Repeaters

When are you guys doing this impression at the Stones River NP?

We are forming a large company or small battalion for the 150th Chickamauga event in September. We are portraying the 17th Indiana Mounted Infantry (dismounted) part of Wilder's Brigade. Our troops will be armed with both Spencer and Henry rifles. If interested check out this link below.

http://westernsharpshooters.webs.com/ourimpressions.htm

I have researched and written an article about the 17th Indiana and their Henry rifles. I sent it out to several civil war magazines, but I have not been able to get any responses of interest from any of them. All of it is well documented and the foundation is from an unpublished diary from a member of the 17th Indiana.

It is great information and I may just go ahead and just list it on the web myself eventually.
June 15-16
 
What type of firing demonstatration will you be doing? What do you use for blanks?
I'm there to display my Wilder's issue Spencer rifle and talk about Hoovers Gap and on to Chickamauga. The NPS has trained some volunteers to demonstate how the rifle was used and fired. The NPS purchased the rifles and blanks. I have not seen the guns or ammo yet.
 
Bob I an interested in what you have that you display along with your Spencer rifle. The Spencer rifle is an interesting rifle. I have own one rifle and 2 carbines over the years and have shot all of them. I have had a 6 tube Blakeslee box as well as a 10 tube Blakeslee box; these would have only been used late war with the 10 tube box being the one that was probably used. Wilder's boys would not have had them. I think I still have my original screwdriver/tool for the Spencer rifle, I never had the carbine version which was slightly different. Do you have any pictures you could post of you Wilder's display?

On another note concerning Henry rifles, I was able to inspect an original Henry rifle a friend of mine had. When I asked him if I could open the breech he said that he had never done that but said ok. To our surprise at some point in time this Henry rifle had been converted to center fire. Back before the repro Henry rifles came out the movie industry did convert some to shoot centerfire blanks. Unfortunately my friend sold the Henry last year.
 
The Henry repeating rifle did have a rate of fire of around 30 rounds per minute but was rarely every shot at that rate. While the muzzle-loading rifle only fired at a rate of maybe 3 per minute. The fact is that there was far more muzzle-loading ammunition wasted due to spoilage than the entire supply of ammunition the government purchased for the Henry repeating rifle. The self-contained Henry rounds held up far better than paper cartridges in harsh conditions.
 
Bob I an interested in what you have that you display along with your Spencer rifle. The Spencer rifle is an interesting rifle. I have own one rifle and 2 carbines over the years and have shot all of them. I have had a 6 tube Blakeslee box as well as a 10 tube Blakeslee box; these would have only been used late war with the 10 tube box being the one that was probably used. Wilder's boys would not have had them. I think I still have my original screwdriver/tool for the Spencer rifle, I never had the carbine version which was slightly different. Do you have any pictures you could post of you Wilder's display?

On another note concerning Henry rifles, I was able to inspect an original Henry rifle a friend of mine had. When I asked him if I could open the breech he said that he had never done that but said ok. To our surprise at some point in time this Henry rifle had been converted to center fire. Back before the repro Henry rifles came out the movie industry did convert some to shoot centerfire blanks. Unfortunately my friend sold the Henry last year.
I have not got my display together. I do plan on showing the carbine also for a comparison. I plan on wearing the uniform of the Lightning Brigade. When I get it together, I'll take some photos and post them. Any suggestions?
 

