HF Jack Hinson Novel

Historical-Fiction
Like Tarzan?

I think he means holding on to trees while climbing uphill.

"using his free hand to pull himself from tree to tree, climbed to the top of the bluff."
Gents, when we went to Hinson's cave there was five of us and we literally had to use saplings to pull ourselves up the steep pathway to the entrance. It is not "straight up" but it is not far off of that. At least for fifty feet or so.
 
I've been watching Quigley Down Under and I guess that's where this all came from. I should've known; I think Mr. Revel compared Hinson to Quigley.

 
Gents, when we went to Hinson's cave there was five of us and we literally had to use saplings to pull ourselves up the steep pathway to the entrance. It is not "straight up" but it is not far off of that. At least for fifty feet or so.
"Battles And Sketches Of The Army Of Tennessee", published in 1905, mentions Hinson. (pages 596-597

 
"Battles And Sketches Of The Army Of Tennessee", published in 1905, mentions Hinson. (pages 596-597

The article says the sons were shot, not beheaded, after being charged with bushwhacking.

Anderson doesn't claim to have any actual knowledge of Hinson killing anyone. Only what Hinson told him.

Colonel Lowe of the 5th Iowa cavalry is mentioned as well in the article. Lowe died in 1898, so he was dead when this was published. Is there any record of the 5th Iowa being accused of the murder while Lowe was still alive and could respond to the accusation?
 
Probably the most preposterous anything about Hinson is this talk by Rev. John Weaver (former Chaplain-in-Chief of the SCV) defending Hinson on religious grounds. He also presents MacKenney's "speculation" parts as bona fide facts and adds his own made-up stuff. I'd like to borrow his time machine.

 
William E. Goodman of Lewis County, TN, was the gunsmith who made the rifle.

GoodmanWE1860.jpg
 
It's all those Sea Raven Press "books" you insist on reading from your library every night. :DI did find "tree to tree" a little confusing. For lots of reasons, that's probably a bit of hyperbole if he's helping himself up a slope, as seems plausible. He'd have to be built more like King Kong to use that method literally.
You've never climbed up a creek or river bank in the eastern US that had slope to it. Plus I doubt his shoes had Vibram lugged soles. They were slick leather of course.
 
You count the punch marks as decorations?
I honestly don't know if they are decorations or a kill record. That's why I mentioned looking at other rifles from the same smith. The only claim that the marks are a kill record comes from Hinson. No other person seems to have any first-hand knowledge of Hinson killing anyone. Except possibly killing the neighbor.
 
Probably the most preposterous anything about Hinson is this talk by Rev. John Weaver (former Chaplain-in-Chief of the SCV) defending Hinson on religious grounds. He also presents MacKenney's "speculation" parts as bona fide facts and adds his own made-up stuff. I'd like to borrow his time machine.

Not going to "Body Shame" him?
 
You've never climbed up a creek or river bank in the eastern US that had slope to it. Plus I doubt his shoes had Vibram lugged soles. They were slick leather of course.
You have liiterally no clue about what I have climbed. I'll wager that I've climbed up a lot more slopes than you have, lugging a 50 lb pack with climbing gear to boot. That's in the Cascades in WA; RM in MT, WY, CO, AB and BC; Whites in ME, NH; and Smokies in NC. If you don't think up slope bushwhacking is required in those places try reading up on it. Here's a tip, BTW - the various types of Vibram, Stealth, etc don't make any difference in most of that terrain. And "saplings" aren't "trees" and neither are brush, etc etc.
 
You have liiterally no clue about what I have climbed. I'll wager that I've climbed up a lot more slopes than you have, lugging a 50 lb pack with climbing gear to boot. That's in the Cascades in WA; RM in MT, WY, CO, AB and BC; Whites in ME, NH; and Smokies in NC. If you don't think up slope bushwhacking is required in those places try reading up on it. Here's a tip, BTW - the various types of Vibram, Stealth, etc don't make any difference in most of that terrain. And "saplings" aren't "trees" and neither are brush, etc etc.
Then why were you so surprised about that part of the narrative. 3 To 4 inch tree could be grabbed as support. Also a much larger tree could have been grabbed as support to move forward. Put your hand on the back side for support. Lot of the undergrowth today was not as trick back then. Much of that is invasive species that arrived here latter.

Get you a slick leather shoe and compare that to a good lugged soles. They make them for a reason. Try a pain PNW loggers for example.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top