Taking out Whistling Dick

TinCan

Captain
Joined
Aug 20, 2011
Location
Transplanted Texan
U. S. S. STERLING PRICE, Below Vicksburg, June 20. SIR:

Agreeable to your instructions contained in your order of this morning, proceeded with the Mound City to the point designated, but was unable to open fire on account of the hazy atmosphere which hung over the Vicksburg shore, completely hiding it from view. After 7 oclock, was able to distinguish somewhat the location of the batteries. Opened fire on Whistling Dick battery, which was soon silenced; it fired twice, but not in our direction. We also bom- barded the other hill batteries as far up as the Hospital Battery, driving everyone from them, so much that not a single gun was fired after the silencing of Whistling Dick. We also shelled the lower line of works of the enemy, running from the water to the crest of the hill, until there was no longer an appearance of an enemy to fire at. Our army batteries ceased firing about 10 a. in.; we continued to fire at intervals until 11 a. m., whenever the sign of an enemy would make its appearance within our range. About the time we were retiring from action, a rifle gun from the other side of Youngs Point commenced firing at a battery occupied by General Herrons command, from which was flying an Amerlcan flag. Sent a courier across the point to notify them of the fact.

Having been engaged for three and one-half hours, and General Grant's lines being perfectly silent, we retired from action, leaving the Bentom in her old position at the head of the towhead, and will send the Mound City back to Warrenton as soon as I obtain Captain Wilsons report. Enclosed,

I forward the reports of Captains Greer and Wilson, containing expenditure of ammunition, together with the gunners report of this vessel. The Escumbia, Mound City, and Price are destitute of fuel, the Mound City having barely sufficient to take her back to her position, but she will cut wood enough to prepare herself for any brief emergency; the Price likewise. As soon as the harness comes to hand, will be prepared to send teams for supplies for this lower fleet.

Very respectfully, your obedient servant, SELIM E. WOODWORTH,
Commanding Price.
Acting Rear-Admiral D. D. PORTER.
Commanding Mississippi Squadron.

[Subenclosures..] U. S. S. BENTON, Below Vicksburg, June 20, 18q3.

SIR:

I have respectfully to report that, in obedience to your order of this date, this vessel got underway at 5:40 a. m. and stood up to the canal. It was so thick and hazy that I could not see the batteries or any landmarks. I threw a few shells into the woods to the north- ward of Whistling Dick. At 8 :30 it cleared away a little and I fired at Whistling Dick and a little to the northward of it, also at some cattle which I saw on the lowlands. Whilst lying above the canal, a rifle gun from over the point fired, its shell bursting in the neighborhood of the position held by our troops. Seeing a soldier on horseback on the bank, I ran in and sent him over to the officer commanding the rifle, to state where the shells were falling. We were not fired on, although in good range of Whistling Dick for a long time. We fired five 9-inch 15-second shell and seventeen 10-second 9-inch shell. At 10:55 stood down river to our old anchorage.

I have also to report that last night I received a letter from Major General Herron, asking for some more ammunition for the 32-pounders, which he has belonging to this vessel. I supplied him with all I could spare. Very respectfully, your obedient servant, JAS. A. GREER, Lieutenant- Commander.
 
Thanks for posting this - that is from the one 'Official Records' book I still need to get hold of. This part is odd: "We also bombarded the other hill batteries as far up as the Hospital Battery"
because it implies that they did not bombard any batteries north of the 'Hospital Battery' so could not have fired on 'Whistling Dick's battery. Other sources do confirm that batteries north of the 'Hospital Battery' were actually fired upon.

Source:

Official records of the Union and Confederate Navies in the War of the Rebellion. ; Series I - Volume 25: Naval Forces on Western Waters (May 18, 1863 - February 29, 1864)
 
Forrest,
Even though these are official reports I myself wonder if they were sure as to what battery they were actually firing at. There seems to be a lot of mystery regarding just where Whistling Dick may have been located and for sure what happened to the cannon.
 
When I read your initial post I was surprised that I didn't recognize the content, as I thought I had all the official records related to Vicksburg. I then discovered that I was missing the Navy records from the summer of 1863. I have so many diary entries from that period, and also the Army official records of both sides, that I did not miss not having those!

In any event, volume 25 of the Navy records is easy to get so I ordered a copy from Abe. Thanks again for posting.
 
Forrest,
Even though these are official reports I myself wonder if they were sure as to what battery they were actually firing at. There seems to be a lot of mystery regarding just where Whistling Dick may have been located and for sure what happened to the cannon.
I think you are right. As others on this site have pointed out, for being just one 18-pounder cannon, W.D. sure was feared. Likewise, as others have pointed out, W.D. almost was certainly confused with other rifled cannon like perhaps the two Whitworth English manufactured guns.
 
But having said that.....and even assuming that other cannons were occasionally rrbattery2.jpg being mistaken for W.D. ...still, to be know by name by both sides....."W.D. was a bad a**!" as far as the Yankees were concerned!
 
Made a habit of saving these because the 50th PA was there, then just tried to make more sense of this from Harper's. Have to say, even without having the kind of knowledge it takes to follow this thread well, it's very helpful.

vicksbg1 crop.jpg
 
Made a habit of saving these because the 50th PA was there, then just tried to make more sense of this from Harper's. Have to say, even without having the kind of knowledge it takes to follow this thread well, it's very helpful.

View attachment 174031
Interesting sketch. I'm assuming it would have been drawn after the siege. Is there any text accompanying it?
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top