Repeaters

Krag4.jpg
Expired Image RemovedBy the end of the war almost 10,000 Henry repeating rifles were used. While the Krag has a nice smooth action it was far slower than a 7mm Mauser of the Spanish in the reload. I have 3 Krags as well as a Mauser 7mm. In test of speed the Mauser is able to fire at a rate of at least 3 times faster than the Krag when firing 20 rounds or more. The 5 round stripper clip is so much faster than taking one round at a time from the Krag cartridge belt. The 03 springfield that replace the Krag is basically a Mauser in design. The Sp-Am Krag bullet design was a pee poor stopper. I love my Krags but they are what they are.

http://www.frontiernet.net/~abnb13/Krag Carbine.htm
 
Where did I get Tate's book on Ripley? Tate sent it to me; that and along with his other book on James Burton. We met and the Military Historians' Conference and swapped books. The book is available via Amazon.
 
Krag4.jpg
Expired Image RemovedBy the end of the war almost 10,000 Henry repeating rifles were used. While the Krag has a nice smooth action it was far slower than a 7mm Mauser of the Spanish in the reload. I have 3 Krags as well as a Mauser 7mm. In test of speed the Mauser is able to fire at a rate of at least 3 times faster than the Krag when firing 20 rounds or more. The 5 round stripper clip is so much faster than taking one round at a time from the Krag cartridge belt. The 03 springfield that replace the Krag is basically a Mauser in design. The Sp-Am Krag bullet design was a pee poor stopper. I love my Krags but they are what they are.

http://www.frontiernet.net/~abnb13/Krag Carbine.htm
The .30-40 Krag round was pee poor compared to what? The .44 Henry was pee poor compared to alot of rounds of the period, but to say that the Krag was not a good man stopper is far less than accurate. It's effectiveness was on par with the .303 British at the time and the .303 was used well past WWII! Other developements of ammunition and rifles made it obsolete as the Krag made prior guns and ammo obsolete. The Mauser had it's problems also.
 
The .30-40 Krag round had a very poor bullet design. This is backed up by the accounts written during the time of the Sp-Am War as well as the Philippines and Boxer conflicts. That is why the round did ot last long. The 7mm Mauser was a much better designed round but was also a poor stopper. However the rifle was far superior to the Krag design. With a better bullet the Krag might be close to the .303 British. Teh 03 that took the place is a Mauser desgin. The Mauser desgin was and is a fat better desing than the Krag.

Back to the Civil War, while the .44 Henry round was not the best round; the rifle that shot the round was the best thing that came out of the Civil War concerning small arms. The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times. The Spencer was a "dead end" design.
 
The .30-40 Krag round had a very poor bullet design. This is backed up by the accounts written during the time of the Sp-Am War as well as the Philippines and Boxer conflicts. That is why the round did ot last long. The 7mm Mauser was a much better designed round but was also a poor stopper. However the rifle was far superior to the Krag design. With a better bullet the Krag might be close to the .303 British. Teh 03 that took the place is a Mauser desgin. The Mauser desgin was and is a fat better desing than the Krag.

Back to the Civil War, while the .44 Henry round was not the best round the rifle that shot the round was the best thing that came out of the Civil War concerning small arms. The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times. The Spencer was a "dead end" design.
I'm familiar with the developement of the bullet designs and still disagree that it wasn't a good killing bullet. Better designs came along and the guns got better. The .30-40 Krag, British .303, 7mm Mauser, 7.62x54 Russian, etc. all had the basic bullet design at first and had the same short comings. They all were still very effective in killing soldiers. The loading system of the Krag and it's limited pressure capabilities was the cause of inproving the design. The .30-03 of the Springfield 1903 had a simular bullet design and didn't last either with the developement of the .30-06 and Spitzer bullet. Spanish Mauser far superior? No! A little superior, but nothing to go ape over. The Henry was not the design that continued with the US Military. The Spencer was and was used as the official repeater of the cavalry until 1873.
 