  • Military Battle
  • FORT FISHER, N.C.
    JAN. 13TH - 17TH, 1865
    Fort Fisher, N. C., Jan. 13-17, 1865. Expedition under
    Gen. Terry, and North Atlantic Blockading Squadron. Pursuant
    to orders from Gen. Grant, Maj.-Gen. A. H. Terry on Jan. 2,
    selected 1,400 men from the 2nd brigade, 1st division, 24th
    corps, under Col. J. C. Abbott; 3,300 from the 2nd division of
    the same corps under Brig.Gen. Adelbert Ames, 3,300 from the
    3rd division of the 25th corps, under command of Brig.-Gen.
    Charles J. Paine: 4 guns of the 16th N. Y. independent
    Battery, and Battery E, 3rd U. S. artillery, for an expedition
    against Fort Fisher. The troops were embarked on transports
    at Bermuda landing on the 4th and joined the North Atlantic
    Squadron, under Adm. Porter, 25 miles off Beaufort, N. C.
    Owing to stormy weather the fleet did not reach the vicinity
    of Fort Fisher until late on the afternoon of the 12th and
    landing was postponed until next morning. Fort Fisher was
    located on the narrow peninsula known as Federal point.
    between the Cape Fear river and the Atlantic ocean, and was
    garrisoned by a Confederate force of some 1,2OO men with 47
    pieces of heavy ordnance. When the enemy learned of Terry's
    approach Gen. Whiting reinforced the garrison with 600 men and
    Gen. Hoke, with his division of 6,000 infantry and cavalry
    took a position on the peninsula north of the fort to prevent
    the Federals from landing. About midnight of the 12th the
    gunboats began shelling the fort and at 4 a.m. on the 13th the
    transports moved close to the shore and the work of
    disembarking was commenced. By 3 p.m. 8,000 men were on
    shore, each with 3 days' rations in his haversack and 40
    rounds of ammunition in his cartridge-box. Terry's advance
    soon encountered Hoke's outposts and exchanged shots with
    them, the Confederates gradually retiring. During the night
    Terry threw a line of intrenchments across the peninsula to
    guard against any attack from the rear, and early on the
    morning of the 14th the artillery was brought ashore and
    placed in the works. Curtis' brigade of Ames' division moved
    toward the fort and gained possession of a small unfinished
    work facing the west end of the land front of the fort. As a
    result of the reconnaissance Terry determined to attempt an
    assault the next day and sent word to Porter, who at once
    moved his gunboats nearer the fort for the purpose of
    cooperating with the land forces. At 8 a.m. on the 15th,
    according to Terry's report, "all of the vessels, except a
    division left to aid in the defense of our northern line,
    moved into position, and a fire, magnificent alike for its
    power, was opened." At 2 p.m. 60 sharpshooters from the 13th
    Ind., armed with Spencer repeating rifles, and 40 men from
    Curtis' brigade, advanced on a run to within 175 yards of the
    fort. They were provided with shovels, and in the sandy soil
    each man soon had a pit to shelter him while he directed his
    fire to the parapet. As soon as the sharpshooters had gained
    their position Curtis moved up to a slight ridge about 50
    yards in their rear, Pennypacker's brigade occupied the
    outwork just vacated by Curtis' and Bell's brigade was placed
    about 200 yards in the rear of Pennypacker. At 3:25 p.m. the
    signal to advance was given. Curtis' men sprang from their
    cover and dashed toward the fort, Pennypacker occupied the
    position along the little ridge, and Bell moved up to the
    outwork. With Curtis were a number of axmen who did good
    service in making openings in the palisades, through which
    Curtis' line swept like a tornado and gained the parapet. At
    the same time a column of sailors and marines, commanded by
    Capt. K. R. Breese, advanced up the beach and attacked the
    northeastern bastion, but were met by a murderous fire and
    compelled to retire to the boats. As soon as Curtis had
    gained a firm foothold on the parapet Pennypacker was moved up
    to his support and in a few minutes drove the enemy from the
    palisades extending toward the river, after which he took a
    position on Curtis' right on the north face of the fort.
    Bell's brigade was now moved between the fort and the river.
    On this side there was no parapet, but the enemy found shelter
    in the holes from which the sand had been taken to construct
    the fort, and here some desperate hand to hand fighting
    occurred, the enemy falling back from one to another of the
    traverses of the land face of the fort and using these
    traverses for breastworks, from which they fired on the
    advancing Unionists at short range. The contest for the
    possession of the traverses was continued until about 9 p.m.,
    when Abbott's brigade drove the enemy from his last stand and
    Fort Fisher was in the hands of the Federal troops. Several
    prisoners were captured by Pennypacker in his first assault on
    the palisades and the rest of the garrison surrendered. About
    4 p.m. Hoke attempted a diversion by threatening an attack on
    Terry's line of intrenchments across the peninsula, but after
    a slight skirmish with the Union pickets abandoned his
    intention. Terry's loss at Fort Fisher was 110 killed, 535
    wounded and 13 missing. Gen. Bragg, commanding the
    Confederate forces, reported his loss as about 500 in killed
    and wounded and 2,083 captured. With the prisoners all the
    stores, cannon, etc., fell into the hands of the Union forces.
    Besides the 47 heavy guns in position there were 122 pieces of
    artillery in the fort, 2,000 stand of small arms, full
    supplies of ammunition and a large quantity of commissary
    stores. Brig.-Gen. N. M. Curtis, Col. Galusha Pennypacker and
    First Lieut. John Wainwright, of the 97th Pa., and Private Z.
    C. Neahr, of the 142nd N. Y., were awarded medals of honor by
    Congress for distinguished bravery at Fort Fisher. On the
    16th the enemy blew up Fort Caswell and Fort Campbell, and
    abandoned them, as well as their works at Smithville and at
    Reeves' point.
    Source: The Union Army, vol. 5





