Trivia 5-24-16 Two Commanders

Status
Not open for further replies.

Trivia Master

The Keeper of Knowledge
Forum Host
Joined
Mar 21, 2012
In early August of 62, in N Va, a battle was fought.
One Division conmander was killed, while a second arrived in time to save the day for their secretive Wing commander.
Name the two Division heads.

credit: @CadmusWilcox
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sbc
Slaughter's Mountain (Cedar Run) August 9, 1862.
Principal Commanders: Maj. Gen. Nathaniel Banks [US]; Maj. Gen. Thomas J. Jackson [CS]
Maj. Gen. John Pope was placed in command of the newly constituted Army of Virginia on June 26. Gen. Robert E. Lee responded to Pope's dispositions by dispatching Maj. Gen. T.J. Jackson with 14,000 men to Gordonsville in July. Jackson was later reinforced by A.P. Hill's division. In early August, Pope marched his forces south into Culpeper County with the objective of capturing the rail junction at Gordonsville. On August 9, Jackson and Maj. Gen. Nathaniel Banks's corps tangled at Cedar Mountain with the Federals gaining an early advantage. A Confederate counterattack led by A.P. Hill repulsed the Federals and won the day. Confederate general William Winder was killed. This battle shifted fighting in Virginia from the Peninsula to Northern Virginia, giving Lee the initiative.

Source: http://www.civilwaracademy.com/civil-war-battles-in-virginia-1862.html
 
Battle of Cedar Mountain.
Division Commander Brig.Gen. Charles Winder was mortally wounded and division command devolved to Brig. Gen. William Taliaferro and that division fought alongside the division of Brig. Gen. Jubal Early. The reserve division commanded by Maj. Gen. A.P Hill entered the battle "in time to save the day for their secretive Wing commander"
 
Brig Gen Charles S Winder (Jackson's Division) was mortally wounded. Major General A. P. Hill (Light Division) came up to help se the day. Excellent commanding by the Confederates at the crucial moment of the battle and the fortuitous arrival of Hill staved off defeat, eventually allowing their numerical superiority to drive the Federals from the field.
source-wikipedia.
 
Charles S. Winder and William Taliaferro.

Edit - Taliaferro began the battle as a brigade commander. Though command of Winder's division fell to Taliaferro after Winder was killed, Taliaferro was already on the field, so could not be said to have "arrived." He was also ignorant of the battle plan, so he couldn't really be said to have saved the day.

Hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
At Cedar Mountain Brigadier General Charles Winder was mortally wounded and the other "secretive" wing commander was General Stonewall Jackson.

Edit - Jackson was the secretive wing commander, but the question asked for the name of the division commander who arrived to save the day.

Hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
August 9, 1862 - Battle of Cedar Mountain

Charles Sidney Winder
was killed leading a division (four brigades: 1st/Stonewall [Ronald], 2nd [Garnett], 3rd [Taliaferro], 4th [Lawton] and 3 batteries under Andrews). Winder was commander of the Stonewall Brigade but became Division commander for "a few minutes" as Gary Gallagher puts it (The Shenandoah Valley Campaign of 1862):

upload_2016-5-24_9-25-0.png


A P Hill saved the day, bringing his Light Division into the action around 6pm

T. Jackson was of course their secretive "wing" commander.

Beginning at about two o'clock on the afternoon of August 9, Confederate batteries, including some on Cedar Mountain, exchanged fire with Union artillery. Confederate infantry moved into formation to charge the Union guns and then suffered immensely while charging, while Union infantry also arrived in strength. Instead of retreating in the face of his old Shenandoah Valley nemesis, however, Banks decided to stand and fight. As the Confederates attacked, Confederate general Charles S. Winder of the Stonewall Brigade fell with a mortal wound. Union troops, meanwhile, pressed the Confederate center and right, but their advance petered out.

