As usual Vareb, its all the South's fault! Technically never, but for practical purpose, you can look at it in two steps: 1. Civil War - first income tax, giving the Federal government the tool necessary to actually possess sufficient resources (couple this with the XVI Amendment of course); 2. Great Depression - greatly expanded interpretation of the Commerce Clause
So, since the South secedes, now we're all stuck with the income tax, thanks for that!
I have often ask this question because there are those that say there was no such thing. What do y'all think?
To expand a bit on your original question: "When did the States lose their Sovereignty?"
1. Were the States ever sovereign?
2. When in time did they cease being sovereign?
3. Did the States surrender their sovereignty?
4. Did the States surrender all of their sovereignty?
I'll try and come back with some answers shortly.
I think you have to answer, first of all, which states. Clearly, Texas sovereignty in that it was a soveriegn nation recognized as such by other nations, including the United States.
Vermont may also fall in this category in that it was an independant republic at one point (though I am unsure of international recognition).
Hawaii as well (though a kingdom, not a republic).
The 13 original colonies? More difficult to say. They certainly had aspects of sovereignty but they rebelled and ended the rebellion as a unity. I am undecided on that issue.
As to the other states, they are creations of the Federal government out of United States territories and never were independently sovereign. Any sovereignty they have is derivative of federal sovereignty.
So the states surrender their sovereignty? Yes. Clearly Texas, in requesting annexation surrendered many aspects of sovereignty and could no longer coin its own money, enter into its own treaties, etc. As to the colonies, I would argue that the people of the states removed the sovereignty from those states and conferred that sovereignty on the Federal government when the people of those states ratified the Constitution.
The states, or the people of those states, did not surrender all of the sovereignty of those states in that the United States is a federal system in which the states are sovereign up to the point where their sovereignty is overridden by the sovereignty of the federal government.
I dunno, was not Powhattan trying to bring independent villages under his Powhattan Confederation (english name, for his suzerain)
Most likely. Most tribes that existed pre-European intervention had been shoving each other around and taking and re-taking each others' territories for centuries. Each had as much soverignty as it could keep.Are you suggesting that their sovereignty was thus challenged or abused before the English showed up?
I watch the History Channel threads (but do not post there), what's the story over there? Do the other posters simply hit 'report abuse' and your thread gets deleted?
I think somebody has been beating the state sovereignity drum over and over and over and over and over.....And....I'm right....don't worry Neil, its just a question of time before he gets picked up for tax evasion while he's screaming that he's a 'state citizen' not subject to Federal tax....:laugh2:
I see, again, that the numerous other examples of other views of state sovereignty has once again been deleted.
It is a shame, that once again, you are unable to have an open debate on this topic.
The states never seemed to have full nationhood status at any time in their history, but the closest they came was under the Articles of Confederation.
|"As long as grass shall grow and water run": Confederate States treaties with Indian tribes||Civil War History Discussion||10|
|N||Kindly demonstrate how the US Constitution denies the right of the individual states to secede from the union in the name of “We The People.”||Additional Discussion on Secession||10|
|Milepost 89 Relics of the Great War of the Rebellion of States||Uniforms & Relics||3|
|Research Saxe Coburg and Gotha recognizes the Confederate States?||Wartime Politics, & Debates (Moderated)||16|
|We're people that voted for Breckinridge in Northern states typically Southerners?||The Election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860||5|