Andy Cardinal 1st Lieutenant Forum Host Joined Feb 27, 2017 Location Ohio Nov 3, 2017 #1 If I were to pick one book about Stanton to read, which should I pick? Marvel's Lincoln's Autocrat or Stahr's Stanton: Lincoln's War Secretary?
If I were to pick one book about Stanton to read, which should I pick? Marvel's Lincoln's Autocrat or Stahr's Stanton: Lincoln's War Secretary?
General Butterfield Sergeant Joined Jun 18, 2017 Location Philadelphia Nov 3, 2017 #2 I have only read Marvel's book, its very tough on Stanton. I personally don't like Stanton so I didn't mind it. However I think a more balanced view might be worth reading, I'm unsure if Stahr's book would do a more even handed job. Marvel does have a Cspan lecture. You may want to give it a skim through and see if you like him: https://www.c-span.org/video/?416997-6/secretary-war-edwin-stanton
I have only read Marvel's book, its very tough on Stanton. I personally don't like Stanton so I didn't mind it. However I think a more balanced view might be worth reading, I'm unsure if Stahr's book would do a more even handed job. Marvel does have a Cspan lecture. You may want to give it a skim through and see if you like him: https://www.c-span.org/video/?416997-6/secretary-war-edwin-stanton