The Confederacy's Crack Combat Brigade

Good points. Agree that there were other well-drilled and highly disciplined units with very capable commanders fighting for the Confederacy. But these Missourians were unique.

I read detailed accounts of the battlefield performances of these Missourians during the Civil War, and found them indeed to be a unique bunch of soldiers. Not only were they well-drilled and highly disciplined (like many other units), but they were naturally combative and very determined fellows. It was this feature of deep determination that struck me most about them and this was reflected in their aggressive and effective battlefield actions. To illustrate this determination, this group repeatedly made firm pledges that they would fight for the Confederacy for forty years or until the war ended, whichever happened first. They displayed the stern attitude that 'a job is not done, until completed'.

Cleburne led well-drilled and highly disciplined troops too. I did not include his command in my comparison of Southern combat Brigades here, because he was only a Brigade commander for a relatively short period (from late 1861 to end of 1862). In December, 1862, he was elevated to permanent Divisional Command, and became arguably the best combat Division commander in the Confederacy, until he was killed at Franklin in late 1864. There is no doubting Cleburne's fighting abilities and effectiveness as a combat Division leader. In contrast, I was considering the successful battlefield record of the Missouri Brigade over an extended period of almost four years. Because of these differences, I do not think a direct comparison can be made here.

The Infantry Brigades in Cleburne's Division were composed of regiments of Arkansans, Tennesseans, Texans and units from other Southern states. Under Cleburne's leadership and training, these troops were highly effective and reliable combat soldiers on the battlefield. In my view, however, they were not quite in the same category as shock troops, like the First Missouri brigade.
After Vicksburg the Missouri Brigade reorganized, recuperated and awaited parole near Demopolis. Have read several accounts that by that point in the War many, if not most of the boys had been wounded and many had suffered multiple wounds. Desertion was never a problem with this unit and they exhibited determination and valor in every battle, in which they participated.
 
There were several excellent combat Infantry Brigades that served in the Confederate Armies during the war. Most of them suffered abnormally high battlefield losses.

Four of the best and well-known of these Confederate Infantry Brigades (excluding adjunct units) were the:

. Stonewall Brigade

. Texas (or Hood's) Brigade

. Orphan Brigade

. Missouri Brigade


The Stonewall Brigade was probably the most famous combat infantry unit in the Army of Northern Virginia and were considered reliable fighters, both in defense and as assault troops. This Brigade was often in the thick of the fighting and participated in most of the major battles in the eastern theater. This all-Virginian Brigade, organized and led initially by Jackson (from mid-1861), consisted of the 2, 4, 5, 27 & 33 VA regiments. The Brigade was virtually wiped out at Spotsylvania (1864), after which it ceased to exist. The few surviving members were redeployed to other units and continued to fight with Lee's Army until the surrender at Appomattox.

The hard-hitting Texas (or Hood's) Brigade were probably the best shock combat troops in the Army of Northern Virginia. It was organized in late 1861 and was commanded by Hood for a period. The Brigade's regiments were the 1, 4 & 5 TX, as well as the 18 GA (originally), then the 3 AK (afterwards). This Brigade earned a reputation for being aggressive fighters. Under Hood, it launched savage and ferocious attacks at places like Gaines Mill, Second Manassas, Antietam, and Devils Den, Gettysburg, often resulting in very heavy casualties among its own ranks. The remnants of this Brigade surrendered at Appomattox.

The First Kentucky Infantry Brigade CSA, nicknamed the 'Orphan Brigade', was organized in late 1861 and was originally led by Breckinridge. These independently-minded Kentuckians were tenacious and tough fighters that endured frequent hardships and deprivations, and suffered under poor Army leadership. The Brigade was composed of the 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 & 9 KN regiments. The unit fought gallantly in many of the battles across eight states in the western theater with large losses, which included many of its commanders. It was used in direct assaults at Stones River and Chickamauga. The Orphans suffered horrific losses during the battles of the Atlanta campaign, and were virtually wiped out as an effective fighting force at Jonesboro. After Jonesboro, surviving members were transferred to mounted units and fought in the Carolinas until the end of the war.

The First Missouri Infantry Brigade CSA (the Missouri Brigade) was perhaps less well-known than the other famous Brigades above. This highly-disciplined Brigade of spirited and determined fighters, had a distinguished combat record second to none and often bore the brunt of the fighting. It was a highly mobile unit that fought in many major engagements and skirmishes across three theaters of the war. The Brigade was first organized from Missouri volunteers in late 1861. It was later (early 1863) commanded by Cockrell and became known as 'Cockrell's Missouri Brigade'. By late 1862, the Brigade included the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 & 6 MO infantry regiments. The Brigade launched ferocious attacks that broke through Union lines at places like, Corinth, Port Gibson, Champions Hill and Allatoona Pass, but often lacked the support needed to fully exploit its gains. It was steadfast in defense too, as demonstrated at the Vicksburg Siege and Kennesaw Mountain. The Brigade was slaughtered and almost destroyed at Franklin (1864) in a foolishly ordered frontal attack. Its few survivors later surrendered at Fort Blakely AL in 1865, after mounting a defiant defense against overwhelming odds.


