Bought a book; found a nice surprise

Joined
Apr 1, 2015
DSCN6386.JPG
Like many on the forum, over the years I have purchased numerous Civil War books. My focus has been on personal accounts and unit histories, and last week I purchased a copy of the History of the 146th New York Volunteers, which formed part of the 5th Corps of the Army of the Potomac, fought on Little Round Top at Gettysburg and was one of Fox's fighting 300 regiments.

Tucked into the front cover of the book were several faded newspaper clippings, and tipped in was a note from the author of the book, dated 1916, to a Mrs. Grindlay presenting the book to her. Judge of my surprise, though, when I found, pasted to the second inside page of the book, an old envelope with a letter inside.

I gently separated the envelope from the page to which it had been pasted, and taking out the letter (which literally looked like it had been written yesterday) found that it was from a captain in the 146th, James Grindlay, dated November 3, 1863, and written to a friend back in his home town of Clayville, New York. Excerpts from the chatty 3+ pg. letter (exactly as he wrote it, except for material in brackets) are below:

Dear Sir: Although you no doubt hear from the Army often through the members of the 117th, I know that some news from this part of it may be acceptable. I will therefore offer no apology for this letter but give you a brief sketch of what the Army of the Potomac has been doing for the last 6 mos. and the part the 146th has taken. We went to Chancellorsville, Va. and were engaged on the first day. We had between 60 and 90 men taken prisoners 4 killed & 6 wounded including Capt. Durkee of Co. "A" who lost an arm. We lay still after that until June 4th when we started on our forced march to Gettysburg, Pa. We suffered while on that march, the heat was intense and marching 30 miles a day under such a sun was no joke. There were many sun struck and here let me say that Genl. Hooker managed us splendidly and outgeneraled Lee at every point as that Genl's report testified. Hooker's transfer of this army from Fredericksburg to Chancellorsville taking a round about road and landing us there before Lee knew anything about it was a splendid performance. . . The Army was handled well at Gettysburg it was a splendid sight. I would not have lost it for anything. Our Regt. lost 24 men, 7 of them from my company. We can see now that a splendid chance to whip the rebels was lost by not attacking them at Williamsport, for we could have punished them severely. I believe Hooker would have fought them. Everyone seems however to have every confidence in Genl. Meade he is a careful Genl. his management of the army while falling back from Culpepper was well planned, for the last 3 weeks we have been changing round, the enemy is yet on this side the river and I think we will fight before long. The army is filling up fast with conscripts and the[y] are generally a good class of men. We have recd. 200 of them. The Draft you see is not such a bad thing after all besides every young man ought to be in the army I think and I hope the Draft will be put through in Jan[uar]y. I sincerely hope that N.Y. decided yes[t]erday to vote to stand side by side with Ohio & Pa by the Government and the Union. Could the Soldiers vote I know it would for Copperheadism find no favor among the Soldiers as the vote of the Ohio Vols show. Strange that Pa should vote for Curtin in direct opposition to "Maj. Genl. McClellan" but they did, by the way a subscription was started here a while ago for McClellan but it didn't work, the fact is that McClellan is forgotten by the Soldiers notwithstanding the assertion of the papers. From all appearances another year will see the present rebellion ended and the states all united and represented in Senate & Congress as before. . .

A quick bit of research on Capt. Grindlay revealed that he eventually rose to command of the 146th, and in several instances during the 1864-65 campaigns commanded his brigade. Grindlay would end the war as a Brevet Brigadier General and would receive the Medal of Honor for his actions at the Battle of Five Forks. All in all a nice, unexpected find!
 

Attachments

  • DSCN6390.JPG
    DSCN6390.JPG
    167.6 KB · Views: 183
  • DSCN6391.JPG
    DSCN6391.JPG
    203.5 KB · Views: 184
  • IMG_4057.JPG
    IMG_4057.JPG
    255.2 KB · Views: 191
  • DSCN6387.JPG
    DSCN6387.JPG
    220.4 KB · Views: 207
View attachment 103748 Like many on the forum, over the years I have purchased numerous Civil War books. My focus has been on personal accounts and unit histories, and last week I purchased a copy of the History of the 146th New York Volunteers, which formed part of the 5th Corps of the Army of the Potomac, fought on Little Round Top at Gettysburg and was one of Fox's fighting 300 regiments.

Tucked into the front cover of the book were several faded newspaper clippings, and tipped in was a note from the author of the book, dated 1916, to a Mrs. Grindlay presenting the book to her. Judge of my surprise, though, when I found, pasted to the second inside page of the book, an old envelope with a letter inside.