The Spencer saw military service as late as WW1 and quite a lot of military service through te 1880's... wheras the Henry was abandoned by 1866, no military in the world adopting it or using it even as a second class arm. There was a reason for this, look at the improvements in the lever action design evident to the most cursory look in the 1866 Winchester & the 1873. It wasn't until John Browning got into the act that a Winchester could fire a military grade cartridge. And only two militaries in the world adopted a Lever Action repeater. The Turks adopted the M1866 for their Cav & replaced them /win a decade due to reliability issues. The Russians LOVED the M1895 but replaced it w/ the Mosin Nagant in short order.

The Henry was a pretty little rifle good out to 100 yards, the Spencer was more reliable and more robust thus better suited for military service. Thus why the Spencer served as an official arm of the US military well after the ACW.

The .30-40 Krag... a poor man stopper, not to the men hit by it. For the most parts the ballistics of the .30-40 are the same as the .303... hardly a round anyone in their right mind calls a poor man stopper. Certainly not the Mauser armed Germans in either World War.

The .30-40 Krag round was replaced by the .30-03 then in short order eclipsed by the .30-06 Spitzer bullet.

The only advantage the Spanish Mauser had over the Krag was the stripper clip which allowed faster loading. When it came to accuracy, reliability etc or combat performance in general the Krag was the equal to the Mauser. That it was replaced by the M1903 is testement to the US military seeing a need to improve upon and adopt a better design than the Mauser... and the M1903 is in all ways an improvement upon the Mauser.
 
It seems that some have misunderstood my comments. "The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times." The US was slow to undestand this. The Henry was a design that could be adapted and built upon into the M1866, M1873 and the M1876. The Spencer was a "Dead End" design. Whether the Spencer was used in WWI does not change the fact that it was a "Dead End" design and was never improved, but junked. More Winchester/Henry variations have been produced and used than Spencers by a long shot. The discussion never was that the Henry Rifle was best rifle of all time but the concept of repeating weapons is what came out of the Civil War and the Henry rifle was the best repeating rifle that came out of the Civil War. The M1866 is nothing more than an Improved Henry rifle with a forearm, redesigned magazine and loading gate. How many thousands of the M1866 were produced and used in War?

Unfortunately many of those shot by Krags in the Philippines were able to live long enough to kill those that shot them. This was also true for the .38 Colt revolver. Winchester 1897 and .45 revolvers had their place in these conflicts. The Krag pure and simple was a poor manstopper and the research proves this out. Just because a person gets shot does not mean a round has adequate stopping power for the task at hand. A .22 Short can kill a person but I don't think that we would say it has a lot of "Stopping Power".

The big advantage of the Mauser is the fact that it could be loaded with the use of stripper clips. That in itself makes the Krag an obsolete design even for its time of the 1890s. I have shot both and own both Krags and Mausers the accuracy of both are very good. The Krag as a hunting rifle loaded with the proper bullet does have a very smooth action but as a military rifle it was obsolete when it was adopted.

The 03 Springfield is a Mauser design not a Krag design. That in itself should put to rest which design was a better military design, the Krag or the Mauser.

As I said earlier, The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times."
 
Both the .30-40 Krag and the 7mm Mauser rounds were not very good in the field of "Stopping Power", I mentioned this earlier. Both could pentrate the human body through and through but that is not stopping power. Bullet design of the 1890s did not produce the best, that is why when the 1900 got here bullet desgin changed. The history and research both bear this out as fact.

If a bullet will not stop the "Philippine Moros were hopped up on drugs and their bodies were wrapped tight in bamboo" then it is time to look for another round that will stop them. That is why the 03 was chambered for the .30-03 then the .30-06 and the revolver went from the Colt .38 to the 1911 pistol in .45 ACP.

The Springfield is a great bolt action rifle but it is a Mauser design which over $200,000 was paid to Mauser for the use of the design. The only real difference between the Springfield and the Mauser was the magazine cut-off which was a throw back design. When added up millions more Mauser were produced than 03 Springfields. Again the Springfield was and is a grat rifle.

