Repeaters

Getting Henry rifles and ammo to the troops required wooden crates.
Cartridge%20crate.jpg

Henry%20Box%205.jpg
 
As was said above, it was not simply buying rifles and handing them out. It was getting cartridges which were non-standard and ALOT more of them. Neither side had the institutional knowledge to do it, or the time to test out how to do it either. Logistics was already enough of a problem with the railroads and it was a choice between the devil you know vs. the devil you don't. The union was already doing fairly well without the repeating arms, so why change and risk your supply chain collapsing?

Sgt. Sam, this is a great answer - there are many moving parts, both technologically and logistically. And middle of a conflict of this dimension is not the time to try out new fangled technology. Were the repeaters more subject to fouling as well? How did they do with rain, mud and dirt? How did they behave for the cavalry?
 
Sgt. Sam, this is a great answer - there are many moving parts, both technologically and logistically. And middle of a conflict of this dimension is not the time to try out new fangled technology. Were the repeaters more subject to fouling as well? How did they do with rain, mud and dirt? How did they behave for the cavalry?
This is more of a techincal question, a subject which I have not studied. I think the effectiveness of the repeaters can testify to their usefulness though. They were much feared from what I have read. BTW Welcome!
 
Sgt. Sam, this is a great answer - there are many moving parts, both technologically and logistically. And middle of a conflict of this dimension is not the time to try out new fangled technology. Were the repeaters more subject to fouling as well? How did they do with rain, mud and dirt? How did they behave for the cavalry?

Ripley was also of the old thinking that what had worked in the past was still good enough. However technology does not stand still for anyone, especially today. Sometimes I feel like I am too old to adapt, much like Ripley. It is a good thing the US did not just rely on old technology in WWII and tried the "new fangled technology" of the atomic bomb ending the war.

Fouling is always an issue when shooting black powder. It matters not if it is muzzle-loader or a repeater. The more powder the tendency for more fouling. While most muzzle-loaders of the war use around a 60 grain charge the Henry was only loaded with a 26=28 grain charge. However fouling was still likely to be a problem as several rounds were fired. Also a lot of conflicts were over quickly. A man or regiment armed with a repeater might only fire a few rapid shots ending the threat in a short time. A regiment of 500 men armed with Henry repeating rifles could fire 8000 rounds in 15 seconds. That is only 16 shots per rifle, fouling may not have entered in to it.

Rain, mud and dirt were not near a problem for the repeaters, be it Henry or Spencer, as it was for a man armed with a muzzle-loader. The rim-fire ammunition was pretty much water-proof. Wilder's Brigade mentions many times about getting their ammunition wet and still working even sumerging their rifles and still working. The same cannot be said for muzzle-loading ammunition. One of the greatest wastes of ammunition was paper cartridges disintegrating by the thousands. Just transportation of the rounds could shake them apart. If a muzzle-loader was submerged in water for any length of time it would not fire, not so with the repeaters. Far too many people think that the repeating rifle armed men just blasted away. That is just not true. For sure rapid fire was used when targets of opportunity appeared. Many times volley after volley was fired with great effect on the enemy. Seven or sixteen volleys in a matter of seconds would put an end to a thread quickly.

There were few shortages of ammunition for the repeaters. For each regiment armed with a Henry rifle in Sherman's army there was a wagon load of ammunition for them. More shortages occurred with men armed with muzzle-loaders. Chamberlain sure could have used more ammunition on Little Round Top.

The main cavalry regiments armed with repeaters were the 1st Maine Cavalry, the 1st DC Cavalry, Wilson's Raiders and others. In the history of the 1st Maine Cavalry and 1st DC Cavalry it talks about how effective the repeaters were and the fact that they were able to take on far more than their numbers. The Henry was far easier to load on horseback than the Spencer. Both were far faster than any other carbine in firing at the enemy.
 
On my recent Georgia/Florida trip I had picked up some brochures at a rest stop. One of these was for Roswell, GA. As I was glancing over it in noticed the word Spencer. "The fighting at the Shallow Ford on July 9, 1864 involved the Spencer repeating rifle by Union forces. This was the first time in US history a rifle was used successfully under water during armed conflict."

I had read an account years ago of Spencer armed troops crossing a stream and submerging under water, when they would surface they would tilt the barrel of their Spencer rifle dumping the water and then fire at the rebs on the other side. They would then submerge again and mover a few steps forward, surface and fire again. The rebs didn't know what to think. Of course this would not have been possible with a muzzle-loading rifle.
 
