Repeaters

Repeaters would have been used more often by cavalry than infantry but some infantry regiments managed to have one of their companies armed with repeaters. The only regiments armed with henry repeaters I can name right now are the 12th Kentucky, 65th Illinois, 51st Illinois, and the 65th Indiana who I know all had some of their men equipped with henry repeaters at the Battle of Franklin. Each had one or two companies armed with henry repeaters and used them to good effect at Franklin.

I love that you guys can pull info like thatt out. It is a pleasure to talk to people that know what the hell they are saying. Respect.
 
I know Wilder's Brigade was armed with Spencer's and a few Henry's. Did they or any other regiment using them ever have issues being resupplied with ammo? At Chickamauga they were a huge help to the Union forces in the Vinniard Field area. One soldier of the 72nd Indiana Mounted Infantry stated that they used the rifles for all they were worth and the Confederates just got mowed down. Captured Confederates there asked them what the hell they were using. If the North could have ever got the capacity to mass produce the rifles and ammo the war would have been over a lot quicker.
 
The 7th Illinois Infantry in particular used their Henry Rifles to devestating effect at Atlanta and again at Allatoona. I can think of few battles where the Henry may have been the game changer but Allatoona fits that bill.

The 7th Illinois VI was deployed on the western side of the field in the rifle pits and were pushed back into the works early in the fight. As the Confederate Missouri Brigade charged over the abatais they charged into the face of a single Napolean double shotted w/ canister at every discharge, Springfiled rifle muskets and the boys of the 7th w/ their Henry Rifles. As they surged over the works of Rowetts Redoubt they were met w/ the massed fired of between 50-100 Henry Rifles of the 7th Illinois. That stopped them in their tracks and gained enough time for that Napolean to be manhandled about 250 yards, up hill, into the star fort where it would continue its devestating fire until it ran out of cannister & shell where they resorted to firing bags of brass buttons.

Allatoona Pass was a supply depot so small arms ammunition wasn't an issue, arty ammo was for the US. The CS ended their assault because, or so Genl French said, because he was running low on ammo. Judging by the devestation wrought upon the CS forces by long range fire from the 4th MN VI on the east side of the field... I call BS.
 
But as someone on the sharp end you get ****** when you find out there was something out there that could have saved lives and you never got it because it was not cost effective.
It has little to do with cost, and I have been on the "sharp end of it" too believe me. The issues are paramount as I stated above. You cannot safely overhaul an entire system with which you fight a war, while you are fighting a war. You risk the total collapse of said system and the inability of it to accomplish its original task. Could it have been done, probably but the Union/Confederate commands didn't want to try as their supply lines were already tenuous enough in many places.
Amateurs study tactics, professionals study logistics.
That a good rule of thumb, but the real gold is in studying how both of those topics fit together and understanding the planning process, and failure points in that process, which go into planning a major campaign. The 6 P's have saved many a commander in my observation (Prior Planning Prevents **** Poor Performance).
 
Don't forget the Colt 5-shot revolving rifles. A few units used the Colts to good effect, such as the 21st OH Infantry at Chickamauga. http://chickamaugablog.wordpress.com/2010/01/17/the-21st-ohio-and-the-colt-rifle/

My ancestor's unit, 37th IL Infantry, was able to issue Colt repeaters to the flank companies (A & K). The unit was sponsored by the wife of Gen John Fremont, who arranged (paid for?) the weapons.
 
1bc.png
1bd.png
 
While searching around I found a great site on the henry's usage during the war with a lot of individual accounts and things from individuals who had the advantage of a henry.
http://44henryrifle.webs.com/civilwarusage.htm

