A follow-up: The owner of the antique shop, where I got the cemetery star, did a column in the local paper today featuring the star I bought. She said that in the past, in her group shop, she had never considered they might have been stolen. She actually made a public plea that if anyone has these stars, they can drop them off at her shop - no questions asked - and she will make sure they get to the right person (me actually) so they can be transferred to the appropriate veteran's grave.
I don't know how much good it will actually do or what will come of it, but I'm glad she kept her word about writing about it and trying to stop the collecting of them in our area.
We have so much snow in our area right now. When the snow finally goes and the ground thaws, I'll work with the Department of Public Works in our town and I get the star put on an appropriate grave. I'll load pictures here when the time comes.