The 114th Pennsylvania -- Part 2
As the Zouaves crossed the Emmitsburg Road, Bucklyn's battery immediately limbered up and made for the rear. Bucklyn himself would receive "a painful wound while endeavoring to take from the field a cassion, some of the horses of which had been killed."
The 57th Pennsylvania seems to have advanced across the Emmitsburg Road slightly before the Zouaves did. In his official report, Captain Bowen wrote that as they crossed the road, he "attempted to form a line with the Fifty-seventh Pennsylvania Volunteers, who were already there," but that he was "only partially successful" due to the heavy firing they were already receiving form the direction of the Peach Orchard. Private William M. Boggs of company F recalled going "out in advance of our line to an old chimney that stood in the rear of the brick [Sherfy] house." There he and a companion saw "a general officer heading the first line to the attack and we distinctly saw him fall." Boggs believed the officer was Barksdale himself, but he was mistaken; Barksdale would be mortally wounded later that evening as his Mississippian surged toward Cemetery Ridge.
Givin was kneeling between the Sherfy house and barn when Lieutenant-Colonel Cavada came up and knelt beside him. Cavada asked if the enemy was coming. Givin replied, "Bet your life they are!"
The Mississippians advanced to within 100 yards of the Sherfy farm, reaching a rail fence and opening a devastating fire. Captain Lamar of McLaws' staff, watching the Mississippians advance, "was anxious to see how they would get over and around [the fence]. When they reached it, the fence disappeared as if by magic, and the slaughter of the 'red breeched Zouaves' on the other side was terrible!" he recalled. Givin remembered, "The leaden bullets flew thick and fast about us as the men fell about me." As Joseph Beaumant fell mortally wounded nearby, he cried out: "Give it to them boys! We have them on our own ground."
Givin later wrote: "The rebels advanced in two lines and in good order, until they reached the barn, where our boys met them. Then began a desperate conflict, men on both sides clubbing each other with their muskets." He would later state:
"How long we fought here, I cannot tell. In battle a person has no real conception of time. We crossed the road and I remember myself standing in the path leading to the house directing some of the men what to do. Of course, all was excitement. I remember that in many cases the fighting was hand-to-hand. It was a desperate battle. Men never fought with such determination as did our little band."
Not far from Givin, Sergeant Joseph DeHaven, "a brave soldier and a true patriot," fell dead with a bullet through the heart, thus fulfilling his morning prophecy. Givin would return to the scene on July 4: "I sat down and cut his name on a shingle, and put it at his grave, and sent word to his sorrowing wife." DeHaven's body would later be disinterred and reburied in Manayunk.
To their left, Graham's line began to fall apart. The 17th Mississippi was heading directly toward the weakest part of Graham's line – the right angle in the line near the Wentz house, at the intersection of the Emmitsburg and Millerstown roads. They struck the 68th Pennsylvania full-force on their right flank, exploiting the gap between the 68th and 114th. Within 15 minutes, the 21st Mississippi would overwhelm the Union positions in the Peach Orchard. The overextended nature of Sickles' advanced line, the salient nature of the defensive position in the Peach Orchard, and the lack of supports were now coming to haunt the Third Corps soldiers fighting along the Emmitsburg Road.
With the defensive position in the Peach Orchard crumbling, the 17th Mississippi began to flank the left of the 114th's line while the 13th Mississippi, with Barksdale riding at its front, pounded their front. As a member of the 13th Mississippi recalled, "Scarcely a minute and we were at the barn and scaling the fences at the lane and right across and in among the enemy, literally running over them." Soldiers in the 18th Mississippi "breasted a hot fire from a large brick barn" as the Zouaves had converted the Sherfy barn into a fortress in an attempt to hold back the Mississippians. Major G. B. Gerald of the 18th Mississippi remembered: "I was on the left of the regiment and the colonel and lieutenant colonel were somewhat to my right and partially protected by other buildings, and I with most of the regiment was directly in front of the barn…. I called to the men that the barn must be captured and to follow me and I would open the door. They followed me with a rush and I forced the door open, and within less than two minutes we had killed, wounded or captured every man in the barn."