The 64th Illinois Infantry also known as Yates' Sharpshooters were armed in part with Henry rifles. While serving with General William Sherman in his march to the sea and then up through the Carolinas Captain Joseph Reynolds wrote letters back home to his relatives in Illinois. In a letter dated January 28, 1865 Captain Reynolds writes about an incident that happened while the 64th Infantry was camped near Pocotatigo, SC. Captain Reynolds writes in the first part of the letter that Lt. Colonel Manning had written from New York stating that he would be returning by next week with his rifles, meaning more Henry rifles. The weather for the past week had been very rainy so the army was unable to move. Finally the army began to move and drove the enemy back across the Saskehatchie River. Reynolds writes that fourteen men armed with Henry rifles crossed the river in boats and were able to close within fifty feet of the rebel fort. Here he was able to capture a rebel artillery captain and two of his men. He even states that troops in any number would not have been able to cross since the river had been "so much overflowed". Reynolds raiding party made it back to their own lines with their prisoners about midnight having to wade water part of the way. The fourteen men with their Henry Repeating rifles were chosen for this mission because of their superior fire power that they could bring on target if it was needed. A larger body of men armed with muzzle loaders would more than likely been discovered by the enemy. For most of the Carolina campaign
Reynolds was the commanding officer of the 64th Illinois Infantry or as he usually referred to it, Yates' Sharpshooters. He was promoted to major and by wars end Lt. Colonel. Upon his mustering out he was given the brevet rank of brigadier general. The 64th
Illinois were used as skirmishers for most of the war usually out in front of the rest of the division or at its flanks. (41)
It seems that Illinois troops saw the value of a repeating rifle more so than soldiers from other states. Illinois troops accounted for more purchases of Henry Repeating rifles than any of the other state. Other Illinois infantry regiment that purchased the Henry Repeating rifle includes the following: 7th, 11th, 16th, 23rd, 39th, 51st, 64, 66th, 68th, 73rd, 80th, 85th, 86th, 96th, 100th, 105th, and the 115th.
The 66th Illinois Veteran Volunteer Infantry also known as the Western Sharp Shooters purchased Henry rifles. Most of their Henry rifles were delivered while the WSS were at Corinth, Mississippi at Camp Davies with delivery taking place a few at a time starting as early as September of 1863 and continuing into 1864 until the regiment had over 200 Henry Repeating rifles in their ranks. Those armed with Henry rifles, early on, were chosen for "Special Duty" as is documented in Lorenzo Barker's history of the Western Sharpshooters.
"December 16th members of the Sixty-six and Company D began to re-enlist for the war in the Veteran service, and on December 23rd fully 500 men had re-enlisted and were mustered in as Veterans by Captain T. D. Mitchell, United States Mustering Officer, of the Second Brigade. Previous to this time the greater portion of Company D and the Regiment, had discarded their "target rifles" and purchased the celebrated "Henry Rifle," or seventeen shooter, at their own expense, which cost the men $50 each, the men owning their guns, the Government furnishing the cartridges. On January, 1864, the Company and Regiment left Pulaski, and marched via Petersburg and Lynnville to Columbia, Tennessee. ...On January 22nd we received four months pay and $100 Veteran bounty. ....Company D and the Sixty-six Illinois, Western Sharpshooters, had the honor on the 9th of May(1864), of opening the fighting of the Army of the Tennessee in this campaign(Atlanta), at Ball's Knob, Snake Creek Gap and Resaca, Ga., unaided and almost unsupported of driving General Wheeler's cavalry and brigade of rebel infantry through Snake Creek Gap, and holding until night the heights of Resaca. In this engagement is where Company D's repeating rifles were used to good effect. On this campaign to Atlanta, Company D was under fire for one hundred and twenty days, and participated in not less that ten or fifteen pitched battles, and skirmishes innumerable, the Regiment losing 225 officers and men killed and wounded, Company D losing one officer killed, George M. Baldwin, two officers wounded, R. J. Williamson, one of whom died of his wounds, Captain John H. Andrews, and eight or ten men killed and wounded. Among the regimental officers, mortally wounded was Colonel P. E. Burke, and severely wounded was Major A. K. Campbell." - Lorenzo Barker's history of the Western Sharpshooters

The men of the 66th Illinois no sooner get their Henry rifles and they are thrown in the thick of things many times fighting their own way into and out of battles, coming out as the victors. Barker also writes of a couple men that are taken prisoner but before surrendering they destroy their Henry rifles to prevent their capture and use by the Rebels. "Orderly Sergeant Albert C. Thompson, and John Randal, while in action at the battle of Dallas, Ga., May 27, 1864, were taken prisoner. The Company was drawn up in line of battle, and had advanced, when Thompson and Randall dropped into a rebel rifle pit for protection. About that time the command was given to fall back. The "boys" did not hear the command, but stuck to their rifle pits, and worked their seventeen shooters for all they were worth against a large force of rebels who were advancing upon them, and ordering them to surrender, which they were forced to, but not until they had used up their last cartridge, and bent the barrels and broken the locks of their seventeen shooters when they surrendered to a mad lot of fellows, who discovered the fact that there were only two "Yank" soldiers, who had caused ten or twelve of their men to "bite the dust." They were taken to the Rebel General Pat Claybourne's headquarters, who was very mad at them for not surrendering instead of holding out to the last against such odds as was opposed to them, and then had to eventually surrender. They were pushed back to the rear of the Confederate Army to Atlanta, Macon, Milledgeville, Ga., and at last into that "hell hole," Andersonville prison pen, where for months and months they were subjected to the horrors of a living death, until they were finally exchanged, near the close of the war."
 
The Colt revolving rifle, when loaded properly, was not prone to chain fire as the myth supports. In properly trained hands, it was an effective repeater that was generally liked by the men who used them in place of a rifle musket.

Another thing the Colt Revolving Rifle had going for it was that it was extremely forgiving of ammo... at Chickamauga members of the 21st Ohio were loading assorted .44 pistol & .52 sharps carbine ammo into some and had no issue making the lead head down range if they hit anything w/ that is another matter.