 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have not got my display together. I do plan on showing the carbine also for a comparison. I plan on wearing the uniform of the Lightning Brigade. When I get it together, I'll take some photos and post them. Any suggestions?

Sounds like you will have a very good display. Basically men armed with repeating rifles, be it a Spencer or a Henry, had the same basic equipment as did soldiers armed with muzzle-loading rifles. I usually say I am portraying the "common soldier" but armed with a repeating rifle. One thing you could do if you haven't already is to make up some "dummy boxes" of Spencer ammunition using a proper label from the CW. Here is a label I have used at times.
Spencer%20label.jpg

The box for the label would measure 4 and 5/8s x 2 x 4 and 1/4 inches. The label itself was yellow with black printing. Copy the picture here, import into a Word doc and print out on yellow paper or just make your own in Word to look like a new label, I have done both. This type of box and label was used from 1863 to 1864. Do you have the combination tool for the Spencer rifle and Carbine? Dixie Gun Works used to offer originals at one time. I have an original for the rifle but not for my carbine. At any rate just a couple of suggestions for what they are worth.

I will look forward to seeing any pictures you will have of your display. Sounds like a fun time.
 
Many have voiced their opinion favoring the Spencer or the Henry rifles/carbine. Certain Civil War regiments come to mind that were armed with both the Spencer and Henry rifles in their ranks. Wilder's Brigade were armed with both weapons. Mainly the 17th Indiana Mounted Infantry scouts were armed with Henry rifles while the main body of men were armed with Spencer rifles. Also the 1st DC Cavalry were armed with govenment purchased Henry rifles. They were consolodated into the 1st Maine Cavalry in August of 1864. The 1st Maine Cavalry were armed with Spencer carbines. These units got to compare the advantages/disadvantages of both repeating rifles. There are many good reports in "The History of the 1st Maine Cavarly" where both the Henry and the Spencer were used side by side.

Chaplain Merrill wrote this description of the incident. "An incident is worth relating as an example of the coolness of the men. Col. Cilley is a little near-sighted. After forming the regiment on the Boydton plank road, the men opened a rapid fire with their Spencer and Henry rifles. A moment later, seeing no enemy and thinking they were wasting their ammunition, the colonel rushed along the line, directing the men to cease fire. Coming up to Corp. Gurney, of Co. B, he shouted: "You are acting like a fool with your ammunition, corporal." "The rebs are right out there," the corporal replied. "That may be so but wait till you can see them." Knee down here, colonel; now look through there." The colonel said no more of wasting ammunition, but remained on his knee and commenced firing with his revolver."
 
This is an interesting story from the First D.C. Cavalry during the "Great Beefsteak Raid" who were armed with Henry rifles.

