Impressions Basic Federal Infantry Impression

Joined
Jan 29, 2019
Basic Mid to Late war US infantry impression. Nothing fancy, Sack Coat, Forage Cap, Knapsack, & M1861 Rifle Musket.

PlainUSImpression1.webp


PlainUSImpression2.webp


PlainUSImpression3.webp
 
Here's some US canteens with various scrap cloth covers...

1793541978808.webp
1793542022049.webp
1793542073524.webp


The Canteen covers varied widely, as apparently they were covered by the contractors who delivered them to the Army Quartermaster Department.

1793542303836.webp


1793542872871.webp


1793543469692.webp
 
Most Federal canteens were covered with (cheaper at the time) gray or tan jean clothe, occasionally blue if there was scrap on hand but that was more expensive material needed for uniforms, not to use up on canteen covers.

Blue is way overrepped in my opinion. You hardly see tan outside of hardcore groups. Mine is covered in now very dirty and thinning in places gray Jean cloth. The strap has also seen better days. I really should get another one and leave this one for heavily campaigned impressions.
 
A gray canteen cover?
Federal issue canteens were most often covered in some sort of jean cloth or scrap wool, most often brown, tan, or gray. Having a canteen covered in gray wool is entirely correct for a Federal infantry impression. Some canteens were covered in scrap dark blue or sky blue wool left over from uniform cutouts. But gray or tan, most absolutely.

554_original-scaled.webp
75939_original-300x300.webp
165428.webp
s-l1600.webp
s-l1600 (1).webp
 
Too clean and tidy for the field
Not at all. Soldiers out in the field wouldn't instantaneously become dirty from head to toe. You'd have gradual fraying of uniforms, fading, gradual staining of the canteen strap with sweat, etc. The shoes and trousers would probably become dirty first, with the fatigue duty of chopping wood, building breastworks, cooking, walking/marching on dusty roads or muddy ground, etc.
 
Blue is way overrepped in my opinion. You hardly see tan outside of hardcore groups. Mine is covered in now very dirty and thinning in places gray Jean cloth. The strap has also seen better days. I really should get another one and leave this one for heavily campaigned impressions.
I agree. It's also very tiresome to see reproduction canteens being sold on sutler row as "Union Blue" or "Confederate Gray". Lol, as if both sides got their equipment from the Acme Company that Wile Coyote always buys from.
 
Basic Mid to Late war US infantry impression. Nothing fancy, Sack Coat, Forage Cap, Knapsack, & M1861 Rifle Musket.

View attachment 593788

View attachment 593789

View attachment 593790
I really like how proportional you are body-wise. Also love the extra material down at the bottoms of your trousers, suggesting an army size with a bit of extra trouser leg length. Few other details of note, super nice the wider canteen strap as was widely produced and issued. The blanket being folded inside the knapsack and not rolled on top, awesome! Looking good private!
 
Last edited:
Federal issue canteens were most often covered in some sort of jean cloth or scrap wool, most often brown, tan, or gray. Having a canteen covered in gray wool is entirely correct for a Federal infantry impression. Some canteens were covered in scrap dark blue or sky blue wool left over from uniform cutouts. But gray or tan, most absolutely.

View attachment 594054

Is it bad that my Federal canteen is in essentially this condition? Minus the cork which is in good condition and I replaced the old rusty chain with a string… lol
 
Is it bad that my Federal canteen is in essentially this condition? Minus the cork which is in good condition and I replaced the old rusty chain with a string… lol
Not at all! Mine is the same condition. I get asked a lot if I'm carrying an original, lol. I do however need to finally coat the inside with beeswax. I'm sure I've consumed a fair amount of rust along with my water, blech!
 
On the subject of canteens, there is a very easy way to make your impression instantly better. A lot of sutler row canteens do not pay attention to the "cork chain vs. the cork cord" rules that go along with the "corrugated vs. smoothside canteen" rules.

There was only ONE depot that produced canteens with the chain attachment for the cork: New York Depot. And New York Depot produced ONLY smoothside canteens. Therefore your canteen should have a chain ONLY if it's a smoothside.

The corrugated (bullseye) canteen was produced ONLY at: Philadelphia Depot. They developed it and made it exclusively. And since we know that ONLY the New York Depot used the cork chain, ALL corrugated canteens should ONLY have a linen/hemp cord attachment for the cork. During the war you would NEVER see a corrugated canteen with a chain attachment as they were issued from the depots.

Final note, the Philadephia Depot produced smoothside canteens as well, and both the smoothside and corrugated canteen had linen/hemp cord for their cork attachments.