Post war many were converted into shotguns and were well liked for the ready firepower.
 
I think I read somewhere here on the forum that the Colt shooters learned to hold their left hands under the cylinder and not on the forestock due to tiny slivers of lead sometimes shooting out the gap between the cylinder and the barrel (forcing cone) and possibly into the shooter's forearm. I imagine if you were shooting off-sized loads that this would be more of a concern.
 
The hard truth for some, perhaps many, to accept that the United States has rarely been prepared for war in their history. The U.S. went through the entire history of the 19th century, basically armed with a single shot rifle.
Late in century, the U.S. went late to the 30-40 Krag, a rather poor rifle compared to the Mauser rifle used by the Spanish in the Spanish American war. It usually it is a waste of a year and more, before they started getting properly prepared.
In the Spanish American war, American soldiers had to be held in the rear, because they were using obsolete single shot rifles that fired tell tale black powder. Due to a president, who had been at San Juan Hill, the Krag got quickly replaced by the Springfield '06. Even the experience of the Civil War was of little help.
 
The hard truth for some, perhaps many, to accept that the United States has rarely been prepared for war in their history. The U.S. went through the entire history of the 19th century, basically armed with a single shot rifle.
Late in century, the U.S. went late to the 30-40 Krag, a rather poor rifle compared to the Mauser rifle used by the Spanish in the Spanish American war. It usually it is a waste of a year and more, before they started getting properly prepared.
In the Spanish American war, American soldiers had to be held in the rear, because they were using obsolete single shot rifles that fired tell tale black powder. Due to a president, who had been at San Juan Hill, the Krag got quickly replaced by the Springfield '06. Even the experience of the Civil War was of little help.

That's pretty much the way of it for most countries, unless they're planning to start a war.

The tales of the Spanish being better armed than US troops is only partly true. They also had blackpowder arms, Rem Rolling Blocks in .43 Spanish in particular.

The Brits adopted the Lee Enfield prior to 1900 and kept it well into the 50's. I've always been amused that the first Brit designed rifle or Inf small arm adopted by the brits after the P53 was the Sten Gun. The Martini Henry, designed by an American, the Lee Enfield designed by an American, The FAL a by product of a John Browning design & FN. It wasn't until the SA-80 there was a home grown Brit design... and the soldiers of the Brit Army are owed a HUGE apology for that circle jerk piece of junk.

The Russians fielded the Mosin Nagant from 1898 till replaced by the AK. Always adopting weapons almost too simple to screw up and so reliable & effective as to be legend.

French various servicable bolt action rifles ending w/ the excellent MAS 36 until replaced by the MAS 49 in 1949.

It was the US that was the first to adopt a semi auto rifle for mass issue to its military in the M1 Garand and then the M1 Carbine. Unprepared for the start of a war, but always prepared to end it w/out crying to anyone else to do the lions share of the fighting. The M16 had teething troubles but has evolved into, arguably, the most accurate off the rack main battle rifle in the world.

Holding on to arms well past the time when something better or more effective is around is not reserved for the US or for the modern era.
 
Something more than 100,000 IIRC. W/ deliveries from the spring of 64, about half coming in 65. A more precise number can be had in Coates & Thomas An Introduction to Civil War Small Arms.

12,472 rifles were manufactured until July 1863, when the line switched to carbines. From 1860 to 1866 a total of 45,785 carbines were manufactured, mostly late in the war. Upto 1st August 1864 the US had received:

20,182 Spencer Carbines
11,470 Spencer Rifles
2,000 Henry Rifles
(OR ser 3, vol 4, pg 593)
 
The Krag was not a poor rifle compared to the Spanish Mauser. It was a smooth and finely finished rifle using the .30-40 Krag round which is equal to the .303 British. Teddy was overly pleased with the Krag and it's main short coming was the reloading method. The Mauser used the stripper clip for a slightly faster reload. Lastest tests prove that the Krag was only a couple of seconds behind in the reload. The Krag's bolt could be manipulated faster than the Mauser due to it's glass smooth action. San Juan Hill was won mainly by the use of the Gatlin gun and Colt's Model 1895 machine guns. The Infantry units at Cuba were equiped mainly with the trapdoor Springfield. The Krag quickly replaced the trapdoor and went on to the Philippines and the Boxer Rebellion. "Civilize 'em with a Krag!":thumbsup:
 
12,472 rifles were manufactured until July 1863, when the line switched to carbines. From 1860 to 1866 a total of 45,785 carbines were manufactured, mostly late in the war. Upto 1st August 1864 the US had received:

20,182 Spencer Carbines
11,470 Spencer Rifles
2,000 Henry Rifles
(OR ser 3, vol 4, pg 593)
Thanks for that, don't have my references handy.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top