why two revolvers?

I wonder if the famous and attention-seeking George Custer routinely carried TWO revolvers himself.
That's a good question. He owned quite a few firearms of various sorts. The only pistols I know for certain was a pair of S&W #2's, an 1858 Remington, pinfire and a Webley. I'd be surprised if he also hadn't owned a Colt SAA.

I want to say at least one of his weapons was in the Rock Island Arsenal collection when I was a volunteer there but I may well be misremembering that as among the arms collected from the Lakota and Cheyenne.
 
You don't have to field strip. Pull the wedge, barrel and load lever slide off, cylinder comes off and new one on and barrel back on wedge inserted and your ready to go. I can change a cylinder in 30 seconds.
that would be the Remington revolver not the colt
 
I suspect a number have not tried any reloading IN ACTION with anything but a M1911A1 or a M9. In the days of cap and ball and even cartridge revolvers, reloading was done during a pause in action - preferably under cover. This is why so many different types of weapon were issued to cavalry. The pistol was almost a 'last ditch' weapon, second only to the various knives carried. The main weapons were the carbine and the sword/saber. The carbine kept the enemy at a distance and the saber was, traditionally of course, the weapon of attack. The war changed all that, with some cavalry with the various armies staying traditional - and being used in their intended role, while some were more like mounted infantry and some being only armed recconaissance. Then you had the 'raiders'.

The effective range of a pistol on horseback is about 10 yards. A carbine, on horseback, maybe 50. Shot and shell are all around too. Dismounted is a different matter - a steady firing platform and available cover. The saber (unsharpened or not) was mainly to put the fear of God into the enemy - a weapon used with great effect and momentum in 'the charge'. That was when the pistol also became a useful asset, a close range, short encounter, melee, on the move. Six shots and get the saber or carbine ready. There was no pause in either the charge or the encounter melee.
 
that would be the Remington revolver not the colt
Remington doesn't have a wedge. The Colt does.

1740961223416.png



1740961157738.png
 
In reading narratives involving Wheeler's Cavalry I see no mention of spare cylinders but they do mention extra "four inch" pistols which I take as pocket sized revolvers. The Whitney Navy seems to have been a popular pistol among them, based on photos. Their primary arm by early 1864 was the 58 Enfield and the 54 Lorenz as they were often used dismounted as Infantry.
 
I have a book on Terry's Texas Rangers, by Bush… I thought I knew where it was but was wrong. I may have loaned it out which will suck. But it's a history of the unit including, IIRC, details on their equipment throughout the war. If I remember right there were no extra cylinders mentioned when they mustered in. As a number of that regiment were actual Texas Rangers prior to the war I would think such would be mentioned.

By the ACW I'm pretty sure the older Paterson Colts were gone replaced by newer models. But I've been wrong before, just ask my wife.
 
Last edited:
My cousins David trains mounted officers. In this part of.the world the preferred mount is a Tennessee Walking Horse.

IMG_2582.png


As a child who grew up around Morgan's & Quarter Horses, the first time I saw a TN Walker was a gobstopper.

Trail riders here in Middle Tennessee have made piebald walkers their signature mount.

IMG_2583.jpeg


I have noticed in all this discussion of apocryphal extra cylinders, the horse itself has not been addressed.

IMG_1309.jpeg

Imagine you are mounted on a horse. It take two hands to
Remove the wedge &
wiggle the barrel away from the cylinder.

IMG_1307.jpeg

If at this point, even on a table top, if you have not juggled the five pieces off into the air, you gotta reverse the process with both hands without falling off the horse.

Anyways, my cousin is the only person I know who survived an ambush that killed his sergeant & prevailed in a 1 v 3 pistol firefight.

My point being, my cousin knows both about mounted policing & pistol combat.

According to him, the only people who can hit a target from a moving horse are either circus or rodeo performers.

The purpose of multiple pistols was riding into to town firing pistols, yahooing like crazy to sow panic, not actually hit anything.

A Tennessee Walker is (+ /-) 17 hands ( ! ) & 1,200 pounds. It is called a walker because of its smooth gate. You could ride all day supervising a plantation or trail riding.

Even when mounted on an animal renowned for its smooth gate, officers can't hit a barn door with a pistol.
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top