This discussion probably belongs elsewhere. Back to the Civil War, the repeaters of the Civil War changed the concept of fighting and arming amies but not all countries learned the lesson at the same speed. It took the US longer than most countries. As I said earlier, The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times."
 
Both the .30-40 Krag and the 7mm Mauser rounds were not very good in the field of "Stopping Power", I mentioned this earlier. Both could pentrate the human body through and through but that is not stopping power. Bullet design of the 1890s did not produce the best, that is why when the 1900 got here bullet desgin changed. The history and research both bear this out as fact.

If a bullet will not stop the "Philippine Moros were hopped up on drugs and their bodies were wrapped tight in bamboo" then it is time to look for another round that will stop them. That is why the 03 was chambered for the .30-03 then the .30-06 and the revolver went from the Colt .38 to the 1911 pistol in .45 ACP.

The Springfield is a great bolt action rifle but it is a Mauser design which over $200,000 was paid to Mauser for the use of the design. The only real difference between the Springfield and the Mauser was the magazine cut-off which was a throw back design. When added up millions more Mauser were produced than 03 Springfields. Again the Springfield was and is a grat rifle.

This discussion probably belongs elsewhere. Back to the Civil War, the repeaters of the Civil War changed the concept of fighting and arming amies but not all countries learned the lesson at the same speed. It took the US longer than most countries. As I said earlier, The concept of repeating weapons has lasted until present times."
The .30-03 used the same bullet as the Krag round. The .30-06 improved accuracy at extreme range and the .30-06 also would zip right through a human body. The .45-70 bullet was a better man stopper when it hit a human target as was the .58 Minie bullet. The Mauser was made for many dozens of countries. We did not market the 1903 Springfield and the M-1 Garand changed everything in repeating military firearms. The .50 caliber Barrett sniper rifle is used today for it's very distructive damage on a human target. Even hit in the arm with one causes instant death. Our current M-4 and M-16 is effective due to high speed multiple hits on a target. Just to clarify some lose ends.
 
out of curiosity....how many Spencers and Henry's saw service with the Union forces?
There were approaximately 9,000 to 10,000 Henry rifles used in the Civil War. Not all of these were used by Union troops. However the Confederates had the problem of attaining ammuntion for any Henry rifles they had. More Henry rifles would have been used but due to the manufacturing process they could only make about 200 to 400 per month. The demand far exceeded the supply. The Henry was a good rifle out to 200 to 300 yards but was a great arm to shoot your way out of a difficult situation. That is why cavalry, sharp shooter units as well as scouts and skirmisher favor the Henry when they could get one. This is one reason why Wilder's Brigades scouts chose the Henry rifle even though they knew the rest of the brigade would be getting Spencer rifles. In fact it is estimated that Wilder's Brigade had between 100 and 150 Henry rifles in their ranks along with their Spencer rifles. The Henry was a very sturdy rifle and rarely got out of action. In fact there are very few if any reports during the war of Henry rifles being out of action due to breakage or porblems. Its biggest problem may have been its open magazine which was redesigned after the Civil War. With that said the open magazine did not cause any great problems. Check the link out for preceived problems or potential problems of the Henry rifle: http://44henryrifle.webs.com/problemsofhenryrifles.htm

Concerning the Spencer rifle about the same number as Henry rifles were used, about 12,000 for the Spencer rifle. The rifle had a 30 inch barrel and was unsuited for cavalry even though Custer used the rifle since the carbine was not produced until late 1863. For the Spencer carbine with its 22 inch barrel over 45,000 of these were used and replace the Sharps carbine by many of the cavalry units by the end of the war. The Spencer was a good little carbine but had the problem of being difficult to load on horse back. The magazine follower/tube/spring had to be removed to load the Spencer which meant you had to hold on to it while reloading, dropping it could be a problem. The Spencers could be produced at a much faster rate since it was a simplier design and used many existing parts from the Sharps. It also had a limited range of 200-300 yards for effective hits.

