Repeaters

Ripley feared that these repeating weapons would use ammunition profligately, and he was concerned about logistics, as another poster noted above. He was concerned about the associated expense that went along with providing large quantities of ammunition, as well as the availability of it. Rimfire bullets--used by both the Spencer and the Henry--were in their infancy and were not common. Ripley had legitimate concerns about his ability to supply ammunition to larger bodies of men.
 
Ripley was replaced in 1863 because of some of his outdated thinking. He also was not a large fan of the rifled musket at first. Ammunition proved not to be any more of a problem for Spencer's and Henry rifles than it was for other muskets. There was more ammunition wasted due to spoilage with muzzle loader cartridges than with Spencer or Henry cartridges. The main limiting factor for the Henry was manufacturing. They could only produce 400 per month at best.
 
Ripley was a man that believed that what had killed men in the past would continue to do so during this up-coming Civil War. He did not want to take into account technology that would bring about new a better weapons. However one can only stick their head in the sand so long before being over taken by technology, true back then and today. While the problem of production limited the Henry rifles to a 400 a month rate that was not the case with the Spencer. The Henry rifle just required too many man hours to produce. That is why the Thompson sub-machine gun was phased out in WWII in favor of the "Grease Gun". Well over 60,000 Spencer carbines were made by the end of the war. However more Spencer could have been made available at least a year earlier had Ripley had a more "modern" approach to his job.

I think that too many times people think that repeaters would have "eaten" through ammunition at a very rapid rate. The fact is in the over all picture you could use less men using repeaters that you would have needed if using the muzzle-loading musket. Less men used would equate to less targets for the enemy to kill or wound. Then you have the age old discussion of would the war have ended earlier if repeaters would have been adopted earlier. The big "if" in any discussion is always unanswered since we know what the reality was. However with that said, Spencers could have been produced faster and issued in larger quantities in 1862 rather than a year or more later if Ripley would have been more receptive to what technology could do. Many may think that war is not the time to be switching to a new weapon system but that is just not true. Any weapon that could give you an edge or end a conflict earlier should be explored and developed even during war time. Case in point is WWII.

The reality of the situation is that Ripley did what he did and there is not going back in time to change history. We can only speculate as to what might have happened with our 20/20 hindsight. Even had the Spencer been produced in numbers in 1862 it still would have been a "dead end design" much the same as the Krag rifle of the 1890's. Both were basically a one war gun for the US as a main battle type of weapon. While a dead end design both were continued to be use however old their technology was. M1 Garand and M1 Carbine are still in use in places well after the Korean Conflict which was the end of their prime use for the US.
 
Interestingly enough, the Confederate army captured a lot of Spencer Carbines and the Confederate Ordnance Department under Gorgas actually instituted a program to set up the manufacture of Spencer cartridges. The problem was, no one, including the Superintendent of Confederate Armories, Lt Colonel James Burton, could figure out how rimfire cartridge cased were made.

Matter of fact, in 1863 when Burton went on his "Shopping Trip" to England to purchase ordnance machinery and other items for the Confederacy, at the top of his "Shopping List" was machinery that could be used to manufacture Spencer cartridge cases. The English firm, Greenwood & Batley, at the time one of the most advanced ordnance machinery manufacturers in the world, did not have a clue as to how rimfire cases were made-so Burton returned to the Confederacy without ordering any rimfire cartridge casing machinery.

The captured Spencers remained in Confederate armories to gather dust. [How clueless the British were when it came to cartridge case manufacturing in the mid-1860's is that the Snider Enfield, adopted in 1864, initially used a cartridge case that was made with an iron base and a body of spiral wrapped brass sheet covered by cardboard!]

Burton had had a "business arrangement" with Greenwood & Batley that predated the war. So, as soon as Macon, Georgia (the location of a major Confederate ordnance manufacturing facility that Burton commanded) fell to the Yankees under General Wilson in the Spring of 1865, Burton put away his Confederate uniform, donned a business suit. Burton headed to Boston to try to obtain a license from Spencer that would allow Greenwood & Batley to manufacture Spencer Rifles and Carbines for sale in Europe.

One thing Burton did do, while in Boston, was to finally satisfy his curiosity as he learned how rimfire cartridge cases were made. (It is actually a fairly simple metal stamping operation just requiring several different dies for the various stages of manufacture.) Although Burton was unsuccessful when it came to getting a license for Greenwood & Batley to manufacture Spencer Rifles and Carbines for the European market, Burton's KNOWLEDGE of how to manufacture rimfire cartridge cases paid huge dividends for G & B a few short years later.

