Trivia 5-4-18 & Bonus

Status
Not open for further replies.
1) Ordnance Sgt. James Reilly
2) Fort Johnston
Bonus
1) When - April 15, 1862
2) Where - Picacho Peak
Regards
David

Edit - For the first question, see the edit to post # 10.

The bonus question also asked for the identification of a unit or units that was/were involved in the action that resulted in the casualties.

hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Regular question:

Castle Pinckney was the fort.
"Castle Pinckney, situated at the mouth of the Cooper River, was in good condition, but garrisoned only by an ordnance sergeant and his teenage daughter."
https://www.civilwar.org/learn/articles/problem-charleston-harbor

The bold sergeant's name was James Skillen.
Snip-it_1525457901452.jpg

https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/26/a-coup-de-main-in-charleston-harbor/

William Harn was among the Union troops at Fort Sumter, while Kate's family stayed with her father, Ordinance Sergeant James Skillen at Castle Pinckney, another much smaller harbor fort.
http://www.blogstaugustinelighthouse.org/lighthouse-history-1874-1894-part-ii/

Edit - Response revised in subsequent post.

hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ordnance Sergeant Henry Douglas
Fort Marion
, St Augustine, Florida

SAINT AUGUSTINE, EAST FLORIDA,
January 7, 1861.


"SIR: I am obliged to perform what is to me a painful duty, viz, to report to the Chief of Ordnance that all the military stores at this place were seized this morning by the order of the governor of the State of Florida. A Company of volunteer soldiers marched to the barracks and took possession of me, and demanded peaceable possession of the keys of the fort and magazine. I demanded them to show me their authority. An aide-de-camp of the governor showed me his letter of instructions authorizing him to seize the property, and directing him to use what force might be necessary.
Upon reflection I decided that the only alternative for me was to deliver the keys, under protest, and demand a receipt for the property. One thing certain, with the exception of the guns composing the armament of the water battery, the property seized is of no great value. The gentleman acting under the governor's instructions has promised to receipt to me for the stores.
I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
HENRY DOUGLAS.
Ordnance Sergeant, U.S. Army."


https://ironbrigader.com/2017/01/10/federals-lose-retake-floridas-fort-marion-shots-fired/

Bonus:
When? April 15, 1862
Where? Battle of Picacho Pass/Peak
Units involved? Squadron of Union Cavalry under Lt James Barrett, 1st California Cavalry. (Total of 13 men)
Patrol of Confederate Rangers under Sergeant Henry Holmes.(total of 10 men)
https://www.civilwar.org/learn/civil-war/battles/picacho-peak
 
Bonus: Piacho Peak / Pass on April 15, 1862. Union squad under Lt. James Barret of the 1st California Cavalry against Confederate Hunter's Rangers patrol under Sgt. Henry Holmes. I believe this to be the answer even though the Civil War Trust estimated 5 Confederate casualties.
Total Estimated Casualties
11
Union
6
Confederate
5
Source: https://www.civilwar.org/learn/civil-war/battles/picacho-peak
 
primary answers : HENRY DOUGLAS. Ordnance Sergeant, U.S. Army.
Fort Marion (i kept wanting to fit Fort Clinch into these circumstances)

At the time, the Federal presence at the fort was light; an ordinance sergeant was in command. The sergeant reported the seizure of the for in this report:

SAINT AUGUSTINE, EAST FLORIDA,
January 7, 1861.

SIR: I am obliged to perform what is to me a painful duty, viz, to report to the Chief of Ordnance that all the military stores at this place were seized this morning by the order of the governor of the State of Florida. A Company of volunteer soldiers marched to the barracks and took possession of me, and demanded peaceable possession of the keys of the fort and magazine. I demanded them to show me their authority. An aide-de-camp of the governor showed me his letter of instructions authorizing him to seize the property, and directing him to use what force might be necessary.

Upon reflection I decided that the only alternative for me was to deliver the keys, under protest, and demand a receipt for the property. One thing certain, with the exception of the guns composing the armament of the water battery, the property seized is of no great value. The gentleman acting under the governor's instructions has promised to receipt to me for the stores.

I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
HENRY DOUGLAS.
Ordnance Sergeant, U.S. Army.

Col. H. K. CRAIG,
Chief of Ordnance Department, U.S. Army.

