How Should the Confederacy be Remembered?

I agree with most of what you said except that the North had many abolitionist. Abolitionism , was a fringe movement based on the moral opposition to slavery.

The North had many anti-slavery people but they did not care about abolition. They were against slavery for their own self interests, as they did not want to have to compete with slave labor.
Did the Union free the slaves and then add a counstutional amendment to outlaw slavery or did the Confederacy do so?
Leftyhunter
 
I didn't say they were false. They're genuine, obviously. But they represent the interests of the minority, of the rich and powerful in Southern society, and don't tell us a lot about the rest of the population.[/QUOTE
Based upon what historical evidence? Why don't the Ordinances of Secession tell us the truth of why the secessionists wanted to secede? After all they were written by duly elected officals.
Leftyhunter
 
I didn't say they were false. They're genuine, obviously. But they represent the interests of the minority, of the rich and powerful in Southern society, and don't tell us a lot about the rest of the population.

I think we can assume 40% of the population didn't want slavery to continue. They were the enslaved people. Of course, their views weren't considered worthy of being sought.

33% of the population were in slaveowning households.

That leaves 27% of the population.

Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they wanted to own slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they rented slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they didn't want blacks to be equal.

The rest were sheep who went along with it.

Edit to add: Except for the Unionists who resisted the confederacy and/or fought for the Union.
 
Last edited:
Based on what evidence are the Ordinances of Secession false?
Lefty, I don't see our friend Anderson1 saying anywhere that the ordinances of secession were false. I see him saying that the will of the southern people was ignored and maligned.
Now, granted, I don't think it's reasonable to assume that ALL the southern people were fairly represented by those ordinances. But I didn't see Anderson1 claiming that, either.
 
Lefty, I don't see our friend Anderson1 saying anywhere that the ordinances of secession were false. I see him saying that the will of the southern people was ignored and maligned.
Now, granted, I don't think it's reasonable to assume that ALL the southern people were fairly represented by those ordinances. But I didn't see Anderson1 claiming that, either.
If that is the case then the reason fir the Civil War was slavery since that is what the Ordinances of Secession say it was.
Therefore the Confederacy should logically be remembered as a failed attempt to preserve slavery . The only Southerners that were in fact oppressed were black Southerners and Unionists.
Leftyhunter
 
If that is the case then the reason fir the Civil War was slavery since that is what the Ordinances of Secession say it was.
Therefore the Confederacy should logically be remembered as a failed attempt to preserve slavery . The only Southerners that were in fact oppressed were black Southerners and Unionists.
Leftyhunter
Once again, I have failed to see the connection which you see. I'm not arguing with your most recent statement. I agree with your most recent statement. I fail to see anywhere that Anderson1 claimed that the ordinances of secession were false.
 
Once again, I have failed to see the connection which you see. I'm not arguing with your most recent statement. I agree with your most recent statement. I fail to see anywhere that Anderson1 claimed that the ordinances of secession were false.
@Andersonh1 was arguing that the Ordinances of Secession are overrated because they don't represent the majority of white Southerners political reasons for secession. If that is the case what historical evidence is there for the argument?
Leftyhunter
 
I think we can assume 40% of the population didn't want slavery to continue. They were the enslaved people. Of course, their views weren't considered worthy of being sought.

33% of the population were in slaveowning households.

That leaves 27% of the population.

Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they wanted to own slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they rented slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they didn't want blacks to be equal.

The rest were sheep who went along with it.

Edit to add: Except for the Unionists who resisted the confederacy and/or fought for the Union.


Your math is fuzzy because the slaves were not part of the Confederacy. Thus, based on your number 67% of the white southern population were not in slaveholding households.
 
Last edited:
Your math is fuzzy because the slaves were not part of the Confederacy. Thus, based on your number 67% of the white southern population were not in slaveholding households.

Going by the US Census the 33% of families is total families, not just white families. That includes free black families and involves the total population. So using the 40% of enslaved people in the confederate states is correct.
 