When the Franco-Prussian War broke out in 1870, the French government purchased huge amounts of Civil War surplus arms and equipment from the U.S. Government-this bonanza of arms included a lot of Spencer carbines and rifles. Greenwood & Batley was quick to take advantage of the situation because G & B set up a subsidiary company that made Spencer ammunition in huge amounts and sold that ammo to the French!
 
220px-Daniel_McCook_Sr.jpg
 
Who is he?
His name is Daniel McCook of the famous McCook family. He was a Major and paymaster. He loved his Henry rifle and almost fought a duel using his Henry rifle. He was killed in an action in which he was ambushed by the Rebs when he got a little too close to the action.
 
This next paragraph is another amusing story about a Henry owner, Major Daniel McCook. Major McCook was mentioned in part one, the 2009 document. He was the paymaster not really suppose to see action in combat; however, he was killed by rebel skirmishers. They stole his horse, watch and his Henry Repeating Rifle. This incident happened in 1863 while McCook was on the steamer at Pittsburg Landing having dinner. A man named Joe Forrest a friend and aide to the Illinois Governor Yates was overheard by Major McCook making a comment about the fact that "he hotly advocated the human character and rights of the negro, he noticed a man in an undress military uniform, with the shoulder straps of a major jump to his feet from his seat at the side of the captain, and then walk rapidly down the cabin toward the stern of the boat…."Who is that man, and what is he going to do?" "That" was the answer "is the famous Major McCook, father of the two generals of that name. He is going for his sixteen-shooter and I'm afraid there will be trouble!" At this, the colonel (Forrest), who had often heard of the doughty old chap and his wonderful repeating rifle, arose and followed the other down the cabin. Forrest met him as he came out of the state-room with his famous sixteen-shooter in one hand and a quantity of cartridges in the other, which he began to transfer rapidly into the magazine of the pistol." (88) I cannot help but think the reference to a pistol is a mistake in that the Henry is a rifle. When Forrest ask McCook what he was going to do the Major replied; "I propose," responded the infuriated major, "to shoot you down in your tracks unless you at once apologize for your abominable utterances, and your damned abolition sentiments!" (88) The outcome of this confrontation was that Forrest did indeed apologize and the two ended up at the bar for a drink. It was touch and go for a while as McCook was bent on shooting Forrest with his Henry Repeating rifle. The Major stated that he was not going to murder Forrest but was going to fight a duel. When Forrest stated that he had no gun McCook went and brought an old carbine from his room for Forrest to use. It was a good thing that Forrest did apologize as he probably would have lost the duel against McCook's Henry rifle.
 
Major McCook's Henry also would fall into the hands of the Confederates. "On the morning of the 19th, the Major insisted on going with the vedette in front of Lieutenant Armstrong's Company. ....... When the vedette rode up the bank of the creek the old Major joined it, his eye flashing and his cheeks flushed with excitement. In return of our remonstrances, he swept a mock salute, and dashed out of sight into the fog, his fine sorrel charger seeming to partake of the spirit of his master. The little party he was with rode almost into the Confederate skirmish line before either saw the other. He and one soldier of the vedette were killed at the first fire. Major McCook's body was pierced by three balls. His horse, watch, and Henry rifle fell into the hands of the enemy." (20)
 
Maj. Daniel McCook was the patriarch of the Fighting McCook family. He was a paymaster officer, and he was present at the Battle of Buffington Island to avenge the death of one of his sons at the hands of John Hunt Morgan's Confederate raiders. Unfortunately, Major McCook was at the wrong place at the wrong time, and he fell right at the outset of the battle. If memory serves me correctly, he was 65 years old when he fell on July 19, 1863. There is a marker to him on the Buffington Island battlefield.
 
