How practical were 2 pound cannons?

I was not climbing over fence into Belfoured's patch. I have a memorized history of the 1841 model history presentation for visitors.
The interesting point raised by yours is that it illustrates the US commitment primarily to iron post-AWI due in large part to the fact that at the time the US had a much greater supply of iron ore than copper or tin and "brass"/bronze cost 5-6 times more. As time went on, in the late 1830's there was an internal "war" in Ordnance that was resolved when the Board recommended bronze in early 1841 and Poinsett approved.
 
The interesting point raised by yours is that it illustrates the US commitment primarily to iron post-AWI due in large part to the fact that at the time the US had a much greater supply of iron ore than copper or tin and "brass"/bronze cost 5-6 times more. As time went on, in the late 1830's there was an internal "war" in Ordnance that was resolved when the Board recommended bronze in early 1841 and Poinsett approved.

I wonder if the choice of bronze coincided with the discovery of the vast copper deposit in Upper Michigan?

People had known about the Kennesaw deposit for 3,000 years. However, it wasn't exploited industrially until the 1830-40's.

Up until that point, like Roman times, copper came from Britain. The metallurgical deposit in the U.P. was like nothing the world had ever seen.

Makes me wonder if the availability of a ready supply of copper was a factor in choosing bronze guns?

Read more here.


Llink

 
This discussion of three pounders does beg the evolution leading to the Hotchkiss designed in 1875.
View attachment 581586

Ideally suited to the highly mobile rough terrain of the Indian Wars, the Hotchkiss replaced muzzle loading artillery. For a history read more here.

Link




View attachment 581585
16 ounce shells were in accordance with prohibition on less than 14 ounce exploding ammunition fired at white people… the 19th Century, gotta love it.

Hotchkiss went on to invent a five barrel revolving 37 mm cannon. Unlike the Gatling gun, the single block Hotchkiss design was more robust. I was not satisfied with the links I found. This one provides the basics. Anyone who the a better one please post it. See more here.

Link




Today the 30mm automatic antiaircraft machine gun has been revived for a whole new type of warfare. Read more here.

Link

There are a pair of Hotchkiss revolving cannons in the lobby of the Bradford County Courthouse in Towanda Pennsylvania. If you google it, I'm almost certain there are photos of the guns. They really are impressive.
 
I wonder if the choice of bronze coincided with the discovery of the vast copper deposit in Upper Michigan?

People had known about the Kennesaw deposit for 3,000 years. However, it wasn't exploited industrially until the 1830-40's.

Up until that point, like Roman times, copper came from Britain. The metallurgical deposit in the U.P. was like nothing the world had ever seen.

Makes me wonder if the availability of a ready supply of copper was a factor in choosing bronze guns?

Read more here.


Llink

I've always assumed that the discovery of more copper deposits and the ability to mine them played a role - as did growing dissatisfaction with cast iron. The irony (pun intended) is that advances in rifling and iron manufacture relatively quickly forced a switch back to iron guns - both cast iron (the Parrott tube, with the wrought iron breech wrap) and wrought iron (the 3" Ordnance tube) - so that after 1865 bronze was on its way to becoming a dead letter.
 
I've always assumed that the discovery of more copper deposits and the ability to mine them played a role - as did growing dissatisfaction with cast iron. The irony (pun intended) is that advances in rifling and iron manufacture relatively quickly forced a switch back to iron guns - both cast iron (the Parrott tube, with the wrought iron breech wrap) and wrought iron (the 3" Ordnance tube) - so that after 1865 bronze was on its way to becoming a dead letter.

And then immediately steel breechloaders. No wonder the Parrott's at Ft Sumpter were just dumped out the gun ports.
 
They are in a couple of the references I checked out. That is a singular thing, that is for sure.
Getting a pair of them to display must have been a real score for Bradford County. If you're not familiar with Pennsylvania topography, Bradford County is a very rural, mountainous and poor county. Towanda itself isn't exactly the garden spot of the Western Hemisphere, either. There is a very impressive Civil War monument in front of the courthouse, too.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top