why two revolvers?

Rate of fire. Reloading a Colt Model 1860* (or any cap & ball, save the Remington design) was a slow process and under the stress of being shot at, putting caps on those nipples was problematic.

A brace of revolvers gave a Trooper up to twelve rounds of ready-use rapid fire at close range, whereas the carbines were generally used on a dismounted firing line.

* .44 caliber Model 1860 Colt Army revolvers were generally known as saddle revolvers (following the precedence set by the .44 caliber Walker/Dragoon family of Colt revolvers).

.36 caliber Model 1851 Colt Navy revolvers were generally known as belt revolvers.
 
Last edited:
Rate of fire. Reloading a Colt Model 1860* (or any cap & ball, save the Remington design) was a slow process and under the stress of being shot at, putting caps on those nipples was problematic.

A brace of revolvers gave a Trooper up to twelve rounds of ready-use rapid fire at close range, whereas the carbines were generally used on a dismounted firing line.

* .44 caliber Model 1860 Colt Army revolvers were generally known as saddle revolvers (following the precedence set by the .44 caliber Walker/Dragoon family of Colt revolvers).

.36 caliber Model 1851 Colt Navy revolvers were generally known as belt revolvers.

Thanks so much for the great explanation! Another text (Bonnell's Sabres in the Shenandoah) says they were Remingtons, but I will double check his source to confirm. Still lots to learn...
 
Why was a circa-1863 Union trooper issued TWO revolvers? Why not one? "[E]ach trooper received an unsharpened Model 1860 saber, ... two revolvers in saddle holsters, a Burnside's Carbine and a McClellan saddle" (from Robert Bruce Donald's Manhood and Patriotic Awakening in the American Civil War).
I would question the veracity of this as a wide practice. There were never enough revolvers to go around on either side of the equation. The reality as often as not was one company carrying revolvers, another sabres and another with carbines. Did it happen occasionally that some Cav trooper ended up with a brace of pistols? Sure, until he was told to turn in his extra pistol to arm another cavalryman.

The US managed to fully equip its Regular Army Cav units but past that the AoP got first pick of supplies then AoC etc, etc. Even by the end of the War there were US Cav units which were a far cry from fully equipped with the one pistol, one carbine and sabre that was the ideal.

The CS never managed to fully equip it's Cav units which is why so many Dismounted Cavalry units existed. They were dismounted for lack of horses and their Cavalry small arms were passed on to other Cav units to get them closer to properly armed and those dismounted units would draw infantry small arms.
 
Last edited:
Note it stated "in saddle holsters". You could call these horse pistols. Their main fighting weapon was their carbine. The hirse pistols provided more fire power while on the run.

This makes a lot of sense, as my ancestors' unit was always on the run (usually from Mosby) from what I have read so far. Thanks!
 
I have never seen actual evidence of this. Carrying a loaded capped cylinder on a pouch on your hip would be about like carrying a grenade sans the pin.

From the CS accounts I have read they were carried in their saddle bags. Also, A lot of Gen Forrest Cav troops didn't even carry a carbine just pistols and sword.
 
I would question the veracity of this as a wide practice. There were never enough revolvers to go around on either side of the equation. The reality as often as not was one company carrying revolvers, another sabres and another with carbines. Did it happen occasionally that some Cav trooper ended up with a brace of pistols? Sure, until he was told to turn in his extra pistol to arm another cavalryman.

The US managed to fully equip its Regular Army Cav units but past that the AoP got first pick of supplies then AoC etc, etc. Even by the end of the War there were US Cav units which were a far cry from fully equipped with the one pistol, one carbine and sabre that was the ideal.

The CS never managed to fully equip it's Cav units which is why so many Dismounted Cavalry units existed. They were dismounted for lack of horses and their Cavalry small arms were passed on to other Cav units to get them closer to properly armed and those dismounted units would draw infantry small arms.

I was curious about the logistics of two, so this is all good to know. Thanks so much for the explanation!
 
From the CS accounts I have read they were carried in their saddle bags. Also, A lot of Gen Forrest Cav troops didn't even carry a carbine just pistols and sword.
A lot of Forrests men carried the P53 or any other arm they could get their paws on. No company was making spare cylinders for mass sale at the time. The CS certainly wasn't they could barely produce enough as it was so making extra cylinders was right out. The only pistol you could swap out a cylinder with any kind of speed that I can think of would be the Remington or Starr. In neither case would that be something I would want to do on horse back or in a combat situation. As far as I can tell prior to Clint Eastwood doing so in the movies you will find no reference to anyone swapping cylinders in combat.
 