There has been great debates as to which repeating rifle of the Civil War is better, the Henry or the Spencer. It depends on the perspective in which you look at the term "better". Having more shots is always an advantage as well as the easy of loading. Both had about the same effective range. The unfortunate thing is that the midrange trajectory at long range limts both weapons as well as most all black powder rounds. For example the midrange trajectory of a .45-70 at 500 yards is over 25 feet. It makes shooting at longer ranges like shooting a mortar. As a scout mostly operating at less than 200 yards and needing to shoot my way out of a situation where rapid fire would be important I would take the Henry rifle. The Henry rifle could be fired at a rate of around 30 rounds per minute where a Spencer was limited to around 14 per minute. A good video on shooting blanks in a Spencer Rifle check out the link:

For a good read on how the Henry rifle was actually used in the Civil War check out the following link:
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/civilwarusage.htm
 
One has to keep in mind that Logistics in the 19th Century were pretty crude. The ONLY way supplies could be moved from the Rail Head to the army was via horse or mule drawn wagons. If I recall correctly in the Overland Campaign of 1864 Grant's supply line of wagons was over 15 (?) miles long.

In addition, most of the roads these wagons had to travel over were dirt roads that turned into quagmires with every hard rain. Another problem-there weren't that many roads back then!

Would the Yankee Army been better off if every soldier had been armed with a Spencer or Henry? Probably...but the logistics of supplying the additional amounts of ammunition that rapid fire repeaters required would have been well nigh, almost, impossible.
 
One has to keep in mind that Logistics in the 19th Century were pretty crude. The ONLY way supplies could be moved from the Rail Head to the army was via horse or mule drawn wagons. If I recall correctly in the Overland Campaign of 1864 Grant's supply line of wagons was over 15 (?) miles long.

In addition, most of the roads these wagons had to travel over were dirt roads that turned into quagmires with every hard rain. Another problem-there weren't that many roads back then!

Would the Yankee Army been better off if every soldier had been armed with a Spencer or Henry? Probably...but the logistics of supplying the additional amounts of ammunition that rapid fire repeaters required would have been well nigh, almost, impossible.

That is a very good question. However it kind of depends on if we are looking are this as a "what if" situation in which everyone Union soldier had a Henry or a Spencer or do we look at the reality of what happened in the Civil War. Concerning the "what if" part, if every soldier in the Union army had a repeating rifle one would think that the ammunition companies would have been producing plenty of ammunition. The next problem would have been to get it to the troops. While roads were not good large amounts of supplies could be brought close to the troops by either railroad or ships. With the kind of firepower being leveled at the rebs the war would have been over quickly or at least a year or 2 sooner. Therefore not as much ammunition would have been needed. At least that is one view of the "what if".

The reality of the war was there was only about 10,000 Henry repeating rifles used in the Civil War. I do know at least the Western army with Sherman around Atlanta, his "March to the Sea" and for the rest of the war ammunition was not a problem for the units armed with the Henry repeating rifle. Case in point, the 7th Illinois Infantry were armed with Henry rifles at Allattoona Pass. Frank Orcutt fired over 400 rounds by himself and the regiment fired over 31,000 rounds of ammunition in about 5 hours of fighting, no shortage there. In the fighting around Resaca the WSS or 66th Illinois Infantry were in several fights and even involved in the recapture of DeGrass's battery. They had plenty of ammunition to repulse one CS attack and then march 2 miles to retake the battery without any resupply problems. Also of interest was Special Field Order No. 26 dated Dec 7, 1864 which stated "Each brigade will take five ordnance wagons loaded with caliber .58, and for each regiment armed with Henry rifles one wagon load of that kind of ammunition will be taken. By order of Brig. General John M. Crose" One wagon load of ammuniton per regiment is a lot of ammunition. How many 2000 round cases of Henry ammunitition could fit in a wagon, I would guess several(10, 20 or more) holding several thousands rounds of ammunition. All during the war Sherman's Henry armed regiments had no problem of ammuniton, at least that they wrote about anyway. Each man also carried around 150 to 200 rounds of ammunition on their person. Also contrary to belief by some, Henry armed men did not just blast away burning through their ammuntion. They did turn it on when the targets of opportunity were in their front.

