My cousins David trains mounted officers. In this part of.the world the preferred mount is a Tennessee Walking Horse.
As a child who grew up around Morgan's & Quarter Horses, the first time I saw a TN Walker was a gobstopper.
Trail riders here in Middle Tennessee have made piebald walkers their signature mount.
I have noticed in all this discussion of apocryphal extra cylinders, the horse itself has not been addressed.
Imagine you are mounted on a horse. It take two hands to
Remove the wedge &
wiggle the barrel away from the cylinder.
If at this point, even on a table top, if you have not juggled the five pieces off into the air, you gotta reverse the process with both hands without falling off the horse.
Anyways, my cousin is the only person I know who survived an ambush that killed his sergeant & prevailed in a 1 v 3 pistol firefight.
My point being, my cousin knows both about mounted policing & pistol combat.
According to him, the only people who can hit a target from a moving horse are either circus or rodeo performers.
The purpose of multiple pistols was riding into to town firing pistols, yahooing like crazy to sow panic, not actually hit anything.
A Tennessee Walker is (+ /-) 17 hands ( ! ) & 1,200 pounds. It is called a walker because of its smooth gate. You could ride all day supervising a plantation or trail riding.
Even when mounted on an animal renowned for its smooth gate, officers can't hit a barn door with a pistol.