Recreated 21st Century Collops

amweiner

2nd Lieutenant
Joined
Feb 8, 2017
Location
Monterey, CA
Hi friends!

If you saw my earlier post on period receipts for collops, you noticed that it's a very timeless, versatile dish that can use different meats, seasonings, and sauces. All of the recipes I saw appear to have a few things in common:

· The meat should be sliced thinly
· Cutlets are floured and pan fried
· A gravy or sauce is spooned on top of the cooked cutlets

All well and good, right? I thought so as I gave this dish a few modern twists, and was very happy with the results. I hope you'll give this a try!

First off, I decided to change up the meat, not being a huge fan of veal; it's hard to cook something you can imagine staring at you with big, adorable, mournful eyes. I debated between thinly sliced pork sirloin and chicken cutlets, finally settling on pork because there was less chance of it drying out. And also because piggies have small, beady eyes.

I gave the pork slices a light seasoning of salt and pepper, then coated them with a flour and cornstarch mixture that had been seasoned with garlic powder, smoked paprika, and a pinch of ground cloves. I stuck with the basic recipe of pan frying the cutlets, but in a mixture of oil and butter as I like the results better – butter adds flavor but can brown very quickly at the temp needed to get a good crisp exterior. These were fried up at medium high heat for a few minutes on each side – to be honest, I went more with the look of the cutlet than time, turning them once or twice to get the right crisp and light brown color I wanted.

Although the period recipes call for cooking the sauce or gravy with the collops, I wanted to keep the cutlets crisp and not have the sauce turn them into a soggy mess: after all, who wants soggy collops? The cutlets were given a timeout in a 175 degree oven while I made the sauce, again with some modifications from the original. I don't have the money or patience to look for morel mushrooms, so I stuck with a mix of fresh sliced white and brown mushrooms, probably about 2 cups' worth. These soaked up the flavor from the oil-butter mixture in the pan, to which I added a pinch of cayenne pepper, a spoonful of tomato paste, some chicken broth, grated lemon peel, and some minced garlic. To thicken this up, I threw in a little of the flour-cornstarch mixture I had left over, and simmered the sauce until it was bubbly and delicious-smelling. The final touch was adding some white balsamic vinegar and fresh lemon juice to the sauce. After spooning the sauce over the crispy pork cutlets, I went for broke and topped this with some crisp-cooked bacon.

The final result was amazing, even though (as our friend @Jimklag will point out) this is a clear violation of Jewish dietary laws. :smile: There's a lot of flavor going on in there, and I think you'll find this dish is worth the time. Fortunately, most of the ingredients are commonplace and you won't have to search for exotic stuff to make a really good meal.

I hope you'll try this out, and let me know of any variations you make along the way! I'm sorry I don't have any exact measurements for this – I just used the original recipe as a starting point and eyeballed with my modern ingredients, but if you'd like my guesstimates, I can certainly post those anytime.

Enjoy!!
 
Last edited:
Hi friends!

If you saw my earlier post on period receipts for collops, you noticed that it's a very timeless, versatile dish that can use different meats, seasonings, and sauces. All of the recipes I saw appear to have a few things in common:

· The meat should be sliced thinly
· Cutlets are floured and pan fried
· A gravy or sauce is spooned on top of the cooked cutlets

All well and good, right? I thought so as I gave this dish a few modern twists, and was very happy with the results. I hope you'll give this a try!

First off, I decided to change up the meat, not being a huge fan of veal; it's hard to cook something you can imagine staring at you with big, adorable, mournful eyes. I debated between thinly sliced pork sirloin and chicken cutlets, finally settling on pork because there was less chance of it drying out.

I gave the pork slices a light seasoning of salt and pepper, then coated them with a flour and cornstarch mixture that had been seasoned with garlic powder, smoked paprika, and a pinch of ground cloves. I stuck with the basic recipe of pan frying the cutlets in a mixture of oil and butter as I like the results better – butter adds flavor but can brown very quickly at the temp needed to get a good crisp exterior. These were fried up at medium high heat for a few minutes on each side – to be honest, I went more with the look of the cutlet than time, turning them once or twice to get the right crisp and light brown color I wanted.