"Soon it became apparent that it was impossible that we should be able to hold our ground against such overwhelming numbers," Bowen recalled. In his official report, Bowen wrote, "…the enemy had already advanced so quickly and in such force as to gain the road, and, pouring a murderous fire on our flank, threw the left wing of the regiment on to the right in much confusion." "The boys were falling all around me," Givin remembered. "I was almost beside myself as I beheld my comrades' vain efforts to rally." It was a futile attempt, and the Pennsylvanians were compelled to fall back, "although very reluctantly." As Givin recalled: "The line – if such a confused mass could be called a line, when, without a head, some in the house, some in the yard, some back of the barn – the regiment was fighting, had fallen back to the road. The guard was in advance of the colors, defending them to their utmost. The enemy was working around to the Emmettsburg [sic] road and were flanking the left of the line at the peach orchard."
The 114th's colors were posted just to the south of the Sherfy house. Color-Sergeant Benjamin Baylitts carried the U.S. flag, while Cpl. Michael Cannon carried the state flag. During the course of the fighting, Cannon was wounded, and the state flag was picked up and carried through the rest of the battle by Cpl. Barry Hall. Baylitts carried the national flag safely through the battle. Sgt. H.H. Snyder, also of the color guard, was standing to Corporal Kenderdine when he saw a Mississippian taking aim from the corner of the barn. The southerner fired and the twenty-three year-old Kenderdine fell seriously wounded through the buttocks. Snyder returned fire but missed; the Mississippian fell moments later, "apparently dead." Kenderdine "was left lying in the road close to where the monument now is," Givin recalled. He "called to one of his comrades, but he had gone. Sergeant Snyder answered for him, and bidding him good-bye, retreated with the rest." The young corporal lay in agony until the morning of July 4, when his comrades returned to the Peach Orchard. Givin saw Kenderdine as he has being carried away on a stretcher and wrote: "He looked badly and was suffering much from his wound. His clothing was torn, and he seemed to have no care taken of him since the battle, near two days before. I asked him if he was wounded badly. He said, "Oh yes; I am very badly wounded." That was all he said; for they were carrying him off, and I was busy with my awful duties [burying the dead]; but the look he gave me I will never forget, it was so sad."
The Mississippians continued to press the Pennsylvanians as they withdrew from the Sherfy buildings. As Givin remembered: "All was confusion now. The enemy was swarming around the house and in front of the Zouaves; two of their cannon were run into the road and were raking our troops with an enfilading fire, and the last of them were retreating….This was about 6 o'clock.
The Confederate guns were firing double grape and canister with devastating effect. "I saw it would not be wise for us to remain and told the men to retreat slowly," Givin recalled. Captain Bowen reported: "I attempted to rally the regiment across the road, but could not succeed in doing so, the enemy advancing so rapidly and my men falling in such numbers as to prevent my succeeding in doing so. I succeeded, however, in rallying a number around the colors, and brought them off…."
Bowen recognized the danger the Zouaves were in – they were about to be cut off and captured. First Lieutenant Aaron K. Dunkle, commanding Company H, and Second Lieutenant Harry Rulon of Company B were both captured at this point, along with several others. "Only one avenue of escape was open to us," Bowen related, "and that was up the Emmitsburg road."
Bowen succeeded in saving the colors and the remnants of his command by ordering the flag to withdraw a short distance and then rallying the Zouaves in the new position: "Ordering the colors to go in that direction [up the Emmitsburg Road] with the assistance of Captain [Henry M.] Eddy [commanding Company D] and the few remaining officers rallying the few men that were left, we made a stand, pouring a volley into the enemy, who was almost upon us, and then retreated up the road, many falling by the way, for it was far more dangerous to life to retreat up the road and to our rear, than it was to remain to be captured." A bullet slammed into Eddy's chest, but it was a spent ball, and the captain was assisted to the rear. Once the Mississippians had nearly reached the new position, the colors were ordered to fall back further.
