Forrest Catharine Forrest?

Joined
Sep 30, 2022
Location
Michigan
Recently I've discovered a claim that Forrest fathered a mulatto child with a slave named Catharine Forrest. I call baloney on the whole thing, but I thought I'd share a blog post I wrote a while back on the subject, and the original article.


 
Recently I've discovered a claim that Forrest fathered a mulatto child with a slave named Catharine Forrest. I call baloney on the whole thing, but I thought I'd share a blog post I wrote a while back on the subject, and the original article.


If such were true (and I'm not saying it didn't happen), I honestly think that would have been a well known fact many decades ago.

" The person propagating this is Sarah Eiland of the Southern Poverty Law Center."

Well ... that's all I needed to read.
 
I found this thread but it is not the one I am remembering.


I'm not very good with the search function.
Maybe someone else will help.
 
I found this thread but it is not the one I am remembering.


I'm not very good with the search function.
Maybe someone else will help.
While doing research on the topic a while back I stumbled across her comments here, which proved quite helpful. The thread isn't about Catharine, but the topic came up somehow. https://civilwartalk.com/threads/bl...-southern-gentleman”.88413/page-8#post-711758
 
Recently I've discovered a claim that Forrest fathered a mulatto child with a slave named Catharine Forrest. I call baloney on the whole thing, but I thought I'd share a blog post I wrote a while back on the subject, and the original article.



This article makes all kinds of assumptions, and offers little to nothing of real evidence to back up the claim. Forrest did indeed buy and sell slaves at his market, that much is certain. But, if you really study the character of Bedford Forrest, it's very doubtful that he had any kind of sexual relations with any of the slaves he bought and sold. Many accounts at the time mention Forrest as being one of the more humane slave traders in the Memphis area - meaning that he consciously tried to keep family units together and would not separate children from their mothers, etc.

One also has to take into account Forrest's adoration of his wife, Mary Ann Montgomery, who was just as headstrong as Bedford and by all accounts an extremely beautiful woman. I have read many times that she was one of the few people that Bedford feared (the other being his younger brother William Hezekiah).

Mary Ann.jpg
 
If such were true (and I'm not saying it didn't happen), I honestly think that would have been a well known fact many decades ago.

" The person propagating this is Sarah Eiland of the Southern Poverty Law Center."

Well ... that's all I needed to read.
It HAS been rumoured for many years that NBF did father a child with Catherine. It would hardly be a surprise given the oft times unsavory relationships owners had with their female slaves, not saying it occurred with NBF but it could have occured.
 
This is the source of the accusation. This was a newspaper article written by a New York newspaper, immediately after the Fort Pillow incident, titled "The Butcher Forrest And His Family". Seems more like a propaganda piece than anything.


View attachment 500083
Wasn't that " Parson" Brownies " Newspaper"? Not at all saying that it's not true but the Radical Republicans in Tennessee went hard against NBF so depending on the source you have take their " reporting" with block not grain but a block of salt.
 
Exactly. The above article also says that Bedford and his brothers whipped multiple slaves until their backs were cut up and the entire surface covered in blisters, and even whipped one man to death. Keep in mind that slaves cost a LOT of money - the equivalent of $40,000 to $50,000 each! I seriously doubt Bedford and his brothers would willingly throw money away like that. Don't get me wrong, slave trading is deplorable, but purely from a business standpoint, beating your slaves to death makes no sense.

Anyway, much about the article are simply gross exaggerations to vilify a General in the Confederate Army, which throws the accusation of Bedford fathering a "mulatto" into serious doubt.
 
Wasn't that " Parson" Brownies " Newspaper"? Not at all saying that it's not true but the Radical Republicans in Tennessee went hard against NBF so depending on the source you have take their " reporting" with block not grain but a block of salt.

Hearts and minds as it were.

Even late into the war, Forrest's command recruited heavily behind federal lines in Tennessee, (even some in Kentucky) etc., and were almost universally supported/supplied by their families....

1709311601488.png

....


1709313337657.png


The Union government of the State of Tennessee understood that Forrest's successes were based principally on continued public support (including cooperation with conscription at times...)

1709311953400.png

1709311993174.png


Anything to potentially erode public support by planting doubts or fears of guilt by association was fair game in the presses.


In June, 1864, General Washburne, USA, commanding at Memphis and no doubt familiar with the common stories, decided to inquire of General Forrest himself to what extent he was engaged in a war of "massacre" etc.

1709312583176.png


....
1709312547314.png


Forrest replied as follows, essentially claiming a continued support by the general public...

1709312630643.png

1709312701161.png

1709312751227.png

1709312827029.png
 
This article makes all kinds of assumptions, and offers little to nothing of real evidence to back up the claim. Forrest did indeed buy and sell slaves at his market, that much is certain. But, if you really study the character of Bedford Forrest, it's very doubtful that he had any kind of sexual relations with any of the slaves he bought and sold. Many accounts at the time mention Forrest as being one of the more humane slave traders in the Memphis area - meaning that he consciously tried to keep family units together and would not separate children from their mothers, etc.

One also has to take into account Forrest's adoration of his wife, Mary Ann Montgomery, who was just as headstrong as Bedford and by all accounts an extremely beautiful woman. I have read many times that she was one of the few people that Bedford feared (the other being his younger brother William Hezekiah).

View attachment 500075
I have a pet theory that Sherman was scared of women as well.
 
Recently I've discovered a claim that Forrest fathered a mulatto child with a slave named Catharine Forrest. I call baloney on the whole thing, but I thought I'd share a blog post I wrote a while back on the subject, and the original article.


I think absent some good luck with DNA, it would be really hard to prove.
 
Exactly. The above article also says that Bedford and his brothers whipped multiple slaves until their backs were cut up and the entire surface covered in blisters, and even whipped one man to death. Keep in mind that slaves cost a LOT of money - the equivalent of $40,000 to $50,000 each! I seriously doubt Bedford and his brothers would willingly throw money away like that. Don't get me wrong, slave trading is deplorable, but purely from a business standpoint, beating your slaves to death makes no sense.

Anyway, much about the article are simply gross exaggerations to vilify a General in the Confederate Army, which throws the accusation of Bedford fathering a "mulatto" into serious doubt.
And particular brother they did that had been wounded during the Mexican War and wasn't capable of doing so.
 
Recently I've discovered a claim that Forrest fathered a mulatto child with a slave named Catharine Forrest. I call baloney on the whole thing, but I thought I'd share a blog post I wrote a while back on the subject, and the original article.


Southern Poverty Law Center. That's all you need to know.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top