The Battle of Franklin, Tennessee in late 1864 was another battle where Henry rifles played a part. One Henry was used by Gil Harbison. "Among the killed at Franklin was a strange and noble character in the person of Gil Harbison, of Company B, 73rd Illinois Infantry. His home was in Delavan, Illinois where he had been raised on a farm. At the breaking out of the war he was in Cincinnati, Ohio, taking a course at some theological school. One day, while on the street, he saw some of his Illinois acquaintances marching past in the 73rd. He fell in with them, and marched on until the battle of Franklin. Although a strict Baptist and a consistent Christian, he chose reckless Joe Isenburg as his "pard". At Kennesaw Mountain Joe was treacherously shot while carrying water on the picket-line, a duty which, by mutual consent of both pickets, had been preformed unmolested. Gil Harbison then and there, on his bended knee, over his wounded partner, who soon died, swore by the highest authority he called upon that he would be avenged. He sent for a Henry rifle, and from that time forward Gil Harbison could, at night or day, be found as often as elsewhere on or beyond the picket-line. During the night at Spring Hill he seemed to be in his glory, and during the short rest in the rear of the lines at Franklin he remarked to a comrade that he was abundantly satisfied with the way the account of Joe Isenburg stood. Very soon after this he was shot in the head and immediately killed." It sounds like Gil must have made good use of his Henry in the short time he was able to use it. It would be interesting to find out more about how Gil used his Henry and how many men were added to the account of his friend.
 
There is one interesting side note about the Henry Repeating rifle in a book published in 1909 entitled "Butler and His Cavalry in the War of Secession, 1861-1865. In a letter from John C. Calhoun, not the congressman but a Confederate soldier, to his sister about what was going on and how he was recovering from his wounds he adds a PS to the end of the letter. "To Miss M.M. Calhoun. Tell father I will send him a seventeen-shooter captured from the Yankees, by the first opportunity. J.C.C."
 
It was on June 27, 1864 When Alanson P. Webber exhibited bravery and superior marksmanship while using a Henry Repeating rifle. The following information was printed in a 1987 issue of the Peoria Journal Star and was written by Jim Kerrigan. I have the article but unfortunately the date of the newspaper has been cut off. Fife Major Webber would be awarded the Medal of Honor for his actions with the Henry Repeating rifle that day. Many lives were saved due to the rapid fire ability of the Henry and the marksmanship of Webber. "It was August 27, 1862, when Webber and some 900 other men from Peoria, Tazewell, Knox and Marshall counties assembled in Peoria to form the 86th Illinois Volunteer Infantry. Although he had enlisted as a private, Webber's musical talent was quickly recognized and he was promoted to the rank of Fife Major, a position he held during much of the 86th Illinois' three-year, 5,500-mile march through 16 battles of the Civil War. His ability as a sharpshooter, however, remained largely hidden until one day in Georgia when he traded his flute for a Henry rifle and won the Medal of Honor. The day was June 27, 1864, and the place was called Kennesaw Mountain. .... As recognized in the citation accompanying Webber's decoration, the Union toll would have been worse had it not been for his determined, rapid-fire work with the Henry rifle." Webber and the 86th were to attack and take a hill that was held by the Rebels. They found themselves in a desperate spot of not being able to go forward but could not go back without being fired upon by the Rebels. "He(Fahnestock) refused to retreat back across the open field, but he ordered his men to fall back to a slight fold in the ground barely 35 yards below the crest of the ridge. Before Fahnestock gave that order, however, he passed his then high-tech Henry Repeating rifle and 120 rounds of ammunition to Fife Major Alanson Webber, along with instructions to fire every bullet as quickly as possible at the Rebel heads protruding atop the ridge. Webber did, every single bullet. Many of the slugs found Rebel heads, but even those that didn't had the effect of keeping enemy heads down as the rest of the 86th Illinois dug into the shallow fold below the crest. While Webber poured on covering fire, the central Illinoisans used every implement they had--tin cups, bayonets, their rifle stocks--to excavate a life-giving hole in the dirt on the slope of the hill.....Fahnestock and the rest of the 86th Illinois would fight on to the end of the war. And Webber, the flute player from Marshall County, would be called upon again to use his commander's rifle. The 86th Illinois Volunteer Infantry was mustered out of federal service at Washington D.C. in June 1865. When Webber returned home to his Saratoga Township farm, he carried a battered Henry which bore the inscription, "Presented to A.P. Webber, Fife Major, 86th Ill. Int., by Lt. Col. A.C. Fahnestock for bravery in many battles, June 6, 1865." Years later, Alanson Pitts Webber was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor for his work on Kennesaw Mountain. The medal has long since disappeared, but the Henry rifle remains in the family." I have also found his first name spelled several different ways; Alanson or Alason or Alonzo, makes for a bit of confusion. In the book "Deeds of Valor", it has another account of this same incident of Webber's use of the Henry Repeating rifle, however it is referred to as a "Winchester rifle" but this account was written in 1907. "A Musician as a Sharpshooter: Alonzo P. Webber, of the Eighty-sixth Illinois Volunteers, Principal Musician of his regiment when it was engaged at the battle of Kenesaw Mountain, Ga., June 27, 1864, distinguished himself by voluntarily advancing as a sharpshooter. Seeing the desperate situation of his regiment, with no chance to advance, he obtained permission from Colonel Fahnestock to "go in" as a sharpshooter. With a Winchester rifle and 120 rounds of ammunition, he succeeded in advancing to within twenty-seven feet of the rebel line of battle, which was formed in V shape. There he found shelter behind a tree, and although he was at the apex, with the enemy on both sides of him, he stood his ground from nine o'clock in the morning until six o'clock in the evening. Being an excellent shot he brought down a number of the enemy, while the Union forces lay behind him at a distance of a city block or more, unable to get closer to the enemy's line. Webber's courage on that day won him the admiration of his while regiment, none of whom had expected to see him return alive from his dangerous position." Webber died July 27, 1902 at the age of 74. The Medal of Honor was presented to Webber on June 22, 1896. The citation reads: "Voluntarily joined in a charge against the enemy, which was repulsed, and by his rapid firing in the face of the enemy enabled many of the wounded to return to the Federal lines; with others, held the advance of the enemy while temporary works were being constructed."

