Avoiding Lincoln's Call. Draft eligibility

DWMack

Cadet
Joined
Dec 1, 2009
Location
Lake Villa, Illinois
I was wondering what reasons, besides age and health, would exclude men from the Union draft? Many of the civil war letters I have read in a family collection are addressed to and from my GGGrandfather's cousin so did not serve as far as I can tell - at least there are no records of him serving; and yet they were the same age. Can anyone offer info?

Thanks,

Dan
 
I could be wrong, but weren't names chosen by lot or something of that sort? If your name was pulled, you had to show up or otherwise get out of it (doesn't sound like he'd be in a category able to claim exemption, though), but if not, well, lucky you.
 
I could be wrong, but weren't names chosen by lot or something of that sort? If your name was pulled, you had to show up or otherwise get out of it (doesn't sound like he'd be in a category able to claim exemption, though), but if not, well, lucky you.


That could be.... I know My GGGrandfather Volunteered and I figured since him and his cousin were so close he would have joined up too.
 
I think Elennsar is right. There was some kind of lottery; i.e., not everyone was selected. Those who were could hire a substitute or apply for an exemption. The amount paid to a substitute was between the draftee and substitute. The $300 was a bounty paid, usually by the states I think, to fill their quotas.

Ole
 
This site gives a good account of the Union Draft in 1862.

"It is possible that the solution hit upon was a general call-up of more men, under the new militia law. On Aug. 4, Lincoln called up 300,000 men for nine months service, on top of the 300,000 he had already requested in July for three years. The militia call-up was General Order No. 94:
Ordered:
I. That a draft of 300,000 militia be immediately called into the service of the United States, to serve for nine months unless sooner discharged. The Secretary of War will assign the quotas to the States and establish regulations for the draft. II. That if any state shall not by the 15th of August furnish its quota of the additional 300,000 volunteers authorized by law, the deficiency of volunteers in that State will also be made up by special draft from the militia. The Secretary of War will establish regulations for this purpose.
Some confusion about this draft may spring from the fact that both the entire call-up of 300,000 militia, and the subsequent filling of the deficiency in that call-up by conscription, are called a "draft." This was not something that had been done in the lifetime of any of the men in the government, and their terminology was not always clear. Yet Lincoln unambiguously writes of "drafting," in reference to the filling of the quotas by conscription, in many places [e.g. letter to George P. Fisher, Sept. 16, 1862; telegram to McClellan, Oct. 27, 1862, etc.]

Like the earlier call, this one was apportioned among the states relative to their populations. But this time, the government said it would draft men into service from any state that did not meet its quota. Specifying that the call-up would be for nine months, and calling the troops "militia," gave it the power to do so.

The War Department order gave each state until Aug. 15 -- a mere two weeks -- to meet its quota or face a draft. Indiana's quota was about 21,000; little Rhode Island's was less than 3,000. New York's quota of almost 60,000 men was the highest. Wisconsin's was just under 12,000. The governor there pleaded for more time, since it was an agricultural state and the fall harvest was approaching, but the War Department only gave him another week, until Aug. 22.

On Aug. 9, the Secretary of War issued General Order 99, detailing how the conscription should be handled. It directed the governors to enroll all able-bodied men age 18 to 45, and the wheels of the draft began to turn.

The process passed down the line, from federal government to states to counties to the smallest unit of local municipality. The legwork was done by the county assessors, the men who usually collected tax data. They copied the names of each eligible man into record books, noting those already in service, and any obvious physical disabilities. The Pennsylvania enrollment officer in one township evidently hadn't appreciated the random nature of the draft, or else couldn't resist adding editorial comments on some of the men he registered -- "Ran and hid, refused to give age;" "Ought to be taken. Bad influence at home or he would volunteer," "Not healthy ('So they say')," "claims weak eyes," "Saucy & loafing about at home," "Make a first-rate soldier, not worth much for anything else," and so forth."

http://www.etymonline.com/cw/draft.htm
 
I think Elennsar is right. There was some kind of lottery; i.e., not everyone was selected. Those who were could hire a substitute or apply for an exemption. The amount paid to a substitute was between the draftee and substitute. The $300 was a bounty paid, usually by the states I think, to fill their quotas.

Ole

Conscription in the US worked pretty much the same until Viet Nam, except for bonuses and substitutes.
Each state was given a quota to be filled by a certain time. The states broke the quota down by county, usually. If volunteers filled the quota then there was no need to conscript anybody at the state or local level. To encourage volunteering, state and local governments offered enlistment bonuses, usually $300 and sometimes $500. Since the alternative was conscription, the bonus program was very sucessful

If the county failed to meet the quota than names were pulled at random from a list of eligible men within the county. By this random, lottery style selection, a person could avoid service by not having his name drawn.