The outnumbered Sergeant Douglas had little choice except to surrender the fort, but that also meant that there were no casualties.

bonus answer :
The First Battle of Dragoon Springs.
It was fought on May 5, 1862, near the present-day town of Benson Arizona.
Confederates occupied Tuscon until May 14, 1862, and it was a detachment of these troops that was involved in the fight at Dragoon Springs on May 5.
A force of about 100 Chiricahua Apache warriors, commanded by the war chiefs Cochise and Francisco, ambushed the party. Three Confederate soldiers and a young Mexican stock herder were killed.
This minor skirmish is noted for causing the Confederacy's westernmost battle deaths, and is the only known engagement in which Confederate soldiers were killed within the modern confines of Arizona.
 
Henry Douglas & Fort Marion

Federals Lose, Then Retake, Florida's Fort Marion With No Shots Fired

by Mark · January 10, 2017

Fort Marion in St. Augustine, Florida, was one of several masonry forts that were part of the coastal defenses of the United States. The Spanish, who controlled the area at the time, began building the fort in 1672, naming it the Castillo de San Marcos. After Spain ceded Florida to the United States, the fort became a U.S. Army base in 1821.

Forty years later, Florida became the third state to secede from the Union, doing so on January 10th, 1861. But secessionist Floridians were taking action even before the legislative vote, seizing or attempting to seize Federal properties in the state. One of these was Fort Marion, which was occupied by volunteer Florida troops on January 7th. At the time, the Federal presence at the fort was light; an ordinance sergeant was in command. The sergeant reported the seizure of the for in this report:

SAINT AUGUSTINE, EAST FLORIDA,
January 7, 1861.

SIR: I am obliged to perform what is to me a painful duty, viz, to report to the Chief of Ordnance that all the military stores at this place were seized this morning by the order of the governor of the State of Florida. A Company of volunteer soldiers marched to the barracks and took possession of me, and demanded peaceable possession of the keys of the fort and magazine. I demanded them to show me their authority. An aide-de-camp of the governor showed me his letter of instructions authorizing him to seize the property, and directing him to use what force might be necessary.

Upon reflection I decided that the only alternative for me was to deliver the keys, under protest, and demand a receipt for the property. One thing certain, with the exception of the guns composing the armament of the water battery, the property seized is of no great value. The gentleman acting under the governor's instructions has promised to receipt to me for the stores.

I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
HENRY DOUGLAS.
Ordnance Sergeant, U.S. Army.

Col. H. K. CRAIG,
Chief of Ordnance Department, U.S. Army.

ironbrigader.com/2017/01/10/federals-lose-retake-floridas-fort-marion-shots-fired/



Bonus: The First Battle of Dragoon Springs was a minor skirmish between a small troop of Confederate dragoons of Governor John R. Baylor's Arizona Rangers, and a band of Apache warriors during the American Civil War. It was fought on May 5, 1862, near the present-day town of Benson, Arizona, in Confederate Arizona.
Wikipedia, wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Battle_of_Dragoon_Springs

ironbrigader.com/2017/01/10/federals-lose-retake-floridas-fort-marion-shots-fired/
 
Whoops, I forgot the bonus question:

On 4/15/1862
at Picacho Peak in Arizona
Confederate Rangers under Capt. Sherod Hunter (Confederate) were in the area
Column from California under Col. James H Carleton (Union) set out to Tucson
Union squad under Lt James Barrett of the 1st California Cavalry met with
Confederate Rangers led by Sergeant Henry Holmes


(5 Confederate casualties)
 
Regular question:
Forget my former post please, I just found the right guy:

Sergeant Herry Douglas is his name and Fort Marion is the fort!

"At this time, Ordinance Sergeant Henry Douglas, living in a caretaker's house on the fort green, comprised the entire Federal garrison of St. Augustine. Confronted with the overwhelming militia force, Sgt. Douglas demanded they sign a receipt for the fort and all its contents. Only then did he give up the keys. The Floridians, impressed with the sergeant's spirit, took up a collection amongst themselves to pay his passage back to Philadelphia. Thus the first conflict between North and South in St. Augustine was resolved peacefully."
https://www.nps.gov/casa/learn/historyculture/the-civil-war-in-florida.htm

"Upon reflection I decided that the only alternative for me was to deliver the keys, under protest, and demand a receipt for the property. One thing certain, with the exception of the guns composing the armament of the water battery, the property seized is of no great value. The gentleman acting under the governor's instructions has promised to receipt to me for the stores.

I am, sir, very respectfully, your obedient servant,
HENRY DOUGLAS.
Ordnance Sergeant, U.S. Army."

https://ironbrigader.com/2017/01/10/federals-lose-retake-floridas-fort-marion-shots-fired/
 
Bonus:

My first thought was the Battle of Picacho Pass, April 15, 1862. Picacho Pass now lies in Arizona, but during the Civil War was for the Confederates Arizona Territory and for the Federals New Mexico Territory.

