/08/capt-john-k-mcgann/
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top