If a man was selected (hence the name selective service) during the Civil War he could hire a substitute for at least $300. However, hiring a substitute could get your name put back into the eligible pool, depending on local rules. Some unlucky men actually hired more than one substitute, who was a bonus man, but paid by private individuals rather than government. Grover Cleveland and Theodore Roosevelt's father both hired substitutes.

There was also a commutation from conscription by paying a $300 fee to the Federal government. This fee exempted men from future conscription and was highly unpopular. It was abolished in 1864,


So conscription was a matter of chance based on how successful the volunteer program worked to meet the manpower quotas.

Certain exemptions were given for clergymen, sole support of a family, people with special skills needed for the war effort. I do not have a list of exempted categories. Joining the militia
was also a way to avoid conscrition. Militia call up during emergencies were usual 90 days or so and seldom involved combat duty. They were often used to relieve full time army units for combat. The 7th Regiment NYSM was called up several times during the war. Bull Run, Gettysburg for duty around Harrisburg, and the NYC draft riots for sure, maybe more times.
Confederate.

The CSA conscription worked along similar quota lines except with few exemptions, most notably owning 20 or more slaves. Chances of being conscripted were much higher in the south and running down draft dodgers was pretty efficient.
 
This site gives a good account of the Union Draft in 1862.

"It is possible that the solution hit upon was a general call-up of more men, under the new militia law. On Aug. 4, Lincoln called up 300,000 men for nine months service, on top of the 300,000 he had already requested in July for three years. The militia call-up was General Order No. 94:
Ordered:
I. That a draft of 300,000 militia be immediately called into the service of the United States, to serve for nine months unless sooner discharged. The Secretary of War will assign the quotas to the States and establish regulations for the draft. II. That if any state shall not by the 15th of August furnish its quota of the additional 300,000 volunteers authorized by law, the deficiency of volunteers in that State will also be made up by special draft from the militia. The Secretary of War will establish regulations for this purpose.
Some confusion about this draft may spring from the fact that both the entire call-up of 300,000 militia, and the subsequent filling of the deficiency in that call-up by conscription, are called a "draft." This was not something that had been done in the lifetime of any of the men in the government, and their terminology was not always clear. Yet Lincoln unambiguously writes of "drafting," in reference to the filling of the quotas by conscription, in many places [e.g. letter to George P. Fisher, Sept. 16, 1862; telegram to McClellan, Oct. 27, 1862, etc.]

Like the earlier call, this one was apportioned among the states relative to their populations. But this time, the government said it would draft men into service from any state that did not meet its quota. Specifying that the call-up would be for nine months, and calling the troops "militia," gave it the power to do so.

The War Department order gave each state until Aug. 15 -- a mere two weeks -- to meet its quota or face a draft. Indiana's quota was about 21,000; little Rhode Island's was less than 3,000. New York's quota of almost 60,000 men was the highest. Wisconsin's was just under 12,000. The governor there pleaded for more time, since it was an agricultural state and the fall harvest was approaching, but the War Department only gave him another week, until Aug. 22.

On Aug. 9, the Secretary of War issued General Order 99, detailing how the conscription should be handled. It directed the governors to enroll all able-bodied men age 18 to 45, and the wheels of the draft began to turn.

The process passed down the line, from federal government to states to counties to the smallest unit of local municipality. The legwork was done by the county assessors, the men who usually collected tax data. They copied the names of each eligible man into record books, noting those already in service, and any obvious physical disabilities. The Pennsylvania enrollment officer in one township evidently hadn't appreciated the random nature of the draft, or else couldn't resist adding editorial comments on some of the men he registered -- "Ran and hid, refused to give age;" "Ought to be taken. Bad influence at home or he would volunteer," "Not healthy ('So they say')," "claims weak eyes," "Saucy & loafing about at home," "Make a first-rate soldier, not worth much for anything else," and so forth."

http://www.etymonline.com/cw/draft.htm


Wow. Thanks for all the work you put into your post. I imagine he missed the draft by luck. Thanks for the info, really helps answer my question.
 
I appreciate everyones response. I've been wondering about that ever since I came across the letters I have. I thought "Why the heck is my GGG and his brother in the service but cousin Justus was still at home"? You guys are great.....:)

Dan
 
Conscription in the Federal Army was not as large in numbers as in later wars. During the Civil War state and local governments treated conscription as a last resort. The bounty system worked well. There were times that a combination of Federal, state, local and even privately raised bounties might amount to $1,000, enough to buy a house. Many jurisdictions never had the need to conscript anybody.

The Union Army was overwhelmingly volunteer. I seem to recall that about 40,000 of the over two million Federal soldiers were draftees.
 
Wow. Thanks for all the work you put into your post. I imagine he missed the draft by luck. Thanks for the info, really helps answer my question.
Actually, I just searched and found the site, read a little, and cut and paste what I thought was relevant to the Union draft.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top