I am sure there are some examples where units did require ammunition and had to wait but were resupplied in a timely manner. The government purchased over 4,000,000 Henry cartridges and I think around 58,000,000 Spencer cartridges. I have not done the amount of research on the Spencer as I have for the Henry so without looking more into it I would think that the Spencer rifles and carbines in use did not suffer from lack of ammuntion. The Confederates on the other hand always had a problem of ammunition for their captured repeaters.

The bottom line is that for most units, not all, ammunition was not a problem for repeater armed troops.
 
There were approaximately 9,000 to 10,000 Henry rifles used in the Civil War. Not all of these were used by Union troops. However the Confederates had the problem of attaining ammuntion for any Henry rifles they had. More Henry rifles would have been used but due to the manufacturing process they could only make about 200 to 400 per month. The demand far exceeded the supply. The Henry was a good rifle out to 200 to 300 yards but was a great arm to shoot your way out of a difficult situation. That is why cavalry, sharp shooter units as well as scouts and skirmisher favor the Henry when they could get one. This is one reason why Wilder's Brigades scouts chose the Henry rifle even though they knew the rest of the brigade would be getting Spencer rifles. In fact it is estimated that Wilder's Brigade had between 100 and 150 Henry rifles in their ranks along with their Spencer rifles. The Henry was a very sturdy rifle and rarely got out of action. In fact there are very few if any reports during the war of Henry rifles being out of action due to breakage or porblems. Its biggest problem may have been its open magazine which was redesigned after the Civil War. With that said the open magazine did not cause any great problems. Check the link out for preceived problems or potential problems of the Henry rifle: http://44henryrifle.webs.com/problemsofhenryrifles.htm

Concerning the Spencer rifle about the same number as Henry rifles were used, about 12,000 for the Spencer rifle. The rifle had a 30 inch barrel and was unsuited for cavalry even though Custer used the rifle since the carbine was not produced until late 1863. For the Spencer carbine with its 22 inch barrel over 45,000 of these were used and replace the Sharps carbine by many of the cavalry units by the end of the war. The Spencer was a good little carbine but had the problem of being difficult to load on horse back. The magazine follower/tube/spring had to be removed to load the Spencer which meant you had to hold on to it while reloading, dropping it could be a problem. The Spencers could be produced at a much faster rate since it was a simplier design and used many existing parts from the Sharps. It also had a limited range of 200-300 yards for effective hits.

There has been great debates as to which repeating rifle of the Civil War is better, the Henry or the Spencer. It depends on the perspective in which you look at the term "better". Having more shots is always an advantage as well as the easy of loading. Both had about the same effective range. The unfortunate thing is that the midrange trajectory at long range limts both weapons as well as most all black powder rounds. For example the midrange trajectory of a .45-70 at 500 yards is over 25 feet. It makes shooting at longer ranges like shooting a mortar. As a scout mostly operating at less than 200 yards and needing to shoot my way out of a situation where rapid fire would be important I would take the Henry rifle. The Henry rifle could be fired at a rate of around 30 rounds per minute where a Spencer was limited to around 14 per minute. A good video on shooting blanks in a Spencer Rifle check out the link:

For a good read on how the Henry rifle was actually used in the Civil War check out the following link:
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/civilwarusage.htm

But regardless of that isn't the Spencer a better rifle for infantry? I really do not know enough of the weapons of the time but it just "feels" right.

I have to ask, which would YOU have wanted in your company?
 
Would the Yankee Army been better off if every soldier had been armed with a Spencer or Henry? Probably...but the logistics of supplying the additional amounts of ammunition that rapid fire repeaters required would have been well nigh, almost, impossible.

