Some years ago, an archivist showed me two photographs purported to be General Joseph Finegan of Florida, and told me he was unconvinced they were the same man. I see the the differences, but there is also the possibility of injury/illness/stress affecting the general's appearance. Maybe even unflattering lighting in the photo parlor? I'd like to find out what others might think.
Finegan commanded the CS forces involved in the Battle of Olustee, Florida (Feb. 20, 1864), and subsequently commanded a brigade in Lee's army.
Attached are the images in question.
Photo #1. Photo#2.
The first (left) is the commonly seen image of the general, with a colonel's insignia on his collar, and no sleeve braid, etc. the second image (right) is also purported to be of General Finegan. He is wearing a coat with the buttons spaced in twos--per the CS Army correct for a Brigadier-general, like Finegan. there is sleeve braid, but the collar is made plain, and devoid of insignia. I don't see the uniform coats as particularly relevant given the common informality among Confederate Officers. Indeed Finegan is described in combat at Cold Harbor etc. in Virginia wearing a citizen's coat and top-hat, and waving a cane... Now, there is an 1861 image of Finegan, taken when he participated in the State's secession convention. it is at center below, with the others for comparison.
Please share any opinions on the subject.
Best,
Jesse Marshall,
Florida.
Finegan commanded the CS forces involved in the Battle of Olustee, Florida (Feb. 20, 1864), and subsequently commanded a brigade in Lee's army.
Attached are the images in question.
Photo #1. Photo#2.
The first (left) is the commonly seen image of the general, with a colonel's insignia on his collar, and no sleeve braid, etc. the second image (right) is also purported to be of General Finegan. He is wearing a coat with the buttons spaced in twos--per the CS Army correct for a Brigadier-general, like Finegan. there is sleeve braid, but the collar is made plain, and devoid of insignia. I don't see the uniform coats as particularly relevant given the common informality among Confederate Officers. Indeed Finegan is described in combat at Cold Harbor etc. in Virginia wearing a citizen's coat and top-hat, and waving a cane... Now, there is an 1861 image of Finegan, taken when he participated in the State's secession convention. it is at center below, with the others for comparison.
Please share any opinions on the subject.
Best,
Jesse Marshall,
Florida.