Why are the Three Antietam's?

RJSamp

Private
Joined
Oct 28, 2011
Location
Wheaton, IL
Why are there Three Antietam's?

Is there a fourth???

Maryland, My Maryland is the week before the 'battle'.

The NMBP or however that works outs is have one on the week of the battle....not a reenactment but a highly non farby liviing history.

And now those that have brung us the annual GBurg profit fest (GAC) are strongly rumored to be running one versus the National Battlefield living history.....

Fun Times!
 
ugh- I had coordinated with the NPS on our date so as not to conflict with thier plans...
 
I would say two, the National Park Service event will not be a (re)enactment per se,
those are usually historic weapons demos and living history without "battles." There is
no registration, invite only, etc. I plan to do the STRI anniversary programs next weekend.
Also usually anniversary programs at CHCH, Kennesaw and Ft Donelson when they roll
around on the calendar.

It would not surprise me if there was a f-a-r-b festival Antietam event and something
worth doing from Chris Anders. That seems to be the new "big event" pattern. Anders was ahead of the curve with the last Gettysburg two event go-round and the hobby is much more fragmented now. It is about what you would expect. The hobby has two Shiloh reenactments and probably a National Park Service event at the Shiloh Battlefield park, too. Why would Antietam be different?
 
I'm a westerner, and almost never go east, but if I did, Ander's events would be the one I would love to go to. Just so many 150th happenings going on this coming year. I'm very tempted however to make the long drive. Shiloh is a 9 hour drive for me. Sharpsburg would be 12+ at least. It all depends on my family situation. I have been to Sharpsburg only once in my life and it was during my honeymoon with Becky almost 30 years ago.

Shawn D. Swart
6th Ky Co C. CSA / 13th Ky Co D. USA
 
Pvt.A.Wells, sir;

You wrote:
I'm a westerner, and almost never go east, but if I did, Ander's events would be the one I would love to go to. Just so many 150th happenings going on this coming year. I'm very tempted however to make the long drive. Shiloh is a 9 hour drive for me. Sharpsburg would be 12+ at least. It all depends on my family situation. I have been to Sharpsburg only once in my life and it was during my honeymoon with Becky almost 30 years ago.

Shawn D. Swart
6th Ky Co C. CSA / 13th Ky Co D. USA

Could always excuse the extra long drive to Sharpsburg, as a revisit of the "honeymoon." [Insert thumbs up ]

M. E. Wolf
 
Well I will be at the 150th of Richmond Ky, Mills Spring, Perryville Ky, and Shiloh TN, and maybe even Raymond/Vicksburg 150th and Donelson TN 150th. :)
 
Maryland, My Maryland has plans in the works under a fabulous organizer, Stephanie Brennan, for an active civilian contingent.

Here's what she's been posting elsewhere:
I will be helping to coordinate the civilian side of things and am very excited. The event encompasses two battles that of South Mountain and Antietam.The civilians will be brought to live in a town that is situated between the two historic battle sites - Keedysville. Saturday, will give civilians a chance to react to the nearby battle of South Mountain but still maintain everyday life. The next day the battle of Antietam will take place. This should show a marked increase in involvement of the town with backlash from the battle.

Too Afraid To Cry -Maryland Civilians in the Antietam Campaign by Kathleen A. Ernest is a book that covers both battles and the civilians involved. It is highly recommended to help plan out appropriate impressions.

The unique prospect when portraying a town in Western Maryland is the ability to have a civilian impression that is either northern or southern in its loyalties. Needless to say this led to some rather unusual situations between neighbors. We are hoping to bring this reality to the atmosphere of the event.

We will be looking for people who would like to set up shops, businesses, churches, and homes. For those who are limited in gear but would like to do a portrayal of a teacher, sabbath school, lyceum speaker, society meeting, readings, play music, speeches, sing, itinerant workers giving instruction in painting, writing, deportment, and dance; etc. , a hall tent will be set up to help facilitate those needs. I will work with anyone who is intrested in being part of the town, you do not have to be in civilian camp but it is highly encouraged as this brings a great since of community.

Maryland campaign http://www.marylandmymaryland.org/ Registration is now open
Guidelines for civilians have not been posted as of yet but will be similar to the Ball's Bluff event.

