To further detail Ole's point. The M1855/M1861/M1863/M1864 (often referred to as the M1863 type 2) series arms. And the Special model 1861/1863 were all lumped together in the M1861 catagory... which isn't really right as the Special Model 1861/1863 is a different critter. The M1855 was the prewar arm of the US Regulars. The P53 Enfield and it's variations was the standard upon which all other small arms were judged. Both arms were in .577/.58 which meant ammo was interchangeable.
Another often forgotten arm is the Austrian M1854 "Lorenz." It was in .54 or .58 and was NOT an interchangeable arm which led to quality control arms. Despite this it was the third most common arm in use by both sides, seeing particularly heavy use in the West. The originals I have handled are of the highest quality w/ very fine fit and finish which is of a markedly different opinion that some others who have handled other originals. The Lorenz had some dramaticly different opinions of it's quality; though my own reading shows period references of the arms to be generally positive w/ good opinions outnumbering the bad.
Pros and cons were for the M1861 vs P53:
P53 were not interchangeable unless manufactured at Enfield and quality control from the non Enfield arsenal was no where near that of the M1861. The P53 had a better rear sight, training was not up to par and frankly fewer knew how to properly utilize it than were willing to admit. The M1861 series arms were more reliable under adverse conditions, easier to maintain in the field and their accuracy w/in 400 yards was comparable to the P53. There exists no example of US forces in the field exchanging M1861 series arms for the P53, the reverse is true. Now it should be stressed that very few Enfield arsenal interchangeable arms made it into the Civil War... when they did it was to the advantage of the CS. So it isn't quite a fair comparison.
I've live fired original examples of all of the above except an M1855. All will put the bullet where you point it and a man sized target at 400 yards is in serious jeapordy. That said I preffered the M1861 series, the sight was quicker to acquire and much more difficult to get out of sorts. But that is only my experiance. Modern reproductions are pale imitations of the originals... very poor imitations.