Can the Union defeat the South after a Trent War?

At any given moment, the British Army had a peacetime strength of around 225,000 men, including 75,000 professionals and 150,000 part-time soldiers.
I have to say that this is actually an incorrect number for 1862. As of 1862 the British army's peacetime strength is indeed about 225,000, but that's all professionals, and the militia (114,000), yeomanry (for which I have no figures, though the number is small) and volunteers (163,000 in 1863) amount to about another 280,000 part-time soldiers.

In the event of a crisis, the militia and volunteers can be activated; some of the militia will garrison certain posts in the Empire, freeing up British regulars for the crisis response, while other militia and volunteers will serve for home defence. During a crisis these militia units in particular could be continuously embodied for several years, and also provided a useful source of partially-trained battle casualty replacements which could be further trained by depot companies in Britain (attached to the battalions overseas) and then forwarded once trained.



While the British and Canadians will probably not launch their own invasions, they will not easily be attacked.
Here there's a caveat - if the Union posts 100,000 troops along the mutual border, then I don't think the British and Canadians will invade the Union. If the Union posts 10,000 men along the mutual border, however, I think under those circumstances the British would invade simply to cause further pain to the Union and accelerate the possibility of the Union giving up and thus a peace acceptable to the British.


But the real problem is British naval power. Merely breaching the blockade transforms the war in favor of the Confederacy. But it must also be said the Union mobilization was always relatively halfhearted - fighting with one hand behind its back, as Shelby Foote put it. It would be interesting if the threat posed by Britain prompts an earlier and more intense escalation of Northern mobilization, though the Union is not to be favored against Britain in an industrial contest for a couple more decades by this point.

During the first half of 1862 specifically, which is the Trent period, Union mobilization goes from being at the maximum possible for practical reasons (i.e. as of January 1862 the Union has every man it can arm in service) to, due to a shutdown in recruitment and massive imports of weapons and Marshall and Mills iron (for the production of rifle barrels at Springfield) being somewhat under-mobilized compared to what is possible. In the event of a British cancellation of imports and a British blockade, though, I don't think the Union can actually mobilize any more troops than it did historically because it simply will not be able to give them firearms.
 
I'm new to the thread but after reading the Wrapped in Flames timeline I think that even though Britain wouldn't officially recognize the Confederacy, they would certainly help them because it would hinder the Union war effort.

Breaking the blockade allowing the Confederates to get goods shipped out to European ports and resources like uniforms, guns, ammo which would put the CSA in a much better supplied military position than it ever was historically and would stabilize their currency, Britain laying down their own blockade of Northern ports and using their navy to even threaten the West Coast pulls Federal troops away from places like New Mexico and the Indian Territory to fight in other theaters. It would be a much bigger headache for Lincoln, and consequently with all three sides well supplied, a much bloodier conflict than the historic Civil War.

With US aid to the Federalists in Mexico badly hindered, Benito Juarez is toast and the French take Mexico.
 
I'm new to the thread but after reading the Wrapped in Flames timeline I think that even though Britain wouldn't officially recognize the Confederacy, they would certainly help them because it would hinder the Union war effort.

Breaking the blockade allowing the Confederates to get goods shipped out to European ports and resources like uniforms, guns, ammo which would put the CSA in a much better supplied military position than it ever was historically and would stabilize their currency, Britain laying down their own blockade of Northern ports and using their navy to even threaten the West Coast pulls Federal troops away from places like New Mexico and the Indian Territory to fight in other theaters. It would be a much bigger headache for Lincoln, and consequently with all three sides well supplied, a much bloodier conflict than the historic Civil War.

With US aid to the Federalists in Mexico badly hindered, Benito Juarez is toast and the French take Mexico.
Well, I think it's dumb for the CSSA not to receive British recognition yet Britain goes to war with the union. After all for years Britain had diplomatic relationship with a slave hole in countries in the world to name them specifically Brazil, the Spanish empire , and of course, the United States before the Civil War, and technically during the Civil War, as the union still held Kentucky, Missouri, and Delaware in Maryland . As for the confederacy being recognized Britain needs the south cotton just as it was prior to the war. They're already at war with the Yankees.
 