With Mississippians swarming on their left flank and in their rear, the 57th Pennsylvania was also forced to fall back. Capt. Alanson Nelson, seeing the red breeches give way, turned to his commander, Col. Peter Sides, and said: "It looks as if we'll soon have to move out of here, or be captured." "Yes, I think we will go now," Sides replied. As the regiment pulled back, Nelson took a detail to warn those soldiers who were still inside the Sherfy house. Moments later, Sides was wounded as members of the 18th Mississippi swarmed around the house. Nelson was able to warn some of the men; those who did not get the word in time were captured.
With Graham's line along the Emmitsburg Road collapsing, the 73rd New York was ordered to rush to the scene. Captain Frank Moran of the 73rd remembered hurrying "at double-quick to a point directly in rear of the barn where the 114th Pennsylvania (Collis' Zouaves) though fearfully exposed on that deadly crest, were bravely disputing the ground with the Mississippi Brigade, which came swarming up the slope, yelling like devils and led by Barksdale." Although they were taking heavy casualties, they could not return fire at first for fear of hitting the Zouaves who were still in front of them. Moran recalled: "At last the 114th, with a parting volley in the faces of the Mississippians, made room for us and our regiment sent a volley at the enemy who fell in scores among the dead and wounded Pennsylvanians. They staggered under our fresh fire, but waved their flags, cheered and returned our volley, seeing their supports close at hand. Their advance, however, was checked at the barn, as our men continued to load and fire with rapidity and coolness, but our thin line on the left could be seen melting away through the smoke and our wounded in hundreds went streaming back over the Emmitsburg road, and riderless horses went dashing among them in bewilderment and fright. At last an order came to fall back, and our line retired towards the pike, firing as it went."Moran remembered a "tornado of bullets and shells" as the regiment withdrew.
On the brigade's right flank, the 105th Pennsylvania was also desperately clinging to its position on the west side of the Emmitsburg Road. "I noticed the regiments on my immediate left (One hundred and fourteenth and Fifty-seventh Pennsylvania Volunteers) cluster in groups behind the brick house and adjacent out-buildings," Col. Calvin A. Craig of the 105th reported. "A few moments later the One hundred and fourteenth fell to the rear, and the Fifty-seventh very soon followed, leaving my left flank entirely unprotected." Craig redeployed his "Wildcats" across the road where they, along with some members of the 57th, "checked the advancing rebels for a few minutes." But Barksdale's Mississippians advance was overwhelming, and soon Graham's line along the Emmitsburg Road was in full retreat.
The Zouaves continued to retreat up the Emmitsburg Road. As they reached the Klingle house and crossed to the west side of the road, Givin found Cavada sitting on the back step. "Are you wounded?" Givin asked. "No, but very weak," Cavada replied. Givin offered to assist the colonel off the field, but Cavada declined, telling the lieutenant to save himself. Bowen also saw Cavada seated on the step and inquired if he was wounded. "He replied that he was not, but utterly exhausted," Bowen wrote in his official report. "I begged him to make an effort to come on, as the enemy was only a few yards from him and advancing rapidly. He replied that he could not, and I left him there…" Shortly thereafter, Cavada was captured, and Bowen assumed command of the regiment.
In all, the Zouaves had stood their ground around the Sherfy farm for about twenty minutes.
As Captain Frank Fix lay wounded in the road, a Confederate battery was coming up the road at a gallop. Seeing the dead and wounded piled up in the road bed, the Confederate captain ordered his battery to halt. The Confederates lifted the dead to one side of the road and carried the wounded into the cellar of the house and gave them water, before continuing on their mission.
Givin recorded one curious incident that testified to the ferocity of the fighting near the Sherfy farm. On the evening of July 3, Givin led a detail of men who "reported to a captain in the 26th Pennsylvania, who had charge of a burial squad." Givin and the captain were talking near the Emmitsburg Road when the captain bent over and picked up an object. It "proved to be two musket balls – one a Union, the other a rebel," Givin remembered. "They had met in mid-air and melded together. We could distinguish them by the rings, the former having three, the latter two."
