Lead the Way (#5)

1SGDan

Major
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Location
New Hampshire
You and two others escape a Confederate prison camp. Barely avoiding recapture by on several occasions you manage to steal a flat boat and begin a move downstream in hopes that you will eventually manage to link with Union blockaders in the Gulf. You eventually have to pull to shore to search for food. You land but are almost immediately discovered by a small group of slaves. These slaves could face serious consequences if they conceal your presence. What do you do?
 
I pull a thorn from the first slave's foot during a full eclipse of the sun... sorry, wrong movie.

Seriously, I'm in bad shape and I have to get food either by a continued escape or by recapture. I approach the colored gentlepersons and politely ask for assistance, reasoning that the decision to risk danger in helping me is their decision to make - not mine.
 
I pull a thorn from the first slave's foot during a full eclipse of the sun... sorry, wrong movie.

Seriously, I'm in bad shape and I have to get food either by a continued escape or by recapture. I approach the colored gentlepersons and politely ask for assistance, reasoning that the decision to risk danger in helping me is their decision to make - not mine.

Me too, let them decide, and if I end up getting recaptured, don't mention them either way.
 
That happened to the two Andrews raiders who elected to head to the Gulf of Mexico after escaping a Confederate prison. It would be a tough go, deep in the heart of enemy country and a hostile around every bend of the river. Getting food would be a priority and fresh water that was drinkable. The Englishman Wood recognized clams in the river banks - which his friend didn't know - and so they kept from starving that way. But when slaves found them - they immediately told them who they were and the slaves quite cheerfully kept them hidden. There was no option but to trust the slaves, and they were not betrayed.
 
What do *we* do? We give them part of the story, but not the whole thing; certainly not our complete plan of escape. They don't need to know, and what they don't know can't be gotten out of them if it should be discovered that they've had contact with us; it's better for both them and us. If they can point us to something that can help us, or at least tell us what the local threats might be, well and good; otherwise, do our best to step lightly and lively and keep on the move.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ole
I would say no, the more in your party the increase chance of getting spotted and captured.
Makes sense if I was traveling by land, but remember - we are on a flatboat - only stopping for food. They know the environment and more about food sources than me for that area. Putting everyone on the flatboat does two things. It ensures that a potentially "faithful" slave won't report our presence. Secondly, my chances of capture are in no way increased as we are all on an object floating down the river. The slaves may have knowledge of choke points on the river or places to avoid and wait for darkness to pass.

Potentially, it increases my odds.
 
Well going by flat boat isn't going to really help in the first place. There is no way to conceal oneself when you're floating down a river. If you strip down so residents cannot identify you as Union soldiers, then maybe. Having a group of slaves with you means more likely stops for food (more food needed now) as well as just the appearance of blacks floating down the river, which would probably try to duck out of sight if they see whites on the shores would only increase suspicion, IMO.

I think it would be best to not necessarily identify myself as a soldier (unless clothing is a dead give-away), ask for food and hightail it out of the area.
 
The actual story:

One of the men captured at the Tuscumbia Bridge was Henry Feuerbach. Following his capture at the bridge Feuerbach was taken to Mobile, Alabama and eventually to a Macon, Georgia POW camp.

For four months Feuerbach survived on a daily ration of "corn meal, about a pint cupful, a piece of bacon as large as your hand and full of maggots" before he and two fellow prisoners; Robert Timmons of the 34th Indiana and Alvin Bacon of the 14th Illinois; decided that "to stay longer in prison would only reduce our physical strength." On 10 September 1862 the three men used a small stream that served as a latrine to make their escape. By creeping into the weeds on the banks of the stream the men avoided detection by guards until a severe thunderstorm covered their move down the stream and out of the camp. After a series of close calls with local Confederate forces, water moccasins, and slave laborers the men found themselves in a stolen flat boat on the Ocmulgee River. This vessel was "swapped" for a canoe and the journey continued until the men were befriended by a group of slaves that housed them and fed them with smuggled bread and chicken. The slaves also gave them valuable information about a series of rapids on the river and how they could avoid them. Successfully running the rapids and overcoming a fear of alligators brought the men near Hawkinsville. They landed their boat to search for food and found an abandoned plantation where they were again aided by a few elderly slaves.

The trek continued down the river to Darien where they landed near a saw mill to search for food. As soon as they left the boat they were challenged by a pair of "partisan rangers". Determined not to be taken prisoner again, Feuerbach and Timmons convinced the two that they were members of the 12th Georgia Infantry home on furlough and getting in some fishing. So convincing was their story that they were left under guard of one man while the other returned to find an officer to decide the matter. The lone guard became enthralled with Feuerbach's fictional tales of battles and glory and let his attention drift from the task at hand. With time running out before the return of the others Feuerbach, in a bold move, made a desperate lunge forward and snatched the man's weapon from him. The man was quickly subdued and the canoe was freed with a hatchet and the men rowed off before the reinforcements arrived.

The incredible journey took another bizarre turn when they knocked on a door in a seemingly deserted village. The surprise answer came from a man that originally hailed from New York and harbored Unionist sentiments. The lucky encounter gave the escapees another healthy bit of intelligence on the surrounding area, the efforts to capture them, and a good meal. The good hearted Unionist encouraged the men to continue on their way as soon as possible. An overnight cruising down the river with the current brought them to the mouth of the river. In another stroke of good luck just as the sun was rising and threatened to reveal the men they bumped into the Union vessel Western World on blockade duty near the lighthouse. The men were taken aboard and their freedom secured.

The three men returned to their units after a brief stay at New York to recover their strength. Timmons survived the war and returned to the water as a boatman on the upper Mississippi River. Bacon was killed at Vicksburg on 27 May 1863. Feuerbach also survived the war and returned to St Louis for a post war career as a contractor.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top