Telegraphing in Battle

Joined
Jun 7, 2021
I haven't finished the entire book yet, but for anyone who wants to do a deep dive into the subject, this source seems like a good start. It was written by John Emmet O'Brien, M. D., Operator and Cipher-Operator, U. S. Military Telegraph, 1862-1866.

Dr. O'Brien gives credit to Andrew Carnegie for being the "father of the US Military Telegraph." This is not a claim I had ever heard before, as I associate Mr. Carnegie with steel, libraries, and institutions of higher learning, but evidently his contributions to his adopted country did not end there.


See pages 225-226 for the full translation and explanation of the code used to write the message below.
1780779530431.webp
 
Last edited:
The telegraph system failed badly during the Chancellorsville Campaign. There were multiple instances where
orders took hours to get from Point A to Point B which rendered them obsolete before they were received. When it worked well, the system was excellent. But when it didn't, it was potentially disastrous.

Ryan
 
The telegraph system failed badly during the Chancellorsville Campaign. There were multiple instances where
orders took hours to get from Point A to Point B which rendered them obsolete before they were received. When it worked well, the system was excellent. But when it didn't, it was potentially disastrous.

Ryan
I have always been amazed that the telegraph system worked as well as it did. It seems like it should have fallen victim far more often than it did due to simply being easily cut and to weather factors.
 
You might like this one, too, @Reconstructed Rebel since it's written by a local gent who lived in Lombard. The Helen Plum Library there is named for his wife, and the first library in Lombard (in use until the 1960s) was in the first floor of their home after he willed the house to the village upon his death.

 
You might like this one, too, @Reconstructed Rebel since it's written by a local gent who lived in Lombard. The Helen Plum Library there is named for his wife, and the first library in Lombard (in use until the 1960s) was in the first floor of their home after he willed the house to the village upon his death.



Thanks! This looks great - and he mentions Carnegie as well in the beginning of his story. It is fair to say, IMO, that most people underestimate or discount the critical contributions of the telegraph department in the war.

1790194368609.webp
 
If you want to know about signals, telegraph & cyphers during the Civil War there is no better place to start than the "Signal Corps Association 1860 -1865." Many of the authors were U. S. Army Signal Corps members & Viet Nam veterans. At large scale reenactments they set up signal nets with flags, Beardlee & key telegraph wire systems. They are living historians with a deep level of real world experience. Read more here.

Link

www.civilwarsignals.org

IMG_2536.webp

It is important to understand that the telegraph system did not operate on it own. It was the long distance element of a signal network. This photograph is of Fort Negley overlooking Nashville, Tennessee. Notice the tree on the left hand side, standing proud of the horizon.

IMG_2535.webp

Up in that tree was the treehouse site of Fort Negley Station. Radiating out from there were two sides of a triangle (+/-) 45 miles on a side.

Merrill's sketch Roper's Knob 1863.webp

Roper's Knob station overlooks Fort Granger in Franklin on the western corner.

IMG_0127.webp

60 feet up in a tremendous tree on the summit of Pilot Knob was Fort Transit, the eastern corner of the triangle.

IMG_2539.webp

In the center of the base was the Rutherford County Courthouse in Murfreesboro. On the second floor there was a nexus.

IMG_2541.webp

Facing east & west signalists manned two very large telescopes. When a flag or torch signal came in, the bell of the courthouse clock. From below, an officer would take the message recorded by the "scribe" & bring it down to the signal office.

IMG_5226.webp

Powered by ten volt wet cell batteries, the HQ's of Union camps surrounding Murfreesboro were connected by telegraph.

IMG_2116.webp

General Rosecrans orders & reports flowed freely across the network.

IMG_2168.webp

24 / 7 visual signals were exchanged between a stations of observation sited on points that overlooked thousands of square mile.

IMG_2685.webp

Twenty miles west of the Courthouse Station was Triune Station. On this ridge that dominates the skyline there are three miles of rifle pits & a star shaped stone faced bastion atop the highest point. It is all still up there, something like a Mayan ruin. This gives you some idea of the system of observation that flags, couriers & telegraph provided Rosecrans' HQ unprecedented real time intel.