Col. Allen L. Fahnestock with the first Henry rifle that he bought and the one that Fife Major Alanson P. Webber used during the Battle of Kennesaw Mountain, Georgia that he used with such good effect.


Alanson P. Webber with his old Henry Repeating Rifle.


Taken several years after the war, Alanson P. Webber demonstrating the type of position he took on that fateful day, June 27, 1864, on Cheatham Hill, to help keep Confederate heads down while the men of McCook's Brigade dug in.

DRUMMERS AND FIFERS OF THE 86TH ILLINOIS.

This photograph is from Col. Allen L. Fahnestock's Diary, a copy of which can be found in the Peoria Public Library. This picture was taken in the summer of 1863 in Nashville, Tennessee and shows the eight remaining musicians of the 14 who began their service with the 86th as musicians. The men are identified as;
Front row left to right;
Drum Major Samuel B. Silzel, Co. I
Drummer William Stanton, Co. B
Drummer Richard McCarthy, Co. D
Drummer Richard A. White, Co. K

Back row left to right;
Fife Major Alanson P. Webber, Co. C
Fifer James A. Shreffler, Co. I
Fifer Alexander W. Brown, Co. C
Fifer Cyrus A. Fox, Co. H
 
Last edited by a moderator:
While I have posted this before many times the issue of ammunition for repeating rifles comes up. Too many feel that a man armed with a repeated just blasted away. Many picked their targets of opportunity using deliberate fire but at times where the range was close rapid fire was used but that does not mean that they just blasted away. There are always exceptions where a unit did blast away all of their ammunition but that was not the norm.

Special Field Order No. 26 for the Fourth Division, Fifteenth Corps gives an idea of how much ammunition was necessary for troops armed with the Henry Repeating rifle. Dated December 7, 1864 near the Ogeechee River, Ga., the special field order list the order of march. "The Third Brigade will have the advance, followed by the pioneer corps, and then the battery; the Second Brigade will move in the center, followed by the trains hereafter designated; the First Brigade will bring up the rear. The battery will take three wagons loaded with canister, two wagons loaded with shell, and one wagon with shot. Each brigade will take five ordnance wagons loaded with caliber .58, and for each regiment armed with Henry rifles one wagon load of that kind of ammunition will be taken. By order of Brig. General John M. Crose" (69) It would be interesting to know how many cases of .44 caliber Henry ammunition a wagon load consisted of, at any rate, it had to be thousands of rounds of ammunition.

Many that knew the value of having repeating rifles knew that they were worthless unless you had the ammunition to shoot in them.
 