Well, I think it's dumb for the CSSA not to receive British recognition yet Britain goes to war with the union. After all for years Britain had diplomatic relationship with a slave hole in countries in the world to name them specifically Brazil, the Spanish empire , and of course, the United States before the Civil War, and technically during the Civil War, as the union still held Kentucky, Missouri, and Delaware in Maryland . As for the confederacy being recognized Britain needs the south cotton just as it was prior to the war. They're already at war with the Yankees.
The thing about recognition is that it's not a silver bullet - had the British recognized the Confederacy historically, the only way that would have actually made the US position worse is if the US did as they threatened and declared war over it. Conversely, recognition is for Britain usually recognition of an evident fact; if the South already has a convincing case to be made that it is independent and has established that independence, that is when it would get recognized.

...we should be perfectly justified in acknowledging the independence of the Southern States, provided only that that independence had been—in the words which he used—"firmly and permanently established."... The South American Republics were not acknowledged till a great many years after they had practically achieved and obtained their independence. There was a war between them and Spain—separated by the wide Atlantic from her revolted subjects—and unable with any degree of power to re-establish her authority over them; and, I believe, it was nearly fifteen years—certainly a great many years—before their independence was acknowledged. (Lord Palmerston, 18 July 1862)

Popular clamour in Britain might accelerate that, but it would have to be a people-first thing I think.
 
Many people exaggerate the size of the Union army by counting its total manpower pass-through to the single-moment strength of the British Army.

At any given moment, the British Army had a peacetime strength of around 225,000 men, including 75,000 professionals and 150,000 part-time soldiers.

While it sometimes said that the Union Army had "2.5 million men," this is all men who ever passed under arms, not peak strength. The peak strength of the Union Army was around 700,000, or roughly 3.5x the peacetime strength of the British Army - and this was in 1863. In early and mid-1862, the Union Army was considerably smaller, and toward the latter end of that spectrum, the Confederate army was not too terribly behind on numbers compared to the rest of the war.

While the British and Canadians will probably not launch their own invasions, they will not easily be attacked.

But the real problem is British naval power. Merely breaching the blockade transforms the war in favor of the Confederacy. But it must also be said the Union mobilization was always relatively halfhearted - fighting with one hand behind its back, as Shelby Foote put it. It would be interesting if the threat posed by Britain prompts an earlier and more intense escalation of Northern mobilization, though the Union is not to be favored against Britain in an industrial contest for a couple more decades by this point.

They can probably get a lot more manpower - if only because a war with Britain would have a huge impact on the US economy. Between the damage to international and coastal shipping and the economic impact of having markedly greater difficult getting funds for the war.

However how do they train, supply and equip those men as well as provide leadership for them. Also as Saphroneth has pointed out how would they pay them? A large mob that is weakly armed and trained can be a bigger burden to its own side than to its opponents.
 
Well, I think it's dumb for the CSSA not to receive British recognition yet Britain goes to war with the union. After all for years Britain had diplomatic relationship with a slave hole in countries in the world to name them specifically Brazil, the Spanish empire , and of course, the United States before the Civil War, and technically during the Civil War, as the union still held Kentucky, Missouri, and Delaware in Maryland . As for the confederacy being recognized Britain needs the south cotton just as it was prior to the war. They're already at war with the Yankees.

Why would Britain recognise it? The UK is going to war with the union because of the latter's actions, which are both illegal and set a dangerous precedent for British merchant shipping. The union did this because of their war with the south but that's a side issue for the UK. It wants this problem corrected - i.e. release of the hostages seized, an apology and assurance that the union won't do something like this again. If it gets that then its conditions are met and the war could end quickly.

Recognising the south would be an issues that would be likely to prolong and enlarge the war with the union which is something the UK doesn't want. War is expensive and complex and even with relatively few poorer people - who provide the bulk of the soldiers - having any real say what's seen as an unnecessary war - at least once Britain's aim has been met - would become unpopular.

Yes Britain wants cotton from the south for the cotton industry. It also wants food and the ability to trade with the north at the same time. Peace with the union will resume the 2nd while sinking a good proportion of the union fleet and as a result also the removal of southern enclaves would make trade with the south marketed easier - at least for a year or two.

Also was the south still seeking a cotton famine at this point? If so the big issue is the unwillingness of the south to trade rather than the opposition of the union. Britain, like other countries affected have already made clear they won't be threatened like that into recognising the south so nothing to be gained and some costs to doing so. The south needs the trade more than Britain and other big cotton processors do.