IMG_5225.webp

It is likely that very few of you have ever seen a functioning Beardslee Repeating Telegraph. Using a single wire & the earth for a ground, the magneto inside the box powered the indicator on the dial of another Beardslee. A letter at a time, the highly mobile Beardslees could set up all weather coms during an advance.


IMG_0190.webp


IMG_0191.gif

No demijohns of sulphuric acid to carry around, the Beardslee created its own power.

IMG_0189.webp

At night turpentine torches replaced the flags. On cold, clear nights the torch signaled directly 41 miles between Fort Tranist & Fort Negley Stations.

IMG_2619.webp

A "General Services Code" was used by army & navy signalists until 1913. These men are the navy signal team that received notice that Sherman had arrived at the sea.

During the March to the Sea Sherman had to send & receive messages across a 60 miles wide front.

IMG_2848.webp

Sherman had this unique map to guide him to the most productive counties along his line of march. This is the eastern half of the county map over printed with 1860 Census data.

IMG_2849.webp

Sherman knew how to dispatch his columns to where they could do the maximum damage. How, you might ask yourself, did he maintain command & control through out such dynamic movement.

The answer is a simple one. When commanders in Sherman's army group entered a town, first thing they did was to secure the telegraph office. Pretending to be the Confederate operators, they received & passed on messages. This gave Sherman & his sub commanders a comprehensive understanding of what the Confederate commanders knew & what they were attempting to do.

With their men off to war, it was not uncommon for wives to take over the running of telegraph offices in Georgia. On a number of occasions imagine the lady's astonishment when General Sherman himself dismounted & entered her office. He would sit down writing messages, receiving reports & communicating with commanders across a vast swath of country. When finished, Sherman would politely inquire what the going rate for his use of her office. He paid in full, made a bit of banter before mounting up & leaving the lady saying, "Lord have mercy…" under her breath.

Wouldn't you like to know what telegraphic signals were coming into the Military Telegraph Station Washington D.C.? Believe it or not, you can. The signal ledgers still exist. I especially recommend Charles Dana's eyes only bespoke ledger where his secret reports to Lincoln were recorded.

It is all here, the ultimate original source. Read more here.

Link


IMG_1498.webp

At Stones River National Battlefield, living historians present Civil War signal programs all season long. The genius of the General Service Code system is its simplicity.

IMG_1500.webp

Literally, a small child can teach the basics to her schoolmates.
 
Last edited:
Lincoln's telegraphic messages were impossible to read… unless you had the code. As you would imagine, tapping a telegraph line was simple. Attach a couple of wires & listen.

A Confederate "wood cutting party" tapped the line connecting Grant's HQ & Washington. All the messages were copied & smuggled to Richmond. None of them were decoded. They went so far as to advertise in the news paper for volunteers to attempt to crack the messages… never did.

How was that possible? Read more here.

Link

 
Last edited:
The Vigenere Cypher drove Confederate telegraphers crazy. A ten volt battery hooked up in series could only power a signal so far. Messages were received & retransmitted from station to station in a chain. The result resembled my phone texts without spell check a dozen times.

Messages to & from Davis arrived too garbled to be read. Davis read the New York Times every day. On numerous occasions he read the text of messages intercepted before the progressive errors garbled it in the Times.

Telegraphers developed a work around. Davis & his generals began their messages with the same formal greetings. Something like, "Esteemed General (name) greetings…" Knowing the content of the first lines, they easily cracked the key phrase.

With the key phrase, they translated the message into plain text. Errors were corrected. The message was encoded & transmitted. Needless to say, Union telegraphers had tumbled onto the greetings key.

Lincoln's messages were secured using the granddaddy of modern cryptography. Davis, entrusted his messages to a code from the 1500's read his coms in the New York Times over coffee in the morning… go figure.
 
Last edited:
You might like this one, too, @Reconstructed Rebel since it's written by a local gent who lived in Lombard. The Helen Plum Library there is named for his wife, and the first library in Lombard (in use until the 1960s) was in the first floor of their home after he willed the house to the village upon his death.

This is a great source, and I finished this book, but it appears to be the first volume and ends in the spring of 1863. For anyone else who is interested in the rest of the story, below is a link to the second volume that picks up with the telegraphic story of Gettysburg. Plum's stories around the time of Lincoln's assassination and the way various people received the news are also new insights for me. Fascinating stuff!

 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top