Captain Wilson was a very interesting Henry owner that much has been written. "The following letter from Captain Wilson, Co. M, 12th Kentucky Cavalry, is entitled to an introductory statement. The writer is an unconditional Union man, living in a strongly disloyal section of Kentucky. His neighbors had threatened his life. In consequence of this Captain Wilson had fitted up a log crib across the road from his front door as a sort of arsenal, where he had his Henry rifle, Colt's revolver etc. One day, while at home dining with his family, seven mounted guerillas rode up, dismounted and burst into his dining room and commenced firing upon him with revolvers. The attack was so sudden that the first shots struck a glass of water his wife was raising to her lips, breaking the glass. Several other shots were fired without effect, when Captain Wilson sprang to his feet, exclaiming, "For God's sake, gentlemen, if you wish to murder me, do not do it at my own table in presence of my family." This caused a parley, resulting in their consent that he might go out doors to be shot. The moment he reached his front door he sprang for his cover, and his assailants commenced firing at him. Several shots passed through his hat, and more through his clothes, but none took effect upon his person. He thus reached his cover and seized his Henry Rifle, turned upon his foes, and in five shots killed five of them; the other two sprung for their horses. As the sixth man threw his hand over the pommel of his saddle, the sixth shot took off four fingers; notwithstanding this he got into the saddle, but the seventh shot killed him; then starting out, Captain Wilson killed the seventh man with the eight shot."
"This letter is in reply to one asking for an authentic statement of this remarkable feat from under his own hand, which, in the commencement of his letter, he promised to give, but which, it will be observed, he entirely omits (probably from that modesty and dislike to recounting their own deeds of daring, characteristic of truly brave men), but tacitly admits the correctness of the above statement. Mumfordsville, Ky., Feb. the 17th, 1863. O.F. Winchester, Esq. President New Haven Arms Co. Dear sir: Yours of December the 31st, came to hand on yesterday. Thanking you for the too flattering compliments paid to myself by you, I shall proceed to a candid statement of the facts as they have occurred within my own experience. In the use of the Henry gun I have had some experience in the instance of which you seem to have been apprised. When attacked alone by seven guerillas I found it (Henry rifle) to be particularly useful not only in regard to its fatal precision, but also in the number of shots held in reserve for immediate action in case of an overwhelming force. In short, I would state that, in my opinion, the Henry Rifle is decidedly the best gun in service of the United States; can be used with one-half of the usual scouring and cleaning incident to the guns now principally in use, no more liable to get out of trim or unfit for service than any other gun, and will shoot with as much precision and as terrible effect as any rifle in use anywhere, when in good hands. In conclusion I would say, give me sixty men armed with the Henry Repeating rifle, with sufficient quantity of cartridges, and it is not an overestimate to say that we are equal to a full regiment of men armed with muskets. Very truly yours, James M. Wilson, Captain Co. M, 12th Kentucky Cavalry."
 
This past weekend I did get the opportunity to use my Henry Repeating rifle at a reenactment at Wauconda, IL. While I do know that a reenactment is not a real battle and really not even close to what a real battle would have been like there is a certain amount of learning and education that can take place.

We had six of us representing the 66th IL Infantry WSS all armed with Henry repeating rifles. On Saturday we were 3rd Company stuck between 2nd and 4th companies of line infantry. The added firepower we brought to the table was effective but is not what the WSS did to maximize the best use of what they were about which was mainly as an advanced sharpshooter regiment. We did finally maneuver to the left flank breaking free of the infantry line and were more effective before being taken out by a volley from the reb infantry.

Sunday we were able to be located on the flank and were able to work more as the WSS would have operated. The bottom line is that not only did the public get a chance to see that there were actually repeating rifles used in the Civil War but how effective a few men armed with Henry rifles could be. Six men firing a shot every 2 or 3 seconds picking targets still sounds like a very rapid fire company of men when compared to regular infantry. A company of hundreds armed with repeating rifles such as the WSS or Wilder's Brigade would have a devastating effect on the enemy. This was proved to be true many times during the Civil War at Chickamauga, The Atlanta Campaign, the March to the Sea and through the Carolinas and more. It also was a good education for other reenactors that had never heard of a Henry rifle before. Too many times in the reenacting world there are those that think that only muzzle-loading rifles should be used by those portraying the "Common Soldier", whatever the "Common Soldier" may be. I have always professed that I portray a "Common Soldier" only armed with a repeating rifle.

While reenacting is in no way the same as the real war with real bullets flying killing and wounding soldiers it does offer an insight as to the how the weapons of the day would have been used. During WWII the MG42 of the Germans would get the attention of the American soldiers, I am sure that the sound of a regiment armed with repeating rifles would get the attention of the rebs. If you were a reb and heard repeating fire for the first time I would think that you might rethink your chances of winning the war. Repeating fire at reenactments does offer a chance for the public and reenactors to learn another aspect of weaponry used in the Civil War. Education is important, a person is never to old to learn something new.
 