Coupled with the fact that while both union and south are nations with slavery and Lincoln has repeated stated he would be happy to maintain slavery many people see the rebellion as a reaction to a perceived threat to slavery in the US. This is already am emotive issue in parts of the UK as well as elsewhere. Hence recognising the south without a clear basis for doing so would cause internal concerns about a war as it allows people to present it as a war against slavery.

Hence there are no reasons why Britain would give formal recognition to the south and at least two why its in British interests NOT to do so.
 
I actually don't know that a Trent war would be bloodier than the historical Civil War. Put simply I think the Union is in such a bad position so quickly that it's at least quite likely that the war is over quite fast.

I would agree if it leads to a general peace fairly quickly. If the union accepts British demands - which is implicit in the thread title - i.e. that the civil war continues after this then its likely to be longer and bloodier because there is a net shift in balance between north and south. The former would still have greater resources than the south but would have lost a fair bit of ground - ships lost, resultant weakening of any blockade of the south after peace with the UK, economic damage from the war with Britain etc.

If the union as a result fairly quickly decides that it can't force the south back into the union and a peace with the south follows fairly quickly after one with the UK then again it would be less costly for both sides. However given the desire to maintain the south and also issues like losing control of the lower Mississippi - plus that a government that has lost a war with the UK is likely to feel the need to demonstrate it can win against the south I suspect this would be unlikely.

If the war goes on until say a Nov 64 election and then peace is agreed afterward the total damage to both sides is likely to be similar although with less in the south. If it goes on beyond that, regardless of who actually wins, I think it would be bloodier.
 
I'm new to the thread but after reading the Wrapped in Flames timeline I think that even though Britain wouldn't officially recognize the Confederacy, they would certainly help them because it would hinder the Union war effort.

Breaking the blockade allowing the Confederates to get goods shipped out to European ports and resources like uniforms, guns, ammo which would put the CSA in a much better supplied military position than it ever was historically and would stabilize their currency, Britain laying down their own blockade of Northern ports and using their navy to even threaten the West Coast pulls Federal troops away from places like New Mexico and the Indian Territory to fight in other theaters. It would be a much bigger headache for Lincoln, and consequently with all three sides well supplied, a much bloodier conflict than the historic Civil War.

With US aid to the Federalists in Mexico badly hindered, Benito Juarez is toast and the French take Mexico.

I think, as I've said to Saphroneth it depends on what happens after peace between the UK and the union as to how bloody and destructive it is.

In terms of Mexico its difficult to say. Juarez's position is weaker definitely but he's still fighting against what is seen as a foreign invasion to impose an Austrian emperor on Mexico. Maximilian's position is also weakened because while he is fairly liberal his primary supporters are far more reactionary and the French simply want control of Mexico's resources. As such there's a significant divide inside the imperial camp. Also even if say the US or an independent CSA are too weak to support Juarez after their war ends how long can France maintain an expensive and increasingly unpopular [in France] war, especially with what is likely to be happening to their east with Bismarck building a Prussia and then German empire.
 
I would agree if it leads to a general peace fairly quickly. If the union accepts British demands - which is implicit in the thread title - i.e. that the civil war continues after this then its likely to be longer and bloodier because there is a net shift in balance between north and south. The former would still have greater resources than the south but would have lost a fair bit of ground - ships lost, resultant weakening of any blockade of the south after peace with the UK, economic damage from the war with Britain etc.
What I mean here is that I think the Union actually might be outright beatable. The historical point of greatest relative strength for the South is the summer and autumn of 1862, to which the Union responds with a mass mobilization of 300,000 more men; if a Trent war goes on for six months, not only is the Union weaker in absolute terms along the Union/Confederate front line during this Confederate strength peak, but the Confederates are also stronger in absolute terms due to both fewer troops to the Confederate coastline and better arms supplies for the Confederates.

Thing is, a peace with Britain means the Union can move its existing troops back south to the front line, but it can't mobilize 300,000 more troops straight off the bat. It would have to import the guns and gun material to do that, and that would delay the Union's mobilization flush that blunts the Confederate strength peak by several months.


There's a real danger for the Union here that the 1862 summer/autumn campaign sees the Confederates just outright win.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top