I was curious about the logistics of two, so this is all good to know. Thanks so much for the explanation!
As a note in 1864 at Ft Abercrombie in the Dakota Territory there were about 500 men stationed there spread between 4 Cav units with a variety of arms to include: Sharps, Smith & Burnside carbines totaling less than 300 carbines as well as about 200 Colt Revolvers & about 300 sabres. As you can see there weren't enough pistols to go around.

While this was on the frontier the Dakota Uprising/War was an all to recent event with the Lakota being a very real threat.
 
In the ACW Cavalry troopers were issued one revolver, which went into a holster worn on their waist belt. Saddle Holsters were earlier and originally for the single shot "Horse Pistols", when the Walker Revolver made its appearance, it was issued in pairs and carried in saddle holsters because of their ungainly weight, and the tradition of using saddle holsters.

The Colt 1860 Revolver was not known as a "Saddle Revolver"....ever. The Colt bullet moulds issued for them are stamped with an "H", for "Holster" revolver, just as the early Colt 1849 bullet moulds are stamped with a "P" for "Pocket" revolver.

The process for reloading either a Colt or Remington revolver is identical, whether you are on horseback or on foot.

The current concept that Cavalry troopers carried extra cylinders has no basis in history, but is rather a modern re-enactor myth. However, the Pony Express riders did carry a Colt 1849 Pocket Revolver with one extra cylinder, but no extra rounds at all.
J.
 
I don't know a lot about the Army's practice, but I know my ancestor (the young man in my avatar) decided to carry his ONE Colt revolver home with him after the war, along with some other items. I suspect he was never issued more than one pistol, and OMIGOSH would I love to know where it and his saber are today! (In the avatar, you see him holding a Le Faucheaux pinfile. I'd like to know where that is, too!) He went home to the county just adjacent to mine. He is buried about fifteen miles from where I sit. But I don't know where his Colt revolver or his saber ended up!

I can shed some light about the typical guerrilla fighter in Missouri: Those boys carried as many revolvers and extra cylinders as they could manage, because they took a long time to load. In a fight, they could keep pulling out fresh revolvers until they "ran dry". By that point, the fight would have been over, one way or another, and the typical Missouri guerrilla would fade into the bush, where he would clean and reload all his weapons.

I'm editing to change my consideration about carrying extra cylinders. I wrote it (above) because I've read it. But I agree with subsequent posters that it would have been awfully dangerous. I wonder how often it really happened. It seems more likely they just carried as many revolvers as they could manage.
 
Last edited:
Anderson doesn't represent a measure of the usual issue to the usual cavalry trooper. Anderson and his compatriots carried as many pistols as they could stuff into their belts. Then, they would frequently carry two more in saddle holsters carried near the saddle horn--over the horse's neck, not his rump. But Anderson and his compatriots were irregulars. They were guerrillas, partisans....bushwhackers. They very probably acquired some of their pistols from the union militia soldiers they killed in battle. They weren't issued anything. They brought it all with them, or they picked it up as circumstances permitted.
 
Also, many Cav Troopers both North and South carried multiple cylinders per-load so they could just swap them out.

This question comes up periodically on a variety of historical forums. Carrying a loaded, capped Remington or Colt revolver cylinder separate from the frame is so egregiously stupid that you don't even want to think about it, no matter what the script writer had Clint Eastwood do. It is effectivly a hand grenade, People at the time didn't carry spare cylinders, they carried spare revolvers. There are good historical accounts of Confederate irregulars -- Mosby's people, for example -- carrying four or five; two in holster belts and two in saddle holsters were comon. If carrying a spare cylinder for reloads was safe, the contemporary manufacturers would have sold them with their guns. They didn't. The "bible" for Civil War arms purchases is Executive Document 99, 2nd Session, 40th Congress (14 January 1868). In Ex Doc 99, the President transmitted a War Department report to Congress on the War Department's purchases of arms during the Civil War. There is nothing in the report to indicate the the Federal Army purchased Colt's or Remington revolvers with spare cylinders. One can't say that a few individuals didn't have spare cylinders fitted and carry them on their own (getting back to my egregiously stupid comment), but it wasn't institutionalized as is implied.

As for issue weapons, one revolver was the norm later in the war. Early in the war, many cavalry companies were armed exclusively with sabers.

Regards,
Don Dixon
 
Patrick, I did not intend to imply the Anderson was regular cavalry. I was replying to the original question, "Why two revolvers." Much of the effectiveness of the Missouri Guerillas was due to their fire power. The best among them would practice shooting pumpkins off a fence post from a running horse. A band of guerillas, each armed with multiple revolvers and capable of hitting a man-sized target from a running horse would be the ultimate shock troops of the time. Mosby used similar tactics but he also sent much of his captured goods to Lee, Anderson kept what he captured. Early in the war Forrest used shotguns fro the same effect.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top