Private Stephen Gray, of Co. K tells his story in the following: "On the third post were William H. Hill, of Co. K, John Crawford of Co. F, and myself, and we waited for the officer of the picket to relieve us….. We had not gone far when we heard the sound of cavalry coming down the road, which we supposed was from the Eleventh Pennsylvania regiment, but which proved to be a number of the enemy's cavalry. We were ordered to surrender, and Crawford and myself were inclined to do so; but when the officer stepped forward to take our arms, Hill, who was standing behind us, declared he never would surrender, and quickly brought his carbine(Henry rifle) to his shoulder and sent two shots into the body of the officer. Hill then turned and began firing into the ranks of the rebels, Crawford and myself following in quick succession. The enemy returned fire, but we stepped behind some trees and kept up a brisk fire with our repeating rifles for a few moments, when, by Hill's advice, we ran into the woods some distance, and hid under the tops of some trees that had been recently felled. The enemy followed, but soon lost sight of us. We could hear them hunting for us in the woods, and could hear them talk about shooting us when they saw us, hanging us when they caught us, etc. Finally they concluded we had gone through the woods, and returned to the road to take care of the officer. We judged from their conversation that others were killed or wounded, as well as he. We crawled through the woods to near the house of a Union planter, where Hill had been on duty as a safe guard, when a young lady came running from the house and told us to run, as the rebs were coming…… On reaching the camp we found the body of Lieutenant Mountfort lying in the shed by the church, stripped of everything, and even a finger cut off to secure a ring."
 
I like ther reference; "sixteen hummingbirds to sing in the ears of the enemy" and the seven deadly messengers of the Spencers.

"Capt. Myrick, was sent out scouting beyond the pickets and across the creek, to see what was there. The order was passed through the remainder of the regiment to be prepared to fight on foot at any time. The men were already counted off by fours, of course, and now the bridles of horses Nos 1, 2, and 3 were given to the No 4 man to hold, with orders to "look out for my grain," "take care of my haversack," and a thousand and one instructions. The sabers were strapped to saddles, and all superfluities taken from the person and fastened to the saddles or put in the saddle-bags. The grain bags and all baggage were strapped firmer on the saddles---they might go through some heavy shaking before the riders again got to them. The cartridge boxes were filled to their utmost capacity---the spare cartridges in the saddle-bags were put in the pockets---the carbines were examined---the Spencer's loaded carefully with their seven deadly messengers, while the Henry's were wound up to unwind and set flying sixteen humming birds, to sing in the ears of the enemy. The canteens that were full were thrown over the shoulders---there was no knowing how much a man might want a drink of water before he again saw his horse."
 
If you have not read Todd Koster's excellent article on Wilder's Brigade and Henry rifles is is really a must read. Here is information form his article on a Henry rifle in action: http://westernsharpshooters.webs.com/henryspencerresearch.htm

Private DeWitt Clinton Walters of Company I, who also served as one of the 17th Indiana scouts, referred to as both DeWitt and Clint in period accounts, advanced further into the brush with his Henry rifle. Walters went in search of the rebels that had fled from his seventeen shooter. He did not have long to wait. The counterattacking 4th Battalion Georgia Sharpshooters were already heading his way. Walters caught a glimpse of three butternut clad sharpshooters running through the Tennessee timber towards him, including Adjutant John R. Yourie of Major Theodore D. Caswell's Battalion. "So impetuously did they come on, that they ran over De Witt [Walters], who saved himself by lying down beside a log and feigning to be dead." The three sharpshooters continued past Walters and either failed to see him or fell victim to his ruse. Once Walters was sure that the rebels had placed enough distance between them and him, he sprang into action and worked the lever of his Henry. Firing into their rear, he killed the two sharpshooters and mortally wounded Yourie. Walters moved up, captured and brought him into the 17th's lines. Yourie was not to survive for long and shortly thereafter succumbed to the wound from Walter's Henry rifle.(16)
 
One of the things we do not consider in the modern age of vastly improved logistics for our military forces (trucks, trains and air freight) is that during the ACW supplies were delivered from the rail heads by horse or mule drawn wagons over often muddy and badly rutted roads. Only so much could be hauled.

Another objection from professional officers was the theory that the men, armed with rapid fire repeaters, would shoot up all of their ammunition before the battle was "half fought!"
 