I gently separated the envelope from the page to which it had been pasted, and taking out the letter (which literally looked like it had been written yesterday) found that it was from a captain in the 146th, James Grindlay, dated November 3, 1863, and written to a friend back in his home town of Clayville, New York. Excerpts from the chatty 3+ pg. letter (exactly as he wrote it, except for material in brackets) are below:

Dear Sir: Although you no doubt hear from the Army often through the members of the 117th, I know that some news from this part of it may be acceptable. I will therefore offer no apology for this letter but give you a brief sketch of what the Army of the Potomac has been doing for the last 6 mos. and the part the 146th has taken. We went to Chancellorsville, Va. and were engaged on the first day. We had between 60 and 90 men taken prisoners 4 killed & 6 wounded including Capt. Durkee of Co. "A" who lost an arm. We lay still after that until June 4th when we started on our forced march to Gettysburg, Pa. We suffered while on that march, the heat was intense and marching 30 miles a day under such a sun was no joke. There were many sun struck and here let me say that Genl. Hooker managed us splendidly and outgeneraled Lee at every point as that Genl's report testified. Hooker's transfer of this army from Fredericksburg to Chancellorsville taking a round about road and landing us there before Lee knew anything about it was a splendid performance. . . The Army was handled well at Gettysburg it was a splendid sight. I would not have lost it for anything. Our Regt. lost 24 men, 7 of them from my company. We can see now that a splendid chance to whip the rebels was lost by not attacking them at Williamsport, for we could have punished them severely. I believe Hooker would have fought them. Everyone seems however to have every confidence in Genl. Meade he is a careful Genl. his management of the army while falling back from Culpepper was well planned, for the last 3 weeks we have been changing round, the enemy is yet on this side the river and I think we will fight before long. The army is filling up fast with conscripts and the[y] are generally a good class of men. We have recd. 200 of them. The Draft you see is not such a bad thing after all besides every young man ought to be in the army I think and I hope the Draft will be put through in Jan[uar]y. I sincerely hope that N.Y. decided yes[t]erday to vote to stand side by side with Ohio & Pa by the Government and the Union. Could the Soldiers vote I know it would for Copperheadism find no favor among the Soldiers as the vote of the Ohio Vols show. Strange that Pa should vote for Curtin in direct opposition to "Maj. Genl. McClellan" but they did, by the way a subscription was started here a while ago for McClellan but it didn't work, the fact is that McClellan is forgotten by the Soldiers notwithstanding the assertion of the papers. From all appearances another year will see the present rebellion ended and the states all united and represented in Senate & Congress as before. . .

A quick bit of research on Capt. Grindlay revealed that he eventually rose to command of the 146th, and in several instances during the 1864-65 campaigns commanded his brigade. Grindlay would end the war as a Brevet Brigadier General and would receive the Medal of Honor for his actions at the Battle of Five Forks. All in all a nice, unexpected find!
Wow,that is a great find..I am really jealous.congrats.
 
Great find, and very interesting information on the perception of the 1863 draftees from the perspective of a company grade infantry officer - same holds true for the perception of McClellan and the Lincoln Administration.

The 146th was mobilized as a long service regiment in the autumn of 1862, and had a share of veterans, including men who had served in the 5th NY in 1861-62. All in all, probably among the top units of the late 1862 mobilization...

Thanks for sharing your good fortune.
 
Grindlay wrote an article that appears in, Battles and Leaders of the Civil War, 3:315, entitled "The 146th New York at Little Round Top." Grindlay stated that the center of his regiment and the colors were opposite the rock upon which was placed the monument to the 91st Pennsylvania. Grindlay also wrote a historical sketch on his regiment that appears in, New York at Gettysburg, 3:966.
 
Grindlay wrote an article that appears in, Battles and Leaders of the Civil War, 3:315, entitled "The 146th New York at Little Round Top." Grindlay stated that the center of his regiment and the colors were opposite the rock upon which was placed the monument to the 91st Pennsylvania. Grindlay also wrote a historical sketch on his regiment that appears in, New York at Gettysburg, 3:966.
I think I will reread that art of B &L.
 
This is a really great thing to find.
The last thing I found in an old book was a 100 year old dried up carnation. Several, in fact.

The best thing I ever found in an old book was in a used bookshop: inside a copy of John Toland's biography Adolf Hitler was a crisp new-like $50 bill and an empty bank envelope it probably came in. (They weren't together.) I'm sorry to relate that I didn't buy the book but did use my find to purchase others before I left!
 
Grindlay wrote an article that appears in, Battles and Leaders of the Civil War, 3:315, entitled "The 146th New York at Little Round Top." Grindlay stated that the center of his regiment and the colors were opposite the rock upon which was placed the monument to the 91st Pennsylvania. Grindlay also wrote a historical sketch on his regiment that appears in, New York at Gettysburg, 3:966.
Great info Tom. Thanks!
 
This is a really great thing to find.
The last thing I found in an old book was a 100 year old dried up carnation. Several, in fact.
I collect WWII unit histories and have been fortunate to find a decent amount of official papers, docs, etc. tucked into those books; the only other similar find I have had in 30 years of buying CW books was a reunion ribbon for the 1st Maine Cavalry tucked into the pages of their unit history.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top