Doc_Ralph
First Sergeant
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2023
Please pardon -in advance - this seemingly obscure and perhaps even frivolous query. And if you would indulge - this old cannoneer - in something that I can't explain why it bugs me - I will forever be in your debt.
What is it with USA infantry pulling pianos out into the street and having a "gay" old time (in the sense that that word used to mean)?
First Fredericksburg comes to mind. After Barksdales snipers had harassed the pontoon engineers and were dislodged by USA, the town was trashed. A piano was found and hauled out and etc. And IMHO grandmas good china was broken. Maryes Heights brooded down on the festivities in town.
Dunno? I have heard rumors of other pianos being played or trashed but these may just be mean and vile rumors about USA comportment. I am open minded enough to purge them if they are squashed as idle slander. I am discounting Sherman's March through Georgia and the Carolina; . as this is IMHO an example of "total war" which had USA War Department approval and legalization of harsh policy. Maybe for another discussion if I can find my class notes for references.
I opine that looting and high jinx have been with all armies since the dawn of time. Perhaps, it was in "the fog of war" I reality do like Burnside's but believe that ransacking the town was unfortunate. Essentially Grandmas china.
I don't know why it is in my craw and perhaps someone can enlighten me: Is there something in CW USA regs about searching premises for snipers) (Barksdale) and/or acquisition of contraband (loot) in a town?
C'mon? A piano in the street? Reality?
OTC
Spotsy CH
What is it with USA infantry pulling pianos out into the street and having a "gay" old time (in the sense that that word used to mean)?
First Fredericksburg comes to mind. After Barksdales snipers had harassed the pontoon engineers and were dislodged by USA, the town was trashed. A piano was found and hauled out and etc. And IMHO grandmas good china was broken. Maryes Heights brooded down on the festivities in town.
Dunno? I have heard rumors of other pianos being played or trashed but these may just be mean and vile rumors about USA comportment. I am open minded enough to purge them if they are squashed as idle slander. I am discounting Sherman's March through Georgia and the Carolina; . as this is IMHO an example of "total war" which had USA War Department approval and legalization of harsh policy. Maybe for another discussion if I can find my class notes for references.
I opine that looting and high jinx have been with all armies since the dawn of time. Perhaps, it was in "the fog of war" I reality do like Burnside's but believe that ransacking the town was unfortunate. Essentially Grandmas china.
I don't know why it is in my craw and perhaps someone can enlighten me: Is there something in CW USA regs about searching premises for snipers) (Barksdale) and/or acquisition of contraband (loot) in a town?
C'mon? A piano in the street? Reality?
OTC
Spotsy CH