The following is an excerpt from a copy of a circular issued in Philadelphia, July, 1864 that also appeared in the New Haven Arms Company's 1865 catalog. The government seems to always be worrying about wasting ammunition, or for that matter anything that might help a soldier, however they are not too concerned about cutting the "perks" of their office. The circular was written by B. F. Reimer, Photographer located at No. 624 Arch Street, Philadelphia. "Permit a fellow-member of the Union League to call your attention to the fact, that in this age of invention and improvement, there is not material improvement in the infantry service of our army in the method of loading; it is still tear cartridge, draw ramrod, ram cartridge, prime, the same as in the war of the Revolution; the time required to load is from twenty to thirty seconds, all this time our Union soldiers are a target for the Rebels. Persons who are not acquainted with the improvements that have been made in Fire Arms must think it strange that the gun should not keep pace with other improvements. On the 20th of May, 1862, Lieutenant W. Mitchell, U. S. N., reported that he had fired a rifle fifteen times in ten seconds. That he had loaded and fired the same weapon one hundred and twenty times in 5 minutes and 45 seconds, and that he fired 187 shots in 3 minutes 36 seconds in rounds of fifteen shots, equal to 50 per minute. .... Now if our chances of crushing the rebels is more sure with seven hundred thousand men than with one hundred thousand, it is because that the seven hundred thousand can do more execution than the smaller number-they can shoot more bullets-why then not adopt the labor-saving machine? There cannot be any virtue in eating so many rations, but in doing so much killing of rebels. .... This weapon (the Henry rifle), as an inducement with the bounty, would persuade many of the Pennsylvania Reserves to re-enlist. But says a U.S. Senator, men waste ammunition if they have the facilities to shoot often. Seven hundred thousand men waste more ammunition than one , they also waste seven times as many rations, for seven thousand the Quarter-Master must supply with seven times as much ammunition as he would for one thousand, if one thousand men can do the killing with the improved weapon, they require seven times as much ammunition, but not seven times as many rations-an economy in rations. You then say, I would load the men down with ammunition? I would have pack horses or mules, and would have them trained to lie down, tie them down when in battle. I would never permit the men to shoot when the enemy was at a great distance off, but if possible get them under cover, do all the fighting at short range, Charge on them firing, as you could shoot fifteen times with your eyes constantly on the enemy, without looking at your piece except when firing. I would advance, fire! Advance, fire! for fifteen rounds, not firing the first shot until within 200 yards of the enemy. You could shoot down Artillerists in the act of loading, you could shoot instead of using the bayonet, in fact the enemy could never reach you in a bayonet charge, for one-seventh part of the men with the improved rifle could protect and support Artillery. Pickets could much longer keep at bay an assaulting enemy; there could therefore then be no surprise. A skirmisher could be counted as seven without there being seven to shoot at; the one has always the advantage of getting under cover, whilst seven could not so easily find cover. It would make a coward brave, as he would feel he had the advantage, and instead of wasting ammunition, there would be less used, because the enemy would be permitted to come to a close range, as there would be no fear of the bayonet or superior numbers; for if five thousand attacked one with the improved weapon, the one thousand could reserve their fire, knowing they could put fifteen thousand bullets into them in ten seconds; where with the present weapon it is a question if it is not fired at the enemy when in superior numbers, at so long a distance off as not to be effective. In assaulting breastworks, you being constantly loaded and ready to fire, the enemy dare not show their heads above their works, and therefore cold not keep you out, nor could you be driven out; it is also the weapon to defend wagon trains, as a much smaller number of men could defend them; using the wagons as a cover they could defeat five times their number, and knowing the advantage they possessed in their weapons there would not so likely be a panic or disorderly retreat. It is a daily occurrence that our men are either surprised or outnumbered; it could not take place with a weapon that could be constantly kept loaded with fifteen charges, and if desired could be instantly unloaded without wasting the ammunition. The men could have fifteen loads in the gun when off duty, when in camp at night, in fact at all times the whole fifteen charges could be discharged at the enemy in ten seconds, and in a few seconds there could be fifteen more in the gun. If you will only think, the enemy with only one load, an empty gun, you having discharged one, and fourteen more left, the facility for using them all before the enemy would be able to get another in his gun. What can you require more to convince you? Why do you have a revolver in preference to a single barrel pistol? Because if you fail in the first you have five more shots. Do For God's sake give the Union Soldiers what you desire yourself, and in a short time you will not be able to comprehend why it could have been possible we could so long sacrifice our men with so contemptible a thing as the Springfield Rifle. We are about having raised through the means of the Sanitary Fair one million and a half of dollars. Give us your influence to raise one twentieth part of that sum to prevent soldiers being wounded, and as it is said charity begins at home, let our great aim be to minister to and prevent our own Union soldiers from being wounded; the old maxim, "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure," I would put in practice. I would shoot down the rebels so fast there would be very little chance of their wounded loyal soldiers. .... I will show you a weapon, the worth I have tested, that is manufactured, and supposed to be for sale. .... I do not think you can forgive yourself, if, after a few years, the worth of what I am writing becomes universal, and that, had you given your influence, you might have saved thousands of lives and millions of treasure." (79) The above is a very compelling argument for arming regiments with Henry Repeating rifles. You could have fewer men, consuming fewer supplies, to do the same job it had taken thousands to do in the past. In all of this you would have saved both lives of soldiers and the treasure of the country.
 
They must of had a better way of keeping the barrels from fouling, after 12 rounds in my Henry at a Skirmish the barrel is so fouled forget about hitting much...Expired Image Removed
 
I don't fire blanks... live fire and the lead fouls the barrel, I am experimenting with harder lead...

I might almost suggest softer lead or verifying bullet size first... how is the accuracy? The reason I ask is as last weekend I talked w/ a Henry shooter and he was complaining of hideous accuracy when he live fired. Turns out the ammo he bought was sligtly undersized and not expanding enough to really grip the rifling.