For both depots, jean cloth/wool in gray, tan, light brown are all correct.
 
Not at all. Soldiers out in the field wouldn't instantaneously become dirty from head to toe. You'd have gradual fraying of uniforms, fading, gradual staining of the canteen strap with sweat, etc. The shoes and trousers would probably become dirty first, with the fatigue duty of chopping wood, building breastworks, cooking, walking/marching on dusty roads or muddy ground, etc.
A day - and night - in the field would crease it as well as add some 'muck' to knees and the rear of the jacket or pants (where else do you clean off your hands in the field?). Parade wear at depot, for inspection, fine. Field wear? I don't think so.
 
If someone is actively participating in events, the dirt and grime will come naturally. I am against adding "fake" dirt and stains. All uniforms and equipment were issued "new" at one time so it is not incorrect to appear that way at an event, as all of the clothing and equipment will naturally age and get real natural dirt and stains. Also as I have posted before on this subject, the vast majority of individuals (this applies to CW soldiers as well) dont want to be dirt and grease covered. If they can bathe and wash their gear they will. There are always exceptions to this rule and heavy marching and fighting can delay this process but just like today in the 19th century most people were embarrassed to be filthy and having their clothes fall apart. Worn, well used gear that is overall clean (with natural staining) is the most accurate for most impressions.

Another issue is equipment being used by some reeanctors they have used for 30 years and it has worn and has a patina to appear as a museum piece. This is not accurate. during the war equipment was new with the oldest gear at the end of the war being only a few years old at most. Most gear was issued and probably lost/replaced within a year or less. Your canteen and strap should not display 20 years if hard use, its just not accurate.
 
If someone is actively participating in events, the dirt and grime will come naturally. I am against adding "fake" dirt and stains. All uniforms and equipment were issued "new" at one time so it is not incorrect to appear that way at an event, as all of the clothing and equipment will naturally age and get real natural dirt and stains. Also as I have posted before on this subject, the vast majority of individuals (this applies to CW soldiers as well) dont want to be dirt and grease covered. If they can bathe and wash their gear they will. There are always exceptions to this rule and heavy marching and fighting can delay this process but just like today in the 19th century most people were embarrassed to be filthy and having their clothes fall apart. Worn, well used gear that is overall clean (with natural staining) is the most accurate for most impressions.

Another issue is equipment being used by some reeanctors they have used for 30 years and it has worn and has a patina to appear as a museum piece. This is not accurate. during the war equipment was new with the oldest gear at the end of the war being only a few years old at most. Most gear was issued and probably lost/replaced within a year or less. Your canteen and strap should not display 20 years if hard use, its just not accurate.
Great post!

This is exactly what I've tried to impress upon other reenactors over the years.

Human beings throughout history have had the instinct to be in contact with water. We are drawn to it. This topic goes along with the myth that during medieval times people supposedly just stayed dirty and didn't have any desire to go near water.

This is just pure imagination-based myth. People have always wanted to feel clean and refreshed. Are we to really believe that in the year 1,300 people didn't go swimming in the summer to cool themselves like we do now, or take a bath to refresh themselves?

The problem for Civil War soldiers was that because of the size of armies it was often logistically impossible to bathe or wash regularly. If a regiment or brigade happened to be near a lake, pond or stream during a nightly halt they were very lucky. Of course, there was also the issue of neighboring brigades also competing for the same body of water, creating traffic jams to get access to it.
 
Last edited:
Basic Mid to Late war US infantry impression. Nothing fancy, Sack Coat, Forage Cap, Knapsack, & M1861 Rifle Musket.

View attachment 593788

View attachment 593789

View attachment 593790
Another nice touch with your impression is the lack of a musket sling. A practice that I have also followed for thirty+ years.

Regulations did call for slings to be issued with the Springfield Rifle Musket that was produced in the arsenal in Massachusetts and with contract muskets made in various states.

However, the problem that arose was that as the war escalated and the swarm of volunteers swelled the armies to gigantic proportions, many muskets were issued without slings. In some cases, a state contract would deliver muskets to a central arsenal but there were not enough slings and so the muskets went to the soldiers as is.

Foreign purchases of muskets by the U.S. government were hit and miss with slings being included with shipments.

In addition, the soldiers themselves often found the sling to be an impediment with both the musket drill as well as moving through thick woods and brush. And many soldiers preferred on the march to carry their muskets at 'right shoulder shift' or 'trail arms' when on an extended march.

Further problems for the musket sling is that soldiers quickly found many alternate uses for them: straps for blanket rolls, modified into trouser waistbelts, etc.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top