Assassination Sympathizers

NH Civil War Gal

Major
* OFFICIAL *
CWT PRESENTER
Forum Host
Regtl. Quartermaster Antietam 2021
Joined
Feb 5, 2017
I had never seen anything like this before. I'm guessing these men were Copperheads originally.

This is from Robert Gray's FaceBook Civil War Buff's page.

"Here's the complete photograph. The Nashville Press described this image shortly after it was taken on April 15, 1865. "We saw a photograph yesterday of ten men who were arrested at Chattanooga on Sunday last for expressing pleasure at hearing of the death of President Lincoln," reported a correspondent, who added, "Upon the breast of each was a tin plate with the words 'Assassin Sympathizer' painted on it." The men were sentenced to labor on the streets in Chattanooga by day while wearing the placards, and by night they were confined in irons.

The Press also identified the men. They were a mix of soldiers and contract employees. It is unclear if the names listed by the Press match the actual order, left to right, in the photo: Government employees E. Jones, R.C. Jones and James Martin; citizen S. Moxley and blacksmith C.G. Moxley; and 18th Ohio Infantry privates Cyrus Leight, Henry D. Metzer, David Alspaugh and Moses H. Matheny. The soldiers were all late war recruits: Leight, Metzer and Alspaugh were substitutes who mustered into Company K during the last week of March 1865. Matheny mustered into the regiment in February 1864, making him the veteran of the group. The four men eventually received honorable discharges.

They also hailed from the same state as U.S. Congressman Clement Vallandigham, the leader of the Copperhead faction of anti-war Democrats, and a powerful opponent of the Lincoln administration.

A fragmentary period pencil inscription on the back of the mount notes that a lieutenant presented the photograph to a major general.

This most unusual Lincoln assassination image was originally published in the Spring 2015 issue of Military Images magazine.

Albumen by an anonymous photographer. Paul Loane collection."


Photo taken in Chattanooga of men from the 18th Ohio Infantry. They're labeled as "Assassin Sympathizers" for not being distraught Lincoln lovers.


1618529693532.png
 
When not under military control--under usual circumstances--people have the right to poor taste and bad manners. In the environment of the day, it was foolish.

In reading ACW diaries, I came upon an exchange between Joshua Chamberlain (possibly Abner Small) and a local southern lady. When she expressed great happiness at the assassination, he responded that the south was the more vulnerable because of it.
 
Lincoln was not fawned over when he was alive, the way he is today.

"Lincoln had attracted no shortage of bitter enemies, even in the North. Just six months earlier, he had been viewed as a partisan mortal: a much-pilloried politician running in a typically divisive national canvass for a second term as president. "The doom of Lincoln and black republicanism is sealed," railed one of Lincoln's own hometown newspapers after he had been renominated in June 1864. "Corruption and the bayonet are impotent to save them," the Democratic Illinois State Register added. Not even the shock of his assassination could persuade some Northern Democrats that he didn't deserve a tyrant's death.

"They've shot Abe Lincoln," one jubilant Massachusetts Copperhead shouted to his horrified Yankee neighbors when he heard the news. "He's dead and I'm glad he's dead." On the other extreme of the political spectrum, George W. Julian, a Republican congressman from Indiana, acknowledged that his fellow Radicals' "hostility towards Lincoln's policy of conciliation and contempt for his weakness were undisguised; and the universal feeling among radical men here is that his death is a god-send."


https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/what-the-newspapers-said-when-lincoln-was-killed-180954325/
 
I know reading some Southern officers diaries they were quite concerned after hearing about Lincoln's assassination and weren't happy. Doesn't mean they were fawning on him but were genuinely not happy that events had taken that turn AND were worried about what it would mean for the South.

One of the most famous pictures of Lee in a suit and I believe his son standing next to him in a doorway in Richmond shows him looking even more serious and a bit grimmer than usual. He had a telegram in his pocket that Lincoln had been shot. He wasn't happy about it either.
 
I know reading some Southern officers diaries they were quite concerned after hearing about Lincoln's assassination and weren't happy. Doesn't mean they were fawning on him but were genuinely not happy that events had taken that turn AND were worried about what it would mean for the South.

One of the most famous pictures of Lee in a suit and I believe his son standing next to him in a doorway in Richmond shows him looking even more serious and a bit grimmer than usual. He had a telegram in his pocket that Lincoln had been shot. He wasn't happy about it either.
I don't doubt that most people are dismayed by assassination. First, it is an extremely radical and cowardly step and, secondly, there is practical concern about its impact (the old adage about for every action...).
 
Last edited:
He had a telegram in his pocket that Lincoln had been shot. He wasn't happy about it either.
That is just conjecture, He probable wasn't happy about as he knew of the fallout. The South was full "Assignation Sympathizer" IMHO it was Not the way to wage war even though the US has done it on several occasions since then.
 
That is just conjecture, He probable wasn't happy about as he knew of the fallout. The South was full "Assignation Sympathizer" IMHO it was Not the way to wage war even though the US has done it on several occasions since then.
Perhaps he was also dismayed by any precedent of a political end attempted by a so craven an action. He may have killed--but only on the field of battle. Also, the General's attitude after the war was to urge reconciliation; Booth's action was in direct contravention to this.

Unfortunately, several countries have used this mechanism.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top