@Andersonh1 was arguing that the Ordinances of Secession are overrated because they don't represent the majority of white Southerners political reasons for secession. If that is the case what historical evidence is there for the argument?
Leftyhunter
I'll let Anderson speak for himself. The source I found says an average of 32% white families owned slaves. If I understand Cash correctly, he asserts that the number is 33% and involves total families. Neither source tells us how many southern families ASPIRED to owning slaves. Regardless, it seems clear to me that Andersonh1 made a reasonable assertion that the majority of southerners were not represented by the ordinances of secession. Obviously, the politically powerful were well represented.
 
I'll let Anderson speak for himself. The source I found says an average of 32% white families owned slaves. If I understand Cash correctly, he asserts that the number is 33% and involves total families. Neither source tells us how many southern families ASPIRED to owning slaves. Regardless, it seems clear to me that Andersonh1 made a reasonable assertion that the majority of southerners were not represented by the ordinances of secession. Obviously, the politically powerful were well represented.

Actually, it's not a reasonable assertion. It assumes one cannot want to protect slavery if one is not in a slaveholding household.
 
Actually, it's not a reasonable assertion. It assumes one cannot want to protect slavery if one is not in a slaveholding household.
It doesn't assume that at all. To the contrary, you make a reverse assumption. I stated that we can't know how many people aspired to owning slaves. Those that did would certainly have wanted to protect slavery until they could afford it.
 
I think we can assume 40% of the population didn't want slavery to continue. They were the enslaved people. Of course, their views weren't considered worthy of being sought.

33% of the population were in slaveowning households.

That leaves 27% of the population.

Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they wanted to own slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they rented slaves.
Some percentage of them wanted slavery to continue because they didn't want blacks to be equal.

The rest were sheep who went along with it.

Edit to add: Except for the Unionists who resisted the confederacy and/or fought for the Union.

What I was trying to get at is using your numbers 40% of the population were slaves (not part of the Confederacy)

Thus, out of the white population about 33% of families owned slaves.

That leaves about 67% of white families that did not own slaves.
 
It doesn't assume that at all. To the contrary, you make a reverse assumption. I stated that we can't know how many people aspired to owning slaves. Those that did would certainly have wanted to protect slavery until they could afford it.

Not only people aspiring to own slaves, but also people who rented slaves, people whose livelihood depended on the slave system, and people who believed in using slavery as a system of racial control. Indeed, it's highly probable the vast majority of white residents of the confederacy supported the institution of slavery and believed it needed to be protected.
 
What I was trying to get at is using your numbers 40% of the population were slaves (not part of the Confederacy)

Thus, out of the white population about 33% of families owned slaves.

That leaves about 67% of white families that did not own slaves.

The enslaved people were included in the total population numbers for the confederacy.
 
@Andersonh1 was arguing that the Ordinances of Secession are overrated because they don't represent the majority of white Southerners political reasons for secession. If that is the case what historical evidence is there for the argument?
Leftyhunter

We know that the political elite wanted to secede over the issue of slavery, as they made that clear in the Ordinances of Secession.

So the Confederacy was formed to protect the institution of slavery, I don't think that is deniable.

Some say that the Confederacy should be remembered for that reason and that reason only.

However, since the majority of Southerners did not have a material interest in slavery that view may be overly simplistic.
 
We know that the political elite wanted to secede over the issue of slavery, as they made that clear in the Ordinances of Secession.

So the Confederacy was formed to protect the institution of slavery, I don't think that is deniable.

Some say that the Confederacy should be remembered for that reason and that reason only.

However, since the majority of Southerners did not have a material interest in slavery that view may be overly simplistic.

Is that true?

That anti-abolition sentiment was abundant both in newspaper editorials and sermons in the South, would seem to indicate the opposite. So would the fact that the leaders of the Confederacy didn't try to sell an alternative reason for the war to the voters. They publicly proclaimed slavery their rallying cry. One didn't necessarily have to be a slave-owner to believe you, or your county or state, benefited from slavery.
 
What percentage of white families owned slaves?

Close to 33% because enslaved families aren't counted and free black families would be a small number, but definitely less than 33% if we limit to white only.

Edit: That should be a little more than 33% if we limit to white only. Math in public late at night. ;)
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top