After reading about the battlefield exploits of the First Missouri Brigade, I regard this unit as the best combat infantry Brigade that fought for the Confederacy. In my view, they were probably the South's best shock troops for launching assaults or counter-attacks. Like for the Stonewall and Orphan Brigades, these Missourians could also be counted on to mount a resolute defense. And Francis Cockrell, leading them, was arguably the best combat Brigade commander in the Confederate Army.

Interestingly, highly capable and regarded senior Confederate Generals like Joe Johnston and William Hardee, leaders with extensive and vast command experience, both said that Cockrell's Missouri Brigade was the best body of Infantry they ever saw. Similarly, another vastly experienced Confederate General, Dabney Maury, called them the finest troops he had ever seen.

In my opinion, there was no more effective Infantry Brigade that fought for the Confederacy, than this group of Missourians. Cockrell's Missouri Brigade was the Confederacy's best crack combat unit.

Was there a better Southern Infantry Brigade in combat?
I always thought the Stonewall Brigade was overrated, to be honest. Specific instances don't come to mind, but I seem to remember reading that it broke and ran on multiple occasions. I may be completely wrong on this, I admit, but that is my memory. In any event, I have no doubt it was a very good brigade and fought nobly on many occasions.

I second the inclusion of the Missouri Brigade in this list.
 
Missourians. But, I am biased. I had an ancestor, William Ruyle, who fought with the Fifth Missouri. I have a copy of his wartime diary around here somewhere. Funny thing is after he was paroled, he went to Texas for awhile and rejoined his unit at Demopolis. It's always been a mystery to me how that could have happened.
 
Missourians. But, I am biased. I had an ancestor, William Ruyle, who fought with the Fifth Missouri. I have a copy of his wartime diary around here somewhere. Funny thing is after he was paroled, he went to Texas for awhile and rejoined his unit at Demopolis. It's always been a mystery to me how that could have happened.
Demopolis was the parole camp where they stayed until they were exchanged. They were reformed and reequipped while they were there also.
 
I always thought the Stonewall Brigade was overrated, to be honest. Specific instances don't come to mind, but I seem to remember reading that it broke and ran on multiple occasions. I may be completely wrong on this, I admit, but that is my memory. In any event, I have no doubt it was a very good brigade and fought nobly on many occasions.

I second the inclusion of the Missouri Brigade in this list.
Agree. The Stonewall Brigade was not one of the really crack units, but probably the most famous and well-known, at least in the Army of Northern Virginia.
 
Demopolis was the parole camp where they stayed until they were exchanged. They were reformed and reequipped while they were there also.
I maybe mistaken about his parole. After Vicksburg I know he went to Texas for awhile. He is listed as a deserter while supposedly in captivity. I know he eventually made it back to Demopolis, to the Fifth Missouri. I tearing my room up right now looking for the copy of his parole I had.
 
At the beginning of the war there was a man S. R. Cockrill in Tennessee along with Gideon Pillow, and the Governor Isham Harris. All these men were inconsistent with one another on what their direct needs and desires were. Pillow wanted men to go with him to free Missouri, (June of 1861). Cockrill sent this message to Davis;
"It is quite natural that our best representatives should wish to retain the finest regiments, but I think that our best representatives should be sent abroad. This policy applies to military as well as civil appointments...."
[Series 1, Volume 52, part 2, page 112] (It was a fact established later in the war that most troops remaining in their local area were prone to desertion, and mischief.)
Isham Harris at this early date wanted all the forces of the south, Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi, to protect the border of Western Tennessee.
Lubliner.
 
There were several excellent combat Infantry Brigades that served in the Confederate Armies during the war. Most of them suffered abnormally high battlefield losses.

Four of the best and well-known of these Confederate Infantry Brigades (excluding adjunct units) were the:

. Stonewall Brigade

. Texas (or Hood's) Brigade

. Orphan Brigade

. Missouri Brigade


The Stonewall Brigade was probably the most famous combat infantry unit in the Army of Northern Virginia and were considered reliable fighters, both in defense and as assault troops. This Brigade was often in the thick of the fighting and participated in most of the major battles in the eastern theater. This all-Virginian Brigade, organized and led initially by Jackson (from mid-1861), consisted of the 2, 4, 5, 27 & 33 VA regiments. The Brigade was virtually wiped out at Spotsylvania (1864), after which it ceased to exist. The few surviving members were redeployed to other units and continued to fight with Lee's Army until the surrender at Appomattox.

The hard-hitting Texas (or Hood's) Brigade were probably the best shock combat troops in the Army of Northern Virginia. It was organized in late 1861 and was commanded by Hood for a period. The Brigade's regiments were the 1, 4 & 5 TX, as well as the 18 GA (originally), then the 3 AK (afterwards). This Brigade earned a reputation for being aggressive fighters. Under Hood, it launched savage and ferocious attacks at places like Gaines Mill, Second Manassas, Antietam, and Devils Den, Gettysburg, often resulting in very heavy casualties among its own ranks. The remnants of this Brigade surrendered at Appomattox.