The other henry shooter buys from IIRC Black Hills Ammo and had never had the issue w/ fouling or accuracy.

I shoot Muzzleloader primarily so I may be blowing smoke but I can go 25-30 rounds before I note any fouling out of either of my .58 shooters. I've been told the number is closer to 100 out of a trap door or other breach loaders.

there are a couple other Henry shooters taht should be able to chime in w/ a better answer.
 
I have a Navy Arms Henry in .44-40 caliber and I shoot factory jacketed soft points through it. It is a tack driver and being fired with smokeless powder, it doesn't foul. I've shot a couple of does in years past with it and both were one shot kills. I cannot comment on shooting black powder loads as I've not fired any black powder loads in my repeaters. I have fired Pyrodex loads in some of my trapdoors without significant fouling.
 
What is considered accuracy? MOA or MOBarn? Shooting NRA BPCR Silhouette matches for a few years with a Shiloh 1874 Sharps .45-70 I found out a lot can effect accuracy. Loading ammunition was done with a drop tube, card wad, 20-1 lead bullet of 535 grains, SPG lube and 68 grains of Swiss 1 & 1/2 F. That load would shot 2MOA out to 500 meters but that was with using a blowtube after every shot. This load, rifle and practice got into the master class. A rifle that did not use a blowtube between shots and did not shoot the proper ammunition was doomed to MO Barn. Fouling can build up very quickly and accuracy of MOA will go out the window with it.

If one has a Henry or Spencer rifle shooting black powder the barrel will foul out probably after a couple of magazines. What that may mean is you go from 2MOA to MOPerson out to 75 yards for the next several shots. In a battle that may be long enough to get the job down. Using smokeless powder you could probably shoot all day with out any ill effects. If you want 2 MOA accuracy from your rifle regardless of what it is and you shoot 100 rounds or even less of BP your accuracy will be almost non existant or MOABarn at 100 yards which may be acceptable to some.
 
I might almost suggest softer lead or verifying bullet size first... how is the accuracy? The reason I ask is as last weekend I talked w/ a Henry shooter and he was complaining of hideous accuracy when he live fired. Turns out the ammo he bought was sligtly undersized and not expanding enough to really grip the rifling.

The other henry shooter buys from IIRC Black Hills Ammo and had never had the issue w/ fouling or accuracy.

I shoot Muzzleloader primarily so I may be blowing smoke but I can go 25-30 rounds before I note any fouling out of either of my .58 shooters. I've been told the number is closer to 100 out of a trap door or other breach loaders.

there are a couple other Henry shooters taht should be able to chime in w/ a better answer.

Black Hills ammo doesn't do well. Have spoken to several Henry shooters and they smile and say Trial and error, keep trying. I am now on third bullet mold.. longer, heavier bullets seem to be more accurate, more trials next time at the range..Thanks for your input..
 
The following is Captain John A. Smith telling what happened to his silver plated Henry. "I had a boy in my company named William H. Burwell. He was a very large man, not very tall, and on the left of the company. We would wait until we heard the rebels yell as they came up to the side of the ridge. They always yelled first and then fired. When we were reloading after one of these volleys, Burwell turned to me and said, "Captain, my gun is out of order.' He couldn't get the cartridge into the chamber. Meantime I had loaded and emptied my gun several times. I said, 'All right Billie. You take my gun and I will see if I can do anything with yours.' I got down on my knees and got out one of those Barlow knives which you all remember, but I was unable to remove the difficulty." "About that time we were ordered back to the fort and after the battle was over next morning we commenced gathering up the dead. Of course the wounded and dead lay all together that night. The left of the company rested on the Carterville Road. In one of the ruts that had been worn by the wagons lay William Burwell on his face, dead, and under him was my silver mounted rifle all covered with blood. He had evidently been killed in the act of firing. My gun was the only one saved out of the 17 lost by the company." (47) The Confederates ended up with the rest. As long as the ammunition held out, they were of use to the Confederates. "The regiment went into battle with 291 men, and out of that number 150 were killed and wounded, more than half the regiment. With the Henry sixteen shooter, purchased with their own money, $52 each, 31,000 cartridges were fired, 163 to each man. The flag in mind was pierced with 217 bullets, and much of the staff was shot away." (58) The 31,000 cartridges differs what has been given in the Official Records but then the Official Records just track government purchases. The 7th Illinois more than likely purchased much of their own ammunition at this time. Not all members were able to fire 163 rounds, some fired less but some, such as Frank Orcutt, fired over 400 rounds. This was a spirited three hour fight with the Henry rifle barrel becoming very hot.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top