How-To: Breaking in Brogans

Joined
Nov 26, 2024
Location
Maryland
Had to order an emergency pair of brogans that came in the mail today, and thought I would post my guide for breaking them in.

First, you're gonna want to soak them in water for a few minutes
1000044486.jpg

Then, wear until dry. These should take a few hours to completely dry, and you can do whatever. I personally went on a little walk. As they dry, the leather will comfortably conform to your feet. Do NOT try to dry them by a fire, as this will cause the leather to crack and warp.

Once they're dried, make sure to clean the brogans completely from any dirt, dust, etc. that you might've picked up. Using a horse hair brush on the body will do, but the soles will be considerably more dirty and will need more effort. Don't worry about making the sole pristine, just clean the big chunks off. You should do this after any event to preserve the life of your brogans, as I'm sure everyone familiar with the quagmire that was and is Cedar Creek can attest to.
1000044491.jpg

For the conditioning, some people like to use neetsfoot oil, Huberd's oil/grease, etc. I prefer mink oil, but it's up to you. You can apply the mink oil in its solid form, but I find it much easier to use when it's melted down.
1000044492.jpg

Remove the shoelaces and once the oil is melted, take a shoe brush and generously apply the oil to the brogans in a circular motion, paying close attention to
the seams where the stitching is.
1000044493.jpg

When finished, leave it in the sun or a warm place to dry for a few hours. Once the oil is fully soaked into the leather, it will waterproof the shoe and soften and condition your leather. I usually do this around once a year.
1000044494.jpg

-UnionistMarylander

1000044492.jpg


1000044493.jpg
 
Cheap Brogans will fall apart, no matter how well treated they are; some within a year, others a little longer..
Just as I ordered my hat, I am going to have my Brogans custom made, then "break" them in and treat them according to manufacturer's suggestion.
The first pair of Brogan's I ever had, I treated them with Mink oil, which seemed to work well.
 
Cheap Brogans will fall apart, no matter how well treated they are; some within a year, others a little longer..
Just as I ordered my hat, I am going to have my Brogans custom made, then "break" them in and treat them according to manufacturer's suggestion.
The first pair of Brogan's I ever had, I treated them with Mink oil, which seemed to work well.
That is a fact. I've owned 4 sets of Brogans over the years. The best were a set of 2nd hand Missouri Boot & Shoe which I wrecked by accident. My father has owned a pair for the better part of 10 years as he wanted to own a pair of shoes that truly fit him once in his life. The 2nd best were a set of Fugaweee which lasted well enough. I had a cheap pair from sutler row that lasted maybe a season IIRC and finally I have a set of customs made from Vietnamese leather with rubber bottoms as my leg wouldn't handle the leather bottoms anymore. They've lasted since sometime in 2010 or so.
 
That is a fact. I've owned 4 sets of Brogans over the years. The best were a set of 2nd hand Missouri Boot & Shoe which I wrecked by accident. My father has owned a pair for the better part of 10 years as he wanted to own a pair of shoes that truly fit him once in his life. The 2nd best were a set of Fugaweee which lasted well enough. I had a cheap pair from sutler row that lasted maybe a season IIRC and finally I have a set of customs made from Vietnamese leather with rubber bottoms as my leg wouldn't handle the leather bottoms anymore. They've lasted since sometime in 2010 or so.
Second that on MB&S. I bought my pair in 2006 for Rich Mountain and despite looking a little worse for wear, they're still great shoes to this day.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top