No, I think not. Yes, you can shoot faster but you kill more too. Remember, battles are won or lost in the minds of men and if you see your unit ripped to shreds before you can even shoot back you would break. The South was not made of super men, just men.
 
That is a very good question. However it kind of depends on if we are looking are this as a "what if" situation in which everyone Union soldier had a Henry or a Spencer or do we look at the reality of what happened in the Civil War. Concerning the "what if" part, if every soldier in the Union army had a repeating rifle one would think that the ammunition companies would have been producing plenty of ammunition. The next problem would have been to get it to the troops. While roads were not good large amounts of supplies could be brought close to the troops by either railroad or ships. With the kind of firepower being leveled at the rebs the war would have been over quickly or at least a year or 2 sooner. Therefore not as much ammunition would have been needed. At least that is one view of the "what if".

The reality of the war was there was only about 10,000 Henry repeating rifles used in the Civil War. I do know at least the Western army with Sherman around Atlanta, his "March to the Sea" and for the rest of the war ammunition was not a problem for the units armed with the Henry repeating rifle. Case in point, the 7th Illinois Infantry were armed with Henry rifles at Allattoona Pass. Frank Orcutt fired over 400 rounds by himself and the regiment fired over 31,000 rounds of ammunition in about 5 hours of fighting, no shortage there. In the fighting around Resaca the WSS or 66th Illinois Infantry were in several fights and even involved in the recapture of DeGrass's battery. They had plenty of ammunition to repulse one CS attack and then march 2 miles to retake the battery without any resupply problems. Also of interest was Special Field Order No. 26 dated Dec 7, 1864 which stated "Each brigade will take five ordnance wagons loaded with caliber .58, and for each regiment armed with Henry rifles one wagon load of that kind of ammunition will be taken. By order of Brig. General John M. Crose" One wagon load of ammuniton per regiment is a lot of ammunition. How many 2000 round cases of Henry ammunitition could fit in a wagon, I would guess several(10, 20 or more) holding several thousands rounds of ammunition. All during the war Sherman's Henry armed regiments had no problem of ammuniton, at least that they wrote about anyway. Each man also carried around 150 to 200 rounds of ammunition on their person. Also contrary to belief by some, Henry armed men did not just blast away burning through their ammuntion. They did turn it on when the targets of opportunity were in their front.

I am sure there are some examples where units did require ammunition and had to wait but were resupplied in a timely manner. The government purchased over 4,000,000 Henry cartridges and I think around 58,000,000 Spencer cartridges. I have not do the amount of research on the Spencer as I have for the Henry so without looking more into it I would think that the Spencer rifles and carbines in use did not suffer from lack of ammuntion. The Confederates on the other hand always had a problem of ammunition for their captured repeaters.

The bottom line is that for most units, not all, ammunition was not a problem for repeater armed troops.

Ok, I have said this before but where the ^^^^ do you guys get this info????? I love it.
 
But regardless of that isn't the Spencer a better rifle for infantry? I really do not know enough of the weapons of the time but it just "feels" right.

I have to ask, which would YOU have wanted in your company?

No the Spencer is not a better rifle for the infantry. I have shot thousands of rounds in both the Henry rifle and the Spencer Rifle and Carbine. If my life was on the line and I had the choice of a Henry or a Spencer, without a doubt the Henry rifle would be a far better choice. I know others may not agree but I have shot both since I got my first Henry and Spencer back in 1979, reproduction Henry and original Spencer.

I think this question was best answered by Wilder's Brigade. His first choice was for the Henry rifle but for most of the men they had to settle for the Spencer rifle, an excellent second choice. However for the scouts of Wilder's Brigade and a few other lucky soldiers a few of the Henry repeating rifles were available. A much faster follow-up shot can be done with a Henry. Yes, a Henry repeating rifle is my choice. It is a very robust, ruggedly built rifle that was accuracte at all engageable ranges. 17 shots for the Henry and only 8 for a Spencer. Seems like a "No Brainer" to me.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top