Rangers vs. LBG's

infomanpa

1st Lieutenant
Joined
Feb 18, 2017
Location
Pennsylvania
When visiting Gettysburg during the anniversary days, you can choose to attend programs or take battle walks with a Licensed Battlefield Guide or National Park Service ranger. How different are the expertise and knowledge levels between the two? I've heard both and they both seem extremely knowledgeable. Since attending ranger programs are free, is it worth the extra cost of a LCB? If so, why?
 
A long time ago I went on a ranger talk at Gettysburg concerning Little Round Top. He gave an excellent talk concerning the July 2nd fight. He was very thorough and I enjoyed it immensely.
 
When visiting Gettysburg during the anniversary days, you can choose to attend programs or take battle walks with a Licensed Battlefield Guide or National Park Service ranger. How different are the expertise and knowledge levels between the two? I've heard both and they both seem extremely knowledgeable. Since attending ranger programs are free, is it worth the extra cost of a LCB? If so, why?
It was worth the cost to me. Private guided tour. No large groups - just Mike and me and Howard Wallace. It was worth every penny. The best part is, the LBG will work to your schedule and take you to see the things you want to see. Ranger programs are great, too. But you're following their schedule and agenda and there may be fifty people or more on your tour.
 
Correct that LBG's do private tours, unlike the rangers. I am relatively familiar with what is required to be a LBG, but what is required to become a ranger? Do they also take tests, etc.?
 
LBGs are worth the cost if you want a custom tour. With this being said, do research to find out which one would best meet your purposes.

http://work.chron.com/apply-civil-war-battlefield-park-ranger-29269.html


How to Apply to Be a Civil War Battlefield Park Ranger
by Christopher Raines
78459594.jpg



The U.S. National Park Service preserves the sites of important Civil War battles to tell the story of a divisive period in American history. As a park ranger at one of these battlefields, you wear the hat of historian, teacher, and tour guide to students and other visitors. You also enforce rules and regulations that seek to safeguard the cleanliness and artifacts of these solemn places and ensure they are treated with respect.

Know Civil War History?

Your application should highlight teaching and research, especially in the Civil War or the battlefield where you want to work. Build your knowledge of and experience with battlefields such as Gettysburg by participating in summer internships. If you rely on your academic background, a bachelor's degree in American history with courses or a concentration in the Civil War could bolster your resume. Park rangers also present Civil War lectures in the the Department of Interior's Park Ranger speakers' series, so some public speaking classes or experience, along with knowledge of the Civil War, could help.

Able to Enforce Rules?

Battlefield park rangers, especially those employed full time, enforce rules and regulations against alcohol use on park grounds, hunting for relics, and taking artifacts and other cultural and natural resources from the battlefields, so rangers generally must obtain some enforcement experience. Law enforcement officers in the Park Service must pass drug tests, physical fitness tests, which include a 1.5 mile run and an agility run, and criminal background and security checks. Your physical endurance will also come in handy because leading tours of battlefields requires constant walking.

Can You Drive Safely?

Present any records, such as your past and present driver's licenses, that show you have held and currently hold a license. You will likely have to submit your driving record and a completed GSA Form 3607, which you can download from the U.S. General Services Administration website. Form 3607 inquires about your accidents, tickets, convictions for driving while impaired with alcohol or other substances and any instances when you have used a government vehicle without authorization.

Applying for Federal Jobs

To apply for federal government jobs, create an account at the USA Jobs website. During the process, enter information about yourself and fashion a resume. Type in "park ranger" and follow the specific instructions for applying for particular park ranger positions. Depending on the job, you might need to complete a questionnaire and furnish your college transcripts. To obtain a veteran's preference in federal jobs, submit a copy of a form showing your honorable discharge from the military discharge letter, known as a DD-214; an application for a veteran's preference, called an SF-15; and Veterans Administration preference letter. Go to the National Archives website to get your military discharge record and the U.S. Office of Personnel Management site to download the veteran's preference application. Some jobs may be available only to applicants who have lost jobs in the federal government.
 
I always go on the NPS battle walks because they're free. They are highly knowledgeable and well trained.

There are pluses and minuses to both.

The minus for the NPS walks is that you have to do the subject they're doing, and if you want something different you're out of luck.
With an LBG you can get the tour you want.

The NPS tours are free, but you have to pay for the LBG tours.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top