Here's an excerpt from the Civil War Diary of Henry Carl Ketzle, 37th IL Volunteer Infantry, Co A, 1861-1866, describing use of the Colt repeater in action at Pea Ridge:

March 1862 (Battle of Elkhorn Tavern / Pea Ridge)
...The 37th filed into the lane, a fence and open field on the left, when the Peoria Battery, belonging to our Brigade, was stationed shelling the woods in front or to the north of us -- on the west on our right it was tall timber with a very heavy undergrowth of young oaks which had most all the dry leaves hanging on yet. When about two-thirds the distance down the lane, we filed by the right flank into those woods, Company A in the lead having entered the underbrush, somewhat more than the length from the regiment we left flanked, and some of Company A noticed some troops before us and wanted to fire, but they wore blue overcoats (stolen the day before form some of Sigel's train) an officer of Company B cried to us "Don't shoot, they are our own men" -- scarcely had these words been uttered when we were staggered by a heavy volley fired almost in our faces which extended the whole front and even in the rear of the first three companies. Underbrush being very thick we couldn't see much but smoke and fire, but we dropped to the ground and let them have it as fast as we could pull trigger with our five shooters -- Company A and Company K of our Regiment had Colt's revolving rifles and our rapid firing disconcerted them some, but being a whole brigade of Texan and Louisiana troops, they crowded us back with heavy loss to some of the more advanced companies -- back we fell to the lane, then over the fence and into the field and finally behind our battery and the fence, hard pressed by overwhelming numbers of rebs, but when once composed, the Indiana Brigade rose with a yell and poured it into them which not only stopped the rebs but soon sent them flying pell mell before us, more so, as about that time another of their leaders, McCullough, having been killed and now McIntosh had fallen, we drove them till near dark when some of us returned to our knapsacks and to take care of our wounded.​
We found we had lost of Company A, 5 killed, 4 mortally wounded and 24 others more or less wounded, out of a total of 54 which entered battle....​
 
R.K. Williams writes on March 3, 1863 of witnessing the use of Henrys in Kentucky. He feels that the Henry is the most effective weapon in use. He writes: "The Henry Rifle is regarded in Kentucky as the most effective known, and some most astonishing things have been accomplished with it; among these we mention one: Whilst the gallant Colonel Netter was raising his regiment of Kentucky Volunteers at Owensboro, Ky., he sent fifteen of his men armed with this rifle on a scout; these men were attacked by two hundred and forty rebel soldiers in an open lane, where there was no timber for shelter, and the fifteen Union soldiers, armed with the Henry, successfully repulsed and drove from the field the two hundred and forty assailants. This unparalleled feat could not have been accomplished with any other arm known to us. Respectfully, R.K. Williams, W.W. Gardner"
 
The Battle of Corydon, IN in southern Indiana is going to have their 150th commemoration in July. So here is a little information on the use of the Henry rifle at the Battle of Corydon.

As soon as they approached in range the Henry Rifles opened fire and did good work, the enemy being in full view. Soon the fire became general along the entire right wing, which checked the advancing column of the enemy, and compelled them to undertake to flank both our wings at the same time, a performance which the great disparity of forces enabled them easily to do. .......Upon the right wing a large flanking force was sent against our lines and the fighting was very sharp for the space of 20 minutes in that quarter; twelve Henry Rifles and a squad of 30 to 40, some 100 yards to their left, armed with the ordinary rifle musket holding a heavy body of flankers in check for ten or fifteen minutes and compelling them to dismount. Being completely overpowered by numbers our forces gradually fell back to Corydon and the cavalry and mounted infantry generally made their escape." (62) In a letter written by Attia Porter dated July 30, 1863, she describes the battle and the fact that her father, "Judge Porter", was out fighting with his Henry Rifle but they did not get him or his Henry.
 
