Repeaters

Spencer carbines do not become available until the fall of 1863 in numbers. Custer's cavalry were armed with Spencer rifles. There were a few Henry rifles close by but not at Gettysburg. Buford did indeed have Sharps carbines.
 
Buford did not have Spencer carbines. The Spencer carbines were not even out until the Fall of 1863. The Sharps carbine is what Buford's cavalry were armed with. A single shot breech-loading carbine capable of maybe 5 to 7 shots per minute. NO Spencer carbines were at Gettysburg.
 
T
Buford had no repeaters of any kind. He had no Spencers at all. The only repeaters at Gettysburg were w/ Custers men who weren't even on the field that day.
Then explain how his dismounted cavalry held off most of the confederate army for a few hours? With the wonky parade swords or pistols that didn't have a great range? No sir, they had Spencers and that saved his division from destruction and a possible defeat at Gettysburg.
 
Single shot breech-loading carbines do offer a great advantage over someone with a muzzle-loader. Double the rate of fire gives your side twice the firepower as the enemy. Repeating rifles/carbines offer a much great rate of fire over the single-shot breech-loaders. A Spencer has about 2 to 3? times(14 or so per minute) the rate of fire as the Sharps while Henry rifle has over 5 times the firepower(30 rounds plus per mintue) as the Sharps and about twice the rate of fire as a Spencer when firepower is defined as rounds down range.
 
In a report dated March 28th, 1865 Major Edward S. Johnson of the Seventh describes their use of the Henry Repeating rifles during the Battle of Bentonville. He writes, "At 3 p.m. I received orders from the brigade commander to relieve the skirmishers of the Fiftieth Illinois Infantry, then occupying the outer works of the enemy, and to hold those rifle pits at all hazards. I accordingly moved with my whole command, seventy men in all, principally armed with the Henry repeating rifle, to the swamp on the farther side of which those pits were located, and found that our skirmishers had withdrawn from them, and that they were reoccupied by the enemy in force. The enemy immediately opened a galling fire upon me, under which I, however deployed my men as skirmishers, and returned his fire. The left of my line succeeded in getting over the swamp, but was afterwards somewhat withdrawn to allow artillery uninterrupted play upon the enemy's position.....My men also threw up detached rifle pits for their own protection. The enemy attempted several times to advance his lines, but was driven back with little trouble. An exceedingly sharp fire was kept up, however, by both sides during the entire night, until 3:00 o'clock on the morning of the 22d, when the enemy's fire entirely ceased. At daylight I ordered a party over the swamp to reconnoiter the rifle pits in my front, which were found deserted; and I immediately advanced my whole line, occupying a second and third line of works, and finding the enemy had disappeared." (39) Seventy men armed with Henry Repeating rifles would be a force to reckon with. Even if each man only carried a hundred cartridges that would equal 7,000 rounds that could be fired stopping any advance by an enemy.
 
According to the report of Major Samuel Martin of the Thirty-Seventh Kentucky Infantry, Henry Repeating rifles were used at a fight in and around Glasgow, Ky. The date of this report is October 9, 1863. "I now proceed to give you the particulars of the recent raid made on Glasgow, Ky. by the rebel Col. John M. Hughes. .....The town was attacked on the morning of the 6th instant about daylight. I was in bed and heard the rebels passing through town and in the direction of the fort where my men were encamped. I supposing as they passed through town that they were Captain Stone's men returning. I lay still until my father looked out of the window and said they were rebels, and while he was telling it to me, firing commenced in the square. I had Captain J.O. Nelson's company as provost guards in the court-house yard. They numbered about 50 men present. As soon as the firing commenced in the square, I sprang from my bed, loaded my Henry rifle, dressed myself, went to the window and saw 15 or 20 rebels ordering Captain Nelson's men into line under guard. I asked them whose command they belonged to, receiving no reply, myself and Lieutenant Chinoweth fired on them, both about the same time. They returned the fire, some of their balls passing through the window into our room. We fired six or eight times at them from the windows, wounding 3 or 4 of the rebels on the square. Here I will mention one of my orderlies Frank Claiborne. We had shot a rebel off his horse, I ordered Claiborne to go down and get on the horse and try to get to the fort and rally my men, then myself supposing that the rebels had not reached there. As quick as the order was given it was obeyed, and I saw him gallop off from the rebels in the square toward the fort, and I learned since that he was captured by them. Our fire from the windows was too severe, and the rebels left the public square, then myself and Lieutenant Chinoweth, and William Griffith, an orderly, went down stairs to go to the stable to get our horses. When we got down stairs I saw Captain Nelson in the court-house yard by himself, and I told him to follow me to get a horse, which he did not do. When we turned the corner of the square to go to the stable where our horses were we saw that it was surrounded by rebels catching the horses. We fired several times at them and they left the stable, leaving in it 4 horses and saddles. We soon mounted three of them and rode back through the town and started toward the fort. At that time I heard firing and a hallooning at the fort. We went within 200 yards of the fort, where we could see it well, and there I sat on my horse and saw rebels sacking my camp and driving my men into line. I again lowered my gun to fire on them, but was prevailed on by Lieutenant Chinoweth not to do so for fear of killing my own men. We were there helpless, only 3 of us with arms and I considered the greater portion of my command captured. We sat here about two minutes, when we were discovered by the rebels and about 30 of them started after us, but we kept out of their way and succeeded in collecting a few of my pickets who were yet at their posts." (25) This was not a good day for Major Martin of the 37th Kentucky Infantry. But he does use his Henry Repeating rifle with good results to save himself. I have to wonder why his Henry was not loaded and ready to go.
 
Repeaters were far more expensive than muzzle loaders, and it really wasn't possible to say, "OK, make me 100,000. and deliver them next week."
 
Repeaters were far more expensive than muzzle loaders, and it really wasn't possible to say, "OK, make me 100,000. and deliver them next week."

That is what the what if crowd forgets. Reality is a real unforgiving woman when it comes to production numbers and cost fiction and fantasy can be as forgiving as the author wishes.

I'm reminded of a discussion a while ago w/ an enthusiastic young man at the museum after I made a comment about the US Airborne troops in Europe. "The SS were the best troops in Europe in 1944... best this, best that etc, etc." My reply was to ask him if he had ever heard of the Battle of Mortain, to my surprise he looked it up on his magic phone and what I heard from just outside the door was "holy ****!" I told him that when I was doing a lot of miniature wargaming I would often suggest the Battle of Mortain, tried it w/ a half dozen different sets of rules and never once did the Americans win, it was almost always a rather one sided affair. Fiction, fantasy, war games don't take into account certain factors of reality.
 
I belive 1 unit from Maine used the Henry rifle. (See, used the right name this time) :smoke:

Actually, it was the 1st District of Columbia Cavalry, which included a couple of companies from Maine. The entire regiment was armed with the Henry. It was the only unit I am aware of that was armed with Henry rifles.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top