The First Kentucky Infantry Brigade CSA, nicknamed the 'Orphan Brigade', was organized in late 1861 and was originally led by Breckinridge. These independently-minded Kentuckians were tenacious and tough fighters that endured frequent hardships and deprivations, and suffered under poor Army leadership. The Brigade was composed of the 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 & 9 KN regiments. The unit fought gallantly in many of the battles across eight states in the western theater with large losses, which included many of its commanders. It was used in direct assaults at Stones River and Chickamauga. The Orphans suffered horrific losses during the battles of the Atlanta campaign, and were virtually wiped out as an effective fighting force at Jonesboro. After Jonesboro, surviving members were transferred to mounted units and fought in the Carolinas until the end of the war.

The First Missouri Infantry Brigade CSA (the Missouri Brigade) was perhaps less well-known than the other famous Brigades above. This highly-disciplined Brigade of spirited and determined fighters, had a distinguished combat record second to none and often bore the brunt of the fighting. It was a highly mobile unit that fought in many major engagements and skirmishes across three theaters of the war. The Brigade was first organized from Missouri volunteers in late 1861. It was later (early 1863) commanded by Cockrell and became known as 'Cockrell's Missouri Brigade'. By late 1862, the Brigade included the 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 & 6 MO infantry regiments. The Brigade launched ferocious attacks that broke through Union lines at places like, Corinth, Port Gibson, Champions Hill and Allatoona Pass, but often lacked the support needed to fully exploit its gains. It was steadfast in defense too, as demonstrated at the Vicksburg Siege and Kennesaw Mountain. The Brigade was slaughtered and almost destroyed at Franklin (1864) in a foolishly ordered frontal attack. Its few survivors later surrendered at Fort Blakely AL in 1865, after mounting a defiant defense against overwhelming odds.


After reading about the battlefield exploits of the First Missouri Brigade, I regard this unit as the best combat infantry Brigade that fought for the Confederacy. In my view, they were probably the South's best shock troops for launching assaults or counter-attacks. Like for the Stonewall and Orphan Brigades, these Missourians could also be counted on to mount a resolute defense. And Francis Cockrell, leading them, was arguably the best combat Brigade commander in the Confederate Army.

Interestingly, highly capable and regarded senior Confederate Generals like Joe Johnston and William Hardee, leaders with extensive and vast command experience, both said that Cockrell's Missouri Brigade was the best body of Infantry they ever saw. Similarly, another vastly experienced Confederate General, Dabney Maury, called them the finest troops he had ever seen.

In my opinion, there was no more effective Infantry Brigade that fought for the Confederacy, than this group of Missourians. Cockrell's Missouri Brigade was the Confederacy's best crack combat unit.

Was there a better Southern Infantry Brigade in combat?
I cannot add any particular brigades, however, I would not have included the Stonewall Brigade. If it was not for the First Bull Run, the Brigade would never had gotten its famous nickname and thus its notoriety. A hard fighting unit, yes, but nothing special and just equal to the brigades in Hill's Light Division or the Louisiana Tigers.
 
I cannot add any particular brigades, however, I would not have included the Stonewall Brigade. If it was not for the First Bull Run, the Brigade would never had gotten its famous nickname and thus its notoriety. A hard fighting unit, yes, but nothing special and just equal to the brigades in Hill's Light Division or the Louisiana Tigers.
Tend to agree upon reflection. Like your choice of the Louisiana Tigers, as a hard-fighting Brigade.
 
I always thought the Stonewall Brigade was overrated, to be honest. Specific instances don't come to mind, but I seem to remember reading that it broke and ran on multiple occasions. I may be completely wrong on this, I admit, but that is my memory. In any event, I have no doubt it was a very good brigade and fought nobly on many occasions.

I second the inclusion of the Missouri Brigade in this list.
One regiment at Cedar Mountain, the 27th Va. Not the brigade. The 27th was the brigades farthest regiment on the right. With the 1st Va on their right. When Crawford attacked the 1st Va fled, leaving the 27th's flank uncovered and open to Crawford's attack.
Stonewall Brigade proved them self's by standing toe to toe with the Iron Brigade at Brawner's Farm, and 2 days later repulsed the Iron Brigades attack from the railroad cut.
I vote The Stonewall Brigade stays. Are we doing "shock troops" or "crack brigades" here?
 
I think just about every one of the Confederate States can claim at least one combat brigade that they could take pride in for their marital prowess. Besides the brigades that have been mentioned Gregg's South Carolina Brigade, Lawton's Georgia Brigade, Rodes's Alabama Brigade, the Branch/Lane Brigade from North Carolina, Govan's Arkansas Brigade and Perrin's Florida Brigade all have combat records that show their courage, skill and devotion to duty.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top