Although the period recipes call for cooking the sauce or gravy with the collops, I wanted to keep the cutlets crisp and not have the sauce turn them into a soggy mess: after all, who wants soggy collops? The cutlets were given a timeout in a 175 degree oven while I made the sauce, again with some modifications from the original. I don't have the money or patience to look for morel mushrooms, so I stuck with a mix of fresh sliced white and brown mushrooms, probably about 2 cups' worth. These soaked up the flavor from the oil-butter mixture in the pan, to which I added a pinch of cayenne pepper, a spoonful of tomato paste, some chicken broth, grated lemon peel, and some minced garlic. To thicken this up, I threw in a little of the flour-cornstarch mixture I had left over, and simmered the sauce until it was bubbly and delicious-smelling. The final touch was adding some white balsamic vinegar and fresh lemon juice to the sauce. After spooning the sauce over the crispy pork cutlets, I went for broke and topped this with some crisp-cooked bacon.

The final result was amazing, even though (as our friend @Jimklag will point out) this is a clear violation of Jewish dietary laws. :smile: There's a lot of flavor going on in there, and I think you'll find this dish is worth the time. Fortunately, most of the ingredients are commonplace and you won't have to search for exotic stuff to make a really good meal.

I hope you'll try this out, and let me know of any variations you make along the way! I'm sorry I don't have any exact measurements for this – I just used the original recipe as a starting point and eyeballed with my modern ingredients, but if you'd like my guesstimates, I can certainly post those anytime.

Enjoy!!
Mazel tov, Adam. Happy Rosh Hashanah.
 
Hi friends!

If you saw my earlier post on period receipts for collops, you noticed that it's a very timeless, versatile dish that can use different meats, seasonings, and sauces. All of the recipes I saw appear to have a few things in common:

· The meat should be sliced thinly
· Cutlets are floured and pan fried
· A gravy or sauce is spooned on top of the cooked cutlets

All well and good, right? I thought so as I gave this dish a few modern twists, and was very happy with the results. I hope you'll give this a try!

First off, I decided to change up the meat, not being a huge fan of veal; it's hard to cook something you can imagine staring at you with big, adorable, mournful eyes. I debated between thinly sliced pork sirloin and chicken cutlets, finally settling on pork because there was less chance of it drying out. And also because piggies have small, beady eyes.

I gave the pork slices a light seasoning of salt and pepper, then coated them with a flour and cornstarch mixture that had been seasoned with garlic powder, smoked paprika, and a pinch of ground cloves. I stuck with the basic recipe of pan frying the cutlets, but in a mixture of oil and butter as I like the results better – butter adds flavor but can brown very quickly at the temp needed to get a good crisp exterior. These were fried up at medium high heat for a few minutes on each side – to be honest, I went more with the look of the cutlet than time, turning them once or twice to get the right crisp and light brown color I wanted.

Although the period recipes call for cooking the sauce or gravy with the collops, I wanted to keep the cutlets crisp and not have the sauce turn them into a soggy mess: after all, who wants soggy collops? The cutlets were given a timeout in a 175 degree oven while I made the sauce, again with some modifications from the original. I don't have the money or patience to look for morel mushrooms, so I stuck with a mix of fresh sliced white and brown mushrooms, probably about 2 cups' worth. These soaked up the flavor from the oil-butter mixture in the pan, to which I added a pinch of cayenne pepper, a spoonful of tomato paste, some chicken broth, grated lemon peel, and some minced garlic. To thicken this up, I threw in a little of the flour-cornstarch mixture I had left over, and simmered the sauce until it was bubbly and delicious-smelling. The final touch was adding some white balsamic vinegar and fresh lemon juice to the sauce. After spooning the sauce over the crispy pork cutlets, I went for broke and topped this with some crisp-cooked bacon.

The final result was amazing, even though (as our friend @Jimklag will point out) this is a clear violation of Jewish dietary laws. :smile: There's a lot of flavor going on in there, and I think you'll find this dish is worth the time. Fortunately, most of the ingredients are commonplace and you won't have to search for exotic stuff to make a really good meal.

I hope you'll try this out, and let me know of any variations you make along the way! I'm sorry I don't have any exact measurements for this – I just used the original recipe as a starting point and eyeballed with my modern ingredients, but if you'd like my guesstimates, I can certainly post those anytime.

Enjoy!!

Excellent recipe, thanks for sharing. My grandmother was a huge fan of thin pork cutlets. My I make a seasoning suggestion? Instead of clove (which some cook's believe toughens white meats - not sure if that's true or urban legend), ground rosemary is an excellent accompaniment to pork.

And @amweiner shanah tovah :smile coffee:
 
shanah tovah
Thank you so much @Anna Elizabeth Henry!! To you as well - wishing only sweetness and happiness to all our friends here!

Thank you as well for the seasoning suggestion....this is one of the things I appreciate about this forum: there are great ideas for tweaks, additions, changes that can always add something new. I haven't heard about the clove and toughening of white meats, but am really grateful to you for sharing that!
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top