Colonel George W. Kirk was detailed by General Burnside to organize the loyal mountaineers of East Tennessee and North Carolina. The following is an interesting use of the Henry where a small amount of men, twelve, can make a huge difference. There were four hundred rebels at Stackhouse's store and another four hundred rebels in the woods. Here is what the Colonel has in mind for the rebels. "Let Major Rollins get the men under arms at once, and station all of them in the rear of this house, except a small squad that he shall post on the hill to observe any movement of the rebels in the woods. Meanwhile, I will take a dozen men that I know, and who know me, mount them on our best horses, each one with two sixteen-shooters, two revolvers in his belt, and two in his holster and will light down on those sleeping fellows at Stackhouse's. We will steal upon the sentinels, and secure them without noise, and then remount, and move softly till we are between the rebels and their arms, when we will swoop upon them with such yells and firing as well make them think us a whole regiment. Woke out of sleep by such a din they'll scatter to the four winds---all that are not winged by our carbines or revolvers. Having done that we'll toss their stacked arms into the river, and gallop, back here, and help you to whip the other four hundred."….. Before two o'clock Colonel Kirk, with his twelve picked men set out up the river, and by half-past three, he returned, having carried out his programme in the minutest details, without a man so much as wounded. Meanwhile the four hundred Confederates, whom he had rightly judged to be posted in the woods in his rear, hearing the firing, had moved forward, and engaged the force under Major Rollins. The conflict was at its height, when Kirk returned with his twelve men, and rushed impetuously upon the flank of the Confederates. Probably supposing that his small squad was merely the advance of a larger reinforcement, they fled in all directions, leaving twenty dead, and upwards of thirty wounded upon the ground, and losing a hundred prisoners in the pursuit that followed. This, one of the most brilliant of minor conflicts of the war, was the last of civil strife in Madison county. The Union forces in the following spring, with Colonel Kirk, and Daniel and Reuben Ellis among them, drove out the Confederates from all the mountain region, but the clash of arms did not come near the blood-stained district which has been the especial scene of this history." Colonel Kirk chose twelve men for special duty because of the fact that they would be armed with superior firepower by having Henry sixteen shooting rifles. He states that they each would carry two of the sixteen shooters, this is a little puzzling to me but that is what the 1889 source states. At any rate with two Henry rifles and four revolvers those twelve men would have been a force to be reckoned with.
505251825_19bf747438_m.jpg
 
Last edited:
The National Park Service safety manual for the Henry Repeating Rifle taken from my website complete with all of my pictures of my Henry rifle as I took it apart. I am flattered.
http://www.nps.gov/stri/upload/19th-Century-Repeaters-Manual.pdf
Did they ask you first or give you credit?

I once had a large organization reuse, without my permission, an article I had written about racing that was posted on a website ran by a friend. We didn't make any threats or anything, but we made some requests and were granted some behind the scenes access as a result.

I wonder if you could possibly use it as a way of getting to view items in their collection that are not normally on display?

In any case, good job!
 
They did include my website in the Bibliography.

BIBLIOGRAPY
Bresnan, Andrew L. (National Henry Rifle e Company). The Henry Repeating Rifle e Manual of Arms: A Reenactor's Guide
(http://44henryrifl e.webs.com/)
McQueen, John C. Spencer: The First Effective and Widley Used Repeating Rifle e and Its Use in the Western Theater of the Civil
War
, Communicorp, Columbus, GA, 1989
New Haven Arms Company. Henry's Repeating Rifl e, T.J. Staff ord, New Haven, CT, 1865
Scott, H. L., Military Dictionary, D. Van Nostrand, New York, 1864
Spencer Armory. The Spencer Repeating Rifle, Carbines, and Sporting Rifl e (reprint), Invictus, Decatur, MI
U.S. Army, The Ordnance Manual for the Use of the Officers of the United States Army, 3rd edition, J. B. Lippincott and Co.,

Philadelphia, 1861.
 
The Henry Repeating Arms Co. is now finally going to offer a reproduction of the Civil War Henry Repeating rifle.
http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/20...-repeating-arms-the-original-henry-rifle-ish/ I have seen some detailed pictures of one of their new Henry rifle and hope to examine it next month. So now there will be a choice of makers for a Civil War reproduction Henry Repeating rifle, the one made by Uberti in Italy and the one made by the Henry Repeating Arms Company made in the United States. The down side is there appears to be a huge difference in price of nearly $1000 for being made in the United States.

The reproduction Spencer by Chiappa unfortunately is in short supply and is also a very expensive reproduction. I have a Chiappa Spencer rifle and love it. It works fantastic with the blanks I developed for it in .56-50.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top