The moment of crisis came at six o'clock in the evening, when the brigade of Union general Samuel W. Crawford attacked the Confederate left flank and began to roll up the entire Confederate line. The fighting became so desperate that Jackson rushed in and attempted to rally the men himself, cutting a dramatic figure as he waved his sword in the air with one hand and a Confederate battle flag with the other. Crawford's men withdrew under the pressure of the now-reinvigorated Confederate troops. Confederate general A. P. Hill's division launched a counterattack, pushing Banks's men back a bit as night fell. The following day the two sides separated slightly, but stood close enough for light skirmishing to occur throughout the day. The armies remained in place until August 11, when Jackson began to withdraw toward Orange.

http://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Cedar_Mountain_Battle_of#start_entry
 

Attachments

  • upload_2016-5-24_9-22-50.png
    upload_2016-5-24_9-22-50.png
    48.9 KB · Views: 149
Question: Name the two Division heads.

Major General T. J. "Stonewall" Jackson

Major Genearl A. P. "Little Powell" Hill


300px-Battle_of_Cedar_Mountain.png
The battle at Cedar Mountain, by Currier and Ives


The Battle of Cedar Mountain, a/k/a Slaughter's Mountain and as Cedar Run, in Culpeper County, Virginia
At the Battle of Cedar Mountain on August 9, Hill launched a counterattack that stabilized the Confederate left flank, preventing it from being routed.

also: General killed was;
https://www.geni.com/people/Charles-Winder/6000000000911574358

Charles Sidney Winder, Brig. Gen., CSA
Birthdate: October 18, 1829
Death: Died August 9, 1862 in Culpeper County, Virginia, United States
Cause of death: killed in the Battle of Cedar Mountain

http://www.civilwaracademy.com/civil-war-battles-in-virginia-1862.html (this source incorrectly names the general killed as "William Winder"(? reincarnated from 1812 in-fame for a do-over?) actually General Charles Winder was killed.

http://www.civilwar.org/battlefields/cedar-mountain.html

Edit - Answer revised in post # 14.

Hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Correction: I need to reread the question before hitting "Post Reply", can't edit before it is closed, but can re-post before deadline . . .:whistling: . . .:thumbsup:

"One Division conmander (sic) was killed, while a second arrived in time to save the day, . . "

Therefore my answer is:

Division Commander Charles Winder (killed),
Division Commander A.P. Hill, (saved the day)
 
The killed division commander is Brig. Gen. Charles S. Winder, commanding Jackson's Division, and Maj. Gen. A.P. Hill, commanding the Light Division, reinforced and saved the day for Jackson at Cedar Mountain.

Edit - Correct, novushomus. Welcome to the trivia game and to CivilWarTalk.

If you haven't done so already, you're invited to stop by the New Recruits Meet & Greet forum and introduce yourself to some more CivilWarTalkers.

Hope you'll come back and play again.

Hoosier
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This would be the battle of Cedar Mountain. The "secretive wing commander" was Stonewall Jackson, who didn't publicize his battle plans, so the second in command to the killed division commander didn't know what he was supposed to do.
The division commander who was killed was Brigadier General Charles S. Winder.
The one who saved the day was AP Hill--another case of "AP Hill came up."
Sources: wikipedia article, "Battle of Cedar Mountain"; http://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Cedar_Mountain_Battle_of
 
Cedar Mountain
Slaughter's Mountain, Cedar Run
Civil War Virginia


American Civil War
August 9, 1862


Major General John Pope was placed in command of the newly constituted Army of Virginia on June 26.

General Robert E. Lee responded to Pope's dispositions by dispatching Major General T.J. Jackson with 14,000 men to Gordonsville in July. Jackson was later reinforced by A.P. Hill's division.

In early August, Pope marched his forces south into Culpeper County with the objective of capturing the rail junction at Gordonsville.

On August 9, Jackson and Major General Nathaniel Banks's corps tangled at Cedar Mountain with the Federals gaining an early advantage.

A Confederate counterattack led by A.P. Hill repulsed the Federals and won the day. Confederate general William Winder was killed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top