The Zouaves had used the Sherfy barn as cover during the battle, and many wounded men sought shelter inside. On July 3, an exploding shell caused the barn to catch fire. As it burned, many of the wounded men were trapped inside. "Those of the wounded not able to help themselves were destroyed by flames, which were in a moment spread through the straw and dry material of the building," one soldier wrote two days later. "The crisped and blackened limbs, heads and other portions of bodies lying half consumed among the heaps of ruins and ashes, made up one of the most ghastly pictures ever witnessed, even on the field of battle." Although most of the bodies were burned beyond recognition, their regimental affiliation could be surmised from the charred fragments of the distinctive Zouave uniform. Those bodies were recovered and are now buried in the National Cemetery marked, "Unknown Zouave."
A few days later, another passing soldier recorded: "But what a sene was before us or how would a man that had not been seared by the horrors of War have felt to look upon the sene. There is where the hottest of the fight took place and the Barn was fill of dead and wounded which had been set on fire and burned and there was the skelitons of men some all burned up other half burned some with only their clothes burned off. On the same ground that our Regt occupied was where the 114th Penn Zouaves red Breeches as we call them fought. There were as many as 30 or 40 lay dead there of that Regt."
A Gettysburg correspondent reported on July 20 that in the barn "and around the haystacks were about twenty wounded Philadelphia Zouaves, who perished in the conflagration."
Members of the band had been detailed for hospital duty during the battle; on July 5, the band rejoined the regiment. "There was enough to sink our spirits very low on reporting to our regiment," Rauscher reported, "for this formerly strong and splendid body of men could only show about sixty muskets." He continued:
"We resumed our place at the head of the line, but it seemed more like heading a funeral procession, and marched directly over the hotly contested field, on which there remained abundant evidences of the carnage; dead horses were scattered over the vast expanse, and here and there were the bodies of men, some in fragments, the stench adding sickness to the repulsive scene. We marched over the blood-christened Peach Orchard, or what was such on the evening of July I. It was then an orchard of beautiful trees, fresh in foliage; but now not a single tree was left on the whole tract of land; all were cut down by the iron and leaden hail belched forth from artillery and musketry; only a field of stumps from twelve to eighteen inches high remained. If any locality on the battle-field deserves the name of "bloody angle," this is the spot."
Today, a Collis Zouave stands in the yard of the Sherfy house, forever eyeing the advance of the Mississippians. He is in the act of loading his rifle, ramming the shot home. He appears steady and unconcerned; an air of determination is set upon his face. At the monument's dedication on November 11, 1888, Captain Givin remarked: "Standing as it does looking to our left which is being driven back, is preparing to give them another shot. This may appear to be the production of the imagination of the artist's brain, but it not. It is a reality as some of you standing here can testify. Men of the One hundred and fourteenth stood as this man stands, contesting the ground inch by inch. The artist has given to him an expression of determination. He is fighting freedom's battle, the enemy must be driven back. Long marches, short rations, little rest or sleep weaves into the knitted brow a look of firmness. The compressed lips could they be opened would say emphatically, "the enemy must be driven back."
In recalling the events of July 2, 1863, Lieutenant-Colonel Bowen would state "that there it nobly stood its ground, bravely endeavored to the last extremity to hold it against the assault of overwhelming numbers, did all that brave men and well-tried soldiers could do to defend a position in which it was placed, and was driven from it only when more than half its number were killed or wounded, overwhelmed by vastly superior numbers, surrounded on three sides and its commander wounded and a prisoner." Remembering his fallen friends, Givin would state: "Comrades, this ground upon which we stand is consecrated ground, made so by the blood of our own comrades, being so freely shed upon it."
* Edward J. Hagerty,
Collis' Zouaves:
The 114th Pennsylvania Volunteers in the Civil War.
* Alexander H. Givin: "Memoirs of Alexander Wallace Given."
*Oliver Wilson Davis,
Sketch of Frederic Fernandez Cavada, A Native of Cuba.
* Rauscher, "Music on the March."
* Thaddeus S. Kenderdine,
A California Tramp.
* Pennsylvania at Gettysburg
*O. R.