Which was the Better Louisiana Brigade in the ANV?

OldReliable1862

Sergeant
Joined
Jul 2, 2017
Location
Georgia
There were two brigades of "Louisiana Tigers" in the Army of Northern Virginia, and both made a name for themselves as some of the most hard-fighting and colorful units in Lee's army. There was the Taylor-Hays brigade and the Starke-Nicholls-Stafford brigade; after suffering grievous casualties at Spotsyvania, they were combined into a single brigade under Zebulon York. It seems this will be a somewhat difficult question, as the two were both very good units.
 
Top