I keep going back to my old stand-by, an old Ideal 575213OS as the best all around bullet. I've tried others, but without the satisfaction of the old style Ideal/Lyman. I like a healthy charge behind the ball, 45-55gr. of FFFg depending on the musket. I just sold my Hodgdon mold a few months ago, it didn't shoot bad, I just prefer the old 575213OS.
You guys are only casting a few hundred for the year? I used to cast a couple hundred a month, practice, and more practice!
What are you guys shooting? When I retired from it, I was mostly shooting a hand built Fayetteville type II, the gun in my avatar...And an origional Windsor Enfield relined by Hoyt. Still have both, but mostly got rid of the carbines, smoothbores, and revolvers.