The Historic newspaper index of Washington County Free Library and other Md libraries are covering the 150th anniversary with special clips on a day to day basis of the Civil War years in Maryland. This is a wonderful resource for background information and covers both Antietam and South Mountain, plus the surrounding areas of Boonsboro, Keedysville, and Sharpsburg.

http://www.whilbr.org/CW150Hagerstown/index.aspx Go to upper left hand corner to browse collection

For the more complete Maryland listing hit the link 150 years ago this week in the civil war at the lower part of the above page or

http://www.prattlibrary.org/locations/periodicals/civilwar/index.aspx?category=Union Troops in Maryland

For those who would rather day trip consider canal quarters lockhouse at Point of Rocks, MD approximately a 30 minute drive to the site.

http://www.canaltrust.org/quarters/lockhouse-28.php Hint -register early if this something you want to do.

- Stephanie Brennan

*****************************************
The book she references is a personal favorite that I've read many, many times for impression inspiration. The lock houses are a lot of fun... a real opportunity to get your history geek on.

Yeah, you have several events to choose from... this one is gonna be terrific.
 
Well I will be at the 150th of Richmond Ky, Mills Spring, Perryville Ky, and Shiloh TN, and maybe even Raymond/Vicksburg 150th and Donelson TN 150th. :smile:

I drove from Cleveland, Oh last year to be in Richmond, Ky and loved that event. We will be returning this year and taking some of my guys to Shiloh as well.
 
I'm a westerner, and almost never go east, but if I did, Ander's events would be the one I would love to go to. Just so many 150th happenings going on this coming year. I'm very tempted however to make the long drive. Shiloh is a 9 hour drive for me. Sharpsburg would be 12+ at least. It all depends on my family situation. I have been to Sharpsburg only once in my life and it was during my honeymoon with Becky almost 30 years ago.

Shawn D. Swart
6th Ky Co C. CSA / 13th Ky Co D. USA
No excuses! i've got a19+ hour trek to Sharpsburg
 
No excuses! i've got a19+ hour trek to Sharpsburg

lol!, Walk a mile in my shoes, I think you might change your mind. But I know your joking pard. :) Sad thing is, it is looking even worse now. Government has still not clear up thier error in Jan. So I have lost 25% of my income, and the wife Illness is worse, and taking care of her full time is hell on wheels every evening as she fights to breathe.
 
Why are there Three Antietam's?

Because there are too many credit-card Colonels and Generals to all play in one sandbox???

Okay, I am being sarcastic there. But in all honesty, a few events this year have had about as many NCO's and Officers as Privates show up. Maybe it is a good thing that there are multiple events. We can dilute the Officer / NCO pool a little :cold:
 
lol!, Walk a mile in my shoes, I think you might change your mind. But I know your joking pard. :smile: Sad thing is, it is looking even worse now. Government has still not clear up thier error in Jan. So I have lost 25% of my income, and the wife Illness is worse, and taking care of her full time is hell on wheels every evening as she fights to breathe.
Yes indeed I was joking.I am sorry to hear of your troubles.I didnt think I would be here for this event.Stage 4 liver.but I reponded well to 19months of Chemo,and I am trying to make as many 150s as my time and meager disability check allows.I truly hope things take a better turn for you and your lady.Now I hope we can meet on a western field,at some point.
 
Yes indeed I was joking.I am sorry to hear of your troubles.I didnt think I would be here for this event.Stage 4 liver.but I reponded well to 19months of Chemo,and I am trying to make as many 150s as my time and meager disability check allows.I truly hope things take a better turn for you and your lady.Now I hope we can meet on a western field,at some point.

Well Pard, sorry about your struggles. Good news is I found a bunch of pards a hr from me that are going to car pool it to Maryland my Maryland, and can take me along with them. So that will help a bunch. Going campaign style, so I need little to bring other than a full bag of rations. Some have to be at work Monday morning, so I can get back quick to my girl. Looks like I will be there!! Leaving out 7:30 am Friday.
 
Well Pard, sorry about your struggles. Good news is I found a bunch of pards a hr from me that are going to car pool it to Maryland my Maryland, and can take me along with them. So that will help a bunch. Going campaign style, so I need little to bring other than a full bag of rations. Some have to be at work Monday morning, so I can get back quick to my girl. Looks like I will be there!! Leaving out 7:30 am Friday.
Fantastic.I am glad that you are going,and to one that you will probebly enjoy more than the FA-b-fest i,m going to,the week after,and more important,you get to see that great old battlefield after 30 years.Have a blast,and it will be good for the misses,too,knowing youre haveing a good time.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top