67th Tigers
Major
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2006
My citation of the number of soldiers in the AoP and AoJ in 1864 was to show that Union manpower was not the inexhaustable supply that Foote and others seem to think it was. If as late as 1864, with the victories in Atlanta, the Union was unable to muster more troops, where was this "other hand" of which Foote speaks going to come from?
The Union was not completely behind the war effort and I do not believe further Confederate victories would have changed this for the better.
No, it's a tricky issue, the number of men in the Federal Army. I have known people that insist there was a million man army out there somewhere. While the muster rolls did have slightly over a million names on them by wars end, the total strength of every department of the US shows somewhere between 200 and 300,000 during this period, with a major low after the 1864 Presidential election when the soldiers from states Lincoln was in danger of losing were furloughed to vote for him, and then half of them didn't come back.
However, Foote is talking about unrestricted conscription, and he kind of has a point, but even Prussia could have raised the numbers bandied about (with about the same population, new territories included, as the Federal States they but about 800,000 men in arms in 1870). However, the situation in 1864 is so bad that 7 out of 8 new enlistees are deserting soon after enlistment....