Combattants were: 12 Union cavalry troopers under Lt. Barrett from the 1st California Cavalry and 10 Confederates from the Arizona Rangers, led by Sgt. Henry Holmes.

From Wikipedia, (highlighting by me):
Twelve Union cavalry troopers and one scout(reported to be mountain man Pauline Weaverbut in reality Tucson resident John W. Jones), commanded by Lieutenant James Barrett of the 1st California Cavalry, were conducting a sweep of the Picacho Peak area, looking for Confederates reported to be nearby. The Arizona Confederates were commanded by Sergeant Henry Holmes.
[...]
However, "Lt. Barrett acting alone rather than in concert, surprised the Rebels and should have captured them without firing a shot, if the thing had been conducted properly." Instead, in midafternoon the lieutenant "led his men into the thicket single file without dismounting them. The first fire from the enemy emptied four saddles, when the enemy retired farther into the dense thicket and had time to reload. ...

But although the source above states" "four emptied saddles", most sources give the no. of Confederate casualties as five.

On the other hand I found this:

On the east side of Tucson, there is a monument to four Confederate soldiers believed to be the only Confederates killed in battle in Arizona. They were killed by Apaches at the Dragoon Springs Station. The Arizona Division, Sons of the Confederate Veterans maintains the site.
https://www.google.de/amp/s/amp.azf...show-where-are-arizonas-confederate-monuments

Snip-it_1525469363644.jpg

Snip-it_1525469663003.jpg

Snip-it_1525469793083.jpg

http://ktvk.images.worldnow.com/images/14670540_G.jpg

So my final answers are:
When: May 5, 1862
Where: Dragon Springs Station, AZ
Unit: Company A, Gov. John R. Baylor's regiment of the Arizona Rangers
 
Ordnance Sergeant Henry Douglas was the entire garrison of Fort Marion (aka Castillo de San Marcos) in St. Augustine, Florida, when it was seized.

Bonus: I see two clashes in Arizona which resulted in Confederate casualties. The first, at Picacho Peak on April 15, 1862, resulted in three Arizona Rangers being captured. Since the question specifically mentions four casualties, I will go with the second event, the First Battle of Dragoon Springs, in which four Confederate Arizona Rangers were killed fighting against Apaches on May 5, 1862.
http://exploringoffthebeatenpath.com/Battlefields/ForgottenFront/index.html
 
Battle of Dragoon Springs. Herbert's Arizona Company, 2nd Texas Cavalry.

Edit - Desert Kid, you are correct that it was the Battle of Dragoon Springs, but to get credit for a correct response, you would have had to answer the part of the question that asked when it occurred.

Welcome to the trivia game, anyway. Hope you'll come back and play again.

hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bonus: Battle of Picacho Pass, New Mexico Territory, north of today's Tucson, Pinal County, AZ, where two opposing scouting parties engaged: Union Lt. James Barrett (who was killed) and twelve men of the 1st California Cavalry, and CSA Sergeant Henry Holmes and Captain Sherod Hunter of the Confederate Cavalry plus eleven more men. A total of three deaths are recorded to have occurred in this battle, though the actual number of deaths is disputed.
 
Main question: I have no answer.

Bonus: The only action within present day Arizona that I can find was the Battle of Picacho Pass. There appears to be little dispute that three Confederates were captured, but the source I found says that the Union claimed two Confederates were wounded while the Confederates said none were wounded. So according to one side there were three casualties and according to the other side, there were five. I guess if you take the average, that's four. :geek:

So my answer is (a) the casualties occurred on April 15, 1862; (b) they occurred at Picacho Pass; and (c) the unit involved was the Arizona Rangers.
 
bonus:

if this site has all engagements in modern day arizona (i have no way to check that but i didnt find anything saying otherwise) it means there were no yankees involved. it this case it need to be the first battle of dragoon springs
  1. 5 may 1862
  2. close to present day benson, arizona then confederate arizona
  3. a small troop of john robert baylor's arizona rangers and a band of apache warriors
 
Sergeant Henry Douglas surrendered Fort Marion, Florida after requiring a receipt from the Confederates.

Bonus:
Where? Dragoon Springs near present day Benson, Arizona
When? May 5, 1862
Units? Company A, Baylor's Regiment of Arizona Rangers and 100 Chiricahua Apache warriors under Chiefs Francisco and Cochise.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top