Oliver Winchester, president of the New Haven Arms Company, wrote an article that appeared in the March 17,1863 edition if "The Scientific American" on the merits of the Henry Repeating rifle. "....A magazine gun like the Henry rifle, carrying fifteen charges, which can be refilled in fifteen seconds, and the fifteen shots fired with deliberate aim in sixty seconds, or fifteen times before the enemy could reload once, must produce a sheet of fire and lead before which no troops could stand to receive the last shot. The only reason, or excuse rather, we have ever heard against the use in the army of arms susceptible of such rapidity of loading is that the troops would waste the ammunition. Will this bear the test of examination? Consider that it is admitted that in the use of muzzle-loading guns, but five per cent of the shots would take effect, showing a loss of ninety-five per cent of the ammunition! Can a greater waste be well expected under any circumstances? Thus far we have looked at the subject from a mathematical point of view only. Now as to the moral effect upon those armed with such terrible weapons and upon those opposed to them armed with such comparatively defective arms. If, as we think, it is a consciousness of power that makes men brave, and a sense of imminent peril that makes cowards of us all, and oftentimes strikes with panic the best armies, is it not reasonable to suppose that such a weapon would give a soldier the courage and coolness needed to send each of those fifteen shots with more unerring certainty than his trembling opponent could send his single shot? If, to save ammunition, it is essential that every soldier should remain for sixty seconds while reloading, a helpless target, to receive his opponent's fire from one to fifteen shots, why not reverse the order of progress and turn the ingenuity of inventors to the production of more to reload, and thus double the saving of ammunition? Saving of life does not appear an element worthy of consideration in this connection. Yet this is West Point opinion, the deductions of West Point science! Are these results worth their cost to the country?" (66) Wasting ammunition has been an age old concern of the military. This seems to have been a concern down through history even at the expense of saving lives. It is not until we get to WWII that putting fire on a target really meant something. Even this was not taught in training but troops had to be re-taught once they arrived in Europe or the South Pacific. Winchester and others recognized the value of having rapid fire in a life or death situation.
 
Colonel Richard T. Jacob of the Ninth Kentucky Cavalry, commanding the brigade wrote a report of the actions that took place near Columbia, Kentucky in late April and early May. The report is dated May 12, 1863. His brigade consisted of parts of the Ninth, Eleventh and Twelfth Kentucky Cavalry. "The three pickets of Company B, Twelfth Kentucky Cavalry, under charge of Sergeant Dexter, finding that our men had retired, took deliberate aim at the enemy's pickets, and then darted over the hill, fighting as they ran, and succeeded in making good their escape." (52) The Twelfth Kentucky Cavalry were armed with Henry Repeating rifles. "Lieutenant-Colonel Holeman, commanding the charge, being ranking officer and the commander of the Twelfth Kentucky Cavalry, cheered the men on to their work of death, and whenever the fight was most dangerous there he could be found.....Captain Wilson, of the Twelfth Kentucky Cavalry, rushed into the midst of the enemy and laid many a man low with his Henry Rifle......Captain Sims worked his gun with great skill. Lieutenant H.W. Shafer did the most rapid and accurate firing, carrying death and destruction to the enemy.......Captains Wiltsie, Wilson, Allen and Searcy, I am informed with great skill and bravery in Saturday's fight.....I do not know the loss of the enemy, but I think it very heavy. We had 450 men in the fight, and fought Major-General Morgan, with nine regiments, for forty-five minutes, and then crossed the deep river with only one small boat, a few canoes, and a half-broken, half sunken gunnel, floored, and a half a foot of water on it. The enemy did not follow us."
 
Colonel J. Warren Keifer was the commanding officer of the One Hundred and tenth Ohio Infantry. He describes the actions of the 110th Ohio from June 13-15, 1863. His men are involved in fighting in and around Union Mills, Winchester and Harpers Ferry. He makes a special mention to give praise to his group of sharpshooters. "Knowing the risk of being censured for making special mention of officers and men where all behaved so nobly, I cannot refrain from calling attention to my sharpshooters. Armed with the Henry rifle, in each engagement they fired almost continuous streams into the enemy's ranks, creating great loss of life. They also, under my own eyes, shot down a number of the enemy's officers." (24) This report, was written June 16, 1863, documented the early use of the Henry Repeating rifle and its effectiveness against the enemy.
 
Henry Repeating rifles were acquired by both the "Unionist" soldiers of Kentucky as well as the "Rebels" of Kentucky. I am not sure who was involved or when it was in the following shoot-out. "Two or three days ago three loyal men near Owensboro, Ky., armed with Henry rifles, had a conflict with forty well armed guerrillas, and soon put them to a very hasty flight. The three gentlemen were at breakfast when the guerrillas surrounded them and demanded, their surrender, but the brave fellows refused, and bringing their terrible weapons into quick and effective play, they at once cleared the field of their enemies. Western Papers" (79) I am sure the forty guerrillas had not idea of what was just unleashed upon them when